IN THE men comm' or KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 9% DAY 09 DECEMBER, 29-99
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MRJUSTICE N. K. PQTII":
AND 4'
THE I-iON'BLE MRJUSTICE B;'sR1;E§fIVAs;3E:"GdWm2iT_i
M.F.A.No. 1 17.o4pf 2006 (mi;
BETWEEN:
Sri. P. S1.11"y2u1a.1'ayé31i1:;11' IT"<'.:-'1_.V('5*.
S/0. R£iI]]E1(',hE5U1C1l'??1.-..._
Ageci. £1})()_u'E".;)(;:T: 1V1:_1_i* E",z1--._\,».%c)}_.1 15..
8:;--111'g;e;x1é_5'r@3.V .6" 5 5 0 ti 1) '/'~] _ . .
= ' * % A1.:)p'\7_21" P:fi21sz1<:1. A<Ev.)
1 3 "'ITA'1"m_N§%V:j1V1'3('iiz=L Ass31..1a'a1'":<t Cu. I,E.(:i..
R(v5;L_§ia(}},'}i1§.VU"fkfi('i(E. No.72.
, V[.}1'1i.ty'Efizfiitflixlg A1'11'1c:x(_.*.
'""'~E\/Iiv:je:ai(3-ii Road. B.:111§ge-11(.>1"(' 27.
I'Q.' 3}):'t3S(}1'11.(?C1 1:3}-' R(:gic>1'1.211 E\/Ia11.:1gc1'.
'I'J°i1". L. News-L:'2.1_j._ E':/I2.1_j1*,
' "S/0. i,;=m:~ I..,i.1:§__§z'1i.z1]'1.
i\"'E21jo1". N().8E5., Kim (IIr'ss;.
X/'
K;-1}i d :1 R(.)a.1€1._ S1*i1'"1z-1g:11'.
If'3e'=111, --« 50.
I"~{c.=s1)()1 rd '¢;§_1'1'i.$
[By Sri. {Q}. Gi:'iy23p})a for Sri. M. §_VIa1'1(.12-m;1;':1
.;'\ci\:'. 1'01' R1 . R.2v Sc1'\rcan;
JucEgzmer1t and 21w-*a1'd ('iatc?d: 2.1.()4.2.()(.}8 p:¥1.s9.~:.§:'<1.,_"i;;1_.=M\r'{'3_*
N0.2494/2002 on the f.'i}.@ of é'j}~"1.§*iX A(:E'c;:i]_. '¢;J?:V_:i.:'igE:b. Mcmbcrr
MACT. Met1'0p()]i$.:'u1 A_1'c.2=1. £43;-_1__1_T1Vg».2;1_lc:V1j_m'1j:;)p%';='1;s'21iion'A2:1.i'1d scictiiixngg
c:11ha:1ce111em. of C()11'1pt§'X".?3'€511fii(31"'£.1
"H115 e1p})<:._=.e:'1E_ 1' 1 }'r1é2i:1"i1T1g,{. this; day.
N. K. PATIL J; cEi%;';Li.'2c21'c%ci_ 11;':-T1eff''1'}owi'i*1g;___i
"Thm'appmfiTm;u¢z_;
(1
I 'é'1}§e"1i'1'1'r.<;'i" " '(.116 '_']"L'1(.i_L'§r'11'.24§}4/2()()2 on
'=*.:.h<: Qf,i.&1.£} IX. .?\cf1'"(i'}';'§J1,1c.E.g,{&r. E\/!c=,1'nbcr MACE'. MCI" 1'c)pn1itz.11'1
£_'_x1'5<;f¢_t [SCICE---I~ 32) {}'1(t1'ci:1af1c-Ea' 1'vib1'1'<%(i to as
"Fri 131.1 I'12.1E~' ~f'(_.i{i.-- 'r.')T1*e\.-'ii'.y).
V' A. "I'1'1e 'E'1'ih:..11"1a1 by its; j1.1.(.I;§1'n<--*1'1t". zmcl awv;-1:'<.L
_ :e'.:1'*._*xsV'2fi'1'(i'<?.z.':.
few 91_1r§-_ic1'icsa. 1')1.11'i1'1g i1"1is~_4 pc1"io(:I. 2'=1p1:3<~_*1lz;11"1I 1'1':i;;}'1E. 1"12'x\*c-=5'
s.+1)c1"1't' s1.1b$i211'1ti;11 :-11"1'10n1'11 1<)\\=~'211'('1e; v()1'1\sc:y2-1.1"'1ss 2.1.1"1(i IN('?(1i("é?-1_1jm"'(?'X'[')(.f'I'1:9:fi'S;
"I'11C.1'¢-:?f01'c7. ("m acc.*m:1'11 oi" i'.1'1c: i1"1_}'u1'§c.s an:=;1.;.a.ir:~(i"~?i333"~.1:ii:i1'1. iii'-'w.
i'1'1L===~d. 2.1 cl:-;1im pc;*ii1'io1'1 (':1z"1i11':.:i1':g...jj}'(.>iV1'}.1.jc:1'i$re21'1"iV('n; =:;,9f"
R:~;.25.0O,O{)()/A zxgztillst Iflfié' ré's+;};)§>11(iVE-:'1-3_1'é. V
4. "H29 S2116} (.:1a*i.1j1'1 pctii"io.fj"--}"1i:1_-(:1 c:<m'1'C"H11-be-*fb1'<'r the
'1'1'i'm.1nal on 2154436. Tjjiiltt""7§.'i;'i1f)1I1_§é'Ei-1§2 E'fl%C?I' 1':t'2'11'i1'1;g 1.110
1<:'2'11'1"'1e,c1 (:c')t.11'1s:?}',(_)1"1. ?3<ig11'1 'é%s_.i'1jd 2.1fi:t-:1." (1()1'asi(:1e1'i1"1§;§ '1:l"1('
Ora}. zmcl (1<€ic't11.3';:=3:i":Vi.'2-§.1"y4'93'-i_(Li't~1__1Vi'fc~"zf1\.<:;-ai}2:E:)1c on 1'1"1_ WiV:1 pa1"1 znlcl zt\v;=-u'('.1c-:(.1
'<':<11"n1:)1-2-I'1s;a1icm 1:;-if' 523/ -- wiI::.l1 i11£,er-9,531.. -at. (_.*'fi?«"<":; _p,i:t.
{mm 1.12..(? c.121_f{'{* Q?' pc.*:"i1.i'("';1'1 t" iEi I:1'1c (i2.1I (" of ('1c_rpsi1:.
B2'-i_i11g 21gg1*ic\I-'cc.i by t,11(: i1'm)11g1'1('::(:1 J1:(:'1gc1'm*1'1:
i'n.1(i-?'_g1w2::I3tAi., 1Fic."1-t}:)pc2}}a.1'"1I. llas ;'>1'css(:-1'1tL~(.i 1_.l"1is; 2-xppc'-411. rm
,'»I"rib1_11'1;»=i.T' i1."'12.1c1c.(11.:e«1EC e';1_n(:1 1'<:q1.:i1"cs; @1"111;11'1 ""'---_;3;:'(.>..i'1i":},.-* I141'
. 1i2.()'(11'i"3/i2'1;;;{,t1'1.c:j11ci;g1"ne:1t :;--and e21w:.11'ci <1f1.}"1c% '_1'1'i1':)1..11'1-(~11.
X'//J/fly
6. \-V(_' lmvc }"1Ei'z-1I'(I1 the 1()&.1I'I1(.'(1 ('i(:.)1111s(:} a'1p;)c'%z.1.1*i:1;__g
for {.310 21ppc*.E12e111!". Ellld t1'1<':? 1c'2;1.1_'1'1' F01'
ihc: res )o1_1c:'le1T1t No.1 ---- 31131.11";-1i1{'(,". ('70. for <:.r...»..1j'1}~'3_' :f';~1i")"3c
1e.11gj'r.1'1 of Ume.
