h .:;£e,g{ 31:; E <:s– 13Am1»:RIs}J1:-sA Sf-i§sS'{'RY I%"'OR E3
E3? "HQ? PUG}? C{;'}UR"}" (3? A"? B:'%NGA1.,(}RE
-H
DATIEID TEES THE ‘?–“1TI}.AY 41}? ‘MAY. ZOE33
EEEFCERE
mg I-I{;>2~€’BLE. MR. }L?S’I’I<IE H32. 2~sA:-sg<3A.3_»-{{:_')1~:A;\s 13¢-as H. V * ..
WRIT PE-TITIQBE Na. i(}(§59f2I}i}7 {S»'£7E3J
I3E'f'WEEN
gm $HA;N'1'"I~IA ::%A
M} L;=\.”fB; (fIfiEZE~FNAPP.-x :.«:HI~:T”rY
:?x{}}€}Z} ABt…?r 53 YEARS ‘ ‘
xs:121<:,::~s(3~ AS Y1_:”m C.(j)~C)Ri}I}€A_’A ‘.,:«9x~_:;§'{;f:
‘;.’a;”Ei}?iE%,L§’ “:’V{.1’\x’A }::;i:::xm.’n»., m;.13. M1EL’I”IfS’§'”€;7}}?;IE§,D
BU::L1:}IN<2_.::~:£:'m{1;;';ax-i.',m – * “V
EV-I.fa_NG.»XL€DRE,D K131sTR;{:*r * A ~
. 1.,.;-}?:;”:{‘1’;§:e:nx:7£a:2.
(‘By Stir K (}m .
{‘:~J1;’:<_i:::.P» sf";';a1'?3IL?:xfi-.,A' = .. ' –
1s:%:.a,§s”1″ m;;,s’».2;:A.,_ ZVEW’;1§E_LI”‘£2T_1″;»!:r€£:i}2
R.EFI~:E;$EN%:’::; I3Y”I’I_”S A1:r:”1z;£a_;?:’r12. £éL(.P}£RS<1}NNEL)
* ':~:1isi}i;*i£:.x;*1.i3.~ax 1:£t~2£~z;x’rA.:«~:
‘ 1N1.31m’ e;”s-.A.N:aI»n IE\?1′)C)(If)R :F§’I’AI”)I1_T’ix-‘I.
‘ §§_..¢;:+;7i_1>?;iV,sx.;i.;é~;; AV ‘ .
j:’~3″‘££’_’-53 1;»§s:sf;z:§ 13;’s:i;s:>;>.
= Ta.)
321 .<: I I)'-5$1)fiEZA
. V Y<:)U'1ii-E {TS-(T)R};':IE\EA'I"C3R
§~T£iHR'L.i='.I3:"£;F\-'A KEENDRA
.. 1\»=EA;l7)H<ER1
– £?£’f)Q£{G DI.’$”I’R}C’T
‘$.03
RRSI’C}NI}E1’x”f S
~ ;§:;~i ; N..»-m..iARE$£I, AC<..:-Sc mg R1–;3j;
ULLJV”
F3
TI–313 WRI’I’ IPE”I’IT§(}N IS FELED UNDER AR’FE€;”.IL.§iS 226 A.3\E3;.}
“212? OF “£34331 CQNSTI’II.§TIC)N {ILEF EE-‘I”I”H A PRAYER TC)
QUASH THE ORDER BY. é¥~.’}’.I»IOf}7 PASSED BY R2 ‘\f1fI7IIE
E SO Fz”~a.R AS THE S4-“s;\a{EL RELATES TC} TH}Fi TR:’\N§s’;F}3R (LE1?
}3ETI’1″iL”}N1EI”-{.
T}3§::: Writ Peménn h.a\»’ing Emmi beam and resen=’e::d fer §;};*é:i€::’$,”E}1)Efs;– *’
(flay, NAC:&3.=i{}§~L=&.N DAS J, p:’£)nmmc$z§ the fnd€.m. 120.2 in 50 fen’ as it .1:-;l”la:£¢s: §'<:».°f,'§ié"i:::3.tsfé:;1._0f petitiiméz? fmna
?~.-ia.Iz.g;2':,i01'e K0 M21di};e1*i and far t1'z1nsfa:r_'::~f 3'r'§'§€§$})Qi}(i€'1iEv~fI;0§fl 'Ma.cii14;r.e1'i $0
Mzxngaiare.
