High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Venkatachalaiah Since Decd By … vs The Land Tribunal The Tahsildar on 28 March, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Sri Venkatachalaiah Since Decd By … vs The Land Tribunal The Tahsildar on 28 March, 2008
Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh
gut

vi"-.. _ ..

N THE HTG-H

U T 02"' KERN TAKE, u.F~.N'Iam.nf.'I'fiE

um-an THIS -ms 2'1? am an' MARCH 2008 

BEFORE

THE Hotrnun HR. ausrxcn H..=.r,.G.nAr«ii:$H:'.'1,» 

wan PETITION ND.1fldT}'20£J_§5%iJR'iW   ii"

craowmmsa W0 LATE"-'iJ'ENVKF.'?ACE#E%Pg.IEi§
Rfififi aBoUTA?@ ?EaR5~{* *.1% 1 "V
5;.-'0 1c::.Tp.1.:;tJ«strJ_:'s vganms -  ;
flHRJHPURR_HGHLI,'ENEKRL,?ELfiK""
Efi.rac;ALoRE_"~-.     

nmxsfi --. _ yi_  ':2;    V
51"'? "T3 
.n..rs£'n mom 3:: 

:=:.»'~:::: 'sets.-rs: tzurmf 'V1 
fi}--kRJP.P&3.4R;E..,HflfiLIA, " 3'.-.,.L}!P.£.- '1'A.?.-£319.'

s;2:«.:u::su.L.ors.1?:., ' V 

;j%§mA%Gfi1*aNI1:EnmTnPPA Lmou-r
A , tiiEAR VEI§}€ATESINARA TALKIES
"';=.HEi 3cTmaHnfiEEfinY"i

". *g;o"aamE»nanAswnnv
'_fl£EH_A£QUT 30 YEARS

'. an 1$n§Eufi§nnY

,"n _$fO;LAWE numzvnrnn
* '£553 Anna? 49 YEARS
-- 3E'¢H%wnan3?A

' fifO.LHTE nuuxvappa
T 45 vinns

"pr

x

.p-.-1-nun.

I-'uanu 3.312!"



hi

,|'.n. until' .n|.'r&'I.3

13F iifififibl Ei.ru.w-w1nnIInn'I'
EEED ABOUT 3? YEARS

ADD PLRSE RESIDENT BF F3°:.TR1£5UPPE

VILLAEE, Hanan POST

PJGEICKL TRLUK   
EANGALURE Unanm nxsm. ..,mnssroNflnN$s.'-"

¢ny flri : NADIGA saxvmnamnnprng aces FGR 31 i fie' ;7
awn $21 Pnnxnsa T HEEEAR; Agv yon REA we 3333,'. *

THI$ v.9. FILED uNnma fi3§IqpE§*?§6?Afin 227

0? THE CGHSTITUTIDN cf ;Nn1i"Pa3riE5 TO QUABH THE
onnzn av. E0.ii.i9T6" 'H E" E 3wfi;.
3 

 K? V

_--II .-n

I "1" '

' H
F!
I

i imx-E AME ET

vI-v'-u-

in

-' E

 -"*'d .i'.aI'

 is

THIS w;é[fa&fliu¢«§sfim_Ht#3n_nNn nmsnnvsn FOR
Pnnuuumcgu;nT &F}gnngksffnxg ngv, THE counw MADE
THE FnLgow1&c:;,w'} "'

 'Z6-11*-1'§"i6 passed  'the 1'r*8"



'a}'ank.ata::hala.i$-. t.-I-km tr.-aa the as-.-raer in

pcsaaemaiez:-n cf the agricultural land meaa=ii:':i»,fit3"".I'

ah-mt: 2 acres 36 guntars in 

Fsnelml Tza.J.u}r.. The third rgapcnde:;iI:"'.Vv'«*.si--::v'  of land.

