High Court Karnataka High Court

State Bank Of Mysore vs M/S Kalaimaghal Sabha on 8 March, 2010

Karnataka High Court
State Bank Of Mysore vs M/S Kalaimaghal Sabha on 8 March, 2010
Author: H.Billappa
 '§'E.--i I-:1 E-TiI('.,}lI (.?{){..§I{'E' (.,)'§3' K:'XR§.\l.A'I"AKz"-\. B:'\.I\E(f}r\L()RE
E};-\"i'§'-LI) 'H-{IE5 '1'? 11:2. E4"? I1):'\Y ()1? i'\i'if\I'{(:fH 12.0 10

B E I*'() R E

"1'H£<: 1»---1:\I'1:-ms: Mxm 1_}'S'i"'fCEj H.i3II_,LA¥?'PA....__ '  ~

RF./\.Nt_).35 OF 2010

QETWEEEE

Stem" §%3e'ml<. of i\/1_\'5~s<)1'c_

A 1'6: 'mi;-' £1 '.(§ lllidt-'1" (hr

E-Siznc I-3;a.1'1k of Iildid.

(S1...11.")st'("ii::11"y B2'Iu"1k':.s A(.'i.._  -- .
1957.) lieu--'i11g.;' i!".S I'"'I('2}.(_'1 (:)iTi('.;f:';  ' V
:\:~, aw}! am §{c..1a§irs%<*1'('<i V{'}fi'l'('(I'._...  '
At ;\§i}.£'j-«iii. K.(T}'I-{()2;1j2zI:'a:  "  _
\«Vi%'E:125: I'..')'I'&-1i"H__'.}1"(')i~ffi(TC;':V ~._V' ,  --
K1'1.(2w11 22515.5 "I*I}'uL 'II -.:}.;3.1'2Vi;"1'C'l'1."f
At  :\=-'Eni1'1. :z:or*L«~1 .1Tz(-'~,:_:.c'iV.__"..'%'
§!1di§';-.1112;1;,f.eti*.He-11t::ge.w:,l:)'1't' ' é~§: .
Rt:-gg-_1'a..~~;c_:'i {ml i:'):;,' 21.5 U '

C':'..§_'i ii'?  ' . \~'"--:__% zj.-:.~\»'.;-£1. :1 1 ix 1; . . .Ap§')c11a1"1t

'   (E:.i}; S1.':;\5'£'ii";-1<§}:1.:;L:::j.R.i i2_i\.'2-1i(1a:1i". ;'\c'.1v-g-:i-1€':'1."Jf':l 132:1 gi'1z:iI Sa§.')1"t.;;: .
 }'~i__'y'¥;.i'i.a-'* I.)i>s;t.1'i('t
 _  C"Ra§§;isi$23i';*'S}[>m'?i;..11{}f)'1'i"i<*c=*1".
 V  ¥{aViz'i'i'r'11ezzilml 53e}.1')}"3zt.

[E/,..



E\i<').€'é'.«-7". I'1:;;1}2-1y2} 1'11.

N2m1ak1:7'I)('):1€i'c:.:'1f   ff.

(IF">_\,-= §51"i.(f}.Ve-*::-*r(.*1'1(.'11"21 Be':I..'2u. A(:1\='0<*.atc)   ._

Tms E'R/VV '£9;-Vtim 41:...".;I.{ 1.':l£> m'=:1""oi" 
CE5"('T., E.i§_{&ii2'1.".~%1 1.12:" jutjfigc-t111m'1't 2';iz"1ci_ "(i:'.(ireéc§'~ <:1a.1e(.i' .. 'E12.,_.'1*Q...2{)O9. =

pa1.~'~.;.~_s. E5{1$f'>5/ 2002., (")n '*1::§ic fiitt <fr{'f_t"hT;:-ZXXV1 Adcil.
C3113? (Evil and -S«:és;¢si1"1ss «.}:_,:cigL', M.;ayL,)_ Hail L;"i"ai!'.,H B;31ng211()r£:*
[('3(',.f§§ 20}. (r::'m>.i1'1g_g§ 1"}-19 FiL1ii:"'~f()1" _éj(2V(_:{:n1.:"_t.it2.§§:sV_ {.}v'£i:'{5. V'ci2:1y. the Couri
<'1c§i\-*¢--'1't:'..('l 1110 1'(')I1()\"3v§11§}ii\,        

      

51"; 1?.E:'3_.\'7§jélykl1{V:'i:§:':'33._§iI'».. uC--L'.]' "{i'cri"' EVi211'w.;3;¢?1' of IE"1<'.' .+'\1.)pCi1'cu'1'1.«

Batik. SIT.M:;,}«.g-1yk'i1iE'ii'1f}T.':11:'{'..If' Rc2gi()1'1a.E 1\/121I121;ger'  M/S.

