Sri S P Nagaraj vs The State Of Karnataka on 27 May, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri S P Nagaraj vs The State Of Karnataka on 27 May, 2009
Author: V.Gopalagowda & Malimath


EN “ifiii Eiiiéfi <:§_:m’ 6}?’ §{a§%NA’:’,%§<A A'? EE%AN%C}AL{3R'3;
.'£';u%'§'EZE3 mag 'E'HE§- 272% my a:;:;;:s' §v%;1':', 2&9?'
§RE8E§T J u'
*2*§«;2«: %i{}F*€'§LE sv:_;%:,§.;:,::~;':'-§<'::~*:: E!" <;:;}?§AL&.{f{:$s,§%:§_5f V' '% T'
'i"i~%.E:- §§<::ma§<:; ;a452.3'£;饧'§Cfi4§'2;§ifiA.:~;::;s,;§§::s%.;é;':*§»: n 1.
S'§'RP gva
8E:'I'?fJ §«:.£:%§: V' 'V '
S E" ?éag.£~1§"a§, Pinprifiter " J V V __
M f 3. 8a$avé:sE:wa:*a Cefggsuraifzi-:31 = _'

iiammissimiz £xg::'~".2f;t"_'.

APMC ‘fard

fi:’asii<i;§re__ . j Egtitioner
" 4' {$337 's§%::–ég3. Gswzia, ;'%{iv,}

§g§'€ fig' '' _

" '?§:§é' %1.:é'%,E <3? ataka

2 ' "f§7E'3'1"<:;ug§;"%.%':2;:*.AV €i::x._1i:1mis§i0:z1:$2* sf Commfirciai '§'a.x€$
A '§3:;1.%j§ a.V'i'?Tg15€;:"iig€: f.%{axj_za.E,aya
35*'; 'Main ' Eékéaii Cvagndfgiaagar
Ba;:1ga};::m»~_Sj€3TG C389 §€f&s_g3m1:§.e3:1t

{By Smf $66313 Evimfmn, AGA)
V' mas pafiiiezz is gm "aimiar Eisctiéjn 233; $2' ms KS'?

“;iC”i: égaifisi the jziciigmemt 8.§1{.i Qlfifif 5.3″-aisfi ;2¥}~4-2QGé§ §}{:3$Sf:(3L
ii}; $’?}% ?€0:233§ 230% 9:: $316 flit: ef ms Eiégzéaiaka figyefiaée

‘T » ._ T ‘V ::.:~i’m:,::ai; 8a:3.gai<::rt:: fiismissirig {EM §i–

ix}

Yet it ion
'T'1*rLs£rQm:T;1g 3:1 f:::sr arziars this aiafg, GG§'i3;LF1€}€.§WDEE
J; zitriiivemsi the frsfiswingz 5

JU§{3_§rfEf§T

'§'§:w2:e is a {Esta}; 3%" 5-§{} etiajm ix: fiiéng this §::::§.i.§{_f:i=.:.}'

have hazard £16: lfialfiifid c:£213.11S€§ £01"bhasérg-.¢§3za3"£:i§é§«._0::*iE'1€'1

a;';p§i;g”1:.’%;:si[s”._

§3f3{Cif,’iOIL Accfipiizzg 133$ :”<%a$<::i33"3§é%fii€{i Eff: 12.33% *2.-1ffi:_dét.:?VV§ "fi'VVf':"}c§d :31: 'V

ssugggyeri Qfap;{3}1?caii::2fi §a'2f..<is§a}€§"§aé;§3: é§.f_%S {§.?;;3j§;;'i:é'=i:;'?§~A';";%Z)7Z1G1;<}I72§§{i
arid acceraiéngi}-', aha §;a1?€i'a:§,*»'§33i'C.s§if:;: wide :;:§é:'<"' §%'=::.I{S'E'.;%P §31fQ;3-{}fi fxamgizzg "ihf:

.__§'::§E§»;}'éx?i.:';,g'»:;"§§s3S5:ié;;:s Gf Eaw for C{msid€1*a$iG:1 0? this C<:2:,1z'i.

. ';f—-;z} Er: {ha facts 32153. e:::ir<:*ums'£a1;c€s of §.'l'Z§.€

* ;:;5t2"EiCsner's Cam Whether 2zufi1m*éi;i€s balsa'

am iigézi 131 Gaming 53:: a mrsezrlusgigm faizai tbs

giiatitioiisr has gmrqthased. <7-sgizra fmm ;%P'M€3

jgaré, fizlbhi 333$; 81E_§§_3I'fiSS€fi '£26 szfia xxgéizifia
séiiiizg it"?

