High Court Karnataka High Court

State Of Karnataka vs Nagamalla on 27 October, 2010

Karnataka High Court
State Of Karnataka vs Nagamalla on 27 October, 2010
Author: K.Sreedhar Rao B.V.Pinto


1 £21’U»’s..5S£f2£’&5

31 Tim mam CQURT as’ I{ARfl’ATAK§AT E1?-.–Ii?’Qg?§;3gE:}ii*E’~AV Q ”

mama 1:-as Tm 2% my cm éacmésia

PREsEET2_ A
THE: I-I€3I*I’BLE r»m.._1::_s’rr<::E _1; é::;i31 =I:2s'%:%.5*,1:':1~£zx§:_
mm HQIWBLE

CRHfifl§§§&?fi$;LiRi5E%"vf

BETWEE :

By €§mxfi.1ug¥¢ta_e”Po1iec;.’ Apwfiant

(By %sr%;

E? _

I:?&ju,.._§fz.°§’%m ‘ tmailmfi

at
.Be3-ambadfl Vilma,
._C§ufid1upet:: Taiuk, mikaaperrfianta

A % kj §E;8§y”‘S§*§3£¥,R!£3ffi’¥mh§ Adm;

uuuuu any

2 €.’3li.fi’~.55£?’29fi

ms cam IS mam u;s.373(:; as (3; CR7P’;’f3 .–«’3Y:V”‘ _
Tim 3?? FDR TEE STATE mama THM’ 1’2′!-.,I£$” T

HQEWBLE CWERT REA? BE F’i.Efi.SED TC) GRA3.”a’TI_

To FILE AK A2’=mAL AGAESI’ gaxfmit
GREEK GP’ ACQUIT’1’AL mama 24.C%Q.2QQ#: mssE%nk3*:€
Tm 11 Asm…sm….m:>GE, MYS£3iRE*_H*if sm,;ms3’%»

Ho.77;2w1, aceuzwma Rfispergmgmfsfi
ACCUSED ma ‘rim 0FFEHcEs 9;k1:1/wssvé, 5%
OF [PC AND SECTIQK 3(i){xii,) er ${:;~$T–g_mA} Act, _i%

T153 AW: mnmg* :7for’A–. htwm am mg day:
B.V.P.B’xFT€I§ J., cifilivmeci tbs fai}.9wi:1g:-

Being 24.69.2304
pamcd Judga, Myaerra in
Sfiiai Cagé the zwpmldentzas af

«mg exam” sg¢::g:%.s 356, 376 anfi sea 1?: am

& 3 {Q3671 of Snhfiule

caa§e;%kSe§1¢§i§kk {Ex-mt.-am. afaamizzsmg Act, 3939,

the stag aka 1.-his apwz

It 13 the case of the prwenutglon that an

at 8.8% a;m§ in i Vflfige sf

Talsskfi aim ammeé awagma mm

3 E§A

Smt.Fut:,%fidamm @ Saxmathayafi

with an ti:

intezm urea with thm am thereby

an afimc urxdaw Sacttigan ” 3:;{z*;…1:h§ %

aha-we mid ciate and ax at
Gmmhspeta Taiuk, E ataga an CW-
1 an €3?iv-2

wmmjtgggé _ IPC. it if fusrther
afiagfi said gm, date and
‘£:1me’ , mg ;.~.m@L* ma. mm” 11151′ in’ ‘ ‘ mean

of cm – 1 and 2 mmby thay

” afime nrzdw Smficm 566
that Mm

‘E; fE& 3..

_ :a £ SQIST ani CW-1 Mai {3W—2 t%w

me fiehacizzlae (Lasts, the aawuszefi being in? a.

m ziaamzmha the wifi surf the used such

ta mzphit thaw: =

tea siarliich SW3 we 1 aw 2

mt beam athméwushsia

4 C:§A55«é!2fi&§

akgaé is haw mmmittw an aficzm mam’

(mi) of an ami 31* (mg) mg 1939. {

pfince of the amused befiare

charge was flamed aga:rm’ t §:1mm _ «._fnr §#;E1 i£:h, V

pkaadad mt guilty. 1 .

