High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Vatal Nagaraj Mla vs The Hon’Ble Speaker Karnataka … on 2 November, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Vatal Nagaraj Mla vs The Hon’Ble Speaker Karnataka … on 2 November, 2009
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) & Shantanagoudar
Ir: $32 I-iifiii fimim as' mmawmg Ari' Emfimom
BATE!) 11:13 THE oznd D2§.Y oz? r~:cvEr?.i3§:%'V"2é';i;;§A« V.

PRESEi'ZT

TE-IE E-ION'B£.E ram, 9.3.  C§I¥E§?_afiUSTI%:E  

THE Hormm nxR.3Usé?is:§:§Ef~~1s1e§iA2a.$5;§§zu*f;§g§&;aGbiIsA§.
Wm? pE*:1--:sjo1\1 gm. '£59':-»:_2@oé' tamizmsy
SEWEEH  ._ %    

3 3R1§%"z%.:s3;:4L%s,LA;s.:s:4,1;2z:._:;A¥oz3*r, ems'? O?
« .. CHEERS Ragga, '8A;?~iGAL;::Y
-- _"».gaC2'§;»:3 QBGLVF 50 YEARS
' ~:és§i<:~:,:~si§ FGRES'? GFFESE,
V. iii" --:;§L<;Cz{, Bgagpfiaziz
 K-SLAR DISTREC.-'T

 ..  'SEE i€fia..§E?€§'}R;%.

§i§.§.Ji., Si (3 Vq$§'E3§§€§£*v§

sifififi AE{}UT' '$33 %"%5s}?S

48, E3 C¥€{}S§§§ E7€{}i*3sE;§%"§°'S{}§i§?E?'§'
i9i.CnF, KGLAE S§ST'R§C'i'

 ?3§*:";?"§"'§'§"§€}§'*E'%Z}'\?S
{E3}? Sré J E3'%%5;%S§%A?%'§T'§§, §%.E3'§{){§§%'"§'%§}
 ' V

KA¥€3I*€A*E°'AKA LEGESEATEVEE As:-3§;MBL3%f  V
SANGALQRE 1. ..  ,\ _

S"E'AT'E§ GP K1§RNA'T.%KPa I

RE§3'R§3SEN'E'E}}'£) BY IT'S <::?:«;z*:§s%?1's§:céé§:%V§'.s2$§a%.VV  

vii}:-imsa SC}U{}HA  _
Barésazokfi 1 ' "

SR: 3 :7; E{L§M£;RASW$.3siY.._   
MEMBER 0? LE:§3Is;_LATi's;£fi .:;33EMBL¥
Rig? Mimi :?§%E::§? f{f;§A§;}   
J.i3,NAG--AR  --  *  1 .,
§3A§€§3"3L£§§€E :E§tf§€T§ 1:23;".   ..

$2é:"C'3%'aVL30'vAs§*¥,§§ swam'

 §'§EM:.~3EE2*~%is> ;.;§::;}:';::Lm*ivE: ASSEMELY

« :;,mo:2,V %  k 
2%: ;%,{3::§MA}f€ §AL;s,_ 

-- . 1 Maémfm §j}ES'Ti."'R§C'"i"'

V  SR}; c1~;'§:%i'§:':::;APPA

EVE-§Eff;§a§S§;?R C3?' LE{}§SLfi{§""E'efi:3 .?%.S'$§:?§€E§i1¥

-- 

” «§>;:Q§:s~’1&§~*z:§:?:*

” ” 1.»?’§R§ Sfi;’?%~IYfiN£RAYz%§€’1§
E’+e§’E?vi8E§~? SF E,-§33€}§SLA’§’§’v’E’; z§S$EZ-§\;iB7éf:’

§v’§;%,L§f}E, S§§2;%,,, ‘§”§§ EVEKEJR

SQ? £§fVEA§€E§G{}1¥§§fi 3.:5&”z'”‘¥’§5:§’3%}§33
MEMEER GE?’ §.,.%§}$i$LfiJ§E¥§; éSS%iPf§E§;'{
%j’§§’&§C}i5$,

L3 ?§C’+fiSfiGi} R53
Rfiififiiifi SESTREC?

W:

W

H}

1:»-

zfii,-A:”~% CEEJR SE13 iE*%EV&S

MEMBER 0:2′ LE;GES§.£§’E’i’v%Z ASSE3Mi3};.'{

§§’iAx} {ER ,
NEEELBAGAIJ, KQLAR

E-SEE E) T JA”2″A RU MAR

MEMBER <1}? L&:<3:sL;&§*2*I';fi:A»}§ $s:3'am;:«' .1: '-

Mmqm .