{2} E11 mi: iécis azzé. {7§£’€’§.EE3lSEa£}C€S of Eféaéi

§€§’§’aii{33’§$r’$ C336? £v i?hQfi€ies §)&k;W

war}

amzgi 3.13.5 1’§”‘r:;?:::.maE are 1’i:g§’:t in accepting SE15
pxzrchase: £’€€,’€i§’§ZS 0:” gtopra. w£t’::ze::>u2; veiifiring
the sigigzaium of the pa’2iiii0.:1m’ 333% 3-ézithcui
Suppiyizlg thoss materiais is the gagiéiiéyzgar?

pfifitmnergs cast: whcsthfir ‘f§,i*?3f’ Eiaxxiraisaiia

{$1 in the facts and circ1a1z1s%z§13;:[§{{~:S”‘;3:§,”_ §:7f__1;é

fiagpsfiaffi ‘§’zi§:e§1:1aE is réghét in :I1«E%3T
{ha aiiegad S’3.,§2}3§}I’27”,”§’?:S€:¢’-E.,S%*;i.1€1 {}f–.CC3§}§;é1V”‘I’:f;”§ 312%;

taxable; being a 3e:::9dnc§-.3316? ‘

{4} E1; the faets –._$i11d ci.f(,:,§,n};~:f:é:%3;c€i:’5u’V”””€:a§ SE16′

peti3:iener’$ cas?%E:vV.._x¥?1x_etE1er’-?iA;é ‘ éstfinafion sf
Su§}§)I’€’SS€d s;;11:3:$.Aéfciapra and i<:*.v}:'a'::1g tax far
the S€:{'iQ£if.i time VisL';::x:;rmitted in law'?

3;'”‘f’£1stA ‘E;sari:ifé3£i é-mizzsei _§é:’fi*.%rE.§’s§.Sha;1}~:are Gowda for
EEK: peiitiézgsr _si:’i1L:;2.iiT’vt3iéa§’§.he best juzrigmezzi assessmem:

zzré-::=.r was passezi by It%3e”;:iSs€ssing autheritja an the basis 0?

~ V. &_ CoV;x逧%%1::1f{“:ia§ ‘i’a§§:”‘€}i§i3,:ri:~s;1* éiniefiigence} raga”: ma: were :23 a

‘sJ;i§;§3:r5–s$i§:>:’3«éf{Gig} §1E{‘,{1()V€3i’ amount af §€s.?§3′}’§$@Q]- azgai

§C’}fiE§’1 maziiépiied h}; 3 and éakfin 33

‘V §%s.§¥€~,.3§Z§§V”?{$ i’%j~ far {ha p?;23’§3QS€ 9%’ 15V}? sf gag 0:1 tam}

‘~x’?€%,;i’1E§3V€IV”‘ fer the asssgsmam. yfiar i§§%~2{}€}& figs Safigaé is

1:;-§i’$?i1§p9I*tez;§ h}-‘ a§3;§>’ 2:33.35 23$ cogezfzt raagaggzs gig}; §’§:r::”z:fv::r 2:3 viiéazfiii. “§’§2€1’€§:;r6; ii. is C’Q§I£€.f:Ii{‘§{i'{‘§ §’)§’v}},§{§i§:1 ?;V%EEiE

232.5”: same @159 zxki give E”iEE§€f’,’ {<3 3z.2§3$'i;–'3§::ii3.£ a:;'::£:$%;§o:_:j5§'" M

}%:{i;;3.<:§i :°s<§'ms:$tz~:{.§_. this Cajzzfi E0 azlissvai" ithfi as-2;::§:*§.:1"§3§vm:;e"{$37..

331%? ;;&€ii§<:12:s:x.',

4, E«'11'r§%2:é':; in S"i;§'§}}i'_?E"{ {sf {;:Zi;€.:":3u%:;~s;f,a2'2.{i:fi q;:€3ii2€;:1$k;s§"'L

232$', §<~:a.z":<:§%{£ {?{):£3f2S=~;'i§ C€}§}{€'Z§§€§{§' '§,§;.,ai };t<';§:z;.i2L:$i<f}s;': (2? $323
assessing a'::_':.§'::;’:13a? ‘§?3ié{3:–§iS’v%§é7 _?_é.%?’?§/353 yard ‘jzat

a.ss£s$:3£ _§§Zi;§€§§}é%S§fi_§.- £:-.