3. me pro=secu1:’;§£1.V 3m the case
11:: P15 and gag. mm tfw
Saassinzm Judge
has come that there ‘as a dsuht

‘V§?’§?;s- 8 85 9 (v1’ct1ms’ 3 and has

T9 .’*3 ii :’?”fT%:i!?..’*?i¥€1t awnsaé.

this apmal.

33;. the”£”ejaisft}1ae Scflufie

in the vixme. He has mm that we

tn the éate: fif his eviclerm, he had

a pamhayath £12 which 9.3 ms pmgale 9:’ ms

had gafimm He was fim yajaman er the said

5 C!¥£A.58d»!299§

panchayaflm Tim issuae before thfi pamhayath

the quzaatixm as tn why CW3 —–~ I and 2 _

away fiaom the hause. Both s’I3WsV 1 u

aummsr.-ma and they wme qucs:§i4on:.§:d..:’

behaviour.’ In the panclmyath, V

both CW3 — 1 and 2 <ifi __1':x:st was
ciaczideti tn gitm a. has
mm: mm: haagza gs ma;

«me aha ” ta 1:11: $8135 at” the
grneatzution, gku S Vmulmtaiah,

has stated that be has

on 2L1D.2i3E at 1 1.33 game at the

and has fauna am aisttadg irgiury an

She was brought with flm

amad ramme intm’mume$ He has further

k’nea gm “m pumsiamma and has fmmzzl ixgm-m’

hm: pagan, Tm hfimzy $52321 was that the firs:

had mmmitmfi fomihfie Zuxtarwursg an her: (fir:

£123 amused afi agnfi — –

é €:r$A,§&£!20!Ifi

axamirxatizzxn, he has given him opinion that, f’:.:-at

ofthe age cf 17 3% and the amend ”

mtmmux-ac an mm own: or créartrgf A A

pw-5 Drr.M.La1mhm§.f_1x::
Raju anti has wified ta sages:
that he is umme hq p=g_rfnxjm]

PW-2:3 wamxrm’
accnmci mrfifmate sta’tiI1g
that theme ii: that said amused is mt
in a pamltinn émtemoumefi

.:~1__ ssanatafile whs Irma. tmnsmittad rim

Bfilore.

Sh: has statai that aha: Emma

_ g_ accused are bakngfing ta flayaim
_V K She has furtlrm atated that abmxt 2 yezars
fit abant Ekw a.m.§ whmz herseif and K

‘E9 the farm: arm far: arzswerffi {kw natxzrfis wfi

393. mugfn £3?

7 Gr!A,53£é’EB&fi

he: and awusad No.2 aauglit mm of

Though they brimd tn exmm.’ ne tixmaeiveeg acmzmé

ham 3 kmre’ ami thmatsened that he A

told tlm tn go akzm wzth’ tlfmm, hem

went with the azrcxmed. Afier a,

am. mm, both we mmse&¢%kL::maV%~sp§:.m”~
of the threat, they did forr:.ib§e
mmmme with with
. at about
7m pm. Ifithg had cafleci
the pamimyafi§1.._A 33:3. afice sirzm tha
a¢¢::§;:&d they did mt dimiase the
memkm fmrcevfi them m tall

=31: fsam. imyath want haaig an ihm tzexi:

J _ the intmmmfi niighg they swam
E3?’ the panehayathdara and they wvsra ticd tn 3.

