in THE HKEH comm >MA£;§fif§A§'H
WRIT ?§;:T1T§0£~§ % ;sf{)M,V:ée'%fia=;2 ='I3i"«," 2<{:=m'{G:M»R;c;
3.
1?.
;: 3'E:'2,*'i4;:s Stmiaahayya 3?eI1katapuram.a.th,
"i.A»_gg:mi.%ahui 3'?'j9'E2a3"S, Gcc: Archaka,
S:'i.§€i"aC:§33§:yaT E~;'£1r"ge:x§f:g;;§";§j1;' iv
Sgfg; {}s3;"i23E;§3;1;ti3;3;3*ya Hiremtith,
éégeii "aE:g:mt 33;?' Q jv»2_:é1;?;§,
;'3;:fs:§:aaEs::2g'E%§f&z_£}LWatgVara Gui,
Saundati;-.§.,V ;':;?::w%::;§.1f2;€f:z-1;f€§E.§, §3e§.gaum EI>:1smie::t.
Sri.Ré3v*a3'msié:§d?iy§?éE1 V31"2ka.mpurama$§1.,
R;'a ?é:«s»._t. ';"a3;E.ammm:aa Gudda,
_"E"'a;; E§:a"x}.;:j(§.;a£:£i, Bfiigauxxx Diastrict,
§'§'§E'f§3£}'lfifi".£,
.. fife? £151 §'a;1chaks21arayya Hirematla,
Aged abozmt. 36 years, GEO: Amhaka,
§.?f'«ast Passt Yaflamémaraa G-udda,
n 'T Tq: Sauxtadaitii, Eeigaum §};Esé::*§.¢:t.
Sri.SE1i.'va§mmar E-ikelnaih,
S19 €'i.§1a1'a.n$?1ayya fiimmatim,
Aged abmii 35 yaam, Dec: Archaka,
Rial Past Yaiiammana Gudda,
Tq: Saaundam, Baigsmm ffiistrim.
Qcéicm
#3.
hi
Sri.;l£iaI':garayya Himnaatia, A A_ »
S; Q Mamkazgkmayya. §'§iI'€i3§Ili':?f.fl1,:_' ~ T ..
Aged abaui 33 years, Gare: Amhaka,
E12 ,4' at Post YaEia:z1:naI1aT'(;'§';xdfia',*-_ '
Tag; Samadatti, E%eiga.:;:m~»_;}ist:"i<:'&:. '
Sfi.Smvax:anda;y§,za §~£ir<:z:xz1$f.h-,, *
Sim (Eadagajgrya Eiif€KX1i'%.t31.13.~; . V " a _
Agaaci about 35 yezi3,:?'°s_s,',' f.¥{*:a::3" §aFChéiE{{3., " 2
Riga': Post Yaiiamgziaizxa %.ZmQm--1 yaéwagsg, Om-:V:. .A,;*<:ha}:a,
[ at Ya§§ammz~*;;:a&2b Gxzzicia,
'§'_'q: --§~§muid.r£i:t§; Bzséigafizriz Diatrict.
. S:"i."E31a&a,nagQi1da; R%;aya:1za.gQudr=a_,
' S ,9' 0 E7~§2'::3;£a;t1.;ag0z3,a:};a '"E'€a§:a:1ag0u¢.im,
if Aged ah<m.t «E38 }f§'3&I'$, flea: .!&rchsm<a,
EIj.a1;~.P;0st wifgargoi,
'§'<;:..é3;33;xn.dat£i, Beigaum Biairict.
$:%'I'§fscv'§id«;:§appa Nmiamgm',
fife? Yéflépyagauda. Nfieiafiagar,
Agefivzibotzi; 533 yfiars, 943:2: Arciiaexka,
,4.
ffljaég ?0:<?~i ~Ugm'gaE,
Tq: Saunciatti, Beigaum Efiistrict.
%:'sz'i.A:sh0k KE3;i'.!Zi:°ii,
$3,! 0 Gavindappa K,§.1m";aE,
Aged abzmt 3'? }'af3€%I'S, Cece: Archaka,
Rfat Pom: -Ugarg01,
Tq: Sauasuiatti, .'Eieig::a.:3331 Di3i;ri:::t,.
°»J§<:"~*
31. $r§.Guz't.1pada3:ya Himnzam,
Sin §§1'i.A§.}jpayya §~firm11at;h,:" '.
Agad aimut 4'? years, {)3, A' "
Tq: Sau:1da'¥:'t.§, Be.igg1e;;m E3i7s%I:_nZ«:1:,
1:2. Sri.GaI1gadharayya 'Ei€E§;:1::i11ath, ' '
8,10 Parayya
Agad abmsi: 36'j;§ear::%, QCC2--.fx1T£fE*}a3~£3,,
Rjat: Post --~ Ciiiiakmzgbhi, " _
Tq: Sauixdatti, Ee}ga1:mfE}i§n"i(:%:I,': ._
:3. §?2«z°i.$3r1iwa§?ya '?§a3v.ags§mfba§ir§:'a$.23?.f
S f (3 ?§€a<::i'ia;grya Er'ax:-'aggzm1§a§,imatE1,
A.ge«:i ,.'ar'§:;=z:.c:: Arcllaka,
,? 2:=.=:i: "§'{:%:=;;€; '&?a%§.a:gma::;;3;\V (}:§I:d£:'!:a4,
' " .S»';;",r3.3.1i'}é'::*:§a£:ifi,',' ;¥3€3iga11x1i"'E}i:::j*' Kazwmtaka,
" ~ Rs;c:r ej;fss::T':':1*::a=:c'.i. $33; its 3€':€2Z'€3i'£3I7y,
§}£f2fCl'3.L, .95 Revexmaéz,
}vi';jS.IEik1i§d§:1gs,
f}:r;'A:::bsdkar Vaezihi,
AA ' EE3a:1gaE0m~~5f;i€) G01.