3. V’:_I*’i1*s~§3;– §N’eV$Vi:§’€I;f’1§Q¥’$:£,iE’ __Y’mra ¥»-Lenciia Séifififiéiihiili is an
éiiitfinflfflfllifi 1309:}: :mdm'”=tlaé” }’z«ii1′[§’:»:§tz”3§= of “Youth affairs, and Sgorts,
(3-ow-rnznetga’ Of ;E.n_£ha. F:i<§ttiV2{?£_}§. to 280'? 112:: petitio-netr wetkeszi at Nchxu
"z'_'u\..%a' Kflidra ?"'as1:':;:~;1_<'1),-'a. {En 29.1.2CK}'}' the '2" responéent passe-d am
<f:«1'der. gmgting {§i€'v..§1r€iIit§(}n.fiI' an inclxazgc baseis 3.3; 't'"euth »z';001'cii21a.tor 57%)} tins:
' N<';hm ':£T.;_1'»ra1_.'i«iiv*::§é'2':*3 at I}a1<;shina Kanraafiza .E}istric.L. Mangaioré:-.
~ : 'v;.~'7'.§Vt2.5z";'.£'C§iEig1'}'z!'}1¢';p€?iEi(}fif:'f w<::-nt £9 lkaiazzgaieraz and £'i2"'=§¥{?§.'f€(i fan' éiiliy on
;9:.?:§2§§-;?}'Eb._ Wlvszzz the pe£.i:§.0m¢:' was s-%;Q:'%;ing as in~«c:ha;'gs": ;§~*uth
., 31.11:?
-sisjmrdiréaior at ;\r1ang;1lfe th .. E’€’é’sp£{}I’1{i€I1E passeai an <':+r<11 It is not in ciispuw Ilia: the 3″ re:spnci¢ni’ is 3 naiéxfi:
:§3;:%? ‘*
}f}2a.E<;shi:1a I£{.a1m;aLia }Z}is4rict. Tin'-.2 Efremsfczr gmlicy/guiciaiixma 0fj:"é;~spaA::&£ei:if'–~
aaatabiéskzment apmzifies than gm 2: mz:ttc':r-;a1° 1.*;:Eic-:s_._-1 .p:;r,s;_tingg.5_’é:nc1$£i’af{:sf<:fS:
jwuth ::m:=1*<iinai.0s:3 In that ;."e:sp€:c.iive Emma i:%4ist:';'{<:'i;s~ 's110E;:'{»a§."~;a's:' faxi 7-IA
pussibie be avmimzéi except undw twat: c§1*::ur1:sutance&'.-V. The i1::T;§V:1g2[::c§–v{2;f§1:=:r
do mi spezaifi 52$ fie what are thze €§.'iI{:€§3fiO§"£Ei§ ui'.:a5?€¢:¥.i3'1'i5§f::t3::a31€:s«–f?;)I' Em Eifrzl' ski'
F5'! xrespczandeni frem §x~:Emii£<;eri IQ-«..E'$~i'<1nra;_1er<§–.V. 43*-..§*¢;'"sA in the §stz::',en1c:ni' of
elujeatians reap-onclemsa 1 and 3A..§1§1??'s'.7-.Vf1U{ s:atte%éi£'v,avs§'*V–'§§} .«-£4113? are: the
e:=s:<:e;:a$;i:s,3″£.21;;V1″i;~:.if”e5;v1*;->-‘fl the 35″‘ 1′{2S§3(}fl€if:f1f
f;”mfz1 ;\}-‘i’ae;i§§<;:3:'i to ?i*£;2ng;:1t:w. '"{"§3¢;a'§é.*%fij;3"$,: =;E3veV'.£1*:2V§;s;u:gir1:3(,i <)rn£i£:fi1; is in–:§§:31′”‘x”imi:§£t.%QIi’ ‘aaf z€:*-§;:1sf%:3′ puiia:’§.=”,»”gu£<i::Iin.es.
?. In E15142: i1T1pug;:e(T2t’1d:”c?,’:’.fi”¢’.’.i’ i:s_Lsi.%_e:d ‘*I<;za-q.:_1::-.33. as 3 speeiai. cziscfi '."{'h:: 3" rezspazsnczieni.