7. '.I.'1'1<' 1c21r1'1Cc.1 C()111"1S'€.j3 ;-é-:;§3§:)C2+,1'i1-lg" 'I"'<'5'1-i,._ '*--?§;1I1.<.?
ap}.30i.12u'1I.. s141i31'11it:t:ec'1 11'12:1t.*f.i1.§: '§'I"I~b1V.'ki'].zV;:1§* E:'.i'§.f:t*'(.}Vii} :%1I'. »
axvarciillg j1.::4:.1_ zmci I:C?E'1S()I'1E}}%T%"».i'.("€311péf'i"S%E.i.fi()1A'¥§ mwarcis
11'1c(iica.} exp(>1'1ses. Ec')s.§% «1'1'cz:11111@1'1'i. ;:3('1"io(T1.
(['1'1vcy:;':.1'1c:c:, r1(;1:,;'x'E§E1i1}.g" V'f:"(.>--:.{;:'§;1 ('é11z'211"g;{ct$ and
$039 of 2:1131€::fI4*1'i:;[I"3'§;'__?._. tI.q..C:1 2i1'J €i'.V; "cVté>:fi"1VV1V:1'1i1tad c*1'm1' in not
z1\x!a.11'c.iii'*:g uzlny"V.<i'fa;i1pc:5'111Ts'z':1~1.ion §'w;-:1r'(':1ss §'1.m2:'e:? 11'1L:<.1iuai
ex_;3e11sc.s.VVTE:-iM1:,i1.'1gg _i1'11. ()"('3(§nsiC1(?1'2111011 the 112;1!'m'c of ir1_ju1*i<:z<;
&=1I."1{ii»"f'.l'1¢? x'1V1z;;1.E'urC'"--:,11f1__§i__«gé1.1mt.i(:_)1'1 of II'("?'c'.!11'1']('",111I. ihv '1'1'iE:)111"1ai
(_:L.1Vg}'1t.. t.-Q Vi=12.iv_c§" é1_\.var(ied '§14t:a'£' e':u1ci 1*(?z1s;<):'1e1.!3}c ('J)11'11')('1'1Sé.l.¥'i()1I
1.
11:’ :,<'ié:~f 1'1'1€~.fi?i;';'3() <.=.re 11C2 1Cl-S.
As 2’1§2_2T1ir’1si. this. the C(“‘JL.111$(.’] fm” £’i”1c=’ E’1′.1’s~;1.
“2i’C5}’f)'(1′)’}’1Ci(?I’1T’ —- Ir1surar1(‘:o C1o.._ i1’1!.<=.=1' z'1.§i21.. ct<_)m.(-=.=1"1clecl %i"1e.1I., iiw
<70}11'1}:3er1$a1;ior1 z–1wa11'(iiL'(" by 1.1"w "i':'ihu11e-11 iss M31251' ;u1<'"1
(1
I'('21S(')1'1E'lb}t:'. 2'.k1'1('1 docs; 1101. (re-11E R31' i1'1tc1'ib1'c:1co amzl 1'1'121.'i the
<":()1'111)c1T1sa1ion E.-1W£E§1.l"dC(1 is 2-1fi.(t1" (Im-* (.*(_)1'}s:ei<'1(_#1'21Eimzftif {he
01':-11 2=111c'1 <"1nm.11'n~;~~-..’ L’ , A’
9. Affi-?1′ (*::11’e>f11l pc1’usal'()’i’7-.i.A.}’1c%_ _;1V1fi’1’_’;_L§Vi1’j.<:f:I_ .z–11";d
zxwarcl 2"11'1d aftcx' (*1"iti<*zi:11 t:'\»'£1iL!2.11.i'QI1 -.()i" ilié-:~ .,ix-1;:fi\i.§T:*'i§Ei… E321.