2'; '.§.'he {)::mmi$sé,0nex',
Fa)? Rafiigious 8.5 €.".L'hm'i'§;za.§::ie §*l'E1d.£32'«'VII1vE33'1tf5,
ChaHaam3'pet., }3a21g.:-1iora.
835;"
For Sri Rmmka. Yaiiamma {§mra::~=tha%1a,,. 'T ' -V
Etzigahim.
«ii. Sri Renzika Yeilazmiaa E}é's:2;sti"1a:1§2§,, ' V'
Ya1£a:mI3mar1aguc§a§.a., " ° "
Tq: Samadatti, Heist: E§€§gm§am,"'LA
Rttpmstzraterti §;?.:<¢c1x.jiiVc {Z)£f;z:é:;x*;,
5, Sz'i.E-iimgomia. }??i?i:'e:':g<3:;€';_tf*a},f . ._ --
Sjm Rzuflazxagaxzéa"H;Zmg€:z2.;;(i:'a, 3 V
Age: M,2g§'t2::,V Rf a.::§39st»~"§}?gé5u1'a;g=sii; ..
Tag': $a.%;;:,'§1zi1%;2;i§;§.--i'a_, Dim'; .
6. Sri.Msan§::¢i;ati1aga%§:E.a"Sagxgiviinani,
V 87; {§ «Z-3%e':1.g*:,1as3::'g;;0?:.%,<_i;<za .§*;§m'zd_im,a:1i,
'Age: Eviajisr-,«w._R'fa Ptgzwkigzarzagai,
"3"-'«=_:;_: Saaaxzdaifiii, };'3si§t';- fie:-;igat_2m.
'1?'. Sri. §3ara$anag0;«gd& 'Kafiinggtagmxdra,
; ' fa (§imppa{g0u§ia. Kaiingagazsudra,
' §'a.._ge: _B£Ea§a;r;. i§%'~?£.,--é".s: 'P<)$t-Uga1z°ag0i,
'E":=:;:; Sazgiaémti, Zfiistz Eeaiigaum.
T' §:'?s.*rfé*'.-.§B7a.::?£.é';§.,%vi':v£':1g<)?.;3da Parasharuslrzi,
A S /0 -?'Sjhi*;;a:1zig0uda Faraslhanzsftai,
;%;g€;:.E£§a§§@r, Rfa Pmsvflgamgei,
.,'E'q; Saundai:::i., }j}is?;: Beigaum.
.. A' ' Sxifikaxzagmada Mmidargagatmra,
* . Sin Yaiiagpagmuda Mudd.a_zmg0udm,
Agea: Major, R/a. Eéhsi:-%£}'gamgel,
Tq: Samzdiatézi, Dist: Eclgaum.
:8. S:1?..N§1aga11age:::mz(§a Sava}«:§§anav;a:°,
fife fihivzanmouda E§ava}§ka1mva1*,
%fi.C:.Ufii:::e §7,Q;§a§€?E.:i1§i;'--- 4' A A'
13..
12.
33.
14.
Ages: Megan Eiija §'ast~Ugar3,g<3.E,
Tq: Saumiaiizti, ffiistt E«s:};ga'u1ra:{." A
331. Keiiappagouda i}andE§iga§&°g§§i,
Sfa Sha;n§§a1'ga21tia.i}9:;di':ig:»;_ *.*9a:iV, _
Age: Mésgfur, Rja Paaiia-{3ga1*ag@i,'--« _
'§'q: Smm,d.-axti, Dist: Baigazzrgi.
3z*i.J'aganImti2.age:3§.::¥_a E?:§ji.e:;-:;--§*1i,% " ' a _
Sjo 'I'h§r€hag01:ai.%;'1~"016':§&izi, " ..
Age: Mafi.-301*, £iija..§?;<.33t~'i}gar3.g;o1,"r " "
Tq: Sa,a{1x1:i§1E:t§_g D§15¥,';.:'£"§;:Ejg:a:3M;m; "
Sxfi; Vfiaméihimaxxi,
Sfp Farlagarzagquéa j_S3;£3.d§1:I:1az1£,
._ %.:gge:..%Maj:;r, _I~:;=_;;3. '§?G:=st4'Ug«22;{'ag03,
Te: :"?£,~i'~Ia.,m1t§:m;i, I3§.iE_.s<:,: .E§~ttfE aura.
A * « Sr:£..Par'a$§;ée1':ag::i:'ii:3; Renkegatkdrm,
S 19% VSVur€:$hggu1;d:<'-a,
Ages: M.g;§a:*s.§*, §~7$t--~Ugamg0},
<Tq.: Sa'azn§§afi.&iV, Digit Efiaigaunz.
vASi;£%,A§ia$a1i:ag0mcia E§het'£i3'2ag011€i3;*a?
f 0" Re;j:ke::go1.1é.1*a E-§EmitiI1agoud:~a,
A «fig$:'~M@§ar, Rfa, ?e$t--EJgm~agai,
E.''?'.