1’~%’ANJ?;f\%Gi}i}U _
MYSORE £)ES’TRi{Zf’E”‘ _

8531 M E{HUBP§.

MEMBER 0;: L;::;<;1$L;»tt1'1'%§':f: };i;:-m=;zsa§:;S:

52:31} i'v1AJC}R=._,"_ ;_ .
BAsAvAKAmAm_' % "

i3£DAR,_ ‘

M:s_:§:””;?§s’i31%armxsA1’~:§ ;$Af'<£*::V_; r?§E:a3g:.,-

Mj§;Fv'§'53:%E_£;?? :€.'}E<' * §J3§{§_§f3L£i'3'E§f'E§ &E§§SEjME*3LY

,§«'u;3=-ED §m.§:;t..§:':§;:"'-T'T.__ =

' §:I¥§a'%:*i~§;gV;Pi§.:iz–

<;i.s;;;3a;2(2A'3}:::.:{i:;;e§<;:*r

age; A 'H-§£§_U%g*f;%?é"?*H.%i3PA

V. §v§'}'E';.M8§E'.:§~3 2:v5g}.:3R<;A

«§§€}§3§§§EL :31:ame;R

35:

SEE S£§§%Y§.NARAY§;NA REE}???

KEE REEGQEEQE
BE§L£,é’~§RY

3&2″ $§’i?€”E’§~§'{}Si§ Ejii}
§¥%%§f’.v’i§3E”;E€ GE’ LE{}iS§.A’§”§’V’E 533%)-?*.+§fiLY
AGEE} £?’¥iAJ{}i€
SF$%EZ”PE.§E€

8EZ§,§_,-213!-3′? £’)§$'”‘§’RZ€IZ””§”‘

if}

is

S23} M KRESHRAPPA

MEMBER <3? 1.,§;:G2'$m;:':'vE a3$g:§,z:E3_:,:fi'_ "

AGES Mfiiiiifi
'§'UE?.{}\fE}§{EE€E§
'§'UE§»§}<IUR D£§5"TRETCE'

SEE §'*=ER£'°~%Jf'aM§Ri

MEMBER :92? :;,&:<:r:s:»;;af§f:*s;2"«:';%$$E%::v:2~;:e;;;$:'

fi;C§EiiEj} MAJ{§)R
'§'£'¥'E'i§ E1', TU

SR1" E-E 9 LE-}(§§:§£;,§.;’ii:’£§fE _A$$V;&;§v:,8L¥
AQEB E’£h%J€}R .V
:v§A<;A§:}: _' _
E3A§\%i§r§;E;£}i€E*§. §'::;;2;§:L §;'iaff':':::%';':;""?<:é;%:VV–

1. $§%§”if§.’1:::;§§§:§:::.:é;a§43§%A _~
:%%E:r’v§£§§::§{-~ .g§§2%. E/E;{3:’:~3§,A’E’i’VE3 flSS’,%ZE~;i8E;’r’

* as-3;)’ :x:;:Ag;:V?’§2e:”-;%:§§eAE; §j.3i:~3’E’Eii{“T:’i”

V. 532:1′ K AN§%é’A:§A§s:
=f*a%§’%}?;I§§3EZE€ (313 Li&_1{}iSL.%¥’§’£¥E ,a$$_§;;~.,m..¥

‘V >’.;:££<{V–.–;'fi:§¥J;VEr.} 'igmaigk

u?%e§fii:i;3vfi;;,:.;'

2}

V. .§'V§§3'gv%7€i}YA DEESTEQECT

2%; _ 3.531%: M SRINIVASA

MEMBER OF' i;EG§Si.£i"f'§"i?E ?sSSEZ«:'v§E§.f':'
fiafifili} Mfidiiiif
EV§A§'%§l}?§%

SEE Q S PUT'E'2%Rg%.}i§
MEMBER Q3-3' L§';(}§SL&'?E'i§EZ ;%.SSE1E%&.§§L'5
$63}? ?*v*i15;J{'}E?

