High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri.Siddaramaiah vs The Bangalore Development … on 17 December, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri.Siddaramaiah vs The Bangalore Development … on 17 December, 2009
Author: Mohan Shantanagoudar
....--..u 1r1.|r'1i\l-I :u\.1i'1 puux; gar 5AKNAfAKA  C'

1

9: Tim }fiGH cwra' 5'  M

SRI.SIE{3AF£MéAIAH ._  r
sfe hA?E SR: SIBERMBHGVIL , . "a;
we sao.3£.=§,.--';2 -.'_'B"§_§%A1I€ .:KQ?i£%°'--.._ '  '
QMBR LAYQHT is x 3 _ =V~w~
EA£~i{3ALG§"«.E1 ";s4§0«:::4;'3 "   A' 
"'-,,; PEETEQEER

{By sr£;R.$ HEé§gg*g3vg;u§-
ms: V

 ,fi}%§5G.7#;LQR'E awzzmregarsv ASTHGRE W
f?:CHQ¥$AIAH"Rfl§fi
 "1'-:2;§»z:za;aA 23323 was?
 "3P~k§._=;i9'.~LC»!?£¥'..S6flQ2Q
.gREBjEy"zTs,coHfi:ss:Qm§g

EE$§QE§E§T

_-fjw' {Ey Sr£;é aaxgaswxgvy a3v§§;

ZLv ?3ES $32? ?E?ITIQ§ $3 Fiafifi Efiflfifi; ARTESLE

~,'226%A§§ 22? 6? THE C0§3TIT3TI$§ 6? INDIA ?RA?Z§G
, ?@7CALL FGR THE Rfififififlfi EELATI§$ T6 THE $ASE QF
'vn  ?HE FE?ITIGH$Ra FRQ% THE REEP§MfiEE?2 Qfifififi' THE
"EM?§$§EE Qfifififi §T$ E1.5,E§§9 ESSUEE 3? THE

RES?G§fiEfiT Ylfifi fifiX~? A3 Ikhfifififi R33 ¥I?H%§T
E¥?H§RETY 3? &R¥.



----->upun- um-w-s wuu In --nu»-v wu'v'.wp.vu-v-.-urn -_-'p_.-uyv.-1-z-sunny-an-v - supp: - 'gun - 'gs pwpguuygqgpquuq s ggg,-3-g I \,',.5,n; - ',3.-."p'".'r';,"\'q_ g1.'-gr. "Vgfil 'Jr g\','K",'.',,'",. -run"-|.,r' 

2

11% ?m*rr2oN mama cm ma zmnrim T2123  v. V.

Tifil' {EGJRT MAE 'FIE P'C3LI.(3V}IHG:-

"I"h¢ eras: of   

zmgeeg iswed by me 
Daxrebfimmt Authorizcy    _qum'f:§§n in
thaw:-at' patmm    L  A

Heard    on beilaif

afboth    on mm.

2.   ma auotm ma site

'Vi¥n.122i{€%}§Q8 I*$R' gm Stage Layout, £21

%   §'A31'£;4vA'V*$-id&abhcvi. xioamvex, afiicr ma amt; of

32+: rim ma' aim ma. aliattad in Ex 39:: 3;-i.

    was a ma p&fi"£f£o::24;':r mm. The ma
   the safi aim m the 9  allattw
  tax the fact timt lifigatimm ware geing an

 a laxg perm' sf 29 years' 51% tak1x1'g gm

aamieieratisan time facts, 211$ BEA has eiacidafi tat: aliot
aimrnafive mite ta film ailsttam and amardingfy akttfi

"§j'\



awn'-

Elva: F mu-w'u-Ina

3

an aitesrnative site Ho,2BM-389, maasuring 20' K _
Qkmfi Laynnt in fiavtmr 6f the  The  :3I)Eu  "~ E"d  

was ezamuhfi in favzmr sf the  £331  

vkic  'B' by the EDA,

3; Subsequeazitly?   sf
camezxatm 55 issuec 1"'---Q9.   dame:
11.5.2009

; aim
mafia in in tbs: very
‘ s1″mw~£:at.1se mm-,

aamd:14.5.e§wag gatzzigner «mag that
the aiaenxative fifra Drum}? layout ways
mgalorwa Devdcgmgmt
Aufimgi§%”‘af szmj Rules, ::.%4 (

Ruw” £9: sham ami mm
% t9~ tr: why am m sits
famtir szmm mt be mama.