{$23.3 iiéf E%s_;.?,,:::’::V,§’-.~_v£:«23’3.{%-.sé;s;’3§§:ts$§d EEK: 5»;-aiéi f.::’:§.1:$é:c::;z_>:: Ea}

ééis Ef}3§.;z§:*.::::£:::§i: :23′; %:a:§1..;s;};::}w.é;3,g £3}? §*::;:*2’mw:z’ a2:’::}:2::’£ 0%’ ‘aim

fiaifif’§fE££’§Sé?§i;?{‘§i3.ZZiV_fiihfiiéH E323 Eggs? s::.§:>mét%::::i {Em :’€.§>:2.;::::; {Q fizz’:

“::”‘€:i’,’.~§»$iéEE.~’;;’:’~f¢3}:1%’:V§L§ ?;%;;§;h(23’i§}A “?’%:5:'{:§2:3:§: “£325 §.”;:::§:§.§§.zg: “‘s;::{s2:;8i:§%€:*22″£é:3:3 §:2f:f<3:"€ iéjas

:3:$si:jS3§§f::;1g':;%::'§A§3£2.:"'i?;}* 3333 é"i}}_§}$§§E£§§3 a:_;t%:£:§:§}; 23:13 {:r2'::3::.:€<3'a:g £1:

V"'§s3=;'. §%:::::ie::§§ 23$: "%££?s:}i§.i{§. Sifiéiiiii {E233 $:fi;s€a:'.:fi3.E q2.a{:s;§'§a2′. _§:’*:/§4::*;:%:% in E13 am Z%,:€ {£5 in fiifi %%f’.&v§$§.ez: _§.}::*f:;i§;%;:;;}:’; %%'{‘;9E3_§{§

.V _Mi?_€§”a£?;iiE§:§” éiéifié E233′<;%g;':3;.S;1:§é?:":§aim: sf ¥'.§E§i'§ ifiguzé 22:; '§:'*:f'%:=z:§'.2;aE

hw/'"

K./*”|

:a;=*it.1r:z:mt. :~1§}p§;5:<ra€17<3;'z. 5;? ifiiiifii '21:; {ha .§:éi£'§§§ £32" 132:: "§§E:{i.

fivié 63317:? an :'§=:{':{;z':£ 338$ a{%éi;:zi<f{.'l Eégés .f::_.;§::§§_:'1g a§T'§7a:a:iA:9%:»:;§a'};7r£1é<-3;. *

§;2§-=' the 2:§.§$€::s$:?1§;zg as.2§.§;:=:;§";l§j;, Whé} _};3_;s;__ Si:z%.*?.§{%»:f%. €?;":%?{1: %iE'::{§.;=i:: 3}; V

$:.§pp:'€$$§{3:t: §32″:-2v;”:.%;f;fléjixg
$:aj3:.i ammgmi. hag 21:32: §><é%:§I— $%1§§;z;t:§:: '
aSS§'.f§$31EE€E'i§ fg"{"££,E". A
35' Efiamasii :'5's{3z-fig A '4 '£1333: égzggjizgzzed
{3£'"{§€1' §1a$5;*,§':1':a3 film: £i}"}§2*5;".§}.&'E§
£iLi§§102'§§§,7 avg; . :}";;'7_ VV:§jE'{)V£Eii'1{'§S zzzigeii $.33; §.§.§{*.
312:3 C§E"{\~g,f£111${£fl§{'${3E§ 263%;

Em: <,u%2$%;;uV "1~%:§yé:r€§Z;3t §'f:{fe3ii"i'§ zmzri ;§,.§'§5§' frxagzzizsiazgg

332% z:'=§”z’:;:*<":§'2'3»1:~°~;;_<.«;S ' .25}? $3.355: "§3€;$i. }z;{§.g::;€::;3éi E"éSSéi':SS}£flEZ}'.'§ :_ér:"§.::2f

. ., §?€i':s;sé:§?..§}3,' 'z~,%.§{: é;$&;{ééS§§*;g ém%,%:0'§"%Eij§,~=, -:'i7;{% 31$: £i€'{3{":§'_}§'. fiat: 531533 2.12%"

