I-Iv
BEFORE
THE I-1o1rELE MR. JUS'1"lI3E Q
. E "_: A A * Z
uupnuo--u
s;OH'EHmTAGIR&Lfl fi , 591125,
1:2,uu.*z*:sc.-nr.En.!EE:+..s 'fi......A.P.....-'1.?.-,
if--1
E
32
* "Awe N" +9YRs.
'Fl 1 3'!' '|""l"'|'l"'I'l"|l'fl'L'I'l'_ 'l'II'.l I'-III 'DAT TVA
.'l.".J (isle luful-IU'II'lII'\J'IlIllIuI'KI I Ilvlllllg
Stiff) HANJAIAH, 39 YRS, OCC: COOLI,
" _ "R3 .'-'.''1'' %%-4.1'!-.I§J.'~'u":1'.'.'-'. P.'-'.L'.'A,
l?ESR31W3'I)Ei§TS
(BY SI-IRI ll SRIHIVAB, ADVJ
nus CRL.A is FILED ms. 37ama4s1 CR.P.C.
puma T0 GRANT LEAVE To FILE All APPEAL
gamma: mg JUDQEMEKI 1;rr.2.E. mmmp E':
IIVIIE 111- n 'I 1-I-n-I-nun n. nnunri «Inn:-I.nI-u in
1115? run. MM. [U11-Ullj ID Uflfl'\..r.,,,: IUIW-BUN; l.I.'l
' #1 node: an Unndu-an:-i unlhnuunnnan 'I311 Q1'
; ulululllhnl
in CH I-Iljlnl Fiji 51''? III: XW
oonuiabanflar with regaxti tc crueilar which the
accused persons trunhad the complainant Pndmnnrll
fi/
'J
.n_II._-.__- 1..- .n.._1_'I I\___..4 1.- I_.____. 4.1....
mwufifiiffififififiiiéfififim mmuourtw nuvutnmcn
the visw that testimony of the mamarial witxxau-usnjio not
indicate an to who amulua the
of tha accuaueci puslong:
complainant. Heme, the
unreaa-onablp and been ignorant
'.53-' 'cfra }'5Er§'_'§'n, p1"fia..-11$n u...-- '''........s--''-
inreweotofthe
accused. Hence, than an
fly: 1.13.191. Cam; am; 11.; mg
. fun ncutinun In fif ihi
- H ion. than learned Government Plendenr took
6. On tho nthnr hand, hauled Counsel
sh:-1 llsrinixm ii): the respondent: argued that tho
}laI'% cunt IIm 1-'Inn wamnfin
;...._.I 'II 41.....- ._.'I.- 'I_......._ ....-'I_.... ....._l...A 4.1.- _.._..-..._j
IIJIIIHIIIIIOWLIDIHVDIIII 1IlflfllINl-IalWlIK3Il.I%.
pan-souuazwanllclnu ralnfivun
niafié I
andan auch,r1o
Gmtammy of the claw ralntivm. 3gaand1y,%%i:.T- '
----'-rw
wan damand of cash by fir
othar wtitnanau to be
ghnn and right in rujeoflng
F
I
in
ii
1
I
E
II
I}
I}
«.:*:-.= the.-. #4 ~
m tin complainant 'I
nude in that wan with
of 11.1.5 t_hm_a in no
........ n..._._.. I..._:L......._........ _ ...__--A__.__.' ___'A._....._..... .....J __
._ aupporbod the prosecution can and in
V tho prosecution has aha not placed on record
V " evidence by examining another doctor to
.._+,._.;_«._- g_.__, ........1.;.._._;___g ._....na*...-g1__ ig.ua._;_._:-;_.._. $115.5."
theaaaaufibytheanomj
chance at such mudianl avidaruaa mgnrding injurial
3/
_
was
Hm _. f..._.hnt eI.r|d........mne 99.9 mt-;'"r.=r.r
caused to P.W.1, the prrooeoutlon case cannot be
beliwadand another infirmity in the 'H
".93-.:ir.g :9 91'' 5 £.-...--... .1'.n..l-3 ;..-r!~r..=t.;1..n_rII.;..,
v___! ..
;@A.__r,_l '
rafunoci to ac': the
the judgment of aoqumal
7'. Having and also taking
into uxnminad by the:
r__..
b whether the
*3. aa €116 '"356 at' this aurt fi1.
