IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 131' DAY OF DECEMBER 201o%
BEFORE V N
THE HONELE MR. JUSTICE ~
WRIT PETITION NOS;38593--629_;O~P'._2D0_9H
BEE WEEN
1. Sri.S.Nagesharaju
Aged 2 45 Years _
S/0. P. N. S:riniVasé1r2}.ju ~ E V
R/At MIG 33, KHB"'Co10ny ; E ,
100 Feet Road, Vinobanagari " "
Shimoga. " E.
2. srwijaya Bh:is.karH*~E.__" _
S/0 V;;_1S:.1Vde'vap;da
Aged:3;'§--._Years~_ A .
F}/0 Main R_a0"d, Mathur Post
._':I\}£a1.I_L1:1;1EjM, Shimega «Taluk.
AA .HMa1V:hur,
Sri.B. R. Rangaswamy
. O;
'A Aged :72__Years
"R/C»: Raod.
Mathur Post
V' , _ Shimoga Taluk.
S/0. B Ramaiah
Aged :75 Years
R/O Main Road,
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Taluk
Sri.M.N. Subrainanya Shastri
S/0. Narayana Shastri
Aged: 74 Years
R/0. Main Road, I
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shixnoga Taluk
K. A. Subramanya .
S / 0. Late AnandaRéto
Aged : 416 Years H _
R/ 0. Main Road, Ma.thi,1--r P051 " V '
Mathur, _ 1 " .
-- ' . ' 'V
S/0. Ramabhattg' '
Aged :80 '{e_3I'S'
Q.__L M v
A V V°Mafh1,1r' Post
" Mathur_',«.
=."_ShiHit3ga T*a;'{uk
. "'Seei'h'a1néL1§s11I11j.
W /0 'Vishnum1,1rthy Bhatt
A. ,Age{i : 66 Years
R./o. Main Road, Mathur Post
V' " Ivfathur,
Shimoga Taluk.
M N Eshwara Shastri
I0.
11.
E2.
S / O E Narayana Shastri
Aged :73 Years
R/O Main Road,
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Taluk.
J K Srirzivasa
5/0 3 K Manjunatha J _
Aged : 40 Years ._
R/O Main Road, Mathur Posifz A
Mathur, .
Shimoga Taluk.
J Kchandrashekhzara _ _
S/O Late J M Krishita Bi"£atVtV -.
A§ed:56Years ' % A Z "
R/O Main Road.
Mathur Post' _ _ '
Mathur, 'I 4'
M.H.' cr;a,nd;;;ppaT ~ if
S / O E~i'wu:1'1a11th:1pp.a;'
Aged : 47 Years '
,_%%£&:_/Q%'Mgun R0ad.....M'athur Post
V Mat'"h:'ur',
' A " ShiIn0g3..Ta1uk.
I 3.' A
/ Q' 'Kariyappa
14.
Ag~ed";f 68 Years
x ,R/o=Ma.m Road,
Mathur Post
V' "Mathur,
Shimoga Taluk.
Lakshamxna,
R/bi
E5.
E7.
W/O Hanumanthappa
Aged : 60 Years
R/O Main Road.
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Taluk.
Nigamma
W/ 0. Ramanna
Aged : 56 Years
R/0. Main Road,
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Taiuk
Ratnamma
W/O Annappa
Aged : 45 Years V
R/0. Ma,in..R0a'§i,
Mathur. _Pé2.st . 1' V.
Shimoga Ta1uL, '
NagesVii3,_V%M . V _
S;/0 Annappa" "
24 Years. .....
_ R'/o%;Ma-m Road,
"'1\./£afl41'ur: 'Pgist
". »ShiIn0g:1__T'a1u.k
Mafijfiappa
. ,S/O'"KaI'iyappa
Aged:53 Years
V' "R/o. Main Road.
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Taiuk
i/bi,»
I9.
20.
2].
- 22.
L':
K T Prakash
S / O K Thyagaraj an
Aged : 42 Years
R/0. Mail} Road,
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Taluk
J Sakesha Hebbar
S/0. J sridhar hebbar
Age:52 Years
R/o.MaiI1 Road,
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Tami;
Usha " "
W/O M.:;ni.i:anth'an _ M
Ageq%;.4o%'Yeai%:ei % A
R/:0. ik/£airiT.LI_.{Qad., 4 . _
Maithur' Past' -~ % *
Mathtgr'; _ ' '
Shimoga_V'1'a1uk_. A
_"I\i*!. N__LPrg;bhakara.__. e
. VS,/O Négfayana Shastry
A Age "Years
. '«-TR/o'.~ "Road,
3 Mathurimst
"'Mat1i1}1::'
Shimoga Taluk
V Babu Rao
_ "SA/O Nagappa Ghenathe
? Aged : 88 Years
R/0. Main Road,
24.
25.
26.
T f2&
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Taluk
Saxdthrazmna
W/O Babu R210
Age : 55 Years
R/0. Main Road,
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Taiuk
Laiithamiaa .__ _«
W/O Parameshwa1'a~ r
Age:60 Years "
R/0. Main ROa__ci,
Mathur P0'S1; '
Mmhun*x""
Shirnogg » ' '
M Shaf11i;..1ntaha,-Li _
W / :0 M 'NV Sgbraye
Agezfii) '1'c:ar:3,_ ' ---
R/0. Main vR0ad,7._ "
M&;thur Fast' " " V'
.....
” “Shfinf0gaA’§_’a}uk
W W’/O 1\kIL.E’,Venugopa1
“Aged i 88 Years
Rio. Road,
* = : %
‘ ‘. . . ..
“Slximoga Taluk
B R Chancirashekar
29.
30.