V_ 'i7'q;----__E'§aun.da?2:t§, Bistz Efiaigaum.
; V "::"§ri.E{&:7§chanagm:cia Renkegzmda,
3}" 0 Sureshgsuzia §?iez1kt:g0uCEra,,
Age: Magjog', Rja ?ast~Ugarag<3§.,
Tag: Szmxzdatiti, Efist: Bcigaum;
Sri..7Renai£egouda ?arashamshi,
S10 Basmzagouda Péiffifiliafilfihi,
Agée: Maggi", Rfa F*osi;»L?ga:*agcsE,
"Pg: Saundaiii, EI13i2«s'i:: fleigatsmu
%%---~
E8. S.zti.Ganeshg0uda (_"'ih.a::':1{::.a;-§,.3:p::aV.gi'x.!Qc..&».*:*E 901:2
cxrm»14L;v2%.:'m,..:$.5;.,
SR§.V.P,§§UL§§'.tW;.?§§'§ A§}:f\.;?QC£gT§§§ ~:5s--R R4.
M;,3v.m:;::>:3v: .e'g%E*«SsE>;C?E.s?%§§5§:T;$ zecyra EM.
sR'?1.};;T9s.%s§:§«§¥;a&;>A§§§ {:+.A_ F09 R. L3,}
°~.':'m;s gm finds? Articias 2225 & 227
of théé ,_C.');;<1s§,i..m1*:i:)1z1_ "azsf mam prajyréng 3:0 qfua$3:1 ms
impugz1e€§_V u§*de:7a,'-'_ %;i.a$:22e;3:f" 25.8.2037 issmzd by R2 at
Ara:1€;2;':1z*¢~a}.,ag:ti' 'em.-
' 3-.'§"Z?1i¥.:'a... writ pééfiaien ezaaxning on far hemixag, having
» be{e:1.vE1m';d""a:;c§ masezvzaazi far erde1°s,, ihis flay, '£313 {Jami
.g;em::m;;1{:::u§- .'§'jfhE§ §"<:e1iwing:~
_;C},_E:i}iE}2
3%. is the gage 0?" aha _T{1}€':'3Zfi;§.GE}flI'S that the}; haw bean
fixiicfioxiizag as Aracrzhaks in the r*asp01':dAe3m Tsmpie siztsce
.E'?}9i?; on atihoc basis. They essiaim tat: bf: eiigfibie grist}.
quaiifiezi fer hazing appcsimesad as Arachakas in any
vfizw»
natiiied 'l"sm§fie G2' inst§f§:12fi0:1. Tlfaejgf &;u§3§::i%:i:$:§3. ii§1«a;i..i.n;
§}13%3'S1§;8;E"1{3€3 0f"i'It1£: x_¥u€igm§:x1'£: ziatézd
Writ E'$'s:i'£isn N0.3{}993j
imtiamé the process;_ Em' Q' by
Nmjfia:s1£:im": ifiated. puhiished in
"fiamyuktha Kamatakiaé . 8--3~ 280? , mes:
was haidizxg
the pestv {Sf '§:,?;.rigrf::;¢;:*a,1i*%:':%,_.ve::. uf me T':-iampée (:0n<ma:ted
iI7fisz':e};*vié2$,%:.s ' ' <::.;3.__ j'3;A+4§';g:3_{2? % and 2-$4-«20o?. The
resgoiicisém "«-iiaizfimissiaxxer Ewing}; <iis5a.£§sfim:§
23:33; me .Vp;w.x:°£s'S éefiection éirected the haléing <3'?
., _ :'£":'~:-*:§s§};"i.§=a:i'i'°:3fa*i:z:(a?e211fi;"%f§§" the An:'acha§:a.s. Aczcardingly, the Sm
V ~.§?%Sp5';I€§€i€E3.'§"-v(T£f:)};"1{ifliC3'§;€(§ i:"1'£:m°viem? fmm ammigst; i'.§1s*:: 8
A E-kanays *e3;i2'iE.~fii aim 8%" August, 29%? ami. p§'egaa3:'ed :21 lifié;
mfiésfixag their yerfflrmance in the intarview and
* .s§hmitmd the list :0 the EM mfipeudéiit far mafidmg the":
appoi:{1fm.em. The 'BM Respondent Vida gpmceadiizgg
d.a.iaL-‘szi ’25~8–23G{I§7 appemted the respaadentts 5 ta “:8 as
Amhakas S3_fi}j{“2*Ct ‘:0 the cunditian that they Shali ehmiztz
%é’7!«—
E1€£3€E§E§£iE’37 Qguaiificafiam-:. Aggriwezxti E}; ~ ~i;§:;i$§:~:3;*{i«r::r’~ 7a;%a.e_2
p3.”es$31t: gaetitiam is filed,
2. ‘f’§’::=: iaanxed ceumsei f«a1i’VV£,§?:e;3c:’i:ifiG§1§:4g+”Sri §{r£shI1a
§I)i:rs.:i’§’:, $ubm;ifi;eé “mt: .:ip;pé=i:x$a;:3§§::¥; cf A3:’acha§{a,s is
in gross vioiafiom of jfiixafitz Reziiglsus
311:3 {3ha:”‘i£:a;’b?§.é=:A;.I;:;:3€.ii;,L;t:Ef,§: £13.13 pfirgfiflfifi
apgxcziziaiaeig araiez” Each; the
q;ua.§ViE§éQa§€iw:£iSV an zappaimmem. in
view V”.r.;f: fiie — ‘ vquaiiflstatinn, the zficiaxaficwn
gm::;§7:3dVV’E§y tbs. :f$afiit2_%1§i?4é;r1i.s in prcmmfi the qm3ifzf£ca;E;is3z3s
“fio§;…Lp¢;m1i%:§:&d’ ‘*s:m::”§fer me: Act am} hezlce that ;Empz,1gn=ed
‘ €iI'{3.§:3E”‘-.h }{f§k3f?;’g_§f)2;*C§ in Eaw dczserves ta be ac: afiifisrr.
