High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Nanjappa vs Government Of Karnataka on 24 November, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Sri Nanjappa vs Government Of Karnataka on 24 November, 2008
Author: Mohan Shantanagoudar


1%»: ‘mg H154-«i 7*;-4:5 THE 24″‘ ¢ my 0%’ z~&m%t?:;aa3£Lr: :.>._0::’»$7 M’ x

s§? :2§E%: C ‘
we é«§{}?-3’8LE 3:%&JU5T:€§E_?v§GAi¥§.€%5§ ‘S§%}§%§’*§A’%éAéG$§Aé
wax? §E§:_I__'{__IQ%’+.’i*:§¥§.–1§§99f2GG8~-{E¢§~L8)

3%§’.’W%€1f}’Z

Sic; Lats . ‘
fiiged ab91;t:’iaI§.<_yE:;;:'r;~ ' ' V .

Resiéiarxg at’ 1\:’Ef1.Ii3?18.}3″{13′”é;3.¢_ Viiagt: V

&aé{§:;;§11_fiha§1iM_?’£::s;I§:_ –. ‘ ‘ ‘ «-

T13§”a3;:;agGdZh:vL Qbvii V

Neianiazzgaia L’ M

Baaigaig:-175 “R:31*aE_ {.}§.s §f:’iC~’:,__ ” 2 ” ‘T Pfifitienei”

§ fiié Raéflggfiia Anantiian, A{EvoCa’i::. }

A. …..

‘:3, “{‘qC£v§i3,:.fi::1::3.’i sf Hazxiataka

E&a:”;§”E;_€*s€::v;’ii:% Bépaitmeni imné $133.3}
V 3’séu1ti7st:%:’ié:ti Buihtiijzg
“-.Bat;l:g2i£E:”::i*:::>
R’ftpf’ff86I1’£’;e§ by its

. ; Pri:;:¢§_§>a $€C1fi{£i3i’_’§.

— $56 Bepuiy” {iammigsianazz
Bangalore Ru-mt} Uiisixéci
Visveavsaraya “£”<::«wz:tr3
Viéhan V€"i'€§}1.i
Ba::ga1ar$–5§f} {X} L Rfififiifiixiiéffifi

{ By Sm} R.§<Im;2-ax", §~iC:GF'}

"3

-‘_.’-

This ‘fifsfrit Pzgtiigéfima is {E16-:3 uitgifiir .&:°t;;«:t}z:*.3 226 €e5.«;2Z;2’?”‘–::§’–i}1€t
{?»=:)§:sii€’:,1’§€;<::n :3? Iisfiia 1):': yixig f-:3 q11.a&;%:: that. f;@:~""–*:'i«:;fa:'a; __ "{Z'§,';:.€.?

grant erdér dateiti 26;2,2{}()?' markccl as §;nneX11:rx~'2.l%i. —to
£116. iifiiziaziazi af aha market vaiésge. azf RrsJ.Ti,"?{},<€§:-."f§',{§ ag:§.§1::€%§;

the i»{ar11ami«:a Lam} Grant P12111523, 19§§,

'§'i?:i$ "«§».='1'i':t ;¥.3€%'ii'{i<3:3 (:<:s§1:ii§':g rm: '€f=3:':1§:;2%:'i§1:i.é:::z%1'<£' §i:逧§;'i3:2§ii,'_§E1
B' g1'm.3p this day, the {';<3u1.*"!: 31.3613 131.63. __fEE{):vi:3g ‘ v ‘ ‘ *

9 3 z.~%;;;-;:.g
§:”E3i§X§i€J3;’i€’:1′ is the :3vs::.e::;s.*” — £:’§c:«:: Eanazi
:sea;*é.:2 ‘m'”=<g€:2: 1 ;é;s<«;%;2z.;1*:.1.::'i:'1. " .. é:1<::'& 9 2 « g,
E g S V 'K? P4 5 H E "C? gmta

3iT%'.::.a:€:c:§ at _,:E+a,§e;:sm2'z3i§a1i§§. 2 'f€§@§r;:a:aga}.a Taluk,

o

Df¢S"1L}'7:"C.E.:.'_. §iCi';'.{"}i'd' 1g {:3 him, 1'25 has hater:

in zizzatifizérisézii 33:3 «:€:js:33iz:§::':5a :2}? '£6 gzzxiias irasf'

