High Court Karnataka High Court

State By Huliyar Police vs Guddaiah S/O Honnaiah on 23 March, 2009

Karnataka High Court
State By Huliyar Police vs Guddaiah S/O Honnaiah on 23 March, 2009
Author: V.Gopalagowda & N.Ananda
. W. .... .§.,..m............... mm wvuwu W zsnnmmnlxa nmm count cw mmmmm wmm mam 0? MEMAYAM mm cm

3? Tim HIGH CCKJET SF EAREATAIKA AT 

mzrfig ma fim 23% my GE' ngmcieg  " 

?RESE IVE'

"Ei-i"E §~§fi§"BL;€ rm,mgfiaE , 

'rim I--§{}I€'B§..-E1    H 
magma;   
EETWEEK:     
mam by   agmfiaflt

(By Sri    

AND:

S,?:::.Sr§ I-§urz_x':1::;§&E:V 
Agefi a§@:::'i:3;.?.: 4&3 ygagrév

 

 "  .2  ' as' g1;,Z';£:'.".:5  arfi§1;

V fia::'afii; éiuuyar z-anal;
   Rmgmnfi-ant

   {By.v'f£§;E«§.4.ax%@§§&&§ mgagg

 

  afitpmi is.  mfier msusaxs 373:1}

f3j._Cr,lP.Q prgfim gs gmi legs': :9 51¢ an awwl
'  éiicigfiem éamé ;*%&3,.§';G§2 passaifi by the
.   3;;.L§ fimfi E11 $.,§;§§aa11fi{2%fi§  the

 {fir  $fi'!%.fi#§% §f'2:afs.3Cfi & 'X31

"}I'1'Y:.L$ agmaé i  3:1 fag' 
?§.£§§§§E3§§ :33;  {ha faiifiwirg:

 
 

mm K-W/9%-\WW<'!I



IIFIIII 'I¢I'!foI'\l§£"" I l!V.l'1 I

  _  

  _ '_ " 'pm _' '   

"-V$«!.N_ Mr' nfifimmnmmm remrn wvuua ur RAKNMERKR Hlblfl QUURI U?' KAKNAIAKA H3014 COURT 0?' KARNATAKA HIGH COL!

  " fitfihifih Efiwé  

$3'

«.§i§fl§:%e§fi.?'§'§'

331$ §%§$§%§&fiE ~=- amusszti wag Eriflé 3:25; 3  "  
fer afiarw §1.2z®h&%s%e axrzder  

S§C.Em§1é;'§C5f}% 9;: am §%»§g§%_%3;w  

Tumkur. 'i'§m*z'e&:-e§ State has  

 

Q V' *  3.9.13 and

Emrfi fiiammtzfi fif':*«§'t afmr rafarrw

E3 E3 §.QCii3g{%3»  

3.   'p%acu£imr1 is; aa fmlkwm

Tha  sa rmfim cf Eiashalapura.

4...  waa éwsrimilg as an Amdar in

 

:= Tim damfiaerl Eshwaragw wag

    "% ymrs pximr is 3399,

 

péacwfi 'fifiififififi fihe Eaihw zznf'
"   wfiafi ta have

   

V'  Q?' anfiigs in $.13: mwnua mwrés in tam af

 

3 giam Eawem the fat&r Hf

 

 315$ gmzggfir Exrfithar. E: is aimacl that

Y{k'7"'.  k .§3'~'~'"'5({/3.



bani  fl$§i&¢k. '  -T 

éweaaaé hag gm: §s."&.5{$§« ac; 2.12:: aaeusaai. a:c2.,h.i;s

aaaurarm 11: ga: fim emnfim mummd 33:1  V

 

afi mqmfitfi bjé" 

E3}?  i'
W}% fiewasmi  ..::::

   

 

 

WEE  hémg fim wemiV"*;::§'i».&r  

3.s..::z&2@% at aamza  mgtamea

 

and   ham gs   V ;a: is: afimed
mat acszzizaefi  .   wezmld mtum
Emma?' and   Tm aamzzamgwzzgr @

fa agaham  a: that ammsw. had

mlw amufiéxi £1 saw   FWQ afi hath caf mm

 

;&W     gas was 33 mm dmamm'

 
 

  mgnfigzu Ffiwii» : 

 iii {ha quaryxal

'  aficffisad mzé dmzeaswx E-'W~--3 &Eapm 31$ allmai

uww_n§ vi nmnlwmnmxwa u-nun \..u-uau wr nnnuwmimnm ruwn umuwna ur Esmmmmaflnfl mwm muumz um MMCNAMAKA MIG}? 1,203.4

 'émn amzzsaaé ané émsaéefi  ' mwards a

T  :§.%% mmmut grlak-my {am gas at' aescurmncej.

flflIVflil

.§:W-1} is aiéaged ta haw wag; mama-d yang

II wawuewawmm pa uumnauryxwmawm

iv    x   0;.

 Thaugh tikm  *  

géaé agzjszzgafi '€33 fisieztujtnj }:1£*;s:3:iw;;', V 115 _ " ~



cpnuurvv  VII e:\J't£\&'1l"'E!!"\8\J"\ l"!I'\3i"'F V-w'5nv"JH'i,! kl? I\[-'g{E'"}-Qfiijéfifgfi-Q          

    

 .

safi mg agwnut gm: :3}; is gas 2% at’ fimaaam and

hixicaxa,

E: 533 Elma wage a§ aha px*mamu1.:.i.9x;2WVtb}fxat ‘

gpwaj mm mm J
viD%c:srs Wéfli fléflf wwamt ;;71§£:k if
wmbna 8t’iC§§ ting wars afik the
dead may sf Esiawamgfgg fresflfgifié’

‘ – -‘ they

s:@E:aE1 tfsraw ;§,:,::,%::»« §?ié:~é:

$11 23:3 gm? FE?”-T. father emf

amwgsga mfg»; maiyum poliaw,
xgf a mw was ragstatwari far
‘Tha dmfi bafly af Eshwaraypa was

j f:mf%k:2w gm mg (rm: am am-ané um; Aftcr
u had}; was subjmted ts pm’: mnfim

%i§n was

‘fxaxaafimfian, Tim @312

T by Pfidfi firxfl fisfier pflat

.- ?%=%@ fipixmfi ‘mat dwth was due

fig’ _f}’L’«x~–éégfiflz

fig magim ”

. …….m W mmnmm mm-I <:c::2uR1'o'r KAMMAKE 'HuG"i-fcmm M gcmmmm HMBH cm;

.- ..»~– 'n n naval!

asrfiémme am}.

rmrclai by rm trig mutt,

Ermuhtua the faflmwém wma far

1} wimtlmr gm pzmsmutkzfi hm f.3 If§f’s§¢§ «:51: ‘

13.1:e.1%§s§ at afmuz between, §.3€?;p;n5.L,._.%a:;;§
9.15 pm” $2 tkm viilaga s:t~a
amuwd fizm ta §m

eclmwaaé tank the fiwtagad ?%;$ $1233′ giek

up {mad}

fmm ~ yushed
flssesmsaé.._§z§;%t;{:”é;:_;;:V_%~’?ei§r:;§2;*2.§§’:; ” with an
mmnfiégi is} as a 1-malt,

dem.3&d§%d g_fisi;.§}_ .’§i;§ga§*e;§jg4.&.c~au5ed mnmmitteci

an zmzdar Smtinng 3&2 $63?

2:

Sfiaémim Juclga hm
em’ ‘flame in pazatrupa’ pxwpaczfive?

3) film impwwfi aszémr z:-aalh for

V x ‘ ._ fiifisrfiamncg?

__ ;??§} ‘E’::s whm erfiay?

3. We 5% fiam refirfis fix ymamufinn kaa relied

3 an the f$I}fl’§€iI§ $9 brizg km: €113 gziit éf amusafi.

iv.’ \_ 5% I L -5419»

W??? $….l°F.¢E?”’52:.JHt7¢ mmvwmxs manw IXUMW mm

win In ‘ma-WWwt*&s’&& mam

uwwmmnwn-uarmrm-1 ancihiflil “hfllF”‘ fl”%J”\l\Wfi#”lLlP”I!\1P”&. fi'”PlI\%3fl”I WWW”! Ml?” W’Lf’%KVx’V$’l5§”‘.i’K§’K ?”§IW»3’fi1 ‘w5«JgK§ U?

1} evifianca {sf Fwd };.;=&mhm52ah§

? my-3 mgawg arzfi max:

prom that dmaaaaé wag East Sflfifi aliva ii}, ‘ K

nsf awuafi.

2) afsctxa jufiéxzrtiai $m’1f§$$§=:%§1 ‘V

by amusaé mm mmg gmpim-,%j%%j%L%

5. 9mm 3% ms-»1:3 m

B’I’.¥3ha1

‘aasxzteztim sf

f_?3_§’»~1E5 9:3 find that

dL:<sa$.a$v&£% and
death wég ' film ta §row%' .

Fmm. ii £3 mt pmsaébia :3 $213

was $§i;%ss=r…§::.zia$i&,ai; Emmiaidai $3′ azxiéeutal.
gufiaiérgn ag ms wfmfimr fimfia wag
éagwrsd ugasri law? 9%’ ather

«. ,_<3:'.;*<1:%.:.m°:;a;.r'§;::as raliatci zigmz E33; the grmgeaczgtimx

– — fizz ailma-aé $9 fiava mar:

T mzfi éamagad agazafifig mgetfhm at awn: ‘?’.3Q

‘4 Apmg, an aha maé Efizwaéfi Kzzshfigura

r ‘
‘\ /51 ” 411%’

we — ‘\¢\m’*€u(fiUnm man

u §63E§”®&£Z§; Kushaiagum

“””””‘”””””‘””‘ “””*-“”‘ ‘V’-“*’-{‘9-“~’._”-“” “~=M”*”‘-Mififlm WWW”! MUUKB UR” KMNNREAKM HKQH QKJUKT U!” KAKNi~X’U\¥U§ NEG” C(3UR’f U?’ KMRNAYPLKA» HIGH CQU

Sm Ems fispwté. fimt aha: ma fmfiewm

mi seiafi

amugeci, She haé amt: fim amusw pmhéng 3

daposefla am: fig mama ta _i:.h5e ésf ”

mfitrmsé ?%é’~–3 aheut the eacacuxre’
that am had am a:;§aV%s;¢ms¢a

wm g6?% tmwards; . iv

3. The éam mt Imi

mrmizs-&ra’t2′::;z3.,. éfaéf ??’5§&*§; ,

We izfi. aha wéfianm {if FWD

V11 Ezsaving awn tha amusfi

V. A

mm .5: yam, haé mt infmfi ta
gm’ 1 {Em gmzmafi as {Q Why in %ad

5% mm mm. %¥s»3.: £3 m mm

€113′: amuafi Emd gzmhed

mm § 9:; 2113 seam fiiay. £3 get ‘£1115

T waif flm Erxfifigatézg § tftla fiisfsaxam

tha lpalim is

amé gm 2% 9% lean

U’unruI”n. soumwtwts I

“‘”‘””‘”””V.”‘~F_ ‘-” “NNWWMHN-M nun: wvwn: Mr mnxwnznnn nmm £;UL!K’I” (3? Mgmmmym fifififi CQEJK? 0? %’€ARNA’¥AKA HIGH CQU

abmzt 5 mm, ‘ma fm: irzfafwtéan §’&2a§.zg –“‘–«f,¢

fellmving efiay :’..a,, $31 §;§,,§2a§§%§e

A3 per fim eviégfisima cf

the mgm fi§ :3. 22. 3 PW–

3. ba%a aéimk Imé the
ptand. Wiafi, 3 anfi ‘3§BW5@d fimt
daeazi b«::s<:1y waa ;agi&};iv.'r"1 psand. Yhsa
mrzduct 6%' mm the we
91" 3; haé rfsmvaci
am §ma%*m:sy mm 3 awtixzkt,

it % mat '}§s'§3$E§i%f1AAa§_:3V'~$:§ Why tdmé may 93% again'

mg m: ix-,-sam-mum ylvan by

"it. zziaafi mag; at' dwwfi flaamfi an
mm {pang}; amvm am afmmsmm 9:"
mg mfimfimf 22¢ mm: in $3}: peaiiam smtim
t%*m mmpzamz, :x: the am ifinrmafian, it ia

V that am vigagm haéi rmmd 1:233 fiesed bad};

I";

the High: Sf 3.8fi12~§§Q9a
W (“A ;\, x 0″» I/\

. .. wag imdgeé at await 25$ V.

vuw-e nwwwmauz-war-aam:-we u

1%

Eéhem fim szrééaxim sf W?»-23%, %€'”€$ gm that wmn

int’ :2; was zmzfifi urafigr Efil £r,.F,C_5 aha

§ is aiam the éflzgwrimt — ‘

that she haé awn amzmaeé anti I
fiawmfia paw; aha haé Sfififi fig aafifisééi A thg ” Vv .
d izzzs gmgfig, anti fizat

Ealagsga Ma 32% way.

9. Fmm iha efisxfgfiaggta Vs5Ef§§§$9fmV”‘fia’§3f1
report magi fix flmt tkmm

Wm rm If the.

5 hafi the ammaed 311:1

. sf Ffig-1§§ ihégrg ‘gram gm

WW . “V’.’T”5″7.,dl’. fiflmuwflw’ WIWW K-Unix? Vi” nnmmmncsa mun WU”: U!” KAMNAIAWR Hméfl COURT CW Knxwmfimz WGH (IOU

deaé mtg ‘?’1*m$fm’e;.,

shat Essay ‘man mmvvmal dusing the

wmfim atickg as dawafl

Witrzmgm, Ema: tmriam fion

if V6’ QLQ 4

— ‘ A game izxjurw ei!:hm’

L L, 1/

62′ gm: mmrtam 3% gm fiead body.

wfi am &am “tiw mnbwm sf RE€§.E$§wrt and

iiijuzém an

as? P°W–11

Rm . -. fig: she 333$ mam axe aamggesd yuslm the

N 531 w (L5-L,

_., VllW’W mm…,.m.m WW. W mmmmm nmm wum W» maammm mm mam W Mmmam 2-mm cm

&ez:-esawé ifiié pcfifi aaé ‘gm fividmm sf ?%-3

tsawarfia tlw parizi 213% 1%’: igsyim <:anfider2§§_. '- L.

Tha aaridaw af ?'$3-1;

@Ianafi:::z:: agmfi, Ear fifiat

fiflarmafiian wéyufi arraatg axspéarfiifisfm

Th-ca mmmitfig
mzfirtian fie’ .%%{?&3;*–~V§*@m @531; place

mud; an ‘the fifitfififlé.

ma me€.a?%-=.;fi;’ %°§:’&E mgr .

had rmugéx-iigufi & sum mi” Ra.4~QQ{- whsm

E23 R11′ m dwwmfi Eafnvazfipgm by

wax gem he wmaazi Rmm;~ fix:

gas §w~§, in mm ma acecumd that he
‘inset amizgafi ahmifi ga tn the paléce
;s_.ifa3;€Vf::§:ié:3;’A’z-zzzvgfi irzfagm {fig mattzzzu 3%, is net em: mm E316

VT 9? Pfiflé ‘w”Ezm% amusufi

Wmflfin mwmxsna

_.-.-….- -yum… -V. ._ ‘n’wjm.nt-I-I nu-1.»:

w.a§;¥L:;ajé§ m.§§’£a?’ Ea

…….~…. ….-..n.-y-_»_..<f.–w.n.- wnmmnu.-u.uwn-anew»-a uvun: ur nuaswninn-M rslurn uvuxl -VP IEHKNANRKR HEWH §UU§{T Q?' §%.ENRTflKA HIGH COU

éaamé with ax: asszzrarm he azfimi mumfien in

rmmzufi zfwxfis in rmgact fif aha larfi whixch ~ 3
we thg ahaxfe éf tim fitiwr $5 afiwmsfi, It ' H
pzflwmfimn tifxaé am aftm

mfifing was ztisxm by $,(?!3'£.1;'§é¢'3';_€3. arid V'

startad fiatmztiéiw amuaefi

9%' remymm mf mgneg. an ramrd

that éwwfimi gmsmufimn

ma _£2fa§.$f&r avf' katlm, Em

hag mm sum awn

fififii}. .__Vf£. %3 t};¢e mag sf prmecutinn {flat

wiflm ma caraatz.-mi

tha mfléivm $umm% by

V VV iléézi amasaé ézaci thsrmght 0%' mm Ezatfng the
get rié; ai' {Em mpaymnt af @1353? is not
;e:a£g=§a.iihie with {am 3s'ta§3§a§1¢d fmm me svidezm on