High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Shantha Kumara vs Nehru Yuva Kendra Sanghatan on 29 May, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Sri Shantha Kumara vs Nehru Yuva Kendra Sanghatan on 29 May, 2008
Author: H N Das


h .:;£e,g{ 31:; E <:s– 13Am1»:RIs}J1:-sA Sf-i§sS'{'RY I%"'OR E3

E3? "HQ? PUG}? C{;'}UR"}" (3? A"? B:'%NGA1.,(}RE

-H
DATIEID TEES THE ‘?–“1TI}.AY 41}? ‘MAY. ZOE33

EEEFCERE

mg I-I{;>2~€’BLE. MR. }L?S’I’I<IE H32. 2~sA:-sg<3A.3_»-{{:_')1~:A;\s 13¢-as H. V * ..

WRIT PE-TITIQBE Na. i(}(§59f2I}i}7 {S»'£7E3J

I3E'f'WEEN

gm $HA;N'1'"I~IA ::%A

M} L;=\.”fB; (fIfiEZE~FNAPP.-x :.«:HI~:T”rY

:?x{}}€}Z} ABt…?r 53 YEARS ‘ ‘
xs:121<:,::~s(3~ AS Y1_:”m C.(j)~C)Ri}I}€A_’A ‘.,:«9x~_:;§'{;f:
‘;.’a;”Ei}?iE%,L§’ “:’V{.1’\x’A }::;i:::xm.’n»., m;.13. M1EL’I”IfS’§'”€;7}}?;IE§,D
BU::L1:}IN<2_.::~:£:'m{1;;';ax-i.',m – * “V
EV-I.fa_NG.»XL€DRE,D K131sTR;{:*r * A ~
. 1.,.;-}?:;”:{‘1’;§:e:nx:7£a:2.

(‘By Stir K (}m .

{‘:~J1;’:<_i:::.P» sf";';a1'?3IL?:xfi-.,A' = .. ' –

1s:%:.a,§s”1″ m;;,s’».2;:A.,_ ZVEW’;1§E_LI”‘£2T_1″;»!:r€£:i}2
R.EFI~:E;$EN%:’::; I3Y”I’I_”S A1:r:”1z;£a_;?:’r12. £éL(.P}£RS<1}NNEL)
* ':~:1isi}i;*i£:.x;*1.i3.~ax 1:£t~2£~z;x’rA.:«~:
‘ 1N1.31m’ e;”s-.A.N:aI»n IE\?1′)C)(If)R :F§’I’AI”)I1_T’ix-‘I.
‘ §§_..¢;:+;7i_1>?;iV,sx.;i.;é~;; AV ‘ .

j:’~3″‘££’_’-53 1;»§s:sf;z:§ 13;’s:i;s:>;>.

= Ta.)

321 .<: I I)'-5$1)fiEZA
. V Y<:)U'1ii-E {TS-(T)R};':IE\EA'I"C3R
§~T£iHR'L.i='.I3:"£;F\-'A KEENDRA

.. 1\»=EA;l7)H<ER1

– £?£’f)Q£{G DI.’$”I’R}C’T

‘$.03

RRSI’C}NI}E1’x”f S

~ ;§:;~i ; N..»-m..iARE$£I, AC<..:-Sc mg R1–;3j;

ULLJV”

F3

TI–313 WRI’I’ IPE”I’IT§(}N IS FELED UNDER AR’FE€;”.IL.§iS 226 A.3\E3;.}
“212? OF “£34331 CQNSTI’II.§TIC)N {ILEF EE-‘I”I”H A PRAYER TC)
QUASH THE ORDER BY. é¥~.’}’.I»IOf}7 PASSED BY R2 ‘\f1fI7IIE

E SO Fz”~a.R AS THE S4-“s;\a{EL RELATES TC} TH}Fi TR:’\N§s’;F}3R (LE1?

}3ETI’1″iL”}N1EI”-{.

T}3§::: Writ Peménn h.a\»’ing Emmi beam and resen=’e::d fer §;};*é:i€::’$,”E}1)Efs;– *’

(flay, NAC:&3.=i{}§~L=&.N DAS J, p:’£)nmmc$z§ the fnd€.m. 120.2 in 50 fen’ as it .1:-;l”la:£¢s: §'<:».°f,'§ié"i:::3.tsfé:;1._0f petitiiméz? fmna
?~.-ia.Iz.g;2':,i01'e K0 M21di};e1*i and far t1'z1nsfa:r_'::~f 3'r'§'§€§$})Qi}(i€'1iEv~fI;0§fl 'Ma.cii14;r.e1'i $0

Mzxngaiare.