Earsszé siéflziéiisti .,i3;i' .$t;:f<.?ej;;{.'* Na. E 35: 0f Jakariaiaaéfi "wléiage,

.. _ 3;-;§3;£g:%.;. ggijggijgsg '§§;'§f':Vv__§a_§f(';§3fEi"*£§{ ewizaii 5:3}; ?:f'§1€ pfiifiifififif §;.r::%.,

S';.3;;"2.;'%3ff;=' ~ Pfiiiiifififif mafia a}3j_';1i*$8.'§ifi§3 Lzzéésitr '£25:

'§2'_€$%;"i.Si=37f:S"_':::§ E:_§2f;'1ai:.aka, Lani': E«Ee::~v€m1a:: in Fcarm ?€G.;33
1 A . _ . .

§31’§;3z=fs,_:1§,gV_é%’::f }=g§’3§1’£ {sf Eafifi in €653 fe;¥m33: Tim’: §}€:§3=;1§,j;é

‘::OE1’iZE3§fa§f§i}{1€§E’ ELI}? fiiii -if-i§.2,2G{}?’, iméizzateéi ?;h2.:: g-5i;%’%’éa::m=:§:* that; he wiié :93

‘ g:ré:a;:}%’.z=:{§ ‘{;’£:a:;:» iazzezi [:9 am {fI¥Zi’.€}”‘1’§{= {ref guziéaig ijging aéiiaciifiig

V’/>

‘IA 3 ,,
{<3 tilt: iaizd which i$ aireadjg {}'v'z7i'}*3(} 333;: him, $Lai3j&;€fE;.T%_U {his

pajéxfiiéint {sf 13:3_2:1"§<:€:%: Vahifi of R3. 18 iaiahs per az:;"€:_;

Gfiifii' is inads u:'2c_%r::~:* Eviuka 4(2) :3? .'L§1r..::i

Gfééilt E31533, E959 {':'1fire"iI}af§.»'::1fl °sfhé: V§~E_L:}_é3$'"~..

far gheri}. {3¢C}1"iS:f§{§L1€fi'§:§?,Vfflffifl }ge:é'Z;i_'sii'm3€::* ;*.?:3;js,:di:"€:-§;:'iéé{i fie;
pa}; F33. §1,'?='3,{}6ff;/r» 'i:.aWa:£'s:1s §£v§j¥§'}£f§§'il vaimsi T§¥:j%;:: 12%;» guntas «:2?

éaiid as; €§§€r:':i"£:1i:1{-fiié j–':J}? "~–.}§}$}*;23.2i.f:' C£)I"fiiE}iSSi€}E1i:":£'.

'§~'€_:*a;i1Ei9:1fir baigig aggriaviézii. E133;;i:}";ivé'.«:ié:é;::1;:1:ir:a.%;i0n sf 211$

i1'15§'3{€f: a%i;I::,; Es’:Ei%ii{:s:1, p{=:Ti:i’t:i<::§1:3r has

§:=:f<:§!{§'¥;{E'::{:E E'E{3'iifica%;i<:s11 §tS:-5:u§:s:i by $163: E}:-:§sa§"i;1n.€:z":§ zjaf

:'S;'€;53'_;a3i§}*2; :°*3::e;§.T '~§<%?.€g§s€raiiQ§1, ciaiaii 13:33 N91?'€§Ii§3§i" 2€}i3éE:,

d;lS%::§.§2s»%§'i'ig'v "'i"h<-2 fiatizzaaiiifi {§'Li§{i€}_%I3€i ?a4::3ri<::Ei ':£'a1z_1e:=, 93'

: E1313f_fiQ'§'éL§3ié3 §r<';p€§*£,§€$ in 'ms. }i;ri3:ié<:ti.i.0:€: 9%' $€i"£2}.§:?: £3'? '€}":{:

:$s"£m'§;.'§I}'3*:E§i:§$':§L1'fiI"'S {}f'§€§I:'?, B3;§}§,'33{}i"fi E62333}; Efiisizfgii.