1l!;g,z:r:s-;1:r:_ii:'Irg:"'   : petitioners, by

 .___......_.__._.._:-_1_'__,v1__J ;f_  _...:.-,.._.,;l.": _ _ _. __... ._ .1...' 1..
!I1Z1.5]I£?-EPIBBIEIEJ-EB-l|.T.h_l ._e§u!.,.u. Inn u u .L L. In w...w v

 ficfiérdingv to the Patitionaru, the

 '-.f;h.i. r'd._ 3:_,e:§!2a}:§V'u*.:s1iqL-:io:r1t managed to get an exparta

r:.~a1:£:".éJ'§'I&1-r:i.V1':2iAi'4Ij:._~_.,1VtA':*"getting the notice served on the

 I-::.fcanca"rnész1  fi.-aztzson and rather the notice was

E'-.'.'-."£""."¥'~"v,~«3 ""'=I"*

(
I
3::
i
I
1
I
I
I

 "v.$r:§ugh1: for quaahing the impugned o.1:d.eJ:_ of the

\?u//
XV



fin

HI

-... .1! .l.'I.. - .. _ _ _ -

L**n.w'. 'I*:ci}:-:una.:. '"1 the qrc: T 'uni fiha pr pérzty

was nearer in possession arm}! cultivation
third respondent who himself had  "
property t-:1: Venkatachalaiah:-"t1uri1;L§:  

1364, or which, the gatifigfifitfi  ¢fi-.th¢in 7

;; za-is gas; 55; tax 1i'_za_?:.gx._=5.r.:11¢r.le-;:;s~,15a;~~._As-rage V" in' L-as éa 3;;-.I"ié1-1

t

L
§
:1:
fin

fl.   ufiughtvvvj for
quaahing the impugned $ -:.;a'1:civ:«..1\:§'1".. 
3. Per c:aréLt:"§>t;«»:1,: -"*ii4;VI_;1€u{_;;_§§&.1:3t1i:§d5._:ccunsal agpaaring

fcu: t}1Efi""'{2'$I,#t:?$'$é:ijfiQ '-¥;e.5%;_;:'c$r1_mperty in question as a.

 *tez1 a'.u1.:_  -zzonaent: wan given by the

lafi,:1 "a5wx§h1;LT;_  such there 13 no illegality in

'Cu_':ha ¢:a§;i§£ the Land Tribunal, much less the

wfiaéifla ie an;

w
I!
-1!
u
'1
1!
11.
§
3
II'
SI
('1'
5
J'
I
l...:
I!
fal-
I
I'



Eh

'Ian-In..I_:.a:. AF I\'II\.IH.E) §-'Inna. '-an -u-nnvln 'I-"ha uni-4 '|--5 nvuav-m
-Jul-It-I 'J1 'l-[Jr I-I|-\-'J-- EI.fl§'I 'JV T'II'IaLJ ' I-'$3 F E-L  C?

have come up before this court.

4. In the light of the argumenta éfiffifiéefi by '

tha learned. anunaal for  tfié°: §¢§§#¢¢¥§fif 

purtims, lat mm to éafi9;dafi"_whgth§fi"*tha

5-. In the  in the
ET: the nqm€'pfi fink fi§ther pfi ffia reapfindant
is ahnwn ifi fibigmn Q; §fi%fi in Column 12, the
name mi tug f§£fi§§»§£fifih§'£eapandont is ahawn.

Ila 44* In $'l'g'fi!'I. "   "'6':-Ir-.01-I-In-I-'|'--Ir in E-341-3 -I-n 1-Intru-
Fifi' oL'v 9!' 33-J: ._hi'II|nJ.-V"?   «L53 9%" 'PW 'J-3??'