. “if is Emfixer cunmuzfiad that in ierms of R1336 22,
‘ Cmmxlitme cf EvEax1ag::~;a1eut; wamd recommezlci the
ii:-3%: 03” appoinmcts 3112:} 5-suhjfec:i; in the aggprova}; by {ha
Cmmmissianer me €3ammitt;ee wauld makxsz the
7
mé52:~-~
appaimme.-tats, ‘mat h0w{:v’e:r 2:; ma i:1st;r:§,:_1t”~5;a:«§$;~ fizé
apgkmiratnzaxxts having been :1§a{i»:»=:’ ‘a1?.z’*<%;<:%";E§;–
Ciammissianer by the: im;a':1g;r;¢:d cmrfiei'-is bad.i{:« 1€;ml*.
3. ‘me Emma «;£jay9;§:::::1a1;:§j $.Pa$;i§
mpresenting me: ffll’
z°:s:s;p«:>:iI:c:z”:%::f«*; the Tempie is
§g,nvemt:<i=7 §Vjiz§;;sV.-Tc'm~x=:n reflacteé in the
ord.e;r'p"as§g§g: *%';3:e :§I};§'§§f:%;sie':zé5§._"Vi%?§'e:2i::c§1 zimm an 1 1 n 1984 331
19°25, 59?4;1975 axfl
f " E:%::§3'v._cV:€):j:;?;»é:'$§iis«; thai by viI"?tu.e of me Qchezna
fiat: .__01'eia1"" G3-Tfiéfifl Di"¥"3§':"~?eiOfl Beach the Pmgaris i–3fl.€§
V –ihaa Tezmgiea may he agkgmimiezd fmm zammzg
.' A tfie :x;eiaifE;é:z1$; mi' 3 hangs 01' branches of Pzmjmig and the
amirzéxxfiticass. may apyaint othex" p€3K'S{§i'i'§3 @315! in the mam.
* : ;(:i.§'.'._§he ahfiéiflfifi sf Memberfi 0%" 8 bangs. 'E'i'1$mf0m, the
afiypaizxunazxtza am in 33316 saici '{,erm$ 9%" the .}1;<i@r:1ents
gassed by this {:-:mri. Eia farms: suhmiértezi mat there
is :19 vieiaticm of Sufiacfian 10 9? the Ac": in as xnuch 13$
cs§9z:-
1%
magmzxdanta E3 Em 18 have been perfarining. .I}f§ i:.. f:_:.:1¢%;iQ;:1¥s ”
as Archakas in the tx”z:iditi(r;1 of igfiafx fijr’
yearss. Themfam $0 far a:a_qt:a§g§T£§:a.%fi(>I13.33.cargétfirifzeii
iifseair e;:.m3ifm«fiion. for is in &a;§£f§?E’§;駀:ti<3x':
19.. That fixes: i313p:.;gx3.ۤd.. fig am; an
§”i§}p€)iI}§;§ZKk§:’:3T§l <3&'€§€I'. TEE appfimment
£5; 23§§"1{é§ chaiienge to
fiie: §3»t2'£i€:;i<m shmuid §}C
I*e§e{:$:&ed; * T. .V
#3». Th{::«.. * V k3ar:.i:e3{§.- (}0vemm<:".:n'€: Ad.v::;cam
'appea,ri.13.g for respcynéenis 1, :2 85 3
V «i§:31Tf;1:::'.i:i;'7t€':{§» i:'§-fiat filéa ap;m;Z31i;1m:nt: ha:-3 'iaeeeil 13113116 in
" . €€;§*xa"1s.'{}:fU:§1§:: oraim' cf the: Divisioza Bazznch zamezi rim £s:m::s «:3?
t§1z:.P§.<:ja "$2326; hence the impugned arfifix' flaw 110': £233} fear
I '3}; '°mf.€r§e:\ence.
5. Sri V.P.§{uliEm1*I1i, itzarmezi {3()iI}’.RS€1 agypfigzzfixxg fur
reaspamxazicmt Near} m_:?;m:m;s t:ha'{. me appaintment has
w’2A;-
11
bfiéifl rmagize by’ virme (15 £353,122 prem13Eg;a;natier::,_}:»f §:h§%; new –«
Aci, ‘”E”h@re§E::re, fine Scheme ‘ui:;<ie;~…g§;§::iC11.'3:}f§§: ffffflfiilxfl, .'
