High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Nagaraju vs State Of Karnataka on 12 March, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Nagaraju vs State Of Karnataka on 12 March, 2009
Author: N.Kumar
m THE HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA Arr BAN§3s4!§V:_LO §iE;.V:'''« "

Dateé this the 123" day of hfiafch,    '

aemaz %  

THE iamrsuz am. Jissncs "H xuaAa%kk«? A%&%kk 
Writ Petition No...;12Q3V.e1;l29G'3_(€§M-4'R,E§}_ §

BETWEEN:

Sriféagaraju     . 

Sic: iate Pate: Chatuyegcwdag   A V 

Agad abeut  '     .

Resrnéerat of SW¥§Q:¥"l'fijh ii; Vifiage'  
Kc":thaqere.Hc«bi'iw._  '%:;,___  _ " " 

Kunigas 'i"j&§uk"-. 5._ 7'; '  _ 

Tumkur E;-.§strii.'tV   _  ' - ...Petitioner

  - (By s'rs%::,j:aiiore -- 568 001

 



'#21, N

The Head Master

Government Composite High Scheei
Sirsgonahaiii Viiiage

Kothaeere Hcibii

Kuniga! Taiuk   
Tumkur District 1

$2': 6 3 Ramaswamy Gow£.i_ai'*~....
Member cf Legisiative Assémbiy
Kuniaai Constituengy  
Kunigai ' 

Tumkur District

The Block Education"'€2ffi}:';ef"  ii 
Kunigai?5i;:i<';j:__--.'  _  .
mrriigui" _Digi:;fi¢t  .  "

Pubiic Educa€:io7_'n Departmen«t   V. 

Sr§'iVBaSa2*:§faju  " § 
$:'fii_iate Sid'aa~i.ahi _   _
Aged. ai2out--34years__  
Residergi: inf 8"esa"*:;ana"r:.aiya
i<unigai"§'aiViii<._T-- A "

Eixmzaur 923::-i¢t 1

' n , :?;mt...Rati'ma Bai
 T w;'t:--v.St':.. "'h_u'i::iaram
._ "".§ige"d.'a£99u§:"3fi years
' ,_Resid;e?:-t_:=f Kammanahaiii Viiiage
"Kn rxégaiv aiuk

Tu~rrik:::r Bistrict

  Chandra
"Skis fate Chaiuvaiah

Aged about 35 years

Sri Cievaraju
fifc Huvaéah
Aged abeut 32 years



19

Respendents Fig.7 and 8
Ara residents 31-'
Singenahaiii Viliaee
Kcthagezre Hobli

Kunigai Taiuk

Tumkur District

Sri Muniyappa
Sic Huchappa 1 
Aged about 4!) yeah?-A_

Resident of Kareka|"pa§ya"--L  '4 V

Kunioai Taluk
Tumkur DiS!;§'§£:'f:

Smt.Van,*§»5ak£?§5.ma:§f;rfia...._  

W/as Raneaswamy

A9edfib<1v%4f32:;¥ee.ré  " %%  

Ch:énna'iaA?rV:1_apa%'i§,éa '
§(uEfgigaE*T1a¥£xé<"'~-_» '  "

Tumkur.     

Smt. R é'rsukamma"v. 

C» Lfiamdaéah V
-- .}fi§Qa:d.. atvgut 26 '§rears

V 13:: '§<.ir;is§§":::§ p*pa
~. " S,~"o"'P4:3fs;-j__ar§'Kadaraiah
' .__;'-'xeed; abgujt 27 years



Respondents {£9.11 and 12

Are residents of
Singenahaiii Viiiage
Kethagere Hebli

Kuniuai Taiuk

Tumkuz” District

13 Sri Sasha-er Sab
fife Sasha Sab
Aged about 36 years
Resident cf Hosur ‘_
Kuniaai Taiuk
Tumkur District

V _ V’ ;x{.;jR»f¢5pondents
(By for R1;

