mpondmm by amlaxm sy.Na.15+/10 No.15-1»]' 15) m an amen: of :2 acres 6 included it: thus acquisition geding L'.oi'3 .. otlmzx-reliefs. 9. The: facm in for the 'Hf' tmnbestatadma fiztfiawa: V A __ ' fl .' A' aw mire: 6 gumaa purauant two a a copy of the aa1gaeea ia%% Azmmum-A. The schedule amcme that the pefiflonm of sy.Na.15~mo It is not in dhpuw that would mmsuxe a little mm 14 in diapute that out of the said M deeds have tnlnan place and theme are ........... -..,vv_u.m us» ummnwmimmufi mmrw mwwm U?" mmtwnaflfln mew wwwm £3? mmmmm HIGH fiflmw 0? mmamm HEQMQ . Pursuant to the salsa deed excacmed an -war: of the petit1nx3er' , the name crf tha pet.it::1m"' is in tha cancezrnvad xwmuc reoorda far the ywx 20G2--0.'.i. Sufice it 1:: say that purszzant in W \h|iM'\T«.0Wv\"Pw. mu Ilia ' .-.»...- ...M...mM uucncuwraee mwuuw var amnmwmgmwm Wiww mwum W?' mmmmwmm Wiwfi EWWRV 0? Kflflwflyfififi Mimi Q preliminaxy notification dated 19.12.1993, ecpyffixf which is produced at Annuuz-e~C, an exam: of ;i-1' A' % 7 guntan was sought an be acquired mpondem for aumhlishing an it in so be mfleed that the k% fbund at sumxo and that I§::.4ifgk at Sl.No.14. It is ta pursuant tn the 1-mid has not filed his was issued 0;; an mmt of 2 mores §>§j%;.;'I'f'i;a_,15-?1llO is sought to be mquima. to be noticed am. in the 4__ and respondent No.4 are
not be out af place to mention that
h shown as m , who
% to he the vendor of the
A the mm of the petitionea-‘ as well an
mm is also disclosed. When thaw stand
the raaponclenm have mm-3 nut with a
c:::rrigfl.un1, :1 mpg of which his paudumd at
An.nem1m-M dated 991 October 2003. Pursuant to the:
/
INN-.UH'”l muunm ‘UH?’ Wfikfiiflflkfimfifi fill??? W.uf’?.(“§..#W.§ %J%'”‘ flflafifififiwflflwfl. WEWW wwmmi VAJI” Wfififlmfiifififl WEE??? Waufiuifififlfl Wfi” mnnmmamawu l¥”M\}E”°é mmwwa WV mmwmmwmw-3. !£’1lt£W.1HK”w ’em-
aa:tra,t1aebou1:zdar7wagixaantnthae}andtebeaoqu5fez1
i.e., Sy.Ra.154/10 no the mutant af 2 amm 33 ”
sought to be altared imofiar as the: T’
perusal of the mild’ um T_
the. notifications iaaued earlier, g
in unsung’ the mm of the gr well
as the bomzwlaries. At the
woke up and has and tha
acquisition V’ can-igendum
appe.ar_i_n_g aubmim that a perusal of
3 that the land in question
He: furthaar submits that
waasmea 5 acres 13 guntns and
pcfit%§£3ex’ has purchaaed only 2 am and mm
. 221 favour of rmpomlent No.4. He: aha submit: that
re-atnvezy, the land bekuzghtg tr: the petitioner is
shown an Sy.No.l54j1;’5 and that of reapondent No.4 an
Sy.K::.154/16. Tlnm acmrding tn him, in the ahserace
Mww wwwma WK’ rwmamafimmmwwfi WEWW mwwaw mm” mmstrgmmsimmm HIWM wwwwwszaa WW W.&%W¥%.&’%@#*%W%fl<% WEWW 9m'
of any spefic identifiaaiion ef the End an
bebrgfing to the petititznar or reapouimt No.§~,. '"
entire aequiaitinn m canmt ha % J' 1 V
wauld tebr on certain
4. M;-..hya1mzns:
appearmg’ for u mg’ ummh;
to be aeq1J.ia’ed§ eoume.
when as well an
the the prevail. He fi11-that
submit; pmceetzfings in rmpeot cnf
been afirmed by this Court and
In the circumstam. he
in é. small varh 15911 at variance” , the
WWW W*O4H””£$.i§’%¥£t’¥I»rW””&J£99f”‘¢2.’&’1.W”% iii!