'was: being i*3.dTmiI"}':$S§.€3§.'"€$d a:*ad__. t31e§"'é7<§:*;:3ec§13:%§';:*a;§%:§1 g_V
paased by tE1e.Qivis_i_on I§E3en<:';fi'a=s:fE3*:.:1_:d né*i:- to:
any apgxxirxtment bf; ._'_'Z§VjirE:..s:1E3m;fisVAVfhat $116
Tainpie hating g@vems§:§i_ b;yV 'ffieciiame 9, 10
anei the 3'2 meeasris :9 be
mmpiit":d5 V. "?crhmp§iance themfam
Ififiifiir -the ~§.1§:1Vpu:g§'i5£€i' €:%1if%:is'=:1" ?:;s:,~1e:§ in iaw.
6. V_ _ 1 h§I’§%’*3v_Vi’L*ii’-aifti firm commas} appea.:’:§ng 0:: all
A “”” ” ‘V
._ :§§f,aa’i”31’t. has pagsead an arder an 2–»–4~»’£4;ZE€}’? in
‘Writ v?§3é¥it§o:1 No.3{)’99Z§j {£801 foflawimg the Jllfigilififii mf
.. Vfiae ‘3″-fivisimzx Ee2:2c3z::_”t: mi’ ‘ihis £12111’? damd. «Em: 3 -.’§;’é}é3«f§-
” ‘gassed in W.P.E’w’i’o.5E3’?$j};9?5, agaagwza. in mmtm ssf
: am said order and in gmmuanca of me: :~sa§.d fichezxza
which OVSITES km: ‘Tam fie tha rzzeeczmciiite. 3 harm beaan
E E3 E
¢«é?A,«~««*
12
imitiatafi and the iznpugmté mfier has bt:€:}:f:._g2:$;:*a:::jsé:wz§}” ‘SE36 ”
Eivision Efififiilh Of this Circxurfi has s’m*L1€:R’;d.§mrh_ fiigée’ -E.~i§.;fid”g1_ f
Eéiaiigicziga and Char.i*§:ah3c: _E:r1rE€3:s,§1§%1:3:’3t;s ” V
patitianar cazliefsztzcifi fiéam hag czfigifififiged.
bfifflffi ma Su;m’*eme:v ir:€;c;z?§ii1§AVVQ:*{ie3* of
Stay has mm. has 319%:
men §)FOd1§E6§’«;.§§’} Them is no
rdiz*€:<:€:io;1i'e§§* '}§}§I2§i gm fieici. The Temtpia
ther;é”f..’;rét: .011 such $521115 as §}’£”€’V£i§fiE1E
p_at’i,r i.c)xt§:é aaécémaéfit §<lam;3af§a.ka% Act mi' 2893 and
:;;jt3:.1%,gi{ :h»:=:__ g9ve£6:':v*d–«'fl3f tfeiacs Scheme and as flfiifilitiaitfid in
' (2'_1'4'{i'{i'.'.§;" fhe Divisien Bans}; mf this Cflurt fimeai 6»
.' . j_ E-§0:a"'§::§e Dzlvisiwn E€}'if331 of this CGELEET agfiszax'
heezriiizg bath 'me sides haza gasseé. an {3§'(i°$33" Whistth reads
~ 83.. feiiowsz –
‘ fifier these writ petiiians were Bwarii at
rgame iength, we suggested in the Eamned
Caurwei appeming far the mtieg :23 in: why
‘é>«’:2w-~%
these matiers siwuiai 2229: be éigpwefi–fifiimv
Exlgrhi {sf the suggesiians 7e? ‘ us.
saggasted fihai the }€’S°ez:lalE:4§é3°ée3i ‘A
Sm’. Yeilamma TempEé_,'<–.. my
appcénted fmm amamg fiaembérs 'S Imgms
or brandwg me mgshasviitavas
may agppeinz event affii
and suimbie nwmbezrzsr
cf the air braiiafieé ;+%:a;ia:&émg avafiabie
fG?gM£§ is3V__i3§¢e"".zffesf;ec£ive paata. 30
Vvfwf ei*;;3ff§Li;?.:c'€}?';§i?3i€6?tS of the pezrsans
£0 fI§é'Lv%'._appé3ini3_£"«._eii%§'aer as Pujaries as?" as
~a%'e.._':Vmn::mned? they shauzd af
marge .;g:;;$a;r;ér:;%j7d by the reiezimi sfiamfiozrgg
' " me scheme fimned thereunder.
thew suggesafiznns the ieamed
_ far me petéiinneyg the Eeamed munsei
jEaé?”§:}zc§:=fBnard of fiustaw far’ the Adminigirazimn
~.;§S?’z1 Yeiiamma Tempie, and am Eemtned
” ,{T§avemm.em Adyomte yighiiy and fairiy
submitiad that there simuid not he any
c’E§§”mu§’£y in amegstérgg éha fiuggestivns made by
the court” In ifze high? 9f the assmranae given by
the lerzrneai c::sun.:sa£ far the respanfienta Ehai
tiwy are aweeabie for me gfarwaid
$ug@$tizm3. 32-: V;Kr2i3hna f&r?urf?a,§:_–,–»
Cmmsei far” the pet€tiane1’j’;é’.§?fi “Q3? . t}’tm;ase A
réghfly and fairifg
asmrwzce 221% ha §””:’~’.%(‘3’n:;f-,’«3?’_f:$é3d”
may be eiéfimissed as in éfiiiaé af
the a;s3uranam:” ~ gfiven ” “§£’»y ~ . as
afaresaifi, Re®2fi[23s*v,g given fly
mg re$_§30rn&£’:’§.$– tam umit
pe£fi?i@r:.$*
8. 1?2z&V;t%:?’a’ §é3?;~a.a”£:éc§ Singie Jufiga by
the 7r:>:’d?’«:f fiaamé in writ. getition
3-:«a.3%3;g%:.2»3a”1 ._s§.f%;%r’«.§§£311$§<iex§ng the m'<ias:1* of me
FifirisifizzVEe:z:u€:§t1Azf53?e3:»md in above: heid as fi3»110w$:~
* E fact remams the pmferenw sfiwulfi
V A hgé. ' £0 apgimm the pmjaries for the
Z impagg at Yezzamma {Z-'uddafrnm in view gym
u-yideréakirzg hy me msparsfientfmatharity
H hafam flaw éimissiarz bench af this Cmm, tfwy
may have is afihesre in the 5mm in
priariiies m we peapée fifim azrawng 8 bangs
and Q9" in cage fit ané swimmer persans are no:
avaiiahie than cmly mike? qagaizfied nuisiéerzs
'%§s'~;"""
1S
wauéd be agymiruiad. Even in fimxre. L.