I"(".'("().E'd. 1"}'1c only poim. t'ha;1t e11'is:»(:
“‘VVh€t h or LE’i’c-‘-~~.f1’1’iE?a’i_:1 12}’1}- 1j1:–1,¥;’ – ._231\v211’c.16i’.} ‘E 151’
2u1i1i1:}(};’1s23fi’i(i)1’1
~._’o1” (‘)i.::f_ C(‘>.1_1.$’*i(‘1é}–2’2é.’f i’i)1″1 is : V
10. ‘1’h_<;*. «'Zf§'i'i3Lzriz11 -.1t1'g;.1::;:_Ey' z§5rw£"11*c'1_<'éc'1 21 51.211] of
Rs.80.0'()"O"/~"–.}if(:)\ve1"i:'§Ci':; "'p}§1j1'1 éii"'1"("'1 2.[1go1'1y. 'E';211{i1'1g 1:110
-£5-{)1£-5id€1%€1ii1iQ11–[.111(37-I§Ie3:E;i1;1T§3″‘Qi.-~.i.I1ju.1’iC:+s..§u’1_(}. L110 s:1u1″g1t.i0n _o§”. .
E1″cat”r1j1Q1’11. t:I3.<-:: Vs:;1V1V1":c? is .=;mc1 1'(';'z;1$'s()I1211:)1(: and (f1()t:'S :10!"
' '*<–.:a H " :'7<.)E' ii..mc:r1*}':c1*c-2.t:1CCC "" " A
V'»1'§";.r:;t '.1"1"ib11z'1a1 1'32–15% c-:~=.1*1"<:c.'1 in E:i\-'\«'a'-11'(¥i1'1g__f';
Rs.'I£_{}.OOQ/'4~–_.:.'0w211*cls z'};'1<;*c'1i(é21§ (:xpcn$e$. As; 21 1'112m'.r of
” -‘~__ f.7:;1.<-¥.. .2is.sV__ '31'ig%'1€',.1},.'I pui1'11'c('1 out 1'3}-' thczi I(:a1'11e(1 (}i(')1..11'}s5<?E
T £r_;:}vp,(:;:i.–1"i11{g§ for £110 app-'
i12"m1.. 21;)p1§izu1i. 11.213; im:z.11'r<.~(§
1'1'1c?(.Ii("'21} CX}){T1'1.y ‘£}’1(:’. (f)1’ia-‘£112.11 Iz”1r~31i1’211}(‘.’c*. (f0. V.I-‘-I.a\*i:’1\;3_;
r<.:_;_;'a1'(i to E.1'1 ihcts and (éirnri1.I’1}st:e’1m_’css of tE’1g’f “-“ii>0jT..
‘{.()W2;1..:’c1s3 nmdical exzpemses.
12. ‘E’E’:e ‘1″rib1m2=-1.} 11;:-3.T;e.,’_ £.i\.1.=’2’i1’.(.’I”(‘(I <)1'}1f§.I?. Rss«L5.'C)f'}()/
{<')x\«"arc1$ 1’1\»’ey2a111(‘te. 1’1<)1.1s'is17i:'..1_1 g_ foo'ci_-. 2111'1"(1 ¥.;x1tc:'1<'Iz=1111
(':1'1.211*g.§e.s. Tile-=;' .<.:;2'1.i(i1 'm1L<_)i';–1'}1' {is §iE.1g1'L"iV_(:'f}'1"ii:}'I(T. £01' rm-= ;'('as<)11
t.1'1e,1t. appei1a1'1t w;1_s 1'.:11);1.1.i_e-;f1_'1";:. fax' :1'1;_}.1i’:_ “}.12″zi27(é S]”V?i(3’f~.’F1″f. V'(f:o1:’1ssicierah!e ;m1ou11′!
