High Court Karnataka High Court

State Of Karnataka Through The Dy … vs Ashok S/O Janardhan Rao Kulkarni on 24 March, 2009

Karnataka High Court
State Of Karnataka Through The Dy … vs Ashok S/O Janardhan Rao Kulkarni on 24 March, 2009
Author: Subhash B.Adi


EN ‘Fi*iEZ H¥G}% COURT OF KA¥~3?\EA’FA§~Z§
{;’,3i€C3UFF BEDECH AT GU L-BARGA

1:m_*{=:z:> TEES THE 24% my :3? MARCH,

BE}’F{}RE

‘ma ¥{C3N’BLE IK?{R.JUS”§’ICE tétf»E§%é:AS§{‘E2._:A.:§1

§zE:::3:;LA§~2 $E::~sI3 APé§:~:3_L Ni); :_.e::~.3; i;3{}CI’?_ ‘”
cgw REGULAR sracorm AEr~..I;fEA_1,; z~:;. .1€:a»: i209?

BETWEEN:

STATE 9;? §<;s.i=:1M*m:»;A–J'i'.'- "

Tngezgiigsfiy .;1*:2im}Y. ._CQZ*e:PvZ§S_SIGf?NER,
GLILBARGA,5.REP:§V BY ‘?1i~fI”E _ ‘

ma. :;f:Qz~ssrc:v;~2’s;=:¢+;*1’_:)1i&:» (E35 §?:;s»:1:+:s*rs,

GU ;;,B*;s.Ra3A»&:35~2 1;’

PE’,Ti’1*I’EC3?~EI:”§I2
({f:C:M}’v3{;)N)

Séiifi, KUMMAN, Gav? ABVGCRTE)

._

A’SH€§:K Sgt} JA§\§AR}”_)l–£AN RAG }{1_§L}{ARE’%§i,

§&,GEE: YEKRS, (ECG: C3ONTRAC’TC)f~Z,

.. §;o’:«;:3:§sE rm. L24, L€}WE§E€ LANE,
V E§§%¥AMf-£A?Uf€, GULBAI«?GA-E5-85181.

R£iSP€3§’~é£:I£..E§.€}S §’AS53}EZi} if’? Rfi.

iv

§”\§{}, 2E’§2.:€};*12G{}4 {EN “§’§”i.§§Z- FELE 5}}? PR3…” DI§53’TL
;§UI3{3E1:§, €Z%ULBAR(}A, AL§,{}WIN{} ‘I’I–fE APPEEAL E¥’iLE3;’}Z§

z%GAiI*§S”f’ THEE JIEEECEMENT’ AND {FECREEZ HE’. 89.3_.,98r ~._

PASSES 15% 0.3 Ni}. 161196 me? THEE §?’EL1%Z {)E’ ‘_’i”§iIVE’.=–E ._

ADI}L. {731\f¥.I; JEEDGEE, {..}R.DN.), GL§{,»B!5.:RGAK

TEES RI>E3{}{§LAR SECONI3 APPEAL ;::s»fs«’i§i’:~’\é{;’«T~§i1¢:~;

ma m’m*HE:R §;RS Tnasj-az’, ‘E_”f’HI3f:. _C:~£’}_E}§€’T}

§}§LEVE§R§§§} Ti*iEf- ¥3OLLOWiNG: V V
JL:{3Qm;_§T
This agpeai is by S_’§at€ ‘€55
jmigmenfi. and 2334

fiaitsii G6.08.Z2f}{}:f3 on I Dis’C1’ic’£

Ja3{i.§;:}é’,: Vj11dgn1€:2’fi zmd d€C§'(:3{‘;’.
:1-3:1 ,%+;… 1:20. 1€§..§§£é;1:§:;.–~3 s:3g.o:,1gg3 011 me fiisz of

AdV{§}%_€i:3raé::1T–V€Z1ii;§_’§_ 53′;1iig§: Eva.) Gllibsarga.

. 25:2. iiaggzéz” fif;éH#C:’¥ff’Mi'{?{3 note, fliers is a dalay Of 41%

s;’i.:~§?s# ‘1.+:@1;fL§;ri:_}co11};’1se§ appearizzg for the :m5;p011c§s:;t«
‘ :vL:E:§.:;:?;n1i’t3 313:, ms: Efixaser Aygjééiata Smart
§)aS$$%§§.’1~ 53:16 judgillfimi on {}6.{}8X2G§§ whe3:€.tE:$ 333963} is
V’ a bafcrs this Qmxrf. 0:; G9.€}1,;2G{)’?. There is-g a daiay

of iiiélffl than 430 éiayfi. Tim €xp£a;’1ati011 Gfifirefi §:;§: iim

State 11:31′ +:703::d0naii::;nn of zicziaji, (10% net” 3hr:3w 3.21; gz::»0d
étaime is c{3m’i:3:’1€: {Em (£61332. £§xc:::})’:: aiifiging ‘that. 3:316:

{3?r(:sv:?::’:s2;:1s:1t <::’3:§ie:§s:r(:{£ to $116: at: a.§3;:«ur$uam~.e

<35 thc: m"€it*::' eziaiétd €}6,129£Z()(}ff3 arid '?£Z1€;%:aftm* the

z«:p};:€:a1 hag héien f'"31ed 110 ether a<:<:epiab}.e reasongx $}_"€"._V

givezxz. E 311;} not 3a"{f:.sf18d with the Cause ShOWi1.'f{}?',ji§3..;$} :_. '

cm:1t'1{311atio::1. cf {ielaja

3. Eivetl i’)ihEIWiS€, this r6s:};:€3:1:§§_¢e;;1[i~p}.’3gi:1tifi’ if

a suit: for mv€::/V of 211n0ti;:_; ;;~..g§:1 iiitt
was awvardecl a nt;r§«31ct on .1.-1%.

