WP No. 130532097
IN THE HIGH COURT 0:? KARNATAKQQQQ ' ' *'
C§RCL¥I'I' BENCH AT_§)H»ARW_s5a'I}' ~ -- :: _f
DATED THIS THE 18? DA? '&
Baéagm u. .
THE HOAVBLE MR.JG§fiET:':'Ic:-%§_"';~Ig>.
BETWEEN: 'V 1'
S/0 Nagan:ago'Wd&,_...';-_V ' _ _ " = ' »
Aged. about 48 --:j';*é:ars, " '
R/at somaIapura'*%Image; A
B:€11aI'§:"§'a11ik"§%I£1Cl IZ%isi:fi§:'i:.._ _ -- ...Peti{i0ner
{By sx~;'}';3.S;-Y;§c£ra,3::.§i; »£§-:iv._.:)"
' _S:'iv.'i}iie*;;2:;1 Sauna Mafiappa,
. Sf? K*3lfibfi39€P3?3&.
' Aged V:--:1}'3'c;}:i .53 yams,
%R/at Semaiapura Village,
and District. ...Resp0:1dent
{By 'S:i.";;_3asava;«aj, Adv}
» This ysfifion is flied 11n::h.=:r Ariiczies 226 and 22'? 0f £3116
" T '{IJ031,s£:i€utio:1 of India praying to $61: aside the ccmon order
€¥'fi;.18.7.2{}8? an IA NOJEI and W in E.P;34/2905 passsé.
_y}3§;r'£¥:1e learned; 2314 Add}; Civil Judge (Sr.®n.) Baflaxjr', at
" &z:1n5X1;re«& and 51:43.,
This petition: (taming an fer pmliminaxy hearing in 'B'
gmup, this day, the Court mafia the following:
w? No. 13057' ;200':v'
C} R D E R V
1.
The petitioner is the judgment; debtor. _”‘”I'”he’
is the decree helder. The suit by 1;-ém’
money has been decreed €r;1..e ‘e;ia1,’V:C’»0ur’fg Lee
petitioner to pay a sums of at the
rate of 24% 13.3. The execution in
Execution ?et:it;ion. Now3%¥{2{.3rO5.V – _
2. The pf counsel for the
petiti0Ixer”ia;. has been issued eieariy
in violaiiofl _§::>iem~ Xx: Rule 3’7 of the Code
of Civil Prwegiure :i3_ms;.11E1:1§:E1 as before issuance of the arrest
A_ wa3fréznt_x1;-:9 Shem’. V,c_:_a;u»se notice was issued. He further
‘5jihmi:£e_v “‘.~”sf;_i¥3seque13.t1y,_ the judgmem éehtor entered
two applications i.e., fer recalling of the
313$ aise fie ascertain Whether the judgment
K Ldebter V533 means to pay the deereetal ammmt The irial
.’ has iejeeted both the apialicaiions. Tszm more
“éippiieatiens are flied by the }3€f;iii02£1fiI’ inflow’ IAs–HZ and EV
emre again for determining whether the jueigeeent éebtor 13%
WP No, 1305′?/2007
in a position ta pay the ammmt and also fer .
eafiier order. Both the app1iCaiiOI}§”§3IE I”€_jii;:?”C”lit’i-.’3: ” ”
which the judgmfifit. debtor is beforfi-,:’t§1i3′ A’
3. I have perused the . as: ‘as the ‘V
impugned mder passed; Cfyurt oi} all the:
app ficaiiens .
4. Appa:en_€1jf; ;;j[f’i3: not gustified in
Izzjecting the arrest warrant.
I:1dced§ if”§1as: 531 of the Code cf Civil
Pr0cedfi rs:%,vhi§::i1 with 21 pewsr to execute and
9113 of the’: Iliixdés Qf;€.x€r;ufi o:1 in respect. of I’€’COV€I’_§7 of money
* is the 3;4i1t:i”g;:1$11t ciebtor in civii prises}, Endetzd, the
§1*<'"«:«'i:'2*:':';:*:*;<;::"axféiiltiialso indicate that the said order' of detention
£13; F§i"{?'i:i yxiscéfi $3511 {Let be erdemd unless a Show cause natice
is i3s'ua§ '$9 vthe jucigmerzt. dabtor and an cspportunity is given
VA £0 file his objectiens as is Why he shoulfi 1101; be
' ta €116 civfl prison. Imieed Section 51 of the CPC
u required to be rtiaé with Qréer XXI R316 37, Grder XXI
R1116 3? woulé also speak absent the: power to peimit the:
WP N0. ESOSWQOO?
: 4 :
judgment debtar to Sh()’W caursfi against his
prissn. ‘ I’ V
S. A gcrusai of the oxder-sheet wqulgir 4c1ear13.;
no such exercise has been done :’by :2
Indeed, hnmediately after ;
request made by the deems Qzufi has
straightaway iss1:1t:d thé of View that
the said order of in violation
01″ the pxovisioiié. r.fta?jv{);fi:ierV’:XXI Rule 3? of the
CPC.
6. In sbéfai” v§’E3.éV”;L.1’£§V.'(3¥i’€,i:E§:}?’S’ passed by the Executing Court
on ilrfifié: ‘iagypiicafivflfi vef the jusigmeni: debtor so as. iii} ascertain
.ix*h$fE1£;; hfi:.}:§a3 any 33168135 ta gray the dflcltefa}. axnount, the
cannot be fauited.
?, izifilséd; the Exccuting Court Cazlnot go on making a
‘A x V’ Lriovizggg e :iqui3.y as to whather the judgmami iiebtmf has means
. ‘ii? ‘gags; the amount. The factual aspect 0f the matter is not
“disputed. inasmuch as the judgmezit (Ishtar has suffemd 3
/
V/./7
dfigjlfifix Thé Exécuiing Court is aiways obligéd ‘£0 executa 3
W? 539.1305’?/2007
U1
éecree. Indeed, an observation is also made h_j;*..th(f:” =
Judge to the ::fi”€ct that the judgzjcnt d_;+:’bf<§1*i:'_;i:3é;€= _'hav:;j
sufficient means to pay the decre:eia1" T::&.33:o'T;1;1t and : i:t:7:$:
trying to avoid his abligation its safisfj} 'thé r1;ec1*i=;f€§.A..«:
8. Having saié so, i£1i€”‘pe:’titioner i$
enfiiled to succeed o131y’ ‘i£1fl Vjtfofloxxvmg order
is passed: H V’ V V ”
Pfitiiiikfl’ p;3ré:’. ::«’V§’}’1g3:'($¥1it:r pasaed by the
EXeCuti:;g”V {3§iu.1%£ is set aside. The
pefifiofifgr s.}:xé;?.u1 as shew cause notice
to him. the Executing Court and fit:
his 0bj€:€:’£éQns; T21¥é{§:tIza:;rs passed by the Executing Court on
“;§Vi§i1uf5,’t:.I};§L,?;3’€I:”.§:§§}L’j%3§’t7§_E:ltli{}Il$ stamis atenfimscd.
“Rule isstzed and made absolute :0 the extant
S d /_
JUDGE
n Jm,l~=