when vamnsy arises preféflénzxé ‘_ Me’ L.
given ice E hmacrzss. The refipariéiefiif 1″
shaii take mien ta vagwgoéxaz ” ‘~z;a;ag::a¢~;;_;5.;; :2
ihree mvntiw fizzsm me Qf bf
arder as in.&isfiiF:d..¢4bWe’5; =
The izffigugzaci, mwzivzax.’ Eicfaig i*e§°e::’$ »Q{¥<};«::r ;3.a.ese3€e:i by
this Cs:11rt:eav§£,§;§§.';)a33si11g 0§*»:§e:*. fiince ma
imp11g.I1éd <:» ;[*d_§x€.§V1§4' ':;1}g$§'€;dw'iE: $632113 3f the ¢::rd€:1*
}:33;s,vé*§&5éVTb;;y* ;if§§:e:i 'Em: a.§3p'iir€iéI'”–%a’§Ian@”z1g in Em: 8 banas and Eacamceea the
Ti1;a.§§mgiié{§.VQ2′:ier dexas not, mfifi fm” any énfierfaranca.
~. ‘fizibjcct to the: iimzafi ciecisimiz. by the Eéoxfbie
” VT Supmzxae Cami {rf Endia, {Em Tampk: wmxid hava ‘£0 be
gavemeé in 5115?: a mgaxxncr and by such pvmcedums aa
was hang {i(}T{lE2 ii: the 3333?; iadxniatézdiy, priar to mazt
immbdticfinn. at’ the Azaa ma Tempie was bczing mamagad
w;»:N<–
16
and rm”: in, terms of ‘iheft Ssczhemec ‘§’hc:;r~z2f0 iéizé: V.’:’%<:§}"3«r3I§:';fQ "
and the osrdfir gaaaased by Em: E3jv§ss:§(3r£ fj.B5£:1;1«i:}f;i 'm*§m;id_ f
fuifilawfid in :50 far as n3a;a1a;ge::::2é3a::1;t"–z;sf t}:::7~ §§7'aixé.;:1»§e§; £3 L.
azemzezrimid. 'I'he:'ef01*t:, am %jfcs.§,{=_~:' gowf3€-i. flfgsé izgigpugneati
mfier e:a1"m0£: be f€)i1{?§§§"§'£:l11§€i$fi:"§,§;§};'.–.._ ,
16. Tfae ma:-mgfi 3=2,1×2:se:;*§”;E°:}i’-~ t:.§3锑g,a¢:ti:tioz2c:rs :3u%:an1itme:i
that am $é:>::t:i£.:g::»;” :9 ai’ ma Hixéadu
{3§1a2*§ix?§ib§t3~. A::i:_. ‘i.V€§€%? haw: been vizflated.
Sactiikix ii) bf §;h’ee:’:;~’*:;sf_§’it’ as fbik)W3:«
A mf” ‘:§::€é£§,fic~a£:Zom%: far fismhakaxs «-53,; Na
V ..;:9r.§gdfa shaié be appgiyzteai to be <2 Amimka
1 furs passed aéieczst at aefigficaie
{Warm} in the Agmm in the tmditiam cf
' .. temple, firam any remmised Sanaknatcz
'PamshaZa Q?' any other insrémtian as the State
Gammment may by naigfimiiiaya in the afiiciai
gziazetta spm::z_'fg, 0?' has peajfomwd as archaka
is": the iraditimz 43;" the terrapie far at Eeasst three
yeczm,
mfiawv
1'?
{2} xxxx xxxx xxxx
{3} xxx}: xxxx Xmix”
Even assuming ma 3#§’p§%cah}e, it
iztaem ‘be eager: £3193; «:;1″;¢V_ mqujamd far
afififlinwfifi/£3’ j_ ‘§§¥mtVVV’i ‘ha shouid have
perfarmécfi in tile: *§:x”:3d§*.:im71 Q?
the V’ it is, an uzxciispmted fact
ir.§:atVV”‘:’v§§;:s}:2€§z’:$e;:§”:’ai:$;’ gave been fuxzstiomng as
Armchakééfifi Vfivntfie fifafiifiem cf ‘me ‘”§.”e?:xI1§:sEe fmf the Liasré: 3
‘ . ‘3,re7a:”1;;.: Z-4i;ence,A*€hiS gmumi, m’gw:i by tbs pea%:iii.:3m:rs is
_ 3a:=:§§3;:5aj3’,:=2>;;i%.?§;a:%.%§t§.E;;:.
