High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Shivaraju vs Sri Marigaiah on 16 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Sri Shivaraju vs Sri Marigaiah on 16 November, 2010
Author: Anand Byrareddy


IE1 Tifi Efiifirii CQERT {FF %R2’3’fi;T5KA 3′?

msma ma 13$ 15:}: my 8}? §GVE}.{BER 2.m%[ ”

BEFQEE

Km aawam rm. JUSTISE mmgmmgggy

gggwga ggcmm AWE&§.a3§ ${1::§9_ G’?

BE’1*¥?EE1€:’

$E;;E..SiiEVA,R£..3E.I ~ 1, ; x
s;oHA:aAvEGms:nA,Ac;»E:4aYE.&$é8: ‘

Rffi Jafiagfiawa vmassy” – *
§;a&aaAH&§;§,a§:3:§§RE*m1g:£:§ – * ‘

Hassazg Em. a_37%:;2§;21~%_ ~ j_ % A?FELIAN’f

(BY mm;

8RZ{.B£!§.RIG.fi&’ri – ‘ .A

3; as .§;.’§”_.?a”-E-~;–,S
gm Janggsmvra xtmmaz

riaazaz, “I’,ALZ3I{

gag

z=za3s«.a.;§z’;mT, -g 5333 2:32 REERBIQDEHT

Smnd Ayrgaai E: ffiaé; under Swaicsn 1%

‘ the jufigzamant axfi dacree dam& 1.92298″?
if; E8. §f:3.43f2&%-4~ an ‘him file aftitza Civil Jufige
E>I_.1.}”&?§fidi, CJM, Araficere aibwim the asgpseal anti mfiing

V -agidaitllaa jufigamsm and éwfse éataé. 27.1.20$*i- pa%@ in

€?§S;§a.§{?;.%1 an ‘him file :3? the Civii Judge (fir. $11.3 &

‘I’%Tm Apgwal mmim an far gm hmrw this day, aim

Saar: éfimzw the fiikmfngw

.5

mmamm
E-Iearé tha iearfi mufigel appmizg far

a%lLantz Tfmugh ‘rim apwai has bani: admtmdg x

mm su’7ast&nfia1 quasfisn af flaw fiameds

2, fix a§ £ was the §1a§nti;.”‘?1;’;’J

Saurt in 9-. gait fax’ @333 ” L’

bat}. aervwi zéamairm z2r1r::;3;f%a:;m5Q1_;”§’1′:as;_ §:ia§§:;;i:§.fi?’:av’§s:uit far

fi§j fl was dezzraéd 9%: cf the

“?r?m1§$ur;€: ‘
ef the auhmission
mag am;-1 am mam me.»
V 43:» be iza pafiagasaien
‘A 1. égggfiyzfiant sf tha suit acimcluia garepertg
er anbrim in am: am 2, whim}:

A 13* {En am} fivifififiizé :3?’ W2
gfiw suit gcheduie ymyerty 3:333 hem
ggmm dgazimm that it is me; gyfiaianfi.
5;efe:§:.:3a21t 33: nmnbrazy ciaim m m in
F psaseaaimz axis? anjaynmm mi” tha suit m:ha&u1e
gmmrty am} ciaim that it is psmieszz at’
Sy$§$.2 sf Jaéagémtta aifiaga. But ‘aha 33.116.
fact is mt pmmfl %’ meam gf siomzmcniary

6

eazifiezma, $11 iha 331$’ hazaé, 3%’: has!
adm1?’z.t,e& in his crasawaxamfmtiexz fiat mg.
mg. aarmxzie @~fipert3′ is a site am it
prcwrty’ I€a,3.6§ maasmm East wast H
ané Earth Scat}; as 9:, V
mwméa East sf the suit ‘A

thfirfi £3 aim ‘mfimfirg

ms éiaputafi beurxdary t::a§{a..r§;a 3

rm hafi afilumtaziiy %;m:m:§ t%5§£¥°’§:V ‘-€l;’;&r¢«’ aiée
mm 39,3 whioii m%;m gzamafi.

322.: km 12% “ézrwarcis
smh afium. He ::§_ia»t.?::é%- aczmszzaa
the gm-«ms gr mg
payificjzagaa . ;5£$§sm_5ian and mjuymant
amm am gamma tkat the
321i: a:::1[:€.:s§d’t’zl;c1V’§é+a=s§per§ty m belmm ts

% , 3 pamhayam. Hz: baa
_ A . the Gram Famhayath haci
‘V aim in fasmir ef difiereztzt