'A of acquittal 'I mnoanmd, it '1 partzinent
% * -ix: Jaw laud down by the Apex Court in this
than can ou.ni1 Kumur vs. Sum ocl'UP (2005
W.-f"f'-"I.-.3 1%} 9rd he an
'Y_wI W
~'_.1T.'...--.,._- ;;:1. ..'*r -
1 III1I'nIi5IbI_uJI:jyav.II_a.va';ana
ofthe aooum am: the
the View which h %
ahnuld be adopted; the=
that
miscarriage of" A
than fun the
§i' If: i. % fir"x1fi"u
1 S u-pl «uh!
" fi:r thio gm-gone of aooecmining as
'V a/ta "%'uyheflié&*""'angr of the aooueocl really
T. any-oflenoe or not. {See Bhagmm
% sum «mm. [(200214 soc as: 2002
(cm) 735: (2002) 2 szzmmz 567'}.
'
convincing haw been utfiustiflably
eliminated in izha prooeu;-it'+iI A. T %
roman fur
9. Keeping the above parameter
v.I;-gee-_-nn__LIrIi_;I.Is@a1ndm::=g
I
-- ----._--__._
mm" ~ wn1IeI*"" ~ ~m~ ~ wInunI1m""' ""T"T'_ by r:**uw*-1%
wanna' can urethra
relative or the relative of
It in Via'! an unnnunn' tin
to find out an to what
brought hum thn gu1lt' at
T. i.i._iP;W.1 Padmn h u complainant and the ma
......
1’1_e!.Ir_|’f..n=;Ll1_-.ttl_;:@!.:igiIa_I_l;;:-;i;t_h_s:-
__._ _… -.._..;.I__
1 {mmimamonammuiiswmmwinhwar s—
” ‘V.._ii;’ec1:nnadisha:~ln1nbnndnnda:ightyan:IprinrtogiIIing
av1dame.hm-marrlagewithaatookplaoearndatflte
time ufmnn-kg, RI.10.€lJ0f~ wan givann dowry along
In-H11 u. 1-I-an n-nail n
wuum In
‘Him!
3
3′
ch: in nlnn 11-Innlpn fhnt fin’ n A m-
I&–lIl rm W OTC TCT :3
-7:
9.,”
10
mo yuan. the-was looluad after well by the aoomod
pemlmzn ma um ma birth In . funnla child. vV.I1t,:.:’fl..t1u¢1
deposed to by but that there was
-.-..-..’-.-…-..-…-e.-‘… *.~.:.- ‘.:.-‘I.:~.g R:-…2,h’..””….,3– .-.3:-.”.. 5.’-.e_-‘-V-_”‘=’–V”=– 13’1″” “”‘”‘
.E?3 ii’? TKIHQKT
hat husband as has wantnci
nfbar cam: advise by ‘an. am
to the house of used to
gnnult hat on than cloth
._…-…-_1… -._.a, -1… 1.”… ‘~.,.1.V…_.-…….”‘1 ‘,n.’.’* 1. ‘I… Inna.
Iy fl.IlF.’u-lllfl :z1u:a–_uu1;-gsafli ‘misfit sup uni
sought to ba oonvnnod
bufim. mm and thau:Em’o,n!’ba1-lfifhaan
An-an . n. um-I £3,131 Q 1’l__g
__ _ __A.. I…
in so as
* % 11.. boon bmught out to dinhalima
‘erv»ifie ‘ of 1=.w.1. She also adxnitn in her crou-
that bafiaro she girls on complaint .. par
. “‘.E.__. ., __1,_,_ 1…… 0| 4- 3.03′-,9 ¢u-\Uno\’|-nvl«I-II- nnnlvnml 1-1:…
V’ .V nails. 3.. um um: ufiu
JII-Illl-IIIII WU I’ll’!
mcuuaa. I-.w.sHn:nnu.u””‘ ” = ‘ iutinnuztwiuuunncitian
complainant happens to be hb oan–in–law’a mm and
thiuwitmu any! thntaflmfln mun-ingewm yam-fornnd.
Q” /
9′
\ II
two or three years later. A3 [husband] aunuliaod h with
inccnnectionwithhi ammmrcbmmjgwa; and
a Patwhayath was also convened and that 15:2,:
agar’ in annnna ‘
-e.-;.r.-.. 11.:-:-4 w W
been sea-iouuly queationeci in V
P..’W.GI..n1uh.rn1pu’ ……– .1.;1.. ..3..
his wife’: eldnr mm m the fact
of A3 damnnding 1 gnir of cow:
i?ii’l’3 A3 assau1?.h~.-g -fine -‘—-‘~ *”-‘~””’
rm uni annnihati hau-
xoomplninant quarelline
mo Ipankl to tho finctof
9.3 5.!-._’¥;:-L:1g.VL1ii.e_’?_;9ffin,.;,i{_::I”9a.:L:1__I.nt «.9 I_:riI.u_a i.n_ 19 _ng:;;I_i1_:
_…._I.Al .__
V go but in”: ififih wnung
% the mmplnsmm hacnuuu at 1=.w.a taking
ham. P.w.11 aopeuappa is me
._ law of the com_p1Imunt’ and than dnpauing
.’|-1—-O 4-In amnuavli-‘Ea-w a’n-all ah’: jam; niunvn at 1″ A ‘Nf||’IA
” av. -.
H-iv” Illir hllfi m
WEI’ TV HIE! III}?
mnrnng’ a, tin” wimuu says that inner’ the ‘u1rI:n’ ” of n
femala child. quarrel otarbedintrw house ofthe accused
nndthaywmaukingfinconxphhnmm bringmnnny
;/
1%
nndalsotnbrhgoownarndalnoeomplainnntoamaand
informed P.W.11 about the accused her.
P.W.l4-Muddaramaiah is the fathar of
pea-formeclj * aiaout nine’
being given slung with
m of
i_.—-_.__.._._ ….._.._…
in mm and kick Padma
emu house and ,
A.’__
‘ *A and the ruuaulad about the Insult by hm-
mea-eamn-wardn. P.W.1-1 arranged an a
._ thbutan i3.fu’ladoomp1nmt’ was lnd§ed_ . Th’:
MA: 0- I-‘II.-. n 1411:’! an ‘FHA §’nnn nffl
Hull» VII Iflulll amlvv Ijlnn
.V wuucai EH3 $””””5 fiuvdu um «fin-as
|’h1flh.’A nf 1119 campilinnut. and treatment being mm’ in
am In the cream-eunminatldn of P.W.l+. the
ahavravirlnnaa concerning nuuult by AB on than
9/
1/’
4-
ai’ the -uriinaunu F.’v’v’I.1, 5, o, :5. –i-fi~§_:”it
becomes clear that all than ‘i
about the tumult by
in commotion with the
the m-.}’ 3%
mm-“+-f’–‘-..-:-.mV.-.:.§;’..-1′! ii-‘.:!.-.*tl’-.5 5-..’:’..’
accused aim 1′ from the
house of No.3 was
also her consent for him
fiat ta fr’ damarai cf flea-15.-
by tn; k% * and it an in that ammactinn
no the oompladnam. In tho
V j_’:’_ it is not stated that than was demand of
‘ 9.;-:.!I.:..u.sJ. ,r;:~_I’:-aau. 9.1.. the I.1.m.:.2 9! mnrrinna_._…
“.’.’f””” ->.r _-r —–u–
‘A ti.-an innrnnd Gomuai for
H out that the complainant has stated in the
E mu:-uaofcrnan-ununinntitmtl-utuha in not aware oft]:
comma of Ex.P1 and the signed at the immune of the
fi% am the 92.91, yr.-t, P.’.’.’.1 . -‘-n :+..:…… in *..e
I’\
W
1-.. 1.1…. 1.- 1.. ………..
1″
oauraae ofhaf
cnntamiuotfthnaomphint.
wldence of the about: W1t.’l&I_¢s~»iI._l’ g _
in! when the annual’ 1:11.13 ”
um: A3 E;
fi %’i’.:h .m..3:1-ii:-a=:3ftv–:’,’* & -……’-5
not washing the court oouid
indinaim’ ma
is quills country to tha
afitfiisifoia ‘i’Ir””}’16i’i 1-‘-‘.’u’u’.1 ii’: %uuu”*-
aapug tho anuult on her by how
A lawn. but however. in no at an the
Q ‘ »-V-e :*.v.:.}¥r-F-r emnifin in !.!I..i.I; 1’41.-.r-4:.-..r:i. ;-..n_d. P=1l.L¢.S .1213 e1es_rhr
AA that it was A3 who usnuiiaad haw i’-*6
” her head to the electric polo. P.W.5 aha
i d:apouuut11ltitwasA3w11oaIInu1uadtha ocnnplninnnt.
1’hea-ufiara,i11nofiuras!L3-hunharxdinoonoeu-md.tha
ffamwu is %%’..=:1t ar…-i …”-at-.’.-.-Jab.-‘-3-a-…… 1-.-ii.-1′: +__.|—-1.’ #
thumsnuitbyothor’ hm: ‘
aamplamnnt’ in gin her cement to
._.._.-_-:_é’-
mm-im
………_4……..£..1 …__A.__ 1._.._ vii. -. .I._].~.._
amount to treating the
-_-1.1;-..=: 4.-9l_i-A Q! t_h.I_n E
with regard tn as
undnr section 4954: of the
reqnons made out hr this
V “‘ “”””*-“”‘-‘ ‘-.”1′.:1′.’. % ar.’.’..=..- c£’T.-!a.’*.q’……..’*’**-‘ in as *’–‘ —
._ ‘. inoth words’ , ‘ ofiti and
V’? Court will have 1:: be Iultlinad for win: of
‘A evidence with regard to their rah, but as far
qt’ in annnarmd for tha ofinlco unden-
r,n……n.a-_.. Anna 1 .1-
333′ I.
u -rvu-n ‘I’.}’n’: u.-I…-“”‘, ii’1″””””””Inr::m’s%i;’1’n’afi ‘ii s”:fi%n’i H’, 1%?
the nfiirulnii muons.
In
(3/
. i
‘ll
13. i-ieara’ fin: iearnua’ i.”.’.ounnai for the purine” on
the qualtinn of Ilontnuirm.
14.11:: 11 ‘ ammnmun’ “I-:aan’a;~
subsumed that As he sen1:e:r=.eeM.1_
wonrdnnnu with uactinn
;t.;11gt:II_;I_1.i;_:a.11LrI_1_a.m.II._’I,-‘
ML _# ____..I 1____._._..1 -..¢. “‘..*…I.’._ “-… -L………….I…..4._
ll’I:’I’1Bl’ hIll.l:I.,. 1311331 CUIAIQHI vxwupuxmuun
uubmm that true 5. huabana and
happened to the wife but
an ~
ICC V
59¢. i£wn1 ofjuufna and p.mcuJu’ ly,
. ., « ]m’nant__ be benefited an the has got a child
. ‘ V z regard In thn above Iubnliuion mania, I
V. ‘ h some-substance in tho submission mad: by
Juan vusuua. llll’ um suuguuunuu sun in 3:35;.»
axnofttxevhvwthatulaandoofjtntioeoanbeoquareiy
muatbypun’Ih.irnA3i.e.,thalnnbnndwith
3/
auction “l”5fi-ll. at tn: 1n..”””
-1 .A.’I….._
iII1pfi§hfifi16titf6f£i.]iG¢’i6I”ioInmv6fi’fJfifi’1iifiI’ii’ifi’u7
puyai’1nnofRn.3D,O0O,’– tothewifannd indqfanltof
paq:.rmentoffine.toundergofi1rthar . .
'tn pectin' a of 1 murnth. In the mun, 1 T nuflgun Ul. UIUVI I The state appeal is of
cunvu:1:|.Ig’ ‘ A3 for ;..m……a….. nacho’ 11
¢_:1’1:_’r1¢.s_E|I_’. ggmm of all the
A2 for the ofierm
lit: by tho u-in Court ha: In
91′ ifin-tl-Iegflhnoa
_ q— uw– —-.-.-
az A 1 Jun. ¢ I jl’Il’I A _. I’ 4.I_ -.
II’
b oanmnoed to u.-ndurgo SI tbr a period
% nnlto pay at fine nfRu.30,0Cl)I- and in
ofpaymem affine to undango further 31 131′ a
A 1- II.”
fir’-u -‘sf aw “&…….
81noetho.&–3isnai&to1neon’haii.hnoha1i
furtlwithuurrandarbfirathetrinlcourtmundacrgn
9/
Lf
\)
wntonoo imposed upon ‘mm’ on above and tho
Caurtohnllalnntnknnooauuarystopl
onouro that tho aoouood No.3
ufi him an above.