3. V’:_I*’i1*s~§3;– §N’eV$Vi:§’€I;f’1§Q¥’$:£,iE’ __Y’mra ¥»-Lenciia Séifififiéiihiili is an
éiiitfinflfflfllifi 1309:}: :mdm'”=tlaé” }’z«ii1′[§’:»:§tz”3§= of “Youth affairs, and Sgorts,

(3-ow-rnznetga’ Of ;E.n_£ha. F:i<§ttiV2{?£_}§. to 280'? 112:: petitio-netr wetkeszi at Nchxu

"z'_'u\..%a' Kflidra ?"'as1:':;:~;1_<'1),-'a. {En 29.1.2CK}'}' the '2" responéent passe-d am

<f:«1'der. gmgting {§i€'v..§1r€iIit§(}n.fiI' an inclxazgc baseis 3.3; 't'"euth »z';001'cii21a.tor 57%)} tins:

' N<';hm ':£T.;_1'»ra1_.'i«iiv*::§é'2':*3 at I}a1<;shina Kanraafiza .E}istric.L. Mangaioré:-.

~ : 'v;.~'7'.§Vt2.5z";'.£'C§iEig1'}'z!'}1¢';p€?iEi(}fif:'f w<::-nt £9 lkaiazzgaieraz and £'i2"'=§¥{?§.'f€(i fan' éiiliy on

;9:.?:§2§§-;?}'Eb._ Wlvszzz the pe£.i:§.0m¢:' was s-%;Q:'%;ing as in~«c:ha;'gs": ;§~*uth

., 31.11:?

-sisjmrdiréaior at ;\r1ang;1lfe th .. E’€’é’sp£{}I’1{i€I1E passeai an <':+r<11 It is not in ciispuw Ilia: the 3″ re:spnci¢ni’ is 3 naiéxfi:

:§3;:%? ‘*

}f}2a.E<;shi:1a I£{.a1m;aLia }Z}is4rict. Tin'-.2 Efremsfczr gmlicy/guiciaiixma 0fj:"é;~spaA::&£ei:if'–~

aaatabiéskzment apmzifies than gm 2: mz:ttc':r-;a1° 1.*;:Eic-:s_._-1 .p:;r,s;_tingg.5_’é:nc1$£i’af{:sf<:fS:

jwuth ::m:=1*<iinai.0s:3 In that ;."e:sp€:c.iive Emma i:%4ist:';'{<:'i;s~ 's110E;:'{»a§."~;a's:' faxi 7-IA

pussibie be avmimzéi except undw twat: c§1*::ur1:sutance&'.-V. The i1::T;§V:1g2[::c§–v{2;f§1:=:r

do mi spezaifi 52$ fie what are thze €§.'iI{:€§3fiO§"£Ei§ ui'.:a5?€¢:¥.i3'1'i5§f::t3::a31€:s«–f?;)I' Em Eifrzl' ski'

F5'! xrespczandeni frem §x~:Emii£<;eri IQ-«..E'$~i'<1nra;_1er<§–.V. 43*-..§*¢;'"sA in the §stz::',en1c:ni' of

elujeatians reap-onclemsa 1 and 3A..§1§1??'s'.7-.Vf1U{ s:atte%éi£'v,avs§'*V–'§§} .«-£4113? are: the
e:=s:<:e;:a$;i:s,3″£.21;;V1″i;~:.if”e5;v1*;->-‘fl the 35″‘ 1′{2S§3(}fl€if:f1f
f;”mfz1 ;\}-‘i’ae;i§§<;:3:'i to ?i*£;2ng;:1t:w. '"{"§3¢;a'§é.*%fij;3"$,: =;E3veV'.£1*:2V§;s;u:gir1:3(,i <)rn£i£:fi1; is in–:§§:31′”‘x”imi:§£t.%QIi’ ‘aaf z€:*-§;:1sf%:3′ puiia:’§.=”,»”gu£<i::Iin.es.

?. In E15142: i1T1pug;:e(T2t’1d:”c?,’:’.fi”¢’.’.i’ i:s_Lsi.%_e:d ‘*I<;za-q.:_1::-.33. as 3 speeiai. cziscfi '."{'h:: 3" rezspazsnczieni.