31: _ AT’§’1e Eeamzeei cgmnseai far the §}fi€iE”.§GI1€.”£”éi submitted
‘ . _>t’.:%}«2zt mg: aygzmizxxtmsant; is in viaiatizm sf Ruiz: 12 of the
Himiax Resaiigiaus and Chamtabie Endawments Act. En
tamas GE” Ruie E2, the Maxmgng (lemmittm or the
Exccutive Gfificfir shafl after seiwctian ix: tmzms cf the
Q’6?.5~z'””‘”‘
339;?’-_1E§”‘
19
C0″;m21issi<n':a:'z:1" and the A{§II1iii§S€?§'a'§;€§3€' thsr§:f0ré"–.$§?(auici' "
nut have any unbrirciied rig?§:;i.s L ._traa§".£e:¢1r__ T f
ap§ui:m"":1m:n't £13" Archakas,.r ifiépxié
that has exzzmsive gxywez' the:
caméidates. Thca 1.; has a
mstriicied wwgir ta ;;%:§%:j;c:e:t.. Eh: dues
mm: haw: agL3;f:_§bi§’*§;£:;:: fiufiffigfea”, in $12345: insizam
Case, i;k5.§.%:V by the
fisggendent Wm) .13 a
§un<f'Ei9fi1z3x3} if pawer exercised $32 'am 3"'
1"efspon&xé'm:V_is mt: that shauid ha cxsxmisefi by this
1?f;e;Sjpw;1fir:xi€:"te31°ms 0f 131:: Act. Sinca the 4"'
V 1{*e3sa;z2€;:"§CEe:%t':tVT_'i:¢. Ewing xmmaged by tha 3%' mzapamdent
Aii::3i:*;is'§;§:at§ar the Est prepaxwrtei by him wcsuifi in law
mpré:;@z2.§: thee: Eisi: jpregzaxfié 'by the fém :'esp0nd:=:11E:.
" Tizsmfam, {he impzzgmd €.i31"€iE3*."§" appointing mspwmiems
5 in 18 by the EM reaapondcnt aéazmot 'mi: heid ta fia 'had
an the geund that me Camflzimxca has 110$
reccmmenfifld 4:31 2 said Est. A3 rmtesazi Efiiflififi' the imam,
mézr
233
mi’ Ruie 332 is in EIl§§U.”3′.’€’.. mm: «:;r1§y§»Vdam§:sc;tféa?.té::§: .§S£f3i ’11v§3.,’E’)’L2t
aims in centre} that right is a;3gS:;g§rz3;’;**%.:§::3:ia§gi,e*z::a ‘%t2j¢” 3>}»*1~,5f
mapandant aimae. En’ 1:i:=sw.__e£’ £h:t:._ é§33»z}~2:3i§fi;%i/,s?3,«:ea;’§.**;;V V;V::§;’3 {Em «. ”
m%mim§;a’i:x’atcwr, am é:ss12az:s;e%: ivvfflmar ‘£33;
Em ‘?Z&3emfa:}m§
ix’: arémv {if t}’m: fae;’:t 314; m.::’m17ng ‘itha
Tezflzale é ” €3ammiz:m:»& of
Ié’aiiaz2§:=sag«e:€;;t:;g.m,we;_at_’.”l; §??s~1£«€a 1:2 waufid mm
V Thmmibm, awmn
a$m£xnVi’:1gM “;ara:=. a§pj§éca%;ie aha mmemizrjn
‘3:£izsz?t tiizwsssré $3 av: w.<:}§;a"s;:§§:3x"?; of Rm.§:pe..ari:”2g fer the? Szatfis reizlexi
{sin his :=s”i.£§%,e.rme£3_’£ cf ekgemiram, whéfrh reeada em faiiawfsr
“T. E’: is ‘f::s,rt3:1s2r atzbxzmtwé that thsa
impugned eardar has Emarz paasaed kmping in
View the fiimctiam mi” the §€:m’§3§<=: High if-sari
3:0 giva §3§i'€ff3ff3'flC?6 in the Cé¥,E1€iin'f§ti'€.£%%£ fmm the
eight hanaau m xx 39; xx mt"
<€rw
2}
X}; b xx xx xx »
'E-.%, It is furfimr auhmitfied 3§3z:':_.=z':r£: :
rwgwamfinent §«7§<:s.';§ 35 t E*i2s.:e4__g":::);s'z3§g:3=£_a té.=;%:"a*£;
far the e=.=zpprcsva..i {sf §s§a:esW
every atlfiaaritjg. 'ta
.t%§§p0in'£n}$fl't vs§$'$ " riaggamiip' :55 "$'Ei:g4=s §:;:.w.§ii'é{?atian,
fear thea time 2m§;1g %J%;q¢¢;g;%§g:=§g Eiigiz
{ffi<2u,r*€._, '€§.§:*é§r:t.i<:]m=§ 1, .:.;§f:f§ri§;1é,ctx5fi writ
'£'§2£a1.:Statfe; €ii%~:s§=e.=.azj«:e=.=¥.'Ai'm"e:«,.VA i&=:___ 1:02 atfixaar with. mgard '$13 'i.§'33:':'-
appficgbifigr <i'a§7f."§,.V§'Ea?743 Vz"%.:%.";uET;-._:€:7}§g§ the sssxm hand, £:.2%2~:t=3; ttszantsanii
E yztmizes izizpmgziéii Order has '§::wem1 péxamezé in viaw emf tiza
A g£§ric5:2%:if::r:'"'»:sf $3133 mm. an ifw atsthmr hand 'mat téasa
.e?_»ssa§«mW:r:§.._¢Vr'z;é*;:¥tVg;ai:§;;:§*g::i§en'£ '§rx¥.img the fmmgseiezat. azxfiwrity was
Aafitjfiimai Agazzwé; the impztgzwd araévav. if the: Efiisxzésiersn
.Eez3%;§g1A 'énrder 755; béssing *£i:::E.iflwm"i, than it g3re–m1';yjg.w0aeas that
V' flat $3 3193?; in fflffitfi. E"-imvevar, if the pmaziaierans 69%' '$3145:
Act am: in. ibmg, aniy than wcmid Em t.E'§x';e campsflent
aaiiawrity _3'2.1ria~:§:?;<3ti03,*1 ta: paw ordew anti ix": which
evmzt, ihfl mxmpiéamm car Gtémzwifia :2? 'the careiessr £315" 'this;
€x»,9A;–
22
Qatar: chm mat arizssa far r.:z:az13§cEes3’m£@.1=”.1~;–~§*§é1r:»::é$3:,thseixwg
appesaam as a fluid si.t1zati»:jg:: §§?ifi§r. AA
appfieafiifiiy 9%’ the Fast.
