High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Sadath Ali Khan vs The State Of Karnataka By The … on 31 August, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Sadath Ali Khan vs The State Of Karnataka By The … on 31 August, 2009
Author: Subhash B.Adi


W},

Hi THE KEGH CGURT OF KA.R?1IATA.K.& AT EAKG&L9RE
Dfi’T’ED TEES “1”E~iE§ 3 E.” {FAY C3?’ AEECEUST’, 2C?()’?3

EEZ1P{)RE»

“E’Hi«’Zi mrmanf; §v§E.J¥;,¥S’I’E.€1E; SU{~3Ir~E.ASH Bkfigifii’ 5 ;_. A’

CREMENAL ?E37’E’§’E’i(}l\§ N.cm:3120:2?, _A’_j ‘

B E7E’W’ E E N :

” {Q

2 8R§$AB&fi%%&L:KHAN

AGEB£8OUT66Y§A&S

Sflfi$£EEH$&NAKHAN .u > ‘g a_;

axMgM3Ep0§Lmm$ATwEA9$fifimX*aé

AND ::’:r–:za:mv:AN AND Ex <:§~{5_I:r«:§':.;ar~z _

KARNATAKA STATE :~:fi_I~é'€2£2E'?I§;S_ ${"}.?§4§§*s,€.§':Z%S§£I3EVJ

R,/<}F"§"§~iE PREMESES BEAEING 3§s§ 3G,{“:.., ‘ _

“EVEfiSHNfi3,fiWFiO0R, “=2 _.*,<

vN?ALMAmXAR0Aa,~_%'

BF:NGALC3RE–Ei«§£3'«QOE.§:

1 2 ” §*’E’?§’E’§£>§$€E§éi’

{By 1%-3r; :,-%;:_ég ‘:.«:’f»;e §L;;§,r’e*;’~:E:s:~a Azrwég

:12»

1 mg S’I’;€a’E’FZ;.{}F’§N .£-:.§\§ £~’¥i1RE~’; P€}LE€jtE’.; $*m”:’=:s:~s
E3£}Z?’*JG;%2L£}F3E.’ ~-

” « §;as~::3i;’LA_V%’$~g.o ABDUL SATAR S3838,
‘ Ni}.£”;._§i~§§VA;E3.__§{}AE}§
.;3E”{§”»’$J«£’ I*’é:”*’\G£a§ri§
~. 5A,NGAL{§–E€E;= ‘
s;:’;-;::P;:,.:;=:;g:::;%§’:; Vii} ZEATED r29:;::2{:es;
.. RESP€’f}§\§ETJ=§ZNT’S
{By Sri <2,as::w«:, gm? FOR R1,
3?? P;VEN%{AT&Gi§E5 §.:';}'s§i §'€}§ E2}

CEEELF FELEZEE E}/'$x43iiZ *C3E.?iC B'? 'THE :'%DVGC:A'§'E? Fifi? '"f"}§Ei

PE3TI'§'iO§'-EELE ?F%'AYIN€} THAT TENS 'H<'}N'BLE C':ifJL}§'.'T MA'? ETE
" —f'7'LE-ASE!) '?§T;3 SET' AS133 THE GREEK §}'T'.;2€);?.;'2C%iL*? E?'£";SSEf–B BY 'Y?-{E

VIH IXDCEL. Ci"M.M,}, E£'&NC%1%.L€3§?E EN Ci.C,§'§§.1?'5%"§Q;'i2(}fi'?'? EEEEECTING
THE? §§EL'}X$'"i"R¥%.'I"§¥3§'€ if)?' A fifiggli AGA§l"é§"F" 'THE? ;E3E'§'}.'"I'E{§}£\'§EE2 'E¥'f;'z§4E'

{}F§'EN{'iES Pg'Uf§E'L;34§, 448 A239 506 CI?' 198 AND SRBERENG
P}13{}C%?.§§ AGAINST HEM "FOE HES fis.§3"PEiA§3AN{2E {PE TI-$33—__ QEASZLE
BEFORE Tfifi QGURT' AND f"{)R"I'F§EE3 BE Pbffifififif} TO Q{§f~;,f3§€.'E'}i$
ENTIRE PRQCEEDINGS 1N THEE C&.$FA