éléfa-hiss Vsf;<i€z:%:n<:»:1:VGf:cE:§é:c–.ti0ns states that 0:; medicaé grmzndg he scsught for

V Erainfifissi fi"»':2t1'} 1\«-1.2:-iiijizefi £0 M;-zngzilercz. Even R¢spn<:%ent EA amd 2 in :}wr71'

sfzziarnent éiiigie-Ctioiis s£'a.t¢s; E113: ihe 3"; responder}! is s;uffc:1'£r15_3.; fi"£,'3~1'I'3

V 'a3_}§:.5.'«E}:{I.iL}'Vi§~i13l'l<§.»"f§V;{' 5:126 an aim! gtrmnd he was n"a1zs'f:-rred fmm 1'»x£;zéi%»:r:.=:-:*i is

:'.s,+;§«'.;%,:1§g.'=1,}e':is':*:'é.A.A In r;'n:'<Es::s R2 find mm' the Erma 3 c%§re<:£i£3:": was isassuaii I0 i'i'1<:*

–«¥.fi:§2’21e:’c1 c-eurassi £791′ ‘Ehs:: 1r.'<:s5psc:~z'1d@m I zmai 2 to semxm the {E16 :"eia.iir:;"g Es";

.i152:nsf'a:1* 0? 3" r¢s-:p<m-cienl: 2231;? to firsd 011$ wimt is the: E't3-pf'i€é§tf}'Ei.éi€ii)f3 given

(#4./J

fi

' ::_m

by the 3"' resggazpmient, what is: the'; ziihtmnt that he is sufiéring anti the
me:-wziicai c-artiiia-zzte that he hem p1°0:iuce-d. B}s;i that 1
transafe-r of 3″! reszpondeni is not can account. chmnic afimem tizaf. 4ij1e.__is; V A’

sufiE:t’it1g.. Then: is no atlwz” maierial an recard in §3t’€3VE;’ afidMr’;fSffib1′- §5:. %%2;:t

the 3″ r<':sp0n<ic:n.i is suffc::ri:1g from. chronic; ;m.:.:':1e1~;:":a;;%:1 cm that. §;;}1::.i_a '

was tram-;fan"e<:£ fmm ;'\~£.ac:iiE«;{2ri is: E\. 4’i7ha’1?=::rfi>:’e t11%:_=_é.;”:%;}u,;z;11:;;c%’ ”

erdez” 0i’;§”d1*espomi&::1tfi’0n1 .’.’~.«f2:.di§<:r:'::'i E0 .Z%.»:Ez:t§g"a.§Q2'e is Isa; V;2iy ;:«::r§’:*ra:’}’5VI0
*£ara:33f1r::’ p0iic;::=’_gu§<ieIim:s ems} {Em Eéfilfiifi is ;n';:§af§§§e si1":*::i_ ar¥)§.m%i*3%';'A

fa'. Sm' §%aEa.l«;1-mafia}: zxéaazging1’¢1i3nc::..;;§%: ;§j?13_§(1@”§:cs’:i :3f2»’E’A2%: s%;.i.:g;>.sfe;:1’££: azemri in Szzzic: uf

11?. am: fliizéfs V, <;qss;;::;§}:,:;¢:%%J,s2<v%.;s;§a_ 3394 5:0 2:55 a:<m:'e:m:i§g £}:;1t.%E:«'3:
c+;"<im° sf Vtrarzsfer made mfirzz Eta. i:crfi§3;2fassgi{3z*: of zs<;12n§1":1?s;€'1"ai§x-'et guiciaiimasa

czizzrma" 2:is»:;x;€j::' i:1.'E¢:'£7err;:£’::-:::&bE_<: right E
Em ié' €§1és_cQn.£a£1£in 017 §s;’=i*£i”E1t2d €:€JI.mSa’§§ fag’ {ha 1’€3′;’3{}Q§}d@.iHI

2163.3; “I ’31:: E§1:p:§?:::z.:;§Vif-{§a-21f?*’i;1. {3v:>ba1″dhan1a}.’§ casc Stateei thai if aha t:’&i1+’§fs.é§

an tiiIA1};”3l§V}}«’é;Tii;§.-£5)’ is 35:3 an mzicoine af maiafidér <::£a=:'ci.s;c 0%" ;}mvif%:§§f:;®:. :10 Sf}, an arcier of éransfc-3: mm 332:: i11:£%1’fm”:z»:i with. In the:
V. ii is c-ontendccl ma! the £2’ansf<:r 0f'1'e:s;:p0n<ie':::1€ no.3 W£I:€=; £331
%;:i§<:1.isaE g:'un<;i. Bu: no .1nat£+ria} £3 gkéacaci M: ms.:<31"d in S-Ili}f_}i')E'f azrf ibis