S/() B Ratnaiah
A,ge:62 Years
R/0. Main Road,
Maihur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Taluk
B R Panduranga
S/ O Ramachanrappa
Ag<:::48 Years
R/0. Main Road,
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Taluk
S BVenaktesh .
8/0 S L BaS.1varaj;J;”« if
Age:38 Ye,ar:««…vwi’– g
iakkapzm-C&ii1:2 – .1 .
fl/o.i\/ii3j11_:§{Qad;’~~ ‘ ”
Mathur . »
Mathigr’; _ _
Shimoga_VTa1;,11«;._ A
« . 8/0 7Fhyagarajan
“Age:_-£8 Ygars
Mainfibad,
.’ A Mathur?’1?c}’st
“Mat.’_ri1′,n’V,’*”
Shimaga Taluk
. “S5/OThya,garaja11
? Age:67 Yezars
R/0. Mam Road,
35.
Mathur Post.
Mathur,
Shimoga Taluk
M R Ananth.aran1y
S/O M2@_ma Bhat
Age:68 Years
R/0. Main Roaui,
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Taluk
M N Mohan Kumaif
S / O P Narayana Shastry _ A , .
Age:52 Years –
R/0. Main Road,
Mathur Fosfié” . –
Mathur,
ShiIn0ga’Ta__1u1s:.’;’._ = _; ” A
M Sfixiivasgl
S/Q Raxnafihfat V’
Age:’i51Y¢:ars_ V f *
R/0. Ma.iVnvR0ad,*._ ”
Iviathur Posf ” ” V’
…..
” « _ _ “Sh.it:1 0gaA’1’a1uk
R”BhL1av?ar;i
‘ A » Ii)/Q Bhat
“;Age:_’73- Years
R/0.fMaJ’n Roaui,
. , _Ma’thur Post
Mathur.
Fshixnoga T aluk
M N Prabhakara
S / O A Narayana Shastry
Age:58 Years
R/o. Main Road,
Mathur Post
Mathur,
Shimoga Taiuk
(By Sri. M R Rajagopal, Adv.)
AND:
1.
State Of Kamataka
By its Secretary”
Dept. Of Public Works
Ports 8: inland. Watex: Transport V”
Depot, Vidhana Soudha g A
Bangalore -~ 560 001 V ‘ V C
The ‘ C,
By §ts.VsSe’e2fetéi1ry,_ -» _
Departrrient, Qf¥R€V.éIi.ue,_ –
Vidhama SoL’1C.1ha * ‘
Ba.ngaJo’re ‘
The State
its SeCretary..__.. «
. V Depaitrfient Of Irrigation
‘ V. “‘»fidha11.§;vtS’oudha
‘Ba11g%5;lore.C’ ‘1.
The.-__D’ep=tity Commissioner
Shimoga District
A. , __Shii11oga.
.V””I’1E1e Chief Engineer
% Communiczations And Constructions
K.R.Circ1e Bangalore 1.
Petitio1f1fé1’s< ..__f 5 ;_.
6. The Executive Engineer
Public Works Department
Parts And Inland Water
Shimsga Division,
Shimega.
7. The Assistant Executive Engineer
Pubiic Wsrks Department
Parts And Iniand Water
N0.1 Sub flivision, 8.H.Road,y
Shimoga.
8. The Assistant Executive.En_gi.nee:_ ‘
No.1 Sub Division Tunkga._Akn.ekat V
K.N.Niga.II1a B H Raod, 9’ .
Shimoga. .
9. The Viflage Panchayath’
By Its Secretary . ji-
Mathur Vjli€:gej’-, . V:
ShiInoga…Ta1Li;k_ _£_3\1″1d« District. if; . V
10. The Assistant Exact-t1w;Engineer
Rum} sub .D1v:.sic::’,-…
l\?i'<ifi~'~?0II1; '- " V"
_____ Resp-orzdents
V." –,(B§.? 'Sri. ivfistyanarayana Singh, HCGP)
'.12.
The p€l’.lti.01″1€l’S herein have come up before this
court with an apprehension that the respondent host
to 10 herein would take up widenirlg of the existing road
between Mathur and Shimoga as district major
widening the same to an extent of 25 meters?” V’
existing rural road, which is approéiirnatelyt
its width.
3. It is the apprehensioI1____of ..t_he_v_petitio1lfiers that as
and when the responder1Vts_’wou§ld upgradation
of rural road to 1Adristrict”‘roaid.V they’ arediliely to utilise
their prepertiegi:1¢f§fia..i.ch,v4lisgsituated adjacent to the said
road and thatllrio coihpcéirsation will be paid for the same
pi} gretzrid that._aS.~or1 the year 1925 itself, the road
Vhicohriectiegi lvllljathur to Shirnoga was declared as 25
meters thereby depriving their legitimate right
‘to their that may be utilised tor declaring the road
“:fi'()IlIll”1f1Jl’Eil to district major road measuring 25 meters
H»
proceedings for acquisition of the land and after
payment of compensation for such land. it
categorically stated that without h’ V’
proceedings, the lands of the owr1r;i1’s’0ft1{1€3
on either side of the road, bed. “up.
widening of the road.
5. Piacing the ._of the first
respondent — Stvate respondents
on record, of reserving
liberty to when the State
Governrrigeht decide to widen the
road withottt–. the undertaking given by
this__court«totake appropriate steps for breach
v–..’:Further, the petitioner also stated that the
K itftatter of w1’der11′:ng the road is pending before
.’..dy’_-thisddcourt in w.p. No.32327–329/2008, the right of the
“–«::C§oyernmer1t to form the road will be subject to the
‘W:
15′
decision of the said Writ Petition, the said submission is
placed on record.
Accordingly, these Writ Petitions are .
A _
MWf3UD3Eis
JJ