:C1{}L§F«3'I' MASK '}"§~¥E §'€i}LL:C)U.IH'éG:

THIS PE'T'I'i'"i<3§~I COMENG are P:::a§2 CJRBERS ':f:%%:é":3;%;$:f;–

Pafifiancr has Callas} in {;u§::t.$t:i{§_i1 *

202.5230? 31;: <:»:::.;\:o,1?49a;209?=;ggassé::.. 5; %m% p¢:a11…{:.;;5.n4.,-V . "

Bangalore.


2. Rmpoxzdent N92   1:215 Cubbon
Park police 0:1    the §}€'f'iti0I1iE:I"
harem haé    i§':i"VVV'fr011t of his shep,
tliereby has    311$ aiifigss that Elli:

pétitionez’ wjzzi: {.'(}I1S€(}{7t1€E1CE§$. En LE5
regarfi a c:ixss: #v:3§sV ‘ifime 1″é0.96f 2386 far .31; ()fi§’33§”1C£E

p’u3:1isha.b}¢ nS€Ci;};0I1:§’:?.a 448, 536 0f the EPQ “Ph¢: paiicfi

‘<33; i:1v€'§'§'§:ig:a§i0::_, §1as"ii}6cZ~«th€ chmgfi Shtiiff.

3 3-. 13;. of 13:15 Sameg the ieanzzsé Magésizraiz: afifir

" s:;Qgn.§2:a:§§:–«5, has mxiersii far ;§SS£iff Gf sammaizs. 2%? this

–. «gtfaagfi. fi1i$”§;e§;§§:i01} is fiiasi.

4; ~7′”I’h$ iearzzfid; C:6E1I1$if’.–3 apfifiaritzg far E316 gatifiarier

% sa;:;?;;rs.§it{eé 2:232 {ha prewisions $1″ Séfiiiflfi 341 of S16 EEC are 30%
»’3§1§IflCffi{L as fixsrfi is I16 aiiagatioxx as regaztis to the pilgfsigza}

= ahsmzciiarx of £316 mmmal movements of a pr::rs(m§ What: is

aéisrgazfi in the crempiaint 01′ xvhat $3 aiieged in the ecrhargfi Sht?€:§. is
313%,, the Iklétfil ghtéets Ware dumped in {rent of £16 s}.1<::-1:}; . €*.iE_§ that

a<::c:used W33 rtzgaasiring the builcimg anti fu1"£§:e:: €h€r¢.¢.i,s '<*gf

{ha aflagatien cf threat fizzentienad in Ehe compiaifigi, 2"3;;;;1'iVVL"g¥?gM3'g::£;;é

aflagafiolzs 3373 made, The mateizdai caiiected bf; t§{3;€'AT13tz:vsV€c.'a:3.Vtié:?2

{£033 120: maks cut a case a1Zeged:'1«AE1'§*§::1'T tEi€– _SLa€.e:1;n'<=:;'f:!;_. "cf

witzzesseea recerded by the pcficaig they (iii: _:i:;t 5rtc;h5:a1': a11y*

allegation for the Qifence ;1rs.11:;is;3:1za¥:)f:ij"<L{:"V"'€.:i:f_T;£:t:;' tzxidcf 341 01'
undm' Seiction 566 of the also r€fe:*z"€{§ :0
the statement, of €235; '€9E?:i"{.I1Cf_SS(iE$'.-.V sfatas that
the matezriai was 3:3':-i1(:–«::¢:EI;taa:r:aeni as :'eg3;s:&s
to the physicais <31" {hit eompiainant,
'"E'h€: aiiegafitiéii' 9%: specificafljgz" aflegsti. Even
the: aHaga'i'iQn unciezi Sectiezz $66 of the WC

is also not aiiégvfi agaiz1st~t;EJE~.–}§€titi9n€r hzzrein.

< A "1"i:{€ Iéagnad vfgfiifinsai appczaring fizsr the campiaixzam

s'{1?;33§:V1iA:t:s§ {Ea acétugefi dumpeé fhfi shfiats Ei€s:*3ii}=~"

_ a ,, E3}.0ci«.":3'1:__g::Vtl":§:. shap and alga E1h:<'é:a§'t::}i::g {ha €?€)EX1§)§fii.ET1&fi7€,
is ii}. thj§:~f;:}:é<3:I:text campiaiizi is iiifiai. H8 aisc: $u'bm1'EE'{:*::i that,
E138 camplaézzagxzzi a;::g;::"0aci1§:d €335: i;".f饧.E iT:{:a,fi't :&s;:.z:¥
.__;§V§"f:33' ;:1€;4:}£ an i11jm1C%370z1. Ha. furfher siibmiéitad iI%1za;€', '%%E§?3."3t'iSS€3S

have ham: sXa,mi1f3.~»W

r’T{–7;’

6. it is 2302? sztaiezi that the i.i}ji§ii{?{i0E1 £3 G§{iffi’§;§_’£’1§j against.

the accusaifih it is also? S’L’E~3.f£i{i *:E:a.i., {£1232 0E:s$t1ru.i1.1g 011 3’3} fmnt of the $501} and §if\i5″§.V’.Ei£{£{511i;%C’:$3;~

psrsenaiiy or phfigsicailjgi b1<x:}ci;ég""-..;;;f :5: V_mnye;;;e':;is«v»:g' am"

coznpiainani. fit £26: hast, it ma§{*'~._ts%si:;sa iiuisaarxgé "E0 figs

Cgmgzlaalzzant in muming £116. ?§§us::1e:§s;V fa7::<_a$ §11:*€ai.e;t;2l:1g i3

Concexzzed, <:tc:;3:133£ai1j:a;"1§ h.s:s:3v..;1_»:';:~t ::3i€a%iGi'::5d "' £316 fieteifis crf éhs:
£}ff€fi{':€« """ "

‘1 S§j1€€,$§§€g3fi{?f{}.S E2136, £:<:;:::z¥:a3£:-§i:'1: and tbs: ::ha:'g<: 52:55:
and aiss; the–_i21zti:fiiii:.;;i;-.Vs:%c:j:e.1';:#:j:éd..affiihs wéian {hfi a<:<::.:.se:.:i

had ?i'3};;€:.1T1 :V;<*.;3ai:' iX*07S'k," .z1§f3e–:i1:;a%E}:' in case Sf zaiggaéz". $0.312:

0bStI'£lC?§{31I Lwfil E35» fi?{:%:%:. Eu': that iiszzif may get '$35 a ggrmmd fat}

*V.V:321€;v.:~;::€Vi1ie *;}ei';<sg::1.. Siam the: abstmicéiozs is }"€fl10V=$£.i E}.},'3;d figs

cém§§3it:m_sféiss rf:;_zfi;1i:::g {ha iaaisirzsgs 91:25. <::i<§ii 31$: is ziiso

§.3e:1<§.§I1,§; fz2:"ii;':{:L:9._3:siat::r:al €?"§'§§€C§fi{'§ by $313 p:'*0$€a::'u%:i0r: aisa {E963
413;}? maE<::..§%.1:§; cigar C336 agaézzsi, Q38 pc":'{i"£1§9;r3.€3; E find §"§:a§:, ihig

:§3§",:'{i:1L3:{3%i'{:$=i§§ff§; ht: aiiisgtfzéé E725; q1:as.§1i:1g the §rG<:ee<i.1'1;g$. '

§8. Hgwevsr, at ibis stage, iatarzzefiazi cmmséi appéaring fin'

_ iiae pefitionaz' fairiy stibzzmfstcd that, he xvii}; aésa i::2s'i2':1ct' his

20 ha {tfifiiifii with thfi e::0mp£aj.n.a11§.

/-TT

In View 9}” the €1bfi’i?’€_, this peéitigm is aiiasamti Tha

;§m<7:eed.§1:1gs 11:1 {3.I'%o. 3.?"4~9€)j 2&8? stazzdg quashad.

"AP! «»