-- been fiuréhasafi by tha father of the patitioner

VKput"gtn3ra*,&:e no entries in the revenue

r#a$bda fi@ fifi§ affect that there is transfer

: _ 'but iagfigfifient himself has produced the sale

kdgédfigfifacted in fauna; cfi the fiathaz oi tha

 -'In -I-$4.51. 11-than 'lflfifl "film:-u. -vlnunl'-III.
 UH" '-1 Li]. LIJIW PQL L? U'! J-Jul' l"ZJnInl

"xfififitenticn of ths patitianen is, deapite that»

\\./'



mi

,1 _ - 1..., .._.,.Ir-..._ -4: A! ....._;__,.._.A..-- 1...- _--- -4:
LE H. L.I.flJ.'.l.5J.U.I. UJ. LII PI. PBLLY By W Y  -S.?]2

purchmae by the father of tbs petiti0ner; fih§',

same is nut reflected in the ETC to s§fiw ffi$t: "

ths f&thfiI of the petitioper"~ia-:£fih' ¢¥hfi: H

unciar whum the raapcancient wim A"teii&fit~.V «. 

5uTh thn sugar 9: t

estatzemant :31? the  not been

nraaordsd. in ltfirmm {$f ifiuiaH 1f11$f tbs Land

Reforms Ru;éfig 3F@£tha£wgécfirding to him, the

aignatuzam.wfi:ea¢9nfi9cted}*w"

)0

3. Since thwze i£{ a dispute as xngazda the

~1:%tVieJ: emf the Tribunal can'? on the gmuxm t

G}

A ._.|_ _--

aaééptzihg if"

__.%.... '1..- .......,,.a

E tififixl-:..._y at tnu raamgarfint my

though net such a statement in recr::jf¢3."_éci "*.%'
indepmndaxutly but theta is d statazri;it:a;r11V:.:A[:V"f::>'rEu 
oath. I-Iazrs-raveat, his aignatu:§5""'i-3'  

the «murder passed by the 

1:3

t.afl'1-a-n.a'i T the Aggigtgnf--H:=..c»o:n£hViss_si_9iis§f':.. """'11aja
rfi--.r;o"'"~'ad fih-% the v.'».--ff-<51;-*r.';... c'.T'.*"i*"-::*:':.".:.§.'--"*».'1 'as
the tenancy aw sfi=:i};'  it is
man:-lved by   occupancy
rights.  :.t:3?e'r§  signature of

the Rasi$'taf;t.'  well as -:1:-that:

1'v£..,....1:-r.=.:a *.§=.=.»:*a"..r.'Ij§  ;t_:'.1';e pat.it:Lca:;e;~.

 ._':1-fig:-g:_§Vt_%_fr:::&1"«$:1:m'i:, the petitioners' father

 h5aza "uix;a-m}i%fa:%1f§¢--._compen.aation in respect of the

1aiid""ésov'-a;§2jqfi'iVicad and also statement is given

 T.':;«_g; tfw. iifi.-1th9.r of the petitioner bafnra the

 Patitier-ern' father: r'-11311-2nrr.er_3 the

.. -.._ _ _ _ A . -¢_;I

  " .1:heJ:e is no ncatice issued. It appears during

W15'



ND

.

the llf% time cf 1:1′: fa….er l~…’.::sa1£ he ..’…%-.3

participated in the procaatiinqa way bac*.’j:”~»:’;i;~xj”*.%’

the year 1911?. Thereafter, after

tha pnatitionaza have come up befmfie

an the gromud that no notice :’§1f”S’.A_A?i$sfi’¥’3

varif :1-cation, it is 3a§fii’:~._ no’ti__c:-we ‘has.._ “‘baé:n

$3.1

I :

+- .. ..-I 4 -F” 1-.

laatie . In the ci:<:.ums.an::ea.. +2: *1;'…'$:~:.. £ ".3

£3
('1'

fact that patitiorghrfs giifiamaalf has
a.::§n1.'i.t1:ed thy V' find any
illegeslitjgy §:»§.:i_r;|q_¢__a;'J:._Vc';«"f: _1':1:LVV:e-» Land Tribunal

in cc:-n:E Vt 't 1i.:.=:_: s ….right 5 .