{:31 the wt day at almut 10.13% aamg, they mid thee

abeut am irwident and mm with mrmhayatizidm,

ware tahm is the police stafissza. at Gunéfiumt at

“/3

3 ¢r£A58£!20¢5

abeut 33.30 am. 01′ 11.00 am.
Cfllllpbirlt wax gnaw. It is suflmhed ts u
crasunmamizzation that in order is

the pamhayathdara and tar:

disclnseé the m of time aw
incziciezzt has not mppcnsd _

1=w—=3 yer um
wrsfim cf PW-85 hilkacks in
the morrmfg and crowing
back in ” She has alga statad
rwarfifizag by amusfi 110.2 an
1;ma s};§, ma;-am the asaauzx lg
‘Q’ clack in the night. an flrlat éay

Ea a ‘kw by the panchayatlrxdm,

i she has aha aémittzasi that
by cm parwhayathdara am sirsm
“%kmegj%ay;ma1ma that ifthey do mt dixdsaa gm mms
pf ‘acaczxsed, paxmhayatlrxdars wilt mt: alksw thsm in gas:
ham they mm mm the mm fifths amusezi.

5/

9 Cr£A58&!?895

PW-IQ Tm anotkm pamhayatkzdar anti 3 reLatim cf

p-ems is alas reiatad m mam. He: hag

%hayatIfiars abcut the gcing awaygvgf J

8aw;9on.t.hedatc~:2f<:fi"em. V '
PW-llisarelative a::fI"Ws- A'
Pw-12 'm the paiicre tn

the Cnurt,

PW-13 has .§£ V.tE1awv';edct5;ma fmm

the haspinal to {if Police fir

* _ 3 " V.

PW–14 1’3 “:~.:;g,.;-;% :x.m:. mm-, he has
afiatgcfi §u&n§sAA”11c:».:…kx1owr the asnicnim <21' the mid

W515 irzapwtesr ef Gumlupai. E-Ia hm

anfi went the gem in the Smart

has gem tn: aw awm af 211$: m:

§ which in at EXSFE, He has aka

the mag mad by firm amusaci, Whifih was: found at

b wane sf oc .

3.0 (‘3fiA..58£f?Cfl5

PW-3.6 is the Immzzganmg am

canductad the warm’ t:g,a’ 1:135:12, ‘ tip: ‘4 ‘V

of the mums’ ‘ , amastefi the

clmrgfishmt,

8. It 73 E-om the
tbs mm Sessions Judge: §£.*g’i&e::w=c of
PW; — S and 9, and has

afitiuittad .

9. Ema zemma 39?. The;

mm SPF’ aabnpsm cf’ ms — 3 and 9
afzsupkd EILPI arfi otheer cisveumaxits
mused have wmmittzaad the

ta be eenvistm

mm: at the mam-sags amaabze an

is $8531 that at the $33: ixmtarmm, the v1c’hw’ ‘

gag is the hillczelm aé abeut gflfl sum. it} {ha

ané haé. retnrnw Eagle ht: fiwiif §m1.;se at abmsi

/f/

X ,

1 I 3:’lA,.58£!?M§

1% pm. as admitted in mm”: esrfizianca. it is _

that the scans 0f the ac is ‘4

fiflm their housaa. Under the

the; victim that may wem
intenzouraa for such a long 2411.
Further, wen aftar thq; éjfxeaatigned by
the panchayat}1da2’a:i:’t?@ey liificlnae the
11% cf ths gem in. the
manning. It beanzxm by time
pamhayafifiigsfi tha trw, may §’£31″$
forced to give ‘$3.5-efi perscms. Uncier
kaa mt has-an am with
a f2–“£::feA It 33 zwetiimss ts. gay tkmt

w§:A§;}dA marmé by me panchayathdam tn

_ Caurt. Unfim the :

§ it

.*$af é”~%.$ bcliaw thug watsfigm sf Pwfi – 8 and 9 ti.) hefi

amused forcibly usea mm fixr their smug mat.

tlw awry {sf farcihly abductirzg {ham aazmat ha

sefimé’ as & – § thtey wank} have ran. baak ‘:9 their