Evhe bclmfxg $0 $23 Gram

Fanxfigajgath. But he Ems § £32343 gzram’. £351

Q * saw 3? the ‘§%1a7ng am
“::x;%I1§idm*a®:z1 sf tfw admxksiszfzs 9f 33!}. it: his
cmas– fian it mkm ant the suit

scimtduéc pmpezrty ¢ baiang tn:
fiabhanaglmtfa Gram parzeimyaib arzé it is
airs:-. mgzaaurm 43 3; 50?, whiah mm

{mt tkmi tawarfis ms: fif ‘aha 32.1%.
sahwuisa §r:};:2m*t3; thwez is aim} sits in
mzisierm which ‘minngs ta em R§f:§ ,

Wham tlzzfa being Q38 cream the yiainrizifi’
prmmd his cnntezxifinzz tlrzat fie £3 in ;3msm§:;§z5.;’E1_ :
mm: aigiayfimnt 9f the suit aszhfiuie ”
Whig}: ia mmgnisad by {ha
and 2. 53:; the emntraifié’;-.. flag a¢;maag,: RV%%% 7
claémixug ffis pcsawaian e:=g’1j{2ym:::it;VVA. 3

mg: at’ th& suit: 3cha§”1z2§§e”» §rep€fi~’t§%”A
am: as in act at’ mtarfgranca aés; ;a11g§efi.a.'”‘–A

3. In an apgea-:.3_. Caurt, fixg

mwx mat, in a $13.it. far
i1’g.}’uz1::.:’&:r1¥ it aisne whigh is» material
‘_v§ac:§;.§£;;’ titie Emsvssier £3 pméea by the
:§§z;£i:T§:i_ by firm égfandant, tha Tria}; {Baum ought

the titk as W31}; ‘Hhifih is a Ezewn
. 3’m”23prud»*;:nm. Ii £3 fmmd by 11%;: imsérr

V R éilieufl that Em glaintfifi has rm’: prmuced the
aaefiificateg undar whiah ha ciaimw thai, the pmperty
V .’:§;:§;r:%.$ been grantw in big facsmur. Ha has mt even yrcrdumaé

anfz mgr af tin grant wfificata as swenfiagf exridanca.

5

Thfi eniy dacumant relics} upmz is Ex.?-1 – tiw asamsment
mmmctg arfl E;x.F-2 — the éemzfi Ifigisber mm-act for rim

ycar 26036:. It £5 feumi by the Lew»:-gzr AWHa€x:Hi£’;%.:1t1;’t

that thare £3 rm mfemm of the aaié mutafinn

rewards much was 33 rwrds 3. gant >

favcmr as’ am piaizrtifi’. me plainfifi’ g¢3§;.%%:;¢:%k

awn: {Em ard-er sf gm: a.m1i-.._.§:21§:4§€s»f;::ri'<:.a,V flag' v

tezzfimw the Wan
his mm. Ga 'cm crflmr §ia:§i:1,_ had pmduced
E»x,$~1E. m " allataeé in

: :15 matefiai in disimige

Ex'B– 3. and 'aim piaizzfifi' wag apyarently

ucufiei§:;<3;%f£.;;«:3ft!1e ma harm sy,na.2 in tim

rm :'§f"i.€x,E§é;§,;'4.A.If::v+:iji$c§Iansw that rm smh find was anotmd.

Smart aka heié Qua: flmze wag ms

.. '_'~_;.'_a;i'i§na.pt V521. 'Chg wrt cf aha glaintifi ta marina Em

af the Vflkga Panchayat 'Tm fiufiamntiate h§m tame

'§1$1'6 was 8 gm: mda in {Tawny sf the p3air1t§fi' by tfw

Tim fiawm fipfiilatfi Quart Ems nwahed the

evidazmg sf ?Ws-2 mad 3 Whxts haé éagoscsd ii': famur 9f the

6

piaintifi’ 3.136; mm that E::s.?~1 ma 2 wgm

&ar 23% whetma flw suit W93 fiieci in ”

and thg Ceuri has fgufid Ehai aha ssaid d§;c:3a::nf§:::§§.::’u§%¢r¢’

ayparamfiy seaumé w fiie the suitiziifiwifiéifi. “I

warn inmmylets and mafia; fi;3t»’s;;T§§t$i2$3xa>1ts ‘fé’=-.:fi§;?2 §,7;f &

grain: havixg ‘hmn made in it

is in thai vaiiz, €113 lcmmrv §.fi*’~ __ has sag. asiége the

fiudgemni fif the fim,:a*§’.; . if V

4, ‘§?:e1’e gm :§e;mnm $2′ fix: Lower
Rims af iaw a:z**3.s%:m for

mmmyaaagsjfiw fincfinfi 0:’ mg. Tha Lawar

‘viimxrt this mawiai mrifienm

vlfizfgé __ 3.12% ha agsmafi as 8.303%, {mg was mt

quwtimm :3? kw.

E%.%§§§§£igb;, thtz is dismmsmih

Sd/–

Judge