2 m'z.'}a%k§}}.83'E3_.§.§. vifiage: is 3?; S?;,§\E'{;».26. "§'%2Et {}a1i«:i&§i;t1:: §'vf'{EaJ.:'§:i{:%:

"=«§3.'::3$ e::=f §EEE§'¥}{"}'éf3§"}ii;3 ;?:1"{3pé.:r%:;ia$ &:i§«:2i3T[:i§1g }5§§g}fr

-4-

“¥’§?i’€h§1″1 $13 ragga of E<-35.1.8 iakhs {:3 E35. 11 iakfiifi *;;:€§:'-.T.é%';:::1'€:

a:<::.{i Whfiiffiafi, efiasar Ezmiig <3? Jak}*a2":a}1a33§' 1:i§?}§g%§ —

'iai?i?;§'fiE} "ihfi rangfi :31" i%3s.;'é i:»1}«;}'isj"€%*} 'E€:%,6. i:£:«:i_'iS._p::3'* 3{éé:*{i,

§_;§:a3;"§';é:d e::{m:'::s«:~:i far {£26 §3€?i§"3:f31'1fii3T4h§A' iT§3t}§i1'1§gv§.1}3i3I}~ {b;_é'-sgaéifé

£'~E<":tf;ii{:a'i:is:3n afgues iglaai. 'L"}.":*E';'_ '£;?f}.:é.'£7§{€:E?'; v'a}_i3c~. T ":;ié:i%érI;1i:1€<'3
by the: Deput}? CG§11B}i§i~f$_§i€31'}€-i" a§:;- Ei$ ;"}._3 iakiifi ':§{iI' £3.C'£'€: is
13:53 ééxcfissévfi. Ea fuzfizei' v;S1é;':3::'i%*£.':e;«._€:}:;.é;j:. _?;3T»:re ES :"1::":: basis

$3? the B€;::;uij;;._7Sri’. _V Fig fui*t3:1.;%5.’is§;7::;s:a3;ié:i:&:<i" by Eearzzed irauzisfil fer

aha ;:«éé:i'T{i{;i1:';é:*V '*%;;%;;;:n;,%:"%:~3:'=;;1:¢'-…:;:g;'33(3) {sf fiifi Ff'£ji§.€S p:'e$z:::1"i1':s€s
izéizifii m'«:::-:,;§€ §{:€;?:e;:§:%§:it: Vfiléifi 9%' {E25 {and tie '£36 g1*a3:1"{.£*;§

afl{§'.;~%5 Lihe A;v3i'z;:'="g1$§€}I13 a{;=pi§{:..€:§3§{: {:3 that fasiis sf

_§}@;:::i§* éfzmzznéssianfsy is na'i:. _§:.:s'i§i'i{::1 in

:iaf:'%{€i-z*i11§i:§::;g"i"i':t: zziaykei tsaisgvza 3: E8 iaiés gsfir ::ss:::§23

W§ifiu§.1€v.§€fé;:¢m:fi £5 E21116 122 {mi} {sf *{.h<;'~. Efzszifis.

" wsét. g3€"i;itir;;;:: is; ggzgiesed by 811% §«?..§=§ia1"2':a3*, Fsarméd

{'3§'s%:r3'3;*i:€:':?.; ?§f';a{§fii' é;pp€aI;':ir;g {H3 bfiihfiif af ma ;3G§1{i6:.z1'i.s.

E1113

Li"!

3, I3"; is; 1'&§é:*.vafi€i£{} fifiifi the pI'€Cr¥iS§{}i1S of -<3. é::f:s:'§« _

1'2 {2} ti; {3} if the Rzziés in this C{}I'f€fZ"§s'fZ;.'* ii}.

a 3:322 4 :~» Perscns eiigfile fitzxei V'

'2

far agiatiitural §3§3f?:{3$a:€-35. : ;{__s.} 1

avaiiabki far eciisgaasa} E2<:f: §~'a;::55,:;a
agrizzufiturai %thaf-§_§.::;:*:.%r1:3fisAA £0 a.

§}€I'S0fl; H    '  x *

{ii afhgv     eigkitecfm;

312:1 .  

{i’E}”” :fi;g;:*<;aTs:a,é";:3;:11":1;iTa1;i" §fi{3(}fi1€: zigzag :16?