A it is mended by mm mum: far the

that fiwskmwamma mzim ;ima::4.s.o9 was

S mt sartaed ugan témgetitlmmz

Q? ;”_i?

‘lI\’iI” ‘u’|ml’\oI!\I Ml’! 1\J’ll\II-l’lIr1|\.r-I IIiVn7|’ \p\(\aVV’ \l’ ‘\f1I’\I’I!”1I7″‘V-IV!” o-var” 1-as-rI-I

4

4», It caxzmiz be asapmw. that the
mmavmea me mm” ‘mm of Risks mags} of mef ‘
w-hiss main’ mg the aaomem of akernsfififié

01′ ths petiticnar. It cannot afiebbg

make as gamma: by any k
cmtxtravening the gf L
be jxzsirifiecl in V ‘ the
rrect1o’ 23. gr mm 9.

remsorzahle resorted ts:

€srh€:t1 as has

9. mfide: pumhasar cf the

fie: 1mIuab£e mmidmafian. Tim
made as back aa an 3g§;05. At thim
am it:£errfis ta mm: its mistake by
%% the afiemem with an agar m smash gar
%% site ané am: it in: mm, it wifi affwt em

:.Virx’bm~wt affim peti’t3?arzam* who is the mnafide pzlrchaaezx

“”- ‘-“-‘- ‘–”–‘v’\- V: nnnwnannl-\ HIUI1 CC

5

6. At this stage, Sri S. V.

mmisel apgmng’ on hahalf crf BEA.
matter may be sent back té am

ef the matter. The said aubmjssfiafiuarnmfi . t

mafia’. y it deed

in fawn: txfthe A

B: jxnpugrxw crdc;-hr iw
gs-ad the 33% camrmt
be __’t1″m petitiezxer aanrmt be:

fimixzaefl d :1? Absulutely ztm ailegatians

” the petitiomr.

VL the aikmarxti re-«allatmsmt, tha:
suppzmfi Tim fifira the BIIEIL
gag §’%&c§§rds are mam bgfmre the am; me am
‘ % 52$-1mié&’a&n 9f the mamiai an 2%:-cl, aliaettaé

kj Vfi1’£¢Vsit:s £23 fawm arms pemmm. Awarding ts its own

“aiming, the B32’; in at fault. The pefitionzer cammt be

mafia “in sugar bwauss sf tha fault af am; This fiaurt

‘$”H”¥”\’ \I’* “|l””l\’l”‘I’lT’II\l” CIIVJUV ‘Inv\fl”\(l\’ NI’ ‘\J”‘II\I’7″‘lIl’II\l’- ¢I’\I” ‘Vu\-PHI” \F’ I\l’IU\I’l’IUl§I\f’ VII?!’ \i\FH”‘\’ 3′! U\P’l\I’l”If’\I\” !Il\J”‘ \’\I\I[\’ fill”

5

am mt wish to put. ms clock ‘back afier bang u

finme. If the am is perm1’t:taci to raciiza A wmgA { Q

proceriure, it may cause ‘– ‘V

8. in viaw cf tha same,”fl§¢-…V9r§£ér’V:¢f
Vida ‘F’, dam ;..1. ;§iv5:2(i£}9, be
suataixxad and aarrzav u quashed.
Afl£flfi&hmfiY3£h£§hfi£flr§§§%&%r§£§§%%%; ,H

Azmexum–‘F’,
exam 1 — ma, stands
§’£3aaI?@¥ ‘ VA —

‘~ _

‘ ‘»_ *mn;u23.:2.§§