éléfa-hiss Vsf;<i€z:%:n<:»:1:VGf:cE:§é:c–.ti0ns states that 0:; medicaé grmzndg he scsught for
V Erainfifissi fi"»':2t1'} 1\«-1.2:-iiijizefi £0 M;-zngzilercz. Even R¢spn<:%ent EA amd 2 in :}wr71'
sfzziarnent éiiigie-Ctioiis s£'a.t¢s; E113: ihe 3"; responder}! is s;uffc:1'£r15_3.; fi"£,'3~1'I'3
V 'a3_}§:.5.'«E}:{I.iL}'Vi§~i13l'l<§.»"f§V;{' 5:126 an aim! gtrmnd he was n"a1zs'f:-rred fmm 1'»x£;zéi%»:r:.=:-:*i is
:'.s,+;§«'.;%,:1§g.'=1,}e':is':*:'é.A.A In r;'n:'<Es::s R2 find mm' the Erma 3 c%§re<:£i£3:": was isassuaii I0 i'i'1<:*
–«¥.fi:§2’21e:’c1 c-eurassi £791′ ‘Ehs:: 1r.'<:s5psc:~z'1d@m I zmai 2 to semxm the {E16 :"eia.iir:;"g Es";
.i152:nsf'a:1* 0? 3" r¢s-:p<m-cienl: 2231;? to firsd 011$ wimt is the: E't3-pf'i€é§tf}'Ei.éi€ii)f3 given
(#4./J
fi
' ::_m
by the 3"' resggazpmient, what is: the'; ziihtmnt that he is sufiéring anti the
me:-wziicai c-artiiia-zzte that he hem p1°0:iuce-d. B}s;i that 1
transafe-r of 3″! reszpondeni is not can account. chmnic afimem tizaf. 4ij1e.__is; V A’
sufiE:t’it1g.. Then: is no atlwz” maierial an recard in §3t’€3VE;’ afidMr’;fSffib1′- §5:. %%2;:t
the 3″ r<':sp0n<ic:n.i is suffc::ri:1g from. chronic; ;m.:.:':1e1~;:":a;;%:1 cm that. §;;}1::.i_a '
was tram-;fan"e<:£ fmm ;'\~£.ac:iiE«;{2ri is: E\. 4’i7ha’1?=::rfi>:’e t11%:_=_é.;”:%;}u,;z;11:;;c%’ ”
erdez” 0i’;§”d1*espomi&::1tfi’0n1 .’.’~.«f2:.di§<:r:'::'i E0 .Z%.»:Ez:t§g"a.§Q2'e is Isa; V;2iy ;:«::r§’:*ra:’}’5VI0
*£ara:33f1r::’ p0iic;::=’_gu§<ieIim:s ems} {Em Eéfilfiifi is ;n';:§af§§§e si1":*::i_ ar¥)§.m%i*3%';'A
fa'. Sm' §%aEa.l«;1-mafia}: zxéaazging1’¢1i3nc::..;;§%: ;§j?13_§(1@”§:cs’:i :3f2»’E’A2%: s%;.i.:g;>.sfe;:1’££: azemri in Szzzic: uf
11?. am: fliizéfs V, <;qss;;::;§}:,:;¢:%%J,s2<v%.;s;§a_ 3394 5:0 2:55 a:<m:'e:m:i§g £}:;1t.%E:«'3:
c+;"<im° sf Vtrarzsfer made mfirzz Eta. i:crfi§3;2fassgi{3z*: of zs<;12n§1":1?s;€'1"ai§x-'et guiciaiimasa
czizzrma" 2:is»:;x;€j::' i:1.'E¢:'£7err;:£’::-:::&bE_<: right E
Em ié' €§1és_cQn.£a£1£in 017 §s;’=i*£i”E1t2d €:€JI.mSa’§§ fag’ {ha 1’€3′;’3{}Q§}d@.iHI
2163.3; “I ’31:: E§1:p:§?:::z.:;§Vif-{§a-21f?*’i;1. {3v:>ba1″dhan1a}.’§ casc Stateei thai if aha t:’&i1+’§fs.é§
an tiiIA1};”3l§V}}«’é;Tii;§.-£5)’ is 35:3 an mzicoine af maiafidér <::£a=:'ci.s;c 0%" ;}mvif%:§§f:;®:. :10 Sf}, an arcier of éransfc-3: mm 332:: i11:£%1’fm”:z»:i with. In the:
V. ii is c-ontendccl ma! the £2’ansf<:r 0f'1'e:s;:p0n<ie':::1€ no.3 W£I:€=; £331
%;:i§<:1.isaE g:'un<;i. Bu: no .1nat£+ria} £3 gkéacaci M: ms.:<31"d in S-Ili}f_}i')E'f azrf ibis
V ¢;:-s;;;:i£e, gmniing saffiaiw-nt time, i”i3S13{3fi€§t?’I”I§!§ faékzd {‘0
dw.
ofsré
pmd’ua:e the rez:rc:, Eh-at
impugned «::1’de.r of transfer of 3″ 1’espondcm.Ié is an outa:me of maiafixgi-;’*
exez.*c;isa <)1f";30:m:%:*z:11d as such {he szima-2 can be ixzterfereai by {hit}: <.:<;mz'i.'T »V
5% flivissien bemh sf {his QiZ}111'I in f:'§.S:;arfara;: Kimn .':\r"'%$'."'SfEi{§T t*?f
I*x"2zma1:aI<;3 3.41%. Z?,(}£}1 Kai' 1393 h:';Ia:! as uzzaiar':
"ff :3 Wife; fags $fc;Eé'e3 1325;'! fire; c¥:;;???f'??1'l3'£"a'iE?1?éij}rf}:%§3€5?""1?€;i"Zfé$':';§3-:55??? {I26 T
:7f,?e2r*:1.::;s?izz’ ms: Eire Emfézai ;”%*::>2?: {£252 czrfygfaé _’fié’§_°.g2*!}}¢;4:?” fixe ;;;11¢»*2*T%’..Vi::;§ ‘w§2fg’c?2 _~’-ram-:.~
;m9,x:m~mEe ¢?s3:2z=?véa%?7″2é:;¢fe2$f,f€z:i{‘s’fi’zs3 s”:22_;2VzI$j§:*i7eaf era??? w’Iz'<.:Ie2a.'f _f§'.'3i"
a*s"2e;;2=2' :*€:3$.::.:;=2. "
«_ 9. En.__ iheu §113{a;i’iV«at.;:,s£:;withifi as msrimci sf fiw infikmhfi, the
pétit{0a1<:;4'i:.Vt1';az1§fm'$££ from §\:§£EE1g3§€}i"&? :9 :\«'f{€L€§.3°§£"Z'3;'iv ]E*'m°E1mz* me '£1'am;fe:v:'
1'¢sp€§n:i¢ni ii'ii':'33. ?i.T<:~.i;id;iI«-:§*.~';2'3'. K7: 3'x<:§21ng31<m:: if; rim" aaniy C()fiE3"'a3'};' to the
tmz*;:.»;fm" 1"!{)§i4€i}v':'gi1i€1é'.Iii'18E§ efxf 2'r:31:w.)n£ient's es%abii$;h3rm'%.€ and the 33.91% is rm
.V;tf:1:t{:'s::z;<~.: <:f.m.a3Ea.fic%:;: 63;'-siti."-i"£'«i$fi3 9,5 prewar". E3.2:*£:he1' ihazr :*a§§3-e::1ad<-:m§; faiimzi £0
-, ;;2″<;ci.=_,a~;:'€:._ ;3£r'1j;=' .i'3f1£i'i'4:":'E'i2£§ ii': a.=5.iabI.§5;h "£11233" 0:: 1*:1::c§i.ca1 wrouncis EM: 3"
inn.
aw-
T::e$’péim:vck:€.n£ was i’ramfe1*recE. in {he 2:é2’mmsEa:1ca:sg and fax’ the §”€ié3$£’L!f€’tS
” . . gféitéd eibitw-*3 ‘aha f0iE.{2w§:::1.g::
ii)
XEKAEB .
{)R.II}E€,’§£
Wm; pe»£1?€i0’n £5 alleweéi.
“fha im;:suga€:1′:;%:3:’ mi”§17emss’f’::=:r dzamd +1».’?.;7Z{}i”}’? 31:1 5140 fear V ”
it raiziiag: Its) the petilioner 3.11:3 me; 3%”! :.’espa3ne:§~>;:nI §Ii%}T¢2§’:=’:<='. v. L' , A'
quazsiwd. {Z3a*a;im":f:<21 ae¢<'3rcEi:i1gE3-*.