V ¢;:-s;;;:i£e, gmniing saffiaiw-nt time, i”i3S13{3fi€§t?’I”I§!§ faékzd {‘0

dw.

ofsré

pmd’ua:e the rez:rc:, Eh-at

impugned «::1’de.r of transfer of 3″ 1’espondcm.Ié is an outa:me of maiafixgi-;’*

exez.*c;isa <)1f";30:m:%:*z:11d as such {he szima-2 can be ixzterfereai by {hit}: <.:<;mz'i.'T »V

5% flivissien bemh sf {his QiZ}111'I in f:'§.S:;arfara;: Kimn .':\r"'%$'."'SfEi{§T t*?f

I*x"2zma1:aI<;3 3.41%. Z?,(}£}1 Kai' 1393 h:';Ia:! as uzzaiar':

"ff :3 Wife; fags $fc;Eé'e3 1325;'! fire; c¥:;;???f'??1'l3'£"a'iE?1?éij}rf}:%§3€5?""1?€;i"Zfé$':';§3-:55??? {I26 T

:7f,?e2r*:1.::;s?izz’ ms: Eire Emfézai ;”%*::>2?: {£252 czrfygfaé _’fié’§_°.g2*!}}¢;4:?” fixe ;;;11¢»*2*T%’..Vi::;§ ‘w§2fg’c?2 _~’-ram-:.~
;m9,x:m~mEe ¢?s3:2z=?véa%?7″2é:;¢fe2$f,f€z:i{‘s’fi’zs3 s”:22_;2VzI$j§:*i7eaf era??? w’Iz'<.:Ie2a.'f _f§'.'3i"

a*s"2e;;2=2' :*€:3$.::.:;=2. "

«_ 9. En.__ iheu §113{a;i’iV«at.;:,s£:;withifi as msrimci sf fiw infikmhfi, the

pétit{0a1<:;4'i:.Vt1';az1§fm'$££ from §\:§£EE1g3§€}i"&? :9 :\«'f{€L€§.3°§£"Z'3;'iv ]E*'m°E1mz* me '£1'am;fe:v:'

1'¢sp€§n:i¢ni ii'ii':'33. ?i.T<:~.i;id;iI«-:§*.~';2'3'. K7: 3'x<:§21ng31<m:: if; rim" aaniy C()fiE3"'a3'};' to the

tmz*;:.»;fm" 1"!{)§i4€i}v':'gi1i€1é'.Iii'18E§ efxf 2'r:31:w.)n£ient's es%abii$;h3rm'%.€ and the 33.91% is rm
.V;tf:1:t{:'s::z;<~.: <:f.m.a3Ea.fic%:;: 63;'-siti."-i"£'«i$fi3 9,5 prewar". E3.2:*£:he1' ihazr :*a§§3-e::1ad<-:m§; faiimzi £0

-, ;;2″<;ci.=_,a~;:'€:._ ;3£r'1j;=' .i'3f1£i'i'4:":'E'i2£§ ii': a.=5.iabI.§5;h "£11233" 0:: 1*:1::c§i.ca1 wrouncis EM: 3"

inn.

aw-

T::e$’péim:vck:€.n£ was i’ramfe1*recE. in {he 2:é2’mmsEa:1ca:sg and fax’ the §”€ié3$£’L!f€’tS

” . . gféitéd eibitw-*3 ‘aha f0iE.{2w§:::1.g::

ii)

XEKAEB .

{)R.II}E€,’§£

Wm; pe»£1?€i0’n £5 alleweéi.

“fha im;:suga€:1′:;%:3:’ mi”§17emss’f’::=:r dzamd +1».’?.;7Z{}i”}’? 31:1 5140 fear V ”

it raiziiag: Its) the petilioner 3.11:3 me; 3%”! :.’espa3ne:§~>;:nI §Ii%}T¢2§’:=’:<='. v. L' , A'

quazsiwd. {Z3a*a;im":f:<21 ae¢<'3rcEi:i1gE3-*.