Sri D. f3.r§’n§vaf§a’n1urthy’,,Ar§va’cate,for R5 to R13;
iv _ RgspoziEien_ts’.’j2 $9.4 argserved)

ms W:it..?et§ti;:sh i_s”fi§’ed under Articies 226 and 227 of
the Cené;titution”Vof.»_’Endive,”v’pra’ring is quash the Scheoi
Deveioprr:’ent- ans!j_’£~&_ai’n_t$n::~nce Committee {S.9.M.C),
prepared far; ‘the’ ré3.p»:*t?r:.fent–2, ciated 21-7–2908, Vida
AnneX%??43″C. V’ V

?e§iti’€:’r’r”£:em§ng an for preiiminary hearing in

V. $rQup_ ‘th.i:3_ ds:y, the Ccurt made the foflowing;

fi_K_H_E_R
‘§’hev”‘;;4e.tvi’tioner has chailenged in this Writ Petition the

figjaxistittgtisn ef Schaai fieveiopment and Maintenance

for Ge-vemment Compasite i-Eighschooi,

‘ “‘*S’ivz?:11gornai1aii§ ‘Jiifage, Kothagere Hobii, Kunigai Taiuk.

n/

{t{iodei)’V§{‘oies, 2606 it is the Headmaster on’ the
httsefitieit’w§’io:V:Ais’V’et§§i;owered to constitute the committee end,
‘eommittee constituted at the behest of 3
v”‘-.-4.4_’__f;<z,emeer' the Legisiative fiussembiy is one without

' and it is iiabie to be quashed.

otiied a detaiied statement of objections. “they corztene that,

‘J!

2. The petitioner is the father of a chiid stetdV$f»i_io’g-_V_in

fourth standard at the Government Composite;i§iIi§h.s;§h_ooi_,”«_

Singenahaiii Viitage, Kothagere
Schooi Development Managingtgomteitttee is
Armexure-C on 21.120638. A reediwiig of the.s’sisV-iotéettttshows V
the MA of Kuniga! Cons£ite_enc_:§”$%ii’:’S:i§v;Ramass§3fiiy Gowde
has sent a iist of 9 pe:fsofos_ Officer for
appointing them motobe:’s’: ‘Ac<:ordingiy, the
appointment 'fiery same 9 persons
recomm:i§i'o'ed..V.:'TheA téfiesance of the petitioner is
that, after of the Karnataka Grams

Pancheeyet tk(5z_.fhooi'– A"v.DrVfe"'{fe£og:;ment and Management

3. Respondents have entered appearance. They have

H
3

K

schoai gr middle achooi or such other schcaois menticfiézi in

the said definition. A cemposite schoci is one;V”veh’$..%_’e:”itifié.%

primary scheoi and high sczheoi is merged. Ii}. .,

Cemmsite Gevernment Schoels theI$11:ii§éni’s.”‘abrié__ia.:ugiit..ffggri’

i to X standards. Therefore, ‘3a;Vho<§i'-ie«:';_-iifiéfiiigdmurzder
the Ruies. Accordingiy,

6. in the light of the schooi in
question is a_ SQMC is to be
appaeinted the parents of the
chiidren thiiischooi and it is a schooi

where secénidéary anti “;;iri:’§ia.r§’ééhoois are there. In that View

ef theiiiniatterug £hg”‘imfi.£igfied order passed appointing the

soiéifen the raccmmenéation of the iacai

isfiiéitziriifsai.A’.¢f–1″Annexure-R1 which has no farce after

2 _comin-g infiaci f}r.i~r£:é of the Ruias is iiiegai and requires to be

” =.i~i’ence, I pass the faiiswing order :«

(:3 Writ Petiticm is aiicwed.

ii (:2) The impugned amrer is hereazy quashed. H/1

chif-

(iii)

8

Liberty is reserved ta the autho_r§f§e$’J~~._to

constitute SDMC in accordance ff: {T