&;;c<s:3§€i.1*:;:;%§§:=::;s*; –%:§1{:é13$a:'";+:§; 333$"

_ {iii} =i.¥':'1i:;» is-.&ifi_1é-i*"'a "éztma fziifi agréizégéiuréfii
Ctiifivatizég «?'i3.i€;.1aI1{?§ f.?€i'S§1'133§5 9:: has E3333

{ids E:::":*:zi:1%;i:3:"1 tar take up ;:»€::'*s@1'1a§

:::7.;§fi=§'i%::e€Ej£::1':; and

{fii} fifhsia £3 mm': 231 Sfiffiifiifiifi. h@}u::%;§:'::";

§3'r:::v}::3:§-{E ihasi E33 {E25 633$ af E12»:-

séwésfimaii aw} Saiéierg, %Il{§$ may hi:

gi”am:@{§, if the grass a;;3.miaE ificeiéie 91′ {ha
apgaiifiaiii f;X£E€{§ Eupeag aigiit ‘§’.§1€:e1′:$;:2.z’:fi E:«ut

3335 thaii Eéupfiaa twenty ‘§Z§’}{:=<'ilS8.I'}{§,

Ha

113*»

Eravifieci furfixai' iizai; ihfi <':}~;'{:imF Bf — '

g§'éi.':1§6E§ {=3 pésrssfl $27133} 111:3': f.§g€t§1€f."§£T§?}:ji '5 '

ms: ianfi aireadfjg heki by 311(;§1…};;;e41's<}iéé=9§'é:§é%;f§é${i

'iéaié Einiiiis p1"escrib~fi{§ for 3 S: iiziefit. '§1;«::$i£,j'1'"e:'*::' A'

11136 2 {E52}.

{2} N e:}is;e*it}1s’ian€§i:1gVL ‘ ” 2 ‘”1iiig” *
fa} 3-u§:3–§*u}6 {1} aI::§_1j;€r$;én_f:1::§a’.€b€ $’aI1tvéci ii1<:
lanai aéiéacem car s::}{:sS¢' i;fi~-"%:.i"z€~: i::_1:Ii<:§.A'_':sz1 iw:§a:{i¥ hfiid

E2'; him «;:=i3.4~;;¥::2E1:.=:s:":i:'{[e:3i"i Vfiiiviliiéfiiifii 33 2311 the

:f13f:::«';*"~ ":9 be "'a3.ai;{;'*;;"§:1iI1eéi 'E11? {ha
au.a:i1e::1*it¥'$?§":':;e2f;'éi§3':g£'%~€"7i*1sa. iasad, if 312:2}: izmd is, in
$13 ' zggéimén. "3i1:*i€:§s requiraé fer

_%?=<.%f£;f:é=;;:' %;:*g;f€£;3?:13:€ii':; «:3? bfiiiéia" C3"11:§L;§'s»"8.f_i{}§} if the

3:9 h€:i§:'~– —–

V’ * ._ *..~_ }”‘$*s:;f*,:f§:;::.=’d $13: am 3’:1e::h g:”a:z’z. shai}. 5::

‘A ‘ :’;’:a:§fE;’:é§f§_’ an €I><I'E€.':f}f{, exafiaiiixég in thfi €23.33 9:? vans:

ianfi half h€:{:i"a2"'e 3312:}. in iiiéi cam G;

i’

V’ n ;ia:”1<;§ %1':§'1£' hsszcitars grad zhafz the E-zzsigai §§<;f:§.m'

" –. .::'§f Eanii afiséi' fiazah grairi. fiat fil}iC§€i1'Z§ me

cfisééizxg a<:e::ar<:':,i;':g 212:: Eifieit iiaméaiaka Laafiezé

E2af{3r::":$ Argt, M6 1.

W

..’3_

Raise 12 a» Price yayahie fer fihe

ganteii unéer these rates : {.1} in V

‘£326 iarids grmztfiii umgifir ‘§3″§f:’iS€i 1’12}{:%_§g fizzii ”

§}’E.;:i’}3″GS€f <2? agiiicu '£i:.1I'6.» ._

{E} {I26 prim pafisabie fur i';?;€ {.i_:"3f §af;_~:_i%_ amé V

mézifisci Wéi Kauai S.Ei.:::.ii~£.V_%;:a€, 3337?; 3.::;s::_

fifty timzézts axzéi 31::-i"-.. ;1.:–<:,;»

iaiiiidrfifi ':ii;'1r'::_%:.4_.:-*i;'~ iiilfifl §i&§"1{'I ::{§..§é11:1€ §a}"&1§i{3

0:: 591.26%: Eaiid.