K.§:i{§.e-§.iII};:Ei_f;1§i:;:i1V A'f:£z2;1E')1'1.z-1;"... the»? 1'€S}')()1'1d€?2'1l. and the 1<2arned

c'.'(.)'{.:';'1.'«_.a»;;w'.IA"imf "E_?1"€: ;v);.i'§'$§c5a 2-4=.re presetli E3ef0r% w1'1.i:':1'1 :.'e2.1c1s 21$ :,111c.itéI.":

V.



'... 2

JOINT MEMO FILED BY THE APPELLANT AND THE
RESPONDENT 

I. ‘I’l’:c abc;1.>(> appeal filcci Fog; U’l.(..’ /’§_.A,s);€–3(?’l’l.:A(i;. ‘V’.
<'.1_q<.az'n.~;.* {F10_}'ud§;n2('.=u! and (i.ecrc §AZVcz£c:(1 _}”2;_
;)<1.<'<"1 in (.).-f5'.N0. 15555 :2oo2 mg I"!-1?'i¢§i«::jrzi;%;i
/'\("z'

  • t’I and Sc>$.s.;i’m:gT;ul.on-3 (.’:’.i_1,1 {(…'(}’.II ;’\~'(“2;»2_(::i},”~V.i_.Ms” c1’z’:é;’,z)cgs(*3cVViATV

    K [bf i()l.£..'{i lg l.c3I’I’7″ts.’

    {:1} “I’Iu-> Appellant agr’e<é$_Ti.(; 'L2(1§fC:3Li€?_'C'L'I'.l(l'I.V ]"l€.1I"ld~OLJ€?I' (,0
    Elle? I€c.?s1;-c):1<fm:I. £F'é£-é"'51:i«z'I. ';-;r,.j"i7.__ec;i.r;.zIc?§5rc1ni.ses by

    .'3()""

    {bi “[‘l’z’c»’ ‘X3113 iii: :ia’.!l ‘ Lo «lfhe’R:es;3or1(ier’1L. rer1i’f()r”
    ;%f2::2£’9c3r

    20 I U [“:(.’I” V’£*}’I(.;” rfxi icérrns:

    ‘.2. ‘I,”h.ai ‘E;.4I.’i V_§V::’c:-rzb’ c3[“‘-‘!Ti’i€i5. qfcn’e._(*:’e3::% Q/’ l’,I’1e=? Trial
    V”.§”f:’,u§r€» .:j zIza€_F21-3:~;f5o:_jz:c2’c2;’1I Lmlf have no other c’:laim over tile:

    E

    :3; “1”E”.1~s;:~ p;j’::*¥:%c:–‘».s zmci 1′:}’1c=: Icttzzxmz;-sci (.'(>§.15~3r1€?} for the partifis

    _ _f f.?§1é.4}’)1′”¥fi’ii 1}’:;-.12 ct 2:;:);[)<:r;-:1 may he ci_is;_:Jseci ()1? in myths of the

    ._h;’u:’._1:V1=Ejnr:*_2″”:’2¥j;« i’§1e.’*<i 1")? I"I"1£* ;)2'Iarti<~*ss.

    3. z’7\:_~<_'::'<iia'1g_;1_\r. thar. ezpp<-3&1 is ciis1)0sc'-xci off in terms of

    ilué _§:.)i1'H m<':'1'm filcci lay SE10 1.32-1.1'EE<_:és. "1"I'1 j:1cig1’nc:’1t. e-n’1c.iii’i<.*<.'1 in lL'1'1l}.'.~9 of §.E'1<.~ 'joint memo. '1'V1j}"c{zip;3(::'i'l;i11";–i.:is V§;;I'a1'1)i'::’ vac211’1t }’ja).’s”‘..v.(-‘>s:’–‘.’.i(.A3’1~-‘5 (_)i’.1.h°£.’. }3éfe~:1.11sa’s m» L

    Tilt’ :”‘u~’s[;)<.n1(§L=':"1§ an e=*1k”)1’t;j_ 30. §

    I)2’e1.\:v up 1.11:: (.£€'(V’.’1’t-*0. MyLfimi;;§ _($»f’:;{‘ht:.;Vj’dAij’jf::ib__.1*r1er11(>.
    EUDGE

    \r’N /2…}