High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri S Ramesh vs The Commissioner on 29 September, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Sri S Ramesh vs The Commissioner on 29 September, 2010
Author: Manjula Chellur K.Govindarajulu
3% 'Fifi  §i€f§'{.§§E";€" 53%' 

 

§%"§?£E§&§ fififé €§»§.g$EE}

§§5§'E'}§ '§'§$  'ii--;:= 

 

PF€E§E NT

2§§?%'§ fiséii' GE' f£§:?"§E§a§§iI§§:; 

érgg. §«§{'".:;§-Egg: fiR5£§.§§'§E$E §a«i%€;§E..EE_,$ €;§.Vi»f:5Ei:E;i7'§.%fV;§§ V"  

fififi

'"§'§~§ Efifi "E3-E} 'if

 
  

=

E5 “§,”§?$EéE§:

Szésfigfiamfigézi
ggzzggmig ;.sa,2:;;m;:h§
Aga§&*m2.z:,§§§%§1?=i$-_g =i
Esgéziirg at fifimzifiié 1333.233? _: .

Eéiaézfgaémééi Ev’§ai:’;..%g¢&§§;’ ‘.

%fi§&”mz::i2″a%$§g:{§r:a,; Effififigég ‘
§”‘§§a2:mvf:§g§:§.§*?&1.; Vvifigtg, M ‘ « . V
§§v&§{T”2§3»r”%:?R§”‘;*”.¢~p %_ ‘

_ % W,§:9%§§£$§a?§
£33’: $3 Végggraifi

§§”§;$$m;:ia’§m’§

E ; ‘7£”Eia~: v{;€}3%:311’i’f,3i3;3§=3 E34533}

M ” ” ‘ 9 4″ * Féfigar §a:;;%a§a

§§.E’;%qma2::#-2,}
§§;’:§gsz.§§:*e.~:+sw«:§é%C3 $1233,

$gm§;~_:3§ gag §s:,gmz:§g§f2-3%:

figmzi amzzi. ?§ jagarsg
Ejfafiigiégg ai §§%:2,.3’3?; Z Eaiaifi, E §E::2€:;%::g

V ” Efi E fifigyaazag ‘%f”:§”§*’§§*aa§’§p:;ra,

fiafggéaérwfiéfi figfi?

::¢.= $%:§§’%§?§:«?§’E’§:

§:§§m1:%%: % Ea; §§::é§%:§§;z§§&:é§:;i§’ %

EH3′

§%§:*£€: ,;§%§@3i §”‘:°§.e:i “i§§’ *2? =35 iéza Eiaspgtgag Eiiégh
§:{§”§%.§?’?}; 5%: §m.fg%§:§ is; fifii. fifiéfifi éhfi :;§z:%;§:” §}%$$€:€§: £2″: i::2:e:
‘%§»:=::+: §a<a;::::fm %%g§h§§i%2§:?;§::2 {LE«~EEs§Ff';
gzgsggg 232%;

s”‘””%

fib. T fiafiwzfi fim faéim , ”

Hffiffii ‘isiza iaarzzzxi €E%%§§£§”‘i$ifi§ §’$3°’z§’2§’$z§:_§:é&:f.E§%;::i:V{_” a

fiézig apgaérééfa gfimifig §ff:§’: E2}: w:*::ié&2″:§ i§§§’3’§:~i;i’sg…§;£”Ef””;’g~.,_

3.5 ‘§’;’%:”:& §::°&3$:2€ &§§§:®§§a::: “”.§§a”$;:§ A’ 3; :*g#,:$};€::::§%;§é:..V””V

‘wiiare ‘$35 Eaearézigé gfigifi

tézsm %,2*z§§,$ 22:2 gzéséziag Ea; Efiga $2625: E1m:*z§;é:E:§’A”Vsé::g?::&

gftzfiga ia §}f%’}$+$§:§ %@ ‘ 3???? 35¢”

§,{*;’é~§’?2§ iZ§::€§§Q Eéza é§é3§”i$:a5 gaamx Kg ”?3%
E§<f:E§§»*"§»€E1§ :E:é$"a§§fi¢;i;§g%:i é;::-.'%;Lg:§"I'§3:§§ :E$§gE2T:}::3L::§ %'-"ééfiié §¥§&§€3E"

Qéajmiggé 'aha £fi333é§°"'§a,.iz$£?;$Z: af

$§€;aMi:%$$&E"A'§2.:::§A~&$a§§a 'ihéfi &§f3'§§'%%?¢. -. §§'E%s§z*$f<3:*a%§ 33% %g

gi§:.é.§nE§% E':-§.'§'%:e.v %fi"%a%3"&: ?§§3E'%&E":'5E§ii§&§'fa§ szxzzzfi wax fiiaé

V V' a %:2§:::::{:*§:§$«§': fag éjifiifiééfiéiiiffiii g

9'?—$3:°m"§'u$%.i$2:1 Wkégég mag mgmzzihazégfié, E: i&

Tgéggé §'.;<»3§i§£':€§i {@332 233% €.§§f'=§£%?§ 52%;" 323% E€1".£:'"E}é?:=:§ gézzgéa giaziégafz

'magi Ehé aivéi £39223? Eaaé g%r§::.%ma£5§ §;E";sfi§£E"§;§"l fi3"§fi:' :3?'