_ *:§::;: :;{%§'i'§..§.;{.3'3i%;i"£7.__{–§i2§§, ggagsgeé thy: i3:épu§:';e:’°i’§§a2;; ‘figs’: §§°:.E§_E”E’E€€§

figiérgfig §%:;i7:§.é:E ’55:: i%;& §:uj:%.gjg:1s*:§;’§ 23%’ ‘$35: §§i?i§}1″{fE33€’ {7<}1:§'i iii:

{ii}; ;§i«'%Eu§S;F?§§{}?*~€§Z§% SE9' E§;'%§;.§Z-5:? '?;"%¥;, §S;E3%E3§T§'{,?'% §"§%a%§;}ES%§ vs 3%

L§§Z'§§,f§3°P§§.-E E M ?:i?:§§}§T§iz駧,§ E.*':?"?Zé§32§ S'§{i ??§ w%:@z'::i::: £336"

£'~;;;;}{':_s: $1733.12": E22123 fixgzézaizzfisié wéizat fig Qié $<:§3£ s;;>§ §::;’is;a§%Z{r:%:,::’: {sf

agmigaiéig a:,:’£E2:<;:'é"€§; 3:} §}E?£E§S Eiiizé f.%a';*::s2:% §E,§€§gE}E€E§i :%§$S£iS$§'§3éf<E33

\xx/

' …E°{?3$V£'iE}i'. V L'

C3'

mfiitzz" ii' i'%'i{f;i"(i ix ii$€§E'2§}€i{§ izsiixzivsz' E3}: Efiééé e:$3e3sz:~*:z:-":,7.. ii is

Siibfiiéiififi 523:3': fimzzx $3.5 :':§§'{£{:'::" §.}£é%$€{'.§. 'z':»j=: %.h$"'g"2:§u;;:1::=.s

€'

§iz'ii%.fz<;s1'§"i'fy', it cfamigrei E35 saiai 'ihai: it £3 '%:'§':Ii€-i'{.%$€i'{f§E..{:i{f€é%€}§.§§'if. <3:

§£}ié}.§, "§}Z*{ij1.i{"§iC§3 amii iéfi}T{i'€%,$§}§}8§jf§.€fIiZ€_SE§'Lj '§'1;?E1€:V.__ é;'i:%;::':..§;S'$§§:_:.g'

au':§2§3'r§§.§~* §"i£§";§,i'§§ :":::”d ‘ti: ,’t§’z$ féae:;?€S._ of tégéij .{:E2::;é$,

sxaméramg the I’€Ci£>§”{§S:, Ems me 3é::a§§’:{:’3.$=s£::i: “§::.,1rz}s:;i.!=5,=z*
3% 22%-,33,?L1€},’~» b§;* §§”a:.§tipi§%:%:g” f3: t§:1′;c:5; fi’:£*:” S’*Vi::§::§;,’=:*{:5=:${i:’?§
E’m*;2m:’;$’ tile m.e:,>:2i§;:$ $_é? i9*§*{§g ._f§’§3{%:1:”€i%>:’z;é, aha s1;:§:.}:1:§T::S

323.3,: iifféfi’–~Ti:;:’,§.?,”_3. extziffifise-~–<':Vf_ a§3§::(:EEaE€: ;.}§}2=a;'€:' arzfi

j':4':;**%s§.fé’tjg. £;<–:<%a:;rs:'§i::1g vaiiéé 321$; <::3g§3::"i£ r€22s{;»2}$

é§;1{§._§g.':1€%f:fi}:'€ uzéééfi $%.1bmi'§'$ ifmaéi {ggziagtémis sf Eatss; frzaflfifi £23

. mg é:'§i"§.Sé~§{}§°.€;'£'§I};§§i€§f3§"'7c"§_§§%T}i7E sf the E532;

£5"; §§$3.,3;§Ei~Vv.i"$f6I'§E§€'€ {(3 {E23 abiéire rival Esgai c@1x'i€11E;*;@13§;

iwgsd 5:39;. i:;{«:§7:a§ 4:3"? {he pa:":;i$:=;$ 'WE havfi {:81'£f'a2§}§;' sxazzzmezég

';:~svE1s'{i1ié'r '€315 sz:?:}s:a§::t§ai igassiimss 92%' law framssé in "this;

'~§i:*J–*;$éa:1 §,2€*::1iim'3 w:;.:':.:E{i arias §{}1" ma" {:3e:331.5=:i{§£:'a§:i:}.§3 azzfi; Elma

V :'ee:*§§;i:°e{i '£9 ':36 a3?:s2::6§'€{E ii": §§:W:' p§:=sz"i*;é§:2g {}:'::'e'2§3$1%;'i*Z"'E{3

Li

ihe afézfifiaiii g;}¢:;§::'fi.5; art: 2:33. $29215 £2? 'iiias ;"'§~:3§3':.»;§;3:'§.t§é22.