{ii} :'”§%:'{:.}.-hgririéfz ;:Iz;a;j~;%1E:iE'<:: 31:59:" v.g2;r«:§€:1 iaziéis

£21' * K i: ".¥:iiE'§. V éS:su:'sj:i §_:e:'z*igati<§:1
<1}? C§'1a1}.I1sEs ssfiiaii
€:}IT{§:%i'3;?¢E:;i}};."V Es:%$5 than Yiififififi five.
_§":a1i3{i:$_f_{i '' aéxi 37:9'; I3'}~:3I'€ "Q3331 3:531:

= {h;£::';':sa3::a(i"'fiafgeiia 322:3}: §7}*fiC'{E£j€'EE.

'§§:£§;€'2%"i§'fiSf.aI1{?i§§}g anjgfiaiiig c<33::§ai:"1€{§

'~i.§'3 S%*éE§;'§~fi4€Cii£}Zi (3), 'sfiihfifé §;:fi€": "id is '4.;:*&:*3«,r

va§:;a .'13i«:*:, {€16 D§<;:au*;=:,r {::{}}EEE'iEi'SS§{}i1€f {if

«:';~*§fQE"ser Qffinffi-1' 2mfi":£.:3'*i$e;:::§ '£53; Eizém in %};:Es;:=3 ':§€:§:3_':f

3:3}; 3&1} $"a:~::§'; Efifiii Es}; gggubéizt 3;'i:€.:*'i:i::2:,:.

{3} Thfi §Z3E'i{3%i §;':a}"~£}§:3}€3 ii} :'5§;:«-:éC'*=':', 0%" §E':a3"i§.'E-:-

g;s;'.::i_:1i;€éi£ far {:u§"%.§evai§@;'1 Bf §3§a:':'£aEia:'; {:3'€J§f3$

N7'

-3′

aha}? be fhf: m33’Z%;€:T§ ‘i.«’a};u€- :3? iauéth §;:»£”:«:i is

€i£:1:.»::m’1i:”1«::::i EC}:-3? €333 §{–3;:2ui’.§; {Zs31′::ini$$.%:3_:’:&3§’ ‘ L.

$u§:;;§e§:i: ‘£23 3 ;11’i:”:i:}1u:§3 é:r’:” five €’h@11san~:§ ‘

per’ ‘x”:{~:::T§.a3″€: : _

¥’:'<:svi::§€:s:i éhat whzasje. ¥tiii:_;i;–:ai"}{€:'€: %;z3};:;L£v: £55

§«3'=':::t'-,1' {Elma §;;%'1<:f §::i:'3i1:§::;jfi" ~.§}:"'+€5C'1':i§3t=i'i iii:

{1} {E} :23}: 3, is; shaii :::<.:«.:33§?:$:3.€:.xi:3;'::*:;:v*§;<:2
grazafizig a42;§Ir:«:::3;~§§§.,_ :25 gEf'Si3_'3;§_, f;1i::: Eagaé
ijaiieciiail :3? iizarkfit '§;s'*'sV_i'-:."£;«s:;;" x AA '

Pr<?f§::é{§%::s:i V §':,:;§:§h£i%_i: %h3;i.._if} ' spat? {sf §.aI:{%:s

gf'a:':%;s:fi" {;:}V§'§%5§','A..A§:.s*;3, -£&i"{ia3:.§:a:':: €31' §'ub¥;::é::'

c's:Ei?;.ii?a.%;Ai:::s;:3 ts3»':§:séi?;§éi?:§ ,i:iii§ng%r;g fie 3{f§.§€3{ii,1}€5{;§

{Ti:s:':«3é';<E=;:::. éasizii Séééziiciiuiiiii T:"%b€s, E¥§"i€}

__§j21"i<:m%;a€:':-é' ~ :3?' a v{fla~§';;:»€:'z-'3f:.§2:'é: St:';£:i::t§r 's2:§':éTc§";

g:."%7.%;%::§’:§:s€:’:::-, fa? c.1′:1’zi’a.:a?i{3z”; <11?

2 'E355. §'jai"§€j'€E gjayabia fa}? Siiéffi

'§:a%:: i'a?Cf.}¥EE'${.§ E33. %;;ha:: {E115 ifijgzzi iazzééfi

:%.:'é:.j:::§é1fi":§.:'11e{§ in izééeégz' fav$'s;£:*;

E3:':,:2z:'%{§€{i fz.§I€,%'1§:* fizai: :Fa;'%":s5::'<;é 22 §}€:z'*.5;:,:n

*~;é;g;<3 Qwzig ésfifffiéi, ifia, s:"::=:e}"«:%am<}i':i ii? :"1g:'e::§'}€.-:2'