in the absanazgwsf ivy ihss.
E~£o.n.’bEe fiugamrm fire iiwificiczx
eizaiiaxagéngv sf ma flirt, in
terma ‘f2’£sad, it is mm’ 4.224%/~33»
‘E313 tiiaté’ {:3 i;3ii§:éVV¥;§£::i”‘3r§:,mrrze:x1.€ 9.2″ atherwiae
«sf t§:§.€’-=_ .r:Jif. {ha nr:smter, 32%: £3 ‘£’.§’§€’:§f”&3f{3f€§
a;}§;rap§;§fi–?m time in.mrnegz1t.un, pendmg fi.:m.i
ai:i§;’~?=;1c1:;§<js.sai;i%.s5=u– if-in reams flamzrt, *£;E”:i=: State
‘ ,,fi’a3 aazgéii wiikin itzfi atttherity ta pssuzaaés ‘$I§’£t.’5 irzapxxggaecé. uttrrdaiztz’
” .ix*Hf.e2″1f1$? esearfiixear _§ud.gzne1n,%t rmidarezci by this C-£3′-‘:.11″‘$,.
..i1§;g*):igz22:.ec§ nrder having Esee-:3 paraaed in tammz mi’ firm
” .. AA j’a;:;:igz:1a3.nt gzsafiaaaé. thia £,1n’:xi°i:, thfififfifflfsfi, dflfifi 13:1»? caéi
fm'”A any intefiierenwq Meiiiaar in 2′? the cam sf the:
” gxstitimiem that them is a v1?a§ati¢=r: Sf the srzsréiflm’ pauésed
‘:33; thia éficmrrt. in caf 112$ fismmticn zwagazfléxkg tha
w’€%_:”‘”
23
erfiTz:>:’r::er:m:1?: m’ agapiiaaéziiity af Q33 act,’ ‘t’%’m :é_g:1;:i§2gi:.§’«§*~,f:z:;5aé??::M5:£*V§.»1’1 at afigiq Thai:
u:,mn3i&era’iix.§’ti mad E11333 aréaefi
miziy .’i7iT1;B.£§=’5°:E1§§}§3:€f’«fl§3§fi’t. in
:’iVti§.% ‘V fiéxafiirig firm} aiijliiiiflfltiflfi’
by fl’;§¢5.« flf Eneziia, fixes? éxzsagmgnmi
«::>’rv:ie.~g*g thér in wanna mi” the €3}'(‘£.’§8I’ pa;-;=.a_s°5:d
,D’§’§Jf’.§$§0fl AE’€%éfi£1}1 af ficuiaa emu”? 2333 t§iaem§3::aI°e, vaiici
.<.=11'§£x;'§_ dtraé étali 01" any ir:f£ez'fem3.1:::e.
iiii '~ v'Z'i1e iwmed £3f}'il£1§S2'3l apwamsg 123:' mssgwzzdvzanta 5
" : vahementéy mntfiersaieé that ixngmagnefi wrdar at
;fimm:.smm«G £5 Arm: the $.§3§M3i1'1?;mé*.nt stmiim". {Era tilt: Qtixzar
hand, ha mnmntied that? the aVp§:»r}in€;.xnen$t m'a:'ier its file
¢::«@;'.§:-=-K
Qatmriz Exmpez-353 mad éatxpectez that Sfigfjh t.§*":i.;jg*s"
rvapvmtezrfi.
:33 Far’ me afisreaaici i’1Ei&$1′.}1}1′.’e;’r3, {ha Wri’:’ Hbaaing
daamid af n:1z:=..rita is .<£a£:%<':i§33'€§:¥;£:§,_§;;}j.T* figififlfilkfiflflg §§'t;"m5£3.
§~'£1.1..ir:3 t§»iscE1a.rge::"§a; 'M ; Q' dim