{§a€3%.i0z}$ v:::;: 2133 aria? £301' ::re::z:3i{I%€1.'a%i0I: 563:', §::E;1€:' =§;'«::"';";3,;1_::'wi:'2'g., V'

{"8880 1332

it £27: an :1§2{£i3;<::u§€:;§ i%;:?t_ §.ha?"'£&:SS'§iSS€€7}f§§'%iff°§A 5;;'{:..2"§'§.§s:Lé;»:=.gi€'=

<:%0§.3m €i%£i"iE3;g tbs: mo:'2%:}z1s {sf §§6§'éi€7§i'fi'3§' -:3£;. ';§%%%.?€":§:i}.3é)€Z3'
1???? and he hm; ;_}s;?:{:%._ §fi§¥;§§§§§»»}yaEii ii} 8
sum 3%' §s.?;3'?:'"S§~, '¥'E;3;é;f:'::':f%Tr.*,»":§'js::,"V"' §;:zp§):':%s2;€:i
?,?.1E'§"iC3§?'§i'};' at ':nfi§§§§:3E"j;i§}g 3 mirmia
:9 figs an '$12: 'igasig ai' '£15:

€I19m::3:<:'i§*é:€i;'::§_ '7§"'ax':fi.;{7§§§§<::::"- {§:1?é5E§;%igé::::<?€} 2"23§3<3§"§:.. 'E'E"1::::"afG:fi:':,
p:*<3p{';s.é'i§€:a::: :3.§ficé’-.:;3A;}aS.3hiéigé §3’€’;SE §:a(§.gs;::.:a:33;’1: 931$ EEK-‘E§_’£”{§. was
iSafE:'{{i{3{ii ‘§}:€_£ ?L’§’3€f 213+’;S63?-Sizfzg’*-%§s*%.:%i§:{:::’fi}f a§.:{:§ ELEM S8. “;3″£ £3 $€;:”a«*:r{§

u§T:<;:;; 352% aséé;§}_§€5 ::i&’:§>£=r:aE zwa;éEaE;§;e §;€§m”e: {:35 assessgizag zgzzéizaeifigyy

§::~iS’ ;;;a§%:;’:;€{.§ %;a$§. juiigmfim assessmem ::;:’€:§$:’ §f§}’ r€2;:::z’ ‘$6 iii: éfiizéff €::f

” -.§~5Z$_7?;i3?’,;’§{}{§f – :i;§:3l<::.%t: a§E}£}Z§11§i £8 m5i'a.'§.§§Zi:§E-Eiiiii E33" 3 aaié 'ééigéi

2;:.1g}§;:1'*{é$s§:%:'i 'i:m";.:9v:::;" E5'; E8, E~*%,;'33j?5€}j » amcé £316: '?z';'a_a:%;

':)::£:2'1 <t@.:}fim1€<§ E3}; 323% §«;f{i" zzzzgi 2':§'2:i2*€fi§:%:, '£»§!}.f:_";i:;'§'f3.§}.:i'éV' %,_-.:;£:T?:.::'::.–:'e_;1T:' V-

236 iEr£§£{':{§ as {:z"1"£;»:}.€<;:1;;s3 zmii ii": 923;' v1?:t:;:x",' » §§gfi'=

€,§'iE€Sf.'§€}I3;S :'23i3é:ii 2%-*02,:icf3; £,§}."iS€ .§%:::"j::}ur_ {:%:;:1$:«i{§e§i:";¢:§3;_::';::V'i:§"§;§:§$;

3:353:63 '§€z: ix ag'}:t:r::;:31fiz3f: wifis tic .%_é:3§312g:';.::{i–,<:»:*;%{::' §;;a_$–5;%:{1_

2:33?" E:'::.fi EéZ:%'§'. §–§::*.3'2{?€:', izfiiiigécsgé §3§%'i?.Ef§s:': iééiég ;:=:<r;€i

c:ié3:z2i33€z:§.

S&ޤ
Iaagg
§éé§

% “”*-“‘1-2

v%ff”*fi 7§%Q”””% %%%% Efiagg

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *