High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Scaria Mathai vs The Appellate Authority And … on 11 December, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Sri Scaria Mathai vs The Appellate Authority And … on 11 December, 2008
Author: L.Narayana Swamy


GQSSVE 90-S0/T’ON TVH&JV NI ‘LOGZ’0I’ZZ’IG 33Q8O
fl39NfldWI 33$ HSVflO 0% 9NIfiV3d flflfilfl fifi SIHL

(‘AGV JAOQ ‘TIEVH’B’HSEWVEN?§’IHS R8)

SER5flNOd9EH “‘ fiGV9HVH&T3E
NOISIAIG XGVBNVHETES

xasxaao msaaoa aauva an; _g” ‘ ‘V

_ aaoTv9NvK V.

mnvmsrssv TVDINflD3m”~’

xomvnaasuos msauoa ;&fiasa4uHv,« ‘.

aomvnxasmoa msaaoa muvmszssg ax; .z=

fi8fiiVBNwfi Av.

3133:; axotv9mvw;_ V
msaaoa so 8c;vhxsxo3VunV-* ;

xaraonmnv aavzfiaqav 3H&-_Iv}

(‘Aav ‘svgyiqgik $°£aé fig!”

aauoxaxmsa “‘ :~”2 T § g~7 mfiiaisxa H a
2 2”. .’« a _ agv9HvHm1ma

…. _ “”–v*:=ze’xanaIcIvx
V ‘~” 2′ .asno§ BNVNEXAI V/a
¢.’; ” Suva; :9 G29?

, _”na’$”I IH&Y$EH 0/5
‘.’,I?HmVW Vixens I35 I

NEEMEES

‘Hf {$ca¢w®}3GQz:sztz’on xoxmxmaa mraa
xwaMs*vNvxé$vfi 2 zaI&snr’aw a$a.NoH as;
‘ 330333

, $moz**§aafimaau so KVG.mI§ anm sxnm aamvu

” ” V3up&vafi9fi mv Vxvmvxuvx JO mxnoo H913 axm ax

F

panes’; 512:4 en; ‘puet aqjq. xx’; se’n’;.a’3::;o1=z :;sa::o;-«non

EUTOP ST .I8’£10§Q.’§.’.|.9d 3Q}. SEJUTS paw 1393!’? 2.8920; 31[.’.|.

urunm wumo purer was an tretn was am so sears:

tr; uomsanb tr; iiqxecioxé atn :0 sxatmo err;

Keqq ‘.’|.’BT.[7.’; urgezo squapuotisax arm; ‘ATpazrxo:z;.§3..§:uz2AT.VV: ”

B11829 aqq. .§I!1″§:|.13A’F:].'[‘t£O ‘pane s:;ua:>..~~o»;=:_’ s.;f4é:t:.:J1a’¥’ f’g’

IE11-240;; vanes 99 same? 5» 1:22:12 squaa:”ao91 ss;::::é~.

zuersxe mm on I/€02 mm 2/6s’é§;”‘a’Ss :¢~”- t?°!$91é,é6=:€%<i"'-'V

rm: 9'! 9!: train stncmqns ':t'W°1-'=+4_I:=i'§'v'». – g”‘ s{_”it-§e#fiifér’~=I£v sxepm
pazxbnénw; raqq. pa£fs;:a5gV.49:*:a’fi§’ s~e§:i1:T’:’.’iV;2§.§:zo*;q?f;;écI am’,

arm. apt:-at qxnoa ‘:£1=:po:;_ ‘ :;::21o;)” eqq. ezogtaq dnozfi ,3′
I1′.”;I’ .5’££”f£’.I’BGI.[ :6; no ‘i.:;_f;umoo uorqrqad qrxea 91:215.

samtcraaaoua 33353113 ‘I’1:v am:

sLr_IAV ‘z3″V«”Lj$H&: 2:3 aassva ‘SO’8’eI’J3€I uzcrao

‘:&é::;V1;”z;t:~:'”i2’¢1 ‘§00Z’8’O’£’.I.(I aaaao

– ‘-..”_a-;;£wzc;;m:. ‘am HSVQO aw ‘v–»m:rv mm ‘”122! mm 1.9

F

U? firpazzxwe ST I9U0?4T49d zen: snrwqns

.’Ia’f.IO’§3’T.’j.”§’J.9CI 911?]. 10; 189222103 PBIEXEBT E5115, ‘fir

* sqtzapuodsasx sq; V. ” ‘ T ‘-

.-to; xapeafa ::.::auru.:eAo;-3 pauxszat arm pme :r.. ”

0&2 aseum ‘L002/0¥/Z3 peaep ‘zé9#Q_an#”;9w:§$§é§i”w”

so 3:99 an: wnxg sK=p_ es §i§2IMx_H§i¢vd§=95
paz”;.:oq:m1;-rm. eqq. uxo1_; aq’§:;:r£.}x_Aé; gem at;
ujrexaqm 2E:;’;::rot[:m’e $q.B_T'[Bdd;E~- v_ P’?-“ES
aqq, pafiuetreqs
499103 91:12:. on $.33 zarfiasz-93
find on pax§ém’éeQ__%§ %é#§;n;i fine panerndmas
axrgq, 32;; tVi9:r:;’:’;1::-L’ “–.Vf§ev.faeo:oua sq; 1110.2;
azeoan on xa#oI;ta§5.9E: §fii$oexIp S003/6/9 pazep
.:tap:;m. s*e{; ‘ ‘xeguw sq: go sqoadse em

rye ?;1@i3IStI_¢i2 2:;-gzoqqne quapzzodsex BI.[,'[,

C;’u’:xaq:1s:u p.é*:¢’.« §_:.=>:; tIVcV>;> pm: sa’;:nf::oq:;,m2 aw; exegaq

paxéedde firséozqrqad aim ‘ ,:;:’.91;: mm.’ any or;

f’fi§i%é;éxn;;e4:éu1$1eH ‘:96: 49% asexoa ‘exeueuxex

;”C)” “{‘;”A’:[2″!2′)’fi’-fig 9/n uo’;:;:>’_me Jo; :a::>1_::;o’

em; .6u’_rs-s’ecE ptre xauomjqaci aqq go uo’_L’q:>’g:Aa

.6u’_rq.:>a.:’;p 11′; 5411259111 0:: $1: astaqq axogaxaqq

‘pare 2E:n:A’;:;:m 19910;-uou ‘B 9’; zzoxqm ‘B912 qsazag

tr; uogqenxqtno sv,x9::o’;q’g:q:ad atn qsugrefie uo1:;;.:>1%:_A» ~ V ”

tie:-59:; sax; nuatzzqxedap 45910; 911:; ‘1E'[.tSu’;+p:a*~12f.%.>:a’§zf’_{‘».

‘van 219910; aqq tr; sa1:q1f.:x’E::§’e. ‘_ 2).!-;«’.=I_.§lVI'<')§'

-1102: dogs on, puu uo’}:q,:>1=.v axe; on ::’;’s-‘a x,g«. ” ”

aqq. on panes’; 9.13». suo’;::;oa:t*_;f1:$’~V..V_ Axéssaoagx 3

uorsroap was an ;o 14r91-‘A311 ’12a$ii%v’_1’E9xo: “aim.
sazqrarqoe 39910; -ac-u do’1t=a .o*41 V 92939

atn pure nuamuxmos ‘rrz.1a.t=é=Lf–:a_:ir1~*:;> (seat

as 1.65″! an!) suarfio EI¢EIIi:.;§O __:’:0–3′.,§’n§ “””9sA ‘ ‘me

was Vrmmuxz 4.z§i7T_a.: ff’1 I ‘ilénas wxazzdng
an .9112″: pazxxoqqneun
III 9’: 1auo;t’3?519§I ‘ stnrurqnfi xapwata
4ua=3m=”‘°9 P’?'”~”~”?5’*€ ._¥’%>Q:L 35- éféuaq no ‘now an: J0
Y” tx tr; an sxerpxo mm
::>e=r:fi:v§=l£?sI»=”” S7}-‘ ‘tam 13910; am uzruam
ggmoo ‘V ;o uorqzoci q:>’,rzy-1 papraap qcu
‘u$.i’;§aiggb’v Kqsradoztd aq; xano drqsxawao

s’;$,_€;”‘.4″‘VpV§at;z;*;f{q1Véé;sa not: set; quauzxedea qsexog

_ pun”: 9:1; 3:0 uomednaoo pazrxoqgneun

T~:_s.&’1′:.=..*.V:r III .K”|f’.’|,§J’FI’.’.|.§ 9.339 $9′!I’Q.’F.1’Ot[Z|.Il’EZ

arm liq passed sxapxo amt,

-squapuodsaa: aqq.

Aq Jaqqezu mg; gco sqoadse arm. ‘rte

azrexqsuouzevp xapsro peufincixrg any

»gp_'[OD3.I ratqetnzae 9:1; 5:11:11;-;.:r9A Jaqge ”

aqz; passed fie». Jeqqo on qznm :;g:a’r”

8I.[‘.’} H9331′,

care sen. tretm
serntxcugne atn azogaq xxgaddu …%.:f’as=1;§;’;q.’.§£’i;a’z::;,sn.1_I Texzzqeu go xapxcr
tn: uwbv ‘,,pasn;a:r;,”~;§}i”eu§.’ pauznqex
tzaaq set: auxl:-as yg9′}.”.’}”!.’J|IOT.{‘.’].!1’E
aqq. axogaq : V””s.*v1=.-.¢rs sq qogrqn
2:1: zsod pa.fé’a»;1§”;béx– no pangs”;
sen :ao1::}ot;_ut;c¥§§~ auQ’;. “gs:se:’:”:’3’_f;’:;o:z Texanes panssg:

uaaq”~spq ‘§”ae:;,,,~*~-~«’*a{:’p:az’g:xotzq.n’:eun uowgqsanh

2:1: :}:”t.-..1A.=z”[,. aez::,_ ‘V :v’tz<;:f";':;1ednooo at s: xeuonrqed arm

§z?R4 uses at i? féfibxo paufinfimr ans wmxa '9

"101"-T?'-'I-ad '-'1-'37-TM» "«"-'tI3l- 5° 'f99'5"F"15"!-"P

' sxapxo paufinfim:

go zzozqezepxsucza 7″?!

so 9 as 9 %§§é * »V

‘ MPBSI1-J3-In exetxs A’ ‘:pr=§”tx.:€_’V*A”‘.?«~.*””7’,%

‘3[=>oI=uc I”£’ “‘-1;? §0G_3f£_.u/§,_

– .I9I101.’:|.1″.’|.8d aaqz;

max; :1: xemaez prm SSOT 91.12; ssassm oq, quamxedap

sun oz; fiqxaqzrt fiurmesax paqsenb act on ezqert

st uorqxod pres éqq aouag “.;uaIu:;,.:tedap ‘:;.sa;g_’_’:’;

$114 0:; pasmea 99¢”: :10 Mar go qaadsax tn; ‘M

9″?-‘ am: mm are V–#9» rrotrnoes “pas?-€é”‘a§Ei#en«’éfii

fiurssessa axograq name 490;: Kaat oq. O’/\[j’. gang.’ ”

se}::n:.:ot;:;n1:=: quaqadxxoa aqq. ‘:;:::*’;§_”‘~:3,..s:e:zd;.a

arr: .-$0 mrI)v–vv9 uorzoas zaptfit-.VV_:v:§:4
zeuonjrgad ‘ sq; Jog: tesun-3.5:} pa%uxs._s:afl1_”‘ ‘9

V ‘:_”‘7g_§trvr.:2?'{—–:*,’isa:to; mm
II’; psrxxeo 9’3: d;z°:n~:q:; aes oz;
fiqnp ptre V?.’fi§+’2x:.’;z try: zqfizz seq
zmaunxedau qsvéxdg V qsaxog em, Jo; qou
ptre qxnoo ‘[‘yA1’:>L”–«.g,;:e:;;g-.~)§:i1md«p Réqq azogtaq ‘.}!.[5′[.’.It 93:11
1I9’F:’Ef1z_iin’; ‘*aqq ipéxmasqo 3′; 21.1’ ‘uonuaquoo pres

fag: ;o H:;:.féaT§aV.:.:V:’ v*vpme’\;: 49910; 91.11; ;,to uonradnooo

st: 1E?!.LfO’F2i;’;§§3.5¢& eqz; quaqxa qeqm oz; pepxoap

:s§1=::’:.:ou4n1== mm 3’9T-I4 9: xauornned art:

j, :tf:_a}f:;i:_é:1’uéo mg; -9351: ‘gave uoxqemasuog gsaxog

J

ebpnx

-/Ps

“}fiffiQ?p#%$§efl;$_pa§%a§:p st uotqgqaa
31′-us ‘p*::audn “.a’;:aa & arm ‘zoadeaz
xaqqo ux f§£I'”u§IA_}a$3§p3oooe H; xeuoyqrqad
en} wb§; Q@egL§q; x$Aoasx’pue pasnes ssot rename

sq; §$as§eu9q,£4;9§$1 42 9x quamnxedap asaxog sq;

😕 l”m’4a”°H’*A’.’=»’P¢’ié£35} V5QB1a1I 91-‘ nuavnsredap 3’-593:0}

éu; Q4 pééfiuhahkéer go Kxanooax sgoaxrp qaxqn

$w@@&mg€mmma-wmmmfinndmnnw

Hh » §¥#a; 3¢fiéséa: aaoqe sq; go MBIA u: ‘5