§\§ava(ia.g1T vifiage in Vi{.$-{fi’;a1ei%)11-s;j’ the ram (sf
Rs. 5.40] ~ g3€I’,_f€*:et. E3′.Eaj11t§.fi”

hati {it:}}’.}SVi’V{“€z_”V}.”~.__» v $33? eafizfist II1OI}f:”‘._’§’.
iF¥<31%;'5vé::j, 'fine iaiaé' ifmt eiztrzzssteii 3116 mark and
,h€::,:*:iaS asked 10 %.iig"-ai v§'\3avani}.1ai i11s'i.€a{§ :3}? Navadagi.

u{:01:r{'Vt:(§1::~;'ifie::rir1g tbs wiziszicf: has itieid that

V "§§":i£E?"'f7 g;§;;eii;&§:%;3?'1'f'§z;–a$ pmvsizi titiai he was asszigzized w.i'£E1 tilt:

" A°gx.'a32*£< (if-}§%gg=iI2.g pits and 'i.:'€ne:%hes and his !:<3:::.{§::r was

z3_€?=:i:;§:€d..' 4' Hewtsvezg ii «ziisbekéeved $33.6 <:2iS§: of the

V' n that he had €f0mp1tE'{€{i Ehg agsigneé Wadi at:
'?E3é}a<iag£ anzi Cansiderizlg I315 éamagfi Stzfféizréiéé by

p§ai1'3fifi'. Tiéai. Cmwt 52:21}; award ed aiamagéz af RS.

5,€}€}{§/ -; i;<::wzi3"{ES imzxitsrz}. E'::::"m1"€: RS' 1,{}{}{}j' ~; r$§1.1m"£ sf

€ié1.f"§'.3€fiS'{ §.i{:{}3fi{'Z_'é,«' 3&3, 1,'i§{}{},! ~ am? kgsrzé §:’:.:}?

‘z

2

£21 aii R3. ?,?’i’3{};’ ‘M! ii: has 310$’ graI:tt:{i ti{{‘f{“-96$ {E315 ?:.%:z._€

agritizaé ws;:r§<: <:{2:::afg,}i<i':.e(i ':33? $1516: piaimgififl "'§"'.h:: %s;é3.3ii;§.

dz:*.<r:1=:t:: is §:a.s€£§ (':11 the 0:33 fivitienm": as'; 1a:s:j;§i" :.»1$_V:'E3"sFf'~ .

(EGG ulneniéagry Ezvideficfi. $11 é'i}}p{fl§}§',""§§A(;f ioéviif .§:'§:;:s%1§3§'f_€vV

{i121°’E }:1a:~; {L'{T>I1§I’};fi6{§ the s.<.2me'.i' E 'J :'*:=:3*; §';3_:%,i a;:'ifg,–= 7

3z1§a$':3J:%ia} :;11es'£im.1 :22? Saw i_%}'§;"'£.?§V€ifi is t}1és é41§}§)E:;3:i','*vf§.'}.:ii1

fizzeimgs ::}f {aci {E0 ;;10t_._ Cali i7:f__i;’ié.;2;*§%:fe11cé §3j;? ‘E’}j3iSvfi'{f{§’EiIf

“iifidfif Sectiozg E.{}{) Q1? ‘§::x§::}¢'{:R ?}’)§)’?£i’*£- ¢;:.§1″M*§fi1<: grs::su::d. af

eéztiay :;::":::'i 0:: merfit, 1:h@.;{;;;p€:a;~.g;."§,é:19:«;°i$"":%ismigsaii gmd

i?{§}§1f;f;v€';Tf(,}};i.t3'§I§"i'3.f§::* _§}.€:v'i§,}§.' staznfié; ziifigiuifiséaé

¥3'<::L§§1" :'§{:zAé;1;.:;s§E;.;E:s ;<su§;}1':1ét:;~. E11213", RERA5 'f\E'cL

E"€_{4 {,3 2~*i'§{}? @139 arias véithim fiifi Eééiillléi <::.:)};;.1m<31'1

A u;"ai<ig1};;r$3;3"§ ';:a:_;_.:::'; <.%:;::’ ::'<'3a~:.~"a:;:é::..s asfiigzaezi in Ekig zz_g'3}'_.;€:2fi §€.$.fL fin,

' ' j :'_32_€}{}"?3,_ :-:§:ig2;:{§s €§iS33Lii&§E§€{§;

Sd/-

IUDGE

S’w’%-*3′;