AA ‘ a aubsmntsial ground ta quash the
mumwmwww ~umW.wt~}e¢rM*MLm
Mxzfiisgi Vfiabarad, Iaarmd counsel
for the Bcmrd auixmzim in support of the
amtemnnt of objesctioxxsa that theme is no ambiguity and
RWOPIIII …-.. -_…-….. ….. ….. ………—.- nu… an-.-u-1-mun av -cuaaurua x-nun vnvmvavuwa aw LGIILJJ
Siflfiefi Ezhera was a m£s’taE§::: in am bsmfiafiea s;=r1 f.-:.I:_:¢
suuthern afixieg. mrrgenéum was iasusé. Ea
aubmiw zéxat at: extant 52:? 22 acres. %~.€:it>ngi:2§p;£’ i;’¢_: H
wfifiamr 11$ smugixt ti} baa
gamma belmgirzg 21$ aha fmsrtizfi
be acquirafi. 2-{mm fiwre :3 gm;
tha ianzi ts Em amuima ‘sgawgburtii
Imyandent,
6′ .V;¢.eai’Ii§:;§’ fifiififiai agspearim
far rwk§o r1zi:a:;i’:§_§ :>;?$:;;:’;3;.L1§.%_:n.i;:’:fcé if at: fixmni of
33 guntéa ‘bA*+.:EsI§a Rafi is amquimmig be
im no e:~»?é;j§L-~::->.s:;i%I:,§.zr.21:iV; ._ 2 fimmhar aubmits fimt fixer
~ pmym:
incur: -nwr wnwuluu”-aver’ -e
V VV fiuhmifiaimiji by {Em
Id’! In-nu
‘V “«’_?. E ~ fgixzézi my mmfim atim: “:9 $323
magi a§ far
3. inzim, Erfinfayakiimar Sfiatii 13 3%’ Ex ia
fixm in & ginfifi get $5
Judi IUJ HUI” VIIIAIIIUIIA av dnI£Il\fIl glfurrnlu
wrtmlé m%3n?y prfifi may the
%summ:a;:xm. Ea fia right in $ab izkmfé r
fir
“””””‘”‘ *6″‘-“WWI Wm*a«mw”‘mwur”«a- mmwmwrmin wwwww WM! – – – \ . . ..
WWHWXQQWWWKWQEWWQ IIQMWHT9 “b«a’%miWMWkfl WWW wmmxwmmmrmm fi§'”fil$’5na5|Hé””% %.ss’M|V%’fl’W4.§ Emit Fi”is§’§.2’K3Vl5r53*’@:.§a¥”HH’%4£§”‘5e ?§”fi¥%’¥”&1 %u%#’ia.»3lW§s.% Vsmflfi” ¥\lP”§\E’k9<"*&:W"'I«¥ofl"'fi¥°&W'% W'"ll'ia3K'H 'haw
when the acquisition pro-o::eodm am uphmld, the
are loath to quash the mrqukifinn pa-owedings ~
the ground of oermin ambiguity. But 3 K
uigrfifzcant in the case on
Sy.Ho.154 mnanmea 14 scam 3.?' V'
notification would dhczlnse
claiznanta to the; said' Mam the
petita'nnt:a' as well an would
with penom whose.
mg ,a pm — mm am mm
x’ flmt thé acrvw ?’ guntas in nc-rifled for
in the final nntifianatiran, only
33 guntaa is nntificd for acquisition.
% 1: is true that the final notification wauzd
” V nams cf the vendor: cf the petitioner as well
Nc.4. But lzuwevar what is aigzfifzcant is
aneartearxtoffi acres 33 gtmtas is shown as against
thenam:aofthevendorofthepetifi:uner.’I’1mboundar’ns
mm are: on thy: castnm side is Sy.l’Io.153; on the
/ \
8
&SlII\J9 IIQIRII Illvnnvivuial saw! -I-I-I9″!-FUV __-!””””” “””‘” “”‘”””””‘ “” “”‘”‘ “”””‘”*”‘”””‘ new pa-ways’:-In -any -an-waaawaua llhllll VIEVAIVIIE VII HE} .LGlfl%..,l’gl
aequiwfi. Ema hQ§Ef§’5.%%33′, fimffi shaéi gm “% $333?
fiflhnfi fig tbs awnm” im Eéeéxag amzxirmi. En ‘ H
mm can mfw in éxa dmzifiian fif
cafie 92? mmsstas 33.. mza
E C.
731 which wazaa; <:1m}y eafm:=:::a ¢ m%%'fié:*"é'}.;f tbs
iand mum: be }3$._1.i mi: which
is atmghi tn be Vvreitéyatafi 1:233?
rim Ame suégfi fig rmamm
mpnrfi i I I;"'§£"§1iK3%1. reads thus:
"Langri é';£:i<;§;:i3'i*€ ?2<3e:;i"-.§.9:i?é,, 1934 us}; «« Hatifimtiofi -=
._ -= '¥$g':';.;22:-.*::::%a — fibaenca sf datafias surf iand
' 93:" hmfifir in whézfi iafifi is
. sf dataiia sf tifw puiczfic gurge
€43? ,_ ir'1'!.%:i=.5a& awquisififln —~ $635.3 vifiazm the
as; wall as the acquimitiwn;
VT Iiziereigr atafirg the pubiissz puzjaase 21% b
“i”$sifi$fit?1&l”§ haéfig mt afwugiz.” fi-
irmsmuafi $3; the fixtami 3? Eafi
…-………—- -…_….;..
‘” “”‘ ‘W W” -‘V *”*’V-ifmgfnn nu: w.vnmv,n nu LCIIUJ Htm-I vxvwmsvx £0 13330:) R93-I V)|V.i.VN3V)i $0 1.8003 H94?! VXVIVNEIVJI :10 18003 1
$115.3 W 2’7 ii ,5 Z
fi fi§ R$ $5 Elfiéfifi .$E
reperm if: ($993119 see we, Whisk mas .f_
“Lanai Aequimm Am, §3§4~;~«-4-V” $.»§ r§ga:::*m§t:¢g;
mm: – vaguexzm – Hausa?’ é§*s:;?ri1é§:£;;é::.:”‘§9ifV ékgsggf
Lands i.¢., snug numhaiif ‘fig Kfiaaiia VA
mm: mm sf midawnééifi’ iafhaéigz-. warm
acghi ta Em g”ié;?<'é'zL'v:–. j4-« '§*§§1c1,
mgue — Heanm ~—«
High asxiufisifinn
mmpanafifion
in rmyéégst iarldztswnezfis -~
' acguixsifiwu
as am mgr mm in
quzfiéiéiafx. ~ Wifli I Ia? withiga tifiem
3%? 'gig finurt in the was :3?
‘I’:&K.3:. Afifl
in. am 333% R33 22. in the ease
aa stsfgaefl wrfier, them is mmugh mguarms
amnfugiun wseamd ‘by fim Emrd in imtfimg {Ema
VA irmsmush as, bath thif: gzatiaiazxar 3.3 Wfifi
$5 rmmxfiant E%”3.é are rm: a’s&*ar=& mm”! wiiwfiy abiflus
,{
guuggygp-ggqugg ‘.uuw–w-1-uurnu —r 1’1!-Q?-Z-Tu<_w¢.gp -. ..,.– —-.-.:_..-w._— ……-…- …….v.–.–.–..-v — .—-..- –n –_—–r ———–: g.-um»:-.n -urn.—…– –.,. ,",…,'.'.',., .-g',,5' """'I'"'v.'fl, =€ ml-'vi'
af the fast as. in whim. gm'? af tlmir Eané; ix
azzquixwfi.
Q, “I’}1§s fajitas us Ea tha Cfiffgfififilliii i.*3i$.’1;.i$§_» §:ij%::t£1§ u
Emxfik § the praamhée amf
diaeieaes: thai. 331% fizz: §%_V.ca
21% 33am sf ‘him awmmzsaza. the
mrrfieifium £3 Smszimigv fim said
zzixrjzzf:-;:f5f– _;7wtiA”‘$t*:.I.*.§}§ $1.31: &a
:3€:nf:m:1d.@d hamzfimém
am 3E§e3°§¥_fz”–‘:—-a;s VA”‘«:~.>v%”‘; Sy,E{m.1f;:3§ mrt {if
134; 36, -f 5? 134»; m :54; :11?
154; mg 154;§% zmmm gm – :51; and
V ” an ‘thv-53′ Sé.i’.:’§a ..r___R’r:,:I&§.4
~ it apptzam téxea Eifiarfi wantafi fifi
‘ am the saméham aifie is fimw tixafiz
x~.$m1 ma ms: 31% fafifiay Ens as mimm.
2 it Wm ta b& an? tim vaw fientéfiy asf the
, worum certa:in1y flange, izammuefi 3%, mm: £3
3 mien’: af lanfi belarxzgixg aithaer in tha paattrifiianer GK’ ta
ma rwpsarzfifiilt $233? is 3-zzugfii. 22:: km asquimsfi. G2: the
J.
~ ” ‘=Z%:_ff ju:$5’§5.c§; Ezxf
H. —- .—-. …. -11 annual’:-I ‘I’_.lnvJ”‘Il’I vnvsvlvqvn av LGIIUJ fl”-‘EH1′! VHVLVNCVX QC LIIHO3 Haifl VXVLVNBVX |
. «W
2.3
gamma :33’? vagxlfifima fi%@§}fi, fllfi naifgcaiimxm am ifmbkr–«:0
fie quasheé.
13.. Ezaéwfig ax: afiafi. wag '4 $.P:at:i3., Iaarmaci sanriar ' £§:§;*"=:i;_
mpanezmm 5 35%; :5 aha: ggifig ax: %%
in rmpeat ctf a ymjacéi has ihia
Cesar: sham ma: 3%. ‘ms
or K…%%,!&ti’;:’.’.-£g£;iv_.;V Ema xesbaexrvezd
that the ymrmdings. 15
{mt the if firm awnezr mf the
kid ”3 thaé: awalfi mg: {Em aanéa
an llaifi. Exzéasfi, ii :13 mt 9. case
either in tfm petitinmr :33:
“– _.44_:*es§§c:#§ies;%;t:;. is ifiantifmhieg it £3 aha mm imam’: as
is the when? 35′ land which the §e§:i1:?1m.°mer* er
‘. —._ i%@a(§:;%z:*:t’:.c1e3’1t 1*I¢.*§r 3.1% Eiéceiy tm Essa. irmsmtwh as, what.
wen. ghaw 31$ SyxI¥$,1;'”Er«%,€§.Q mms’&.:a1*:irL§ 2 amm 33
gutxiaa % sryght 125 ‘% aaquimé, whsfi afiaz” tbs
pumhasa ‘Q3′ thus getkianar as we}? as 3’%§flI”fi&I1’E’. 3&4;
Jr
.–..– .-..—-.—– —- —–v– -_ —- —- —– — —- ——v – — –~ – —- —- –‘-v —H vn–luv!-urn av I-Illii-Ial I’l?.a|’if’I v)|v.|.vNqv,a :|u ,|,a;]u;_}
{km aam L3 gab-=divids:§£ and gfimdgai mm 15%; 15
154} E5. when fim axaent cf Iaxfi
paetifimfiex w rwgwxzémit H34 fa. Iifixcsé bc u
{If the mm’ fiwt an that aemmg flifzti; §sb¢1’ei§@’:fig;;
be §3’1te1’fez” ed; The& fieieéaimi % ?afi§E:1{iA :$’:fi§:£§;%£?jLi”$1§a’».§iaf;:§;¥§!A’5f€f;$’
case where ‘the mud cf” the
the mmnt and {Em ggm $12
nthsgr gmumfia ‘Whiflh is
not ths mas: has§1f”&s’.: visw tlimi
fim V
Véfigdar 5% gmfisfiz
{1}
{2} E3::r9gii§;::a;é.€:is§$:1 géfi: Ammexixra-3% wk wfi}; aa:
at skrmgxnre-Iv!
“-
‘ _ £3] £t”~.i$ :f§’p$ez;i””f:m* figs rmmnémt Beam ‘:3 idramify
W H ‘T .. the wfmfih they pmspms tr; aceguinas.
pefifigngr as we}! ag rmgzfient $3.4 shafi
tfzia prmmfiims aa natim ta téhammfi fiis
their abjac$2’3$ Wififlirl & wrisd uf fam wmim
fram mziay. fl
/’
._ .. _ _ _._. …… ,.f…. u. -…nuu nu: av umuu fltllfl VNVLVNHV3 £0 .l.lll”lO.’.) H911″! VXVLVNIVX 30 1.3003 H91?! V)|V.lVNllV)l $0 131101)
{5} Haiiézaz {Em psfiaimnar mi’ rwpazzémt
11% firm wait far the flifilfi mp}: mf V V.
finale $3 ismiw Mfi. mmila abméutg ta ‘A
fnrfifmatavd amye.
«saw.-gnu