E’A§’é E’)A’v’A PU RA
§V§;%§i§i}’¥2%.,

22

24

Sféfi S L IEHRFEMEGQWDA

MEMBER OF {,€G2SL2¥I’I\f£§ AssEM:3:_;~§_

AGED §viAJ(“)R
BERU R
CiI~i1KK§i}’vE§€}ALU R

SR1 B C §3A”§”{L

MEMBER <31? LE§GiSL;1'3'E%iEf":1SSEi3\vii%£f:'.,;

AGEI3 Max:212
HEREKERURU
MVER: ;3:ST:?;LT

SR§RKRA"i'HG7i3_Y' V i
MEMBER 01:' i,E<;§i§3LA§':x*E }%SSE%;;§\?i'BLY
AGED_'gvL»xJ91%§:' _ –

*
B_.I<_3'.f'~;'P.T§.}E~.–T: ..:;':1S1?1j§:§__C2::_ »

$:'e'i=

f'.Ii;¥:'.§'*:iB}j}' R'-~.,{)5i?7, LEGE-SL§TEVE agggzsmgjf

3:231?' 5/i.?X.Jjz3:f€;'

Hwfisuk,

. A, MY':;:QR§3; .':32=:*sfi:'§é":"1<:'r§*.

V. Sm .Jg§éEE§z"AHM:;:::3
_ »;~;;33:§~;«zg§:,;2 <2? LE1G§SLA'f'§VE3 A.SSE1§'«sEB§3{
..g<3;:::3 'xgiagoia

A @;:3gA~§g€rA§AgPET,

2:?

28

_ .B€g:~:<3AL<'};%E}

:.SRE BAL2%CH.&§*§'§§}R£% dF§E%KiE~§€}§,–E§
§JEE§s¥§BEJ5i€' (31%? .&Efi§$£&§'EVEZ fisS&§E§§'s/ESL'?

fififii} §z51AJ€f}§€,
E£z%Rf§§§';¥E, BE§_.«GAU?%fi,

32%;' E; %vEU?€§SW&.§¢Eé?P?a
MEEEER 0? LE:<;:$m':*:v€ ASSEEEBLV
Eafifii} Maggy;

s:9mLA:;1–§A’1*”m

:~<;<:: mg, é:'='::'~=. \.

SE}

3}

3323

” __i§4

SEE? EQBAL !:U’~§§$2’3s§{§

MEMBER OF’ LEGESLA.TEVE» ASSEMBLY
AGED Ev’i&§(.f}§€,

{}?aNGAV13(i’Hi

}{(;}P¥’AL

SM’? ViJAYALAi§a

§’s:iEi-iV’iBE:}~4: my LE::3§sLA=:Li=§i.:1:5-;:S:s’§s::g4i~g§.;:s J

AGED MAJOR,
P2XV£%*GA{)A V ”

‘f’UMKUR mS’1=i§:%:4:::f:.

SHE 5;: N_s:u3A:ea.):2.::a.i’Aa _ .
§sf§E’;ii!E_;1é3«§:’:§f:”*€_3E¥’ :,E::}1:§g.i,.A%’§%i’xs§,-..g3ss::MB::r

;-~;U:4:vz3§{=:%::;:2¥::;+:_

‘ «*gf:j’?~.gi:<;U 3 '::::«§: E?°i'?Z.i€;'i."'

§3i§ i '§~£_ E\éii?€.v§§.§§%?}§i..

. 'V *~;v:E::s;;B7ie:}e§ <5}? F,«E{§I:§LA'§'£V?:i: &E£SEE§§«'iE'§§;%'
' a.;–A<3§'::£3 M£;.§'!;}'§%i,

v:g;?N:.z3A§,,,

" T. : =;f§i'5LE?'s*'§3¥§?;3;R §3§S'§'R'§C'§'.

_jsf1é: :I_§»§13 i"'~§'iY2§§'3P§. ;:'vi&§i§i}£P§'§§.

:2/i-§:§a,riB:s:i'"e <22? LEZG£:SLE{fEVEZ Assazéisziariiaiéjy'

A;f3FI;'§=¥*$i;) ?vi?£J<L%3xéALE§

RA§C§'i§.§R.,

fififififi

gifieiiverfid by P.i:3.i;}inakara11, :i{;j'.*; '*7 '

Leaznfifi CG"t11'1Sffi appeaxitlg i'or_ t§;§:"rpe?.itiQi1e;"s 'has 'fi.'i€c;i,_ "V

memo fiatsd (32. 11,2009 i°h€ V§f¥;'!i:f peVt:;tibu11"1'1as

becema ."§I1f}i"E1C'€110uS. 'H16 sa:i:£I:;é":§ recéiizieifi,

in View of 1:113 abémf, _31é2_:h;?;3'g{ é':2f*;;i?e.s K31' C011SiIifi}I'EiI.?L{3=}'1 in
$136 above mar.' –pet:fi"i{:=1':.'*v» 'W§'i?;' pstitian is dismissad

as i:3i*':f:3c§.13l::t3$}"

",;mE'ex:–. ._";"6$3; fie
j'¥?%"s:'§s .}E'_'§Q-SC '$55; fig

-..fSz1:’.«j