'é,;~,%;§:.:§:§a%s:2:: éiififiiéifififiéfi 23%: §;§§§2'":::&:£$:: $3?' graaxgfi. $5

km}

mfifieifiififiiy izfijligzafiiéfifl afigazwézig iiéfit aim z::?€}:"§$§:r:1§'§;i€'}§E

hag E 3% gm: up in -:. E335 gafiaiiflrgié

ggiam if '€§3§:§'%fr 31$ gag; gfigiaééeag ii fig fr}? iiftzg: &:$g.§%2<:z:%°§f£:i&:v§:_':€:s~ " .

éxiifiaia gram? a£§:§.:"§3i'§ £3:

§}f;f€:*’=§&E§”:% @§ §:e$*§”§%E’$;§§%$i31

3, fig, émi mix: fié” ~,é:f_E’:§
Egigiégaas &gg;:~m$§2:m: 22% mg writ
§f§%’?;§%§$:’:. :2: 23:3 33.51% ;m+,;§g::§y sizagia
§13,§;gfi: mfiaaifi “SEE: f:§§§{:s2%>*iz§ §:*:£s§:@:*’:L’ v ‘L A

*’ 5?: :*s?*::§§§;’*:é§ é§”:.§;:é?§2::%$$,; 352$ §§§i§5s5_r’:$%’*

:13 $33 Q;-22:3 ?§§=$?%3′ affigy {sf 3&3
?”€jfi?E_i”§ £%??;°€§.iL1? $£’:.:%?:§:3§:.*?.§.r§w giggzg ;:::£;i:§:
__ Q5 gréfir wig}: €329
:’%;§:%.€:é:f:§§*”§%::f E’%§i:,.2 fiféfi magfi frag: iége

:15.” “?’§&”?’§§’§:._ :5′. 33-23;? erfiga Efiz? fafipémfigfi
‘~.?x%”§.E &%§:§§z;.§§;iL’~3f§:e?1%s§*:’;§(%§*»;»§:* Eta::§:g 5%};-rag fifliififij
£3: Eéfisié’ fig: fix? mafiyxgr séafiefi

. , s:3£:{:»::;a ::;%i::::£ §§:.§§%’?:§% iizg g:%$§§§”§§::,§§* 332% 355% $3″
§*$*’f§”@:gr :;;€§?§§3% Q §§§'”?i$£§ iéf fififé gags:
:§};:a§r§z::;%g%;””‘;§f zéésg mama Sf fig

_ E§,§ ~. ‘ ?2é”&§, 52% zréiréégia in
:::i€:§’§ Eggs; §§§¥Z§:?§.»§§ §i%%§ %%§sz§§:§§§§

V mggéglrgzig fig 35mg 352%? 52% § §E

.- ,.,%%;2, E fig ikzzfifiisfggi gag

‘ §§§i2’T’§:§?§%§’§”.’§

” ¥gi:£*§;a2& af Ehfi giawaa agégi mréasig £3 a mgéiiaf §§

VM 1;: ‘ £2323 mfigéfierafigm %;,%g éfiéfirfiz 3? gig gfaaayzi

fgggfiaiiazzi, 232$ § &§ fiézgiaz ggaziiga gméfi s:2Z;2=$a:’%%:£§::

-1- § ‘%é*;:§§. 3

2%: mi: 33:25 §”$§§§’f$fii”?;’§.’}$§:i€§E§ $2″ fiix: §;:*;%:&::$ §””¥§%§;v{“;fE1§fiZ:’§Z

harfiézz, 233% €T;$:€*§gé§:°:§%§s3z*§ Ema Ea ifiiiifiifi a§:1:§3§§§z*§.§::§

éifiiéiiéifi €37: afimrfianfifi ‘€*’£’i’§Ef3.. Egw 3,222; s;:§&:*::%:’ia*: :%§§§….§§E:§i§E75%::’

wézéfim iii fiafgg.

$2, ‘§’%:& fifirgafiraaiifizi $%€:§J’§3%’éf§Z5

aafifim arsé afiiflf’ Ezaarézag aim §2’%§;é;:%__’i: fie: V’

3232?; simzzaai 3.1: e::*:*€;§;&§ :15 & 3% “ffiié 3&3?
atwnfiizg fize a§3″§§§:.;:§:zf*3;’~;V §t5:z%.’2:”:. ‘:;p§:§. Qamizfi 3? fififififi is E;’–£

mm ghgfifiaga €335: 3-azzgg ifé aazmriéasam iififii Egan ‘ »

Elhiffifi fiéfifififififififi $223 ..%§2:*§.’s:’

::i§fi@ 3333:. amwfi fmf mzmifiafgiéggfigaé.

..«;: ifiiazzgmgegzfigffi §§§§§@§§L;?%:’§i?§éf§§;2;§ :*:5%rsA’§€:m*:,:%£:%g:;§

3. 3, . _ ;_ __ __ _