Eériégiég s::»:;si €'3§'sZ.€L"Z'£i'3%i?'{§§1'}§ "iifi-Ii a::.§'£is ii: €::~;%:§i3§:. €32' sag
'L2 ,-5

;3€:§':;~;::}:""s as:7§3<3 €§.s:}€'5 zz<:e'%.'. ‘»’*.?«.%’:1 fiiéfy’ Eamis £§.}C}’§}1.L%:;’5

)$

30:” Eafiiiia mi’ grémgilag =::0ff’:é:, {£23, ;”?£:r:.1i’;’i’. :’*e3i:;fL1ir*§:.{i is» 33* is: up {.613 §;<:§–':'::§:~§. ._ . '4

a;vhich€'v§:1* is $5383, 3%; E131? *§;%":, .r2?~i:: 3)-ég§a%:sEi:. L”

21212131′ ihiaa SL1bA§””‘Q§€E. ~

34% :- in Ix<:3;:»:–::'a :3? 1%.-::'1<};%£~_é' T

czzéiivf-$3913 :12? p}3.I'§;i3§§§E:i r;.';_:'0ps;A.§f " {E16 :'£}€;ip11%_§¢'

f§Ze:,1:3ii:11is§i pay in .f;;,2;:15;g;:}::a £3215 ‘”3::g:’i€«3 {§£”§e3:§’:<%s
gIa:"§é:&£é, he mag, £5; .:*'<s':{:0?:§€d iii

-E’

‘€7v’§’§”§;i§’i§ :*>«f:mi2ii; “él%i{%A”g:*£a3§:%;€3:€:_%;;;§ ‘V%:§5é::’?ai’a1€ =3;

3:!’ .l.’

S{§i3?{“};”VE£3€37§A;{E§ in ‘if-‘;:§’;’*:~.*%éé* .§{;ua.i €§;:”:;:’iua§ %:1.=3:;3:§§:13erz$:.s.
§’:%: ‘§”1’3:5%;Vi3:é3,%ia1;4:’;a~i:1§%,égfsazgfi :”%:.«::€;5;§:*§i:}
‘$5123 ‘§;;§af§<~::i"—-§3{is:;€:$*§',;G1'1 aé' fiifi éagzfi.

3~3§':i .5 A. E'€{;€v:i%§'1$§a3':{§ii':g azzjgthéfig

A 3 §;-:"s;"é"£.:é€jif;:f:?e:x:%_. in S:.'§:3~.§"s.§.3%: {3} §'§ '£133 23.16, '§E3€< §3:'§£:€:
'f E

V §§3§3.§. ?;3;§7}§€: §:v:VV.é:3s;:s€:~t:Ti, 9 §:'§fi€§§§ gz'a§:'ié':d fer Cafiac:

e::1§%::';§%§3~%:%g;:§: 'Ea 3'36 §€_':3€S£}I§"l'S §'3§i}GI}g§§1§§ {:3 31$

E43::§f§€:t§é::}€<§ aria? Schézduiazi '§':'i%:»€s Shaii

' §3s.2;"E:€},:'«- {£':};:-€65 €:f«;=;s'G hiziiezifitii aituti ":35?

:'3:':E;*} %i€<:'"* *=:~:.;

E

{E??”::p§”iCL5’§LS suppiiéd}

{iv/>

_ 1:”; –

E1? “16 3f«::»s’€3:z1eniTi011<::} gsrsvisiaiaa m;::ii;:{13;Q':3_$i;s;

3<~::ru$€–:{i, 3% its dear 'fi';atT gfaiifii sf ianti ad}a(:e§3fir§'_:A§:.:ii" "c_i;':as!€-2 _

ma §;3,:"s;<§ aére.-adv izatiié 23%;' file": '$301: is #32:'-{.{;:§:Y'E§:;iX{}%§V'~E{.{:'_ fitgss" *

genizrai gas}: {sf ia::«:i$. Quée -4 {*2} E3§;fl*f?;S'~'§f:E'3',i§1:§3"–.§*§§7;.§1

' E

{ha :1<H1»0'%::.=.~;:f,an*:e clauae. ::i~ei-21s:Z%y . éié3,a::;1::Lg:;a:::sH .~m:§.§:,-. '

i'E€§£W§f'€.}1S§£}Ii{§ifiig, aI'15;:E*:i3::g x::<3r;?;a§i::r:t:§ s-'z;:'£::+;'u}_€é {1} am:

"X

p€fE'$=I}fl may' 'as §'a1";i€;=:i"t_:1s':':. §;;.sg3'1i:?{ j.a€ijé»:s:.§:;!u_ £33" €}e:';:-',5: $0 E1116
E3215: a}:'aaa:i}»' he§<:f:"bj;r hi:a"i"VQi;1V':s:s+$iE«é£é'_ti<2:l:: ::f* 1':::a:'i»«;«::"i; vaiua as
333 {ha data. *::;f "Q ~_§_'.'s§*"5v.._=£§<.;"-.',-"%;.£;§,v'3.€"§,I'":€ErC§ §:;a§-" {E16 aL1t}103*'£};
g;'.é;i:{::€:i:€'g._t%'ii:E3_i9z€f3:;':'3}{'fé:i,:S;.._fi"–%:h€:' E31351 ii} gra1":é€:<:i ;§3"1s:ié:::" i9%'.:;i};c'::

IE {2} 22:5 t}':%s;,_R2i§ei':', _ iE2€:':, "'_§*3.*T3-:3 SE-i'£"i}{'E WEE? 136 $1;{2§&$'§. Est; '{}{i€;':

. _ markééi. véiitifi a$"«a¢=.1_j§}f:,§: {$32.6 C2? {ms gfaifii 33:; 'C25: <i{:¥.T€:2":13i:3<:::

gz.;_1%;%i;<3:f§i§;'__ {hit Eajgxd.

_ ‘ ?§1:’:3i’€;1.’iS, ‘£218. §:»:”i::’:e of

‘i’.§’1é:;§§§::§:{§ g:*éi;’-?:*f£3.fé’_T%;<.'é. ':m{i£:::"' Eizmafe 4% {1} C2? ihfi E31363 =.&'%?.§ §':ez1;%s:: Ea

<§§:€&:i*:é:né{% uiagééza" E31136 E2 {3} if ihii Ruéaa. R336 12 3f

~ V Riggs i3 i;1'123.;:=§:aE.%:a%3§:3 ':33; ms gram. Efiaiiiz :m{§.c§* $221133

"Th *1:

G3′ the E23163- *:::::s ‘ix {;’i*i{3i”1’E’}§I”i{“ii§ :.:;31€i<;'::: $32136 E13 {3}

$316: §'~33_§§fiS is g:3:":€1"a3 3:: ;";.am:"<:< arsii is 333:: agxggiicaégée E32:

§%'i=::'; sgiéaciai graziig {Bf Earzci 3%., ii':%: v:;:§'";€ 112.3636 :3:"1«:'I'§ié;'* 'ifiziééj

xv"

«<%{2} Sf €216 §5iuE€:S¢ Suh»~i"u§é_3 {'2} {Eff §¥311E£: E2 {}'§_..'§If§J1f<3

fmfizfiz 3.':3.a;%«:e*:3 it n. ‘;*;€».§; aéssigs, ?:”§’24:t::~1″:;3%§ Sf }%.:f:,;€

112 {if that. Eizsaiefi }J€V€é£}S that 2 {:35
Eaiziigg gfwz’i.=::{§ far cLiEii§;§f;£:;.g§3 Cfifié ;=,§3.:ifi ha
222%: fiififiriéii vaiue._§§ by ‘Q16:

‘)€p13$;.§-* <:<3131:.;3;.%§;:;sii ii:%: ;«}vi9::;{§ifi:ii':£:3.1:1: «:35 §?.$.§3,€}{)%.}f .

Thfig} it §?i’1:i<€': :2 (3; 3f me
E21363 3&9 '£.;%;1é=;y 25.5333 fzavfi be, i"6a'.§

§iss€.i1":<:i3:5;, §i';a$:;.31:c%f: 962:4; apgjficafiia ff}? £116 ialraxziaa

" '~ %3;%ii=:t%_3f¥. ajijsfi g§"a§'}§{':::§.._.._.f%"3'E' {':i5§.i1':{::'. p::;:'p«:}s<:s, 'f'E:u3, Ttize

-V.¥.,?i”:g*é,;% ::*s?”:E’z1§§;<:s_1jt:'~—_mazf§<: Ssgiaraié §31'{}¥§Si*Cv};'3S £233: 3¥::pz"fz2'a%;.:-':

va:{*fs=*~*:f§.%e;5 if '§;'é'f_'":eri3'1$ fair fzxirig i'§'1€ As E396 gram: mastia

':.;m:::1&:r E9,u?:e=: ==%{'2} izf iitia Rfuifis is éi $§;3€:E€:§.a§ grzmt fiifiiifi far

_ 3§;fr?:37::1§_fig 133:1 §3e:§}€§§=:2"?§ $3? §;Vc':'%:.i.=:"::' i."':§1j{}}7E"£1€§'§}: of 2:226

VA 131%: i5:3"i§; 33:16: as Rifiés ééigig is *5€;Ef~:::0:':%;iiI:{:.{i ruifi E3}; §f€Z,S,=€§_§,

. '%;k1{5 sésiéfi §;3;'@vi$i»:33'1 Eggs. Ex; "€343 2::':{£s;:~z'3§.~:::{:s:§ 21%; 3362;' '§.§':a€

Easgjsgasaga fazaiazi in %;_h::: said $5i:<:'§§{3;':. 2%: this §a.;:zg1,:aag€: u$:::<€;§

gm?

I

1:: E3136 =-N2} is piéiim aflsci Simpiss, i}’:s::’:=: is as _f@:’

s._-

{:(;a§”1fu$i922. ‘§’§”:=.a§’ef{2:°=5:, {he ;{}€pu’£’3; £Cfi3’§i1:1:;§–::%§iz;gi’§a::.éf” :2»; ~

justiaisii E1′: aiirfiifiirig E316: pfiiiiisziézz’ ‘§{3~§3§:3§f” :3/1:: V

af ihfi ianéi 33 can ihii {Li-Exfiii of 1:35;: g:’a_§?f£. ”

3. §§{}¥’i=”{‘i”J€i§’, the: riiéirkfii V8:§1″_i§§3 3333 ii}. §:’i€f€%:%E”13ziE:€{i
by the autizeriiifg gra;m:’.é:i?g– %};T:€ »_E:§’aa~;se£:-£1 an rxssééabic
z:1a’?:.€:.ria}. ‘§’§f:€ <3i"1v:1«:s;':=;2€::1€:§': v'%sjir::._;'a:f1§1%i*}:1::=§ig7Ea' is Sfifiifii 35:2

{:3 ":2 Wfiai: H _ ihfi §&§;_i1'é§=-' €;}3"£}}f11%SSi{}31€i" Ems

{§i::€riE:iE1fi;r,i f_'§*;~:;":*' §?&3§1s? 9:? the Eamgi 31: 83.18 E' "E33

3361' .a£3'«:~3. E163' _:.%u€:j~,;»1_ " " £';m1':1"§fi$$é:3:{§E;:' S%":E£a1é3§’:a€:€i: its? ?éZr”1£t §1::*«.=_’2t&£’, fiéés {3x:::1::sr§”; §3m;;s{:ss{:s

V V’ {:3 {E§_1″i::g’i. .§}€:pu’:’;}; {::£T2EE1iE}§$ySi{31§€§’ E0 };}aE§§~§ ‘:5;_3«’:a}§i:”:g

” E¥i'{;§”i-~ ffigafié ii} ~:’§€%.”.fifi11i§;aiis3§:

W..

L,»
0

‘E316 €3fi.{ii§E”S€i”£T;ff3″£'{. zriéié: z’§1″z:’1fi:>’;:ur§«’;%.’ (3333:: $”2f.i’§€i'”?

fez; SE} far 85:3 3?; §€:§a§,€3 ‘SQ iixizzg Gf fiat: Ii}.a1″

iaiiéis pr’:-1′ age, is Sfii; asiszis. “?hé;_ Efiizpiifity’:.3:>:::;:;:z::i;=:esi:::i’s:::’ is

Qiiréaétefi ‘zifi ;;::9:s-3 f1″§:s§”: 0:”z.§§-:-‘1″-..:€§a:i§;:,g” $9 {:E:€f.€i3{‘:.:}§;1anféhi-:3:;1
Tiiaé :I1:ar}§<':i iiaiua in aC<:Q:'d.a§1i§é:.,wiij1 1aé*;,«.1«;é€*:;3ij.é1g E21 ffiiflii

1311*: €;§3$€:"va'i.ie:3:13 i:1a.ci€:;«–_é33af2g ; 1 "

'.¥1'it 1::-&3;%.%';:'=.~:';2.:'t3\':'_' -€53 éiisyazéeé :a§:§€§r€i:%I1gE3?.