mw21r(1:~3 (‘t<)h'\:*.ti'jy211"1:1§c.,'r:..cj)11ris.}"1i11g {noel 211ml £LH('I'1(i12ll1f
"("'.I§'<"1'1"\;*;:Z'L"i'.S. " "'E'1j1ercf0-;:,(?%". "'«'21°\xs2,1i*d' "R54-.'2-O,-()()()/+ ' ' '%<)'\\.r;;11*<'%ss,- .- – – –
ct11\:’1_A1i’i’s”.11_i:’i’;_§ ik_>0(I 2-md z:1t’1c-x:’1c:12mtT. (‘ha
}3., 7i’h..r_;r ‘iI.”rib1..u”1211 }’}£I1S (_’l’l’t’T(‘1 in 21.xv2.1..rc’ii11_g orxiv
f5<s§3{};OV()£AT/'v.+__ E:':s$
— 21nd “rI.is;{;(‘)11i}k):’E.. 1.1′ 1101’ in c’E.isp1.:1″c $1131 2.1ppc1}231:.”2I
“, “1.l}:(‘i£3f_1’\V(fi”}’E’. t’w<,) $1.1rgL*1'ic.s 2,1 mi fiucr <'1o<'mr 112-as e='1tIw'&3(.*.'.~',:.~5("('§ E??):'"§"?rE;
(TI1sz1 1i')Ai1it:U\;T it) p2u'ti(%1,:1211' limb 21nd 3()% c:'1is2_1_13i1it.y to t'.1'1c:
/I
:'\c'<_.*(..)rc1.i1"1§.__;'1y. we e~1\ve11"d R_es.i2.(i)?i_E-)()41/*T lm.v;;'11'c'is 108.5 0%"
i1"i('(')111c.'. c;1111"i11_s,§ E.2"1i('i up pc'.'1'i(3C.1.
15. I’1..11’t1’1c_%:’. 1110 ‘.i’ril:)1..m.aE £12515 z2’1wz.11″c:i(:’E-‘–___oniy
Rs.8.000/- t.(‘)w2=11′(‘1s f1.mt1″(-” I’11C'(1i(‘Efl} (‘..\’p(‘1’1s0>:. “i”‘}’–r,{V-b{0;:'”tv<)z'
112213 ()pi1'1c=;*d mat t':<:m'.ziu".ivc-' (:<")st'. for st11';:c-?1jv 2;-xjingil i1j1T::':if.'E:;f1:*..2_-;i} V'
cxperlscés will be ;<_q.12.0o0/– to 'I?'%?.L§.AA'1V.{'f3','(},'(f)(j',1«/–; i,jw&;g\\r;;«;~(j%: 3
smn of Rs.§2._OO()/A E()\x=*a1"('1sV fut.t11'<: 'I"'£.1_(,'(1i'("d']Vf_ (}§;}')(f'!'1$(}'F§'»'EIVS,
1
21g_{e1.i11s’i’ Rs.8.000/- ‘d’W&1I”C1(;'(‘1 ‘E’1″i}.;)V1″u_’1_2’11’;.
E6. In thv ]ig§E’T1t of 5?;}’V1c 2=:’iV)a5v(_.y_zV-£’1’v1_’§’.1V f(_i;1″ ‘i.}T1 E'()1’e’;_;’2,_1’I’V.1″i”i’et§.{‘~…}py .i:11wc>ci in pé:1I”l” ‘ 23131 . Vi”‘E–:Ve>’ _juc’1§2;I11.c.t’1t” z’1..t:’1c§. e’.1\=\»-“z’;1.:.'<::i <::iz:1.t<"'c.i
:21.<)g:1;;:2;'oaes pa"s:.~:\¢g1 1'1"1:MVC N'o_24.94./2o<32 cm the me or
_v}\cA_:E.(..E.]..:xI1.:c1gL:. E\/icrm}:3c==:1" E\/1A(.'.'l.', M{:)f"I"();.)()}ité-?..I1 ;"\1'<-';21.
— as~:1,.:1i(‘]C1’fi: . ‘
r’\
1551 12), is E.’1c-;*.1’C}.t)y 1’m’)z.11<:.1p is
I///'