I
IN THE HIGH CQURT QF KARNATAKA
CIRCUIT BENCH AT GULBARGA
mmgs THIS THE 8*" DAY GF FEBREJARY 2016
BEFGRE
me HQN'8£._E MRJUSTICE mwm RN".§'i5§¥ '
CrE.A,NG'6§5fZQ§;.Z._
BETWEEN
STATE 6? £;}_
L ?8HQSé,' ,' u~V*~
S/0»§:>%EJRR'jrL;Sw£§A:?¢2--v
:2. mi é.g:~?~3 ' §}é':§:*§:::,a
SZG p'5_H'é}SE=.
393}: MEFAR/@'% gt, a mg:
_____ _.
B?i'$]?R"'E€:T": §?€AfI{'§":._Ef"f§.iR RES?QN§§§'»éT$
' R 3 aggfiammgg Amy";
:'5{:g';&.«: mm é}jS.3?8{1} mg (3; §a,m: av mg
3'. '*$f?";fE.T§§ ?.?*,~- 99% "mg gszarg §RA":'E§\§§ Tm? THIS §»iC::=m§.E
_:':{:;;..;:§2"f'--~«mY 5% mgaggg T0 awn? LE£\;'E TQ mag AE2;
"§:;pI:@E;é;;";a@,ég:rx;3? 'mg iuasgmgsg? §?,:.M;2,2@Q§ in;
*... S}CA§i§&48f2Q§§ Sis; mg mg :2? fififig SESSE§§'éS
--.;%;,s:i:2;i:~;E; ix"? aézaéwézsfi {F,TaC,*E§}~§a{:€§é§E?W?'E?%§§ YHE
RESPON$EN'fS/ACCUSED FOR THE OFFENCES r:>;L;;:§_.";~:J{;4,
305 R,/W 34 0:: IPC. THE APPELLANT/STATE pMYs~.f'rfs§,é¥I a;V£_?;§;3u2: Seamed HQS? far
329 Statif am e%§:ag:;~s.;~;e@ 'r«?3£i§e*_'..L$€::gse$x'é;%:':'i'§":"his daughter §;§§::§a£&§ is ask i_Z°§*:§&§m§a:*am is} give mg dfiugézéfir in
marriage is accused tX§c>.2. The proceedérzgg $2' ?anc§5:§ya.th
was recerdai in writing and mamage was 3%3_é'~.
gerfarmefi an 2'?23.2GGS. Hewever, an
when Kaia had game is fetch waizéir, %'és;3_r:}'§*s_fie?':f':::;*~:».: 1%.».
[father and son] along with v.\:i_fe sf'-féfst acC[;.svS:$w}!,' ébfiséd .
and insulted her. Firgt accused¥'P.::'BE3ose ES' -- tfo {five field
the girf 'ever: if she majrfies s_r;'fe"%:: 9'V?r':V »:'1E;._%§C.s;.$ed,'Véflfiéyw mil net:
be permitted Ea Jive peac::'eV'fe..:'!'§3.>' 'tZ§T£éf'.1€:'AA;*'»"'.§'lf_;':.f'#§_E§:_'.~E't is better ta
die', Aftar kng.x»;;g%gV:._th駧%' éné 2 are mt
wééiirgg far irréuéted hes" in gubfic,
Kaia is kemsene and get: fire
in her 0{}~;;§§ was digcaxrerefi by CW-«§
and CWw6g "-wr:9V:'§:r§Ae$g3.E,€ai '_:1'::gf*'Erea'cment, were fmm she was shéftefi $0
Vifvéfi.'§*:§s§§t$E;.'j_ 'TE*1e::gh she hafl sufferéd axciuséve bum
isjsjuréeé', ..s§*:A§ Ems ztaggabfe of giving siateméai, vzhégh wag
;::ej5:}4vr§ie:«::§§ by the "?ahsi§dar at Ex Pa 5:": E579 stawmeni, gm
'--:«"§;§:*"s*;;~:i&§ imw acsasséé E*.§:§§.;: 353$ 2 am mfg 3:' asatzzgefi
"?:;'V{>¢: Ems hayasgfifi 52$?' meaiaéfis' E5: £"=E3§8i駧E ta gmgéweé
marriage between her and second respandertt, Afte r'§_<;_.:;::"'vi.z:3g
her statement, She died and that statement is 駧": é
pmsecutmn as dying deciiaration.
4. The Case was registeréqi' §§é_'_'{3:9irri é:.
arm aftfi %nv@st§gatEo'n <:f1arg£~: §h-;e3;§3t §§%aSV:_f'i3Ve_;j'»::3é;Aé:é..i:'é's'cw~Both
the respondents, They were iS 'Ii:x'I?:'f_'(§a%%€§j;¥'?-695.,
during which the proséc’§%§’0_n xgszitnesges and
psiaced reiéance en..1v5 G0:<:z;r:'"s:".zs:=.§if:i::§;"agyd '::.:€5;§.::;9;s;:é£eriai objects.
Hawever, evidence not
estabifshéng far offence wider
Sectian "am has acquéittaé them;
Assaifmg this agpeaé,
EL’Es§VVaf§ss£i’€a’§-Egg’ Fwxiwfihféambaram am ?W2$~
‘E<f§a2rV§.:3§£?:a[Ar;':§4:fa=areéated ta K353 ag father am brother.
?W.E E's*é$ ihé mmpfaént vida Ex F35 seekéag 3c'£:§z;3r:
' éggaénsi' Vresganéentgg but what Wiffgi gays £3 0?
§'§'T1:"'Eg:?€:?§'Et§'§§{:fim ficsarfiing is him, an $22883, fig hag fazmé
':':«é's£§7;3fi f'8S§§E"'EfieE"3i ff'? $33 éasuge wéih £3 éaagghiar %<&Ea am
'V ' "E:.e3s£<:'g&§§§m2 fig big grssemag, It 5% aésezz fie saga éaamé" °§';§"E€
é
8. Learmd triaé Eudge has Considered these
asgectg as seen frem the discusgéen from paragragm-..p23
cmwarsg 03′ we Eadgmerzt and has taken mote
gf the Agex Cmzrt, wherein if: fig heid ‘:0 gt’; M
Siiiiih Siméiar utteramce de not a;3fu*;”Lih’:’«tQ “,§’§7S_:f§§g;:€}”L;.§’L’3§’V3 $F”E{:£ ‘
hence; da not fan under Segticm
being beyond the ambit’ cf Se«£:;’t:E{;fi ‘:’1:Ci’3’L._;@f IPC;”‘i§’*’C§G€S net
amount te abatement. §;.rfi§;:§r Section 306
af 1%: Carma}: he%,§::3’$_tai:i§é1b§’ég’V.::
3?, V:f%’}e””§_{eaVrnefi ma: Jiudge ES if:
right §€2§”S2?’§}£LT’–£Z£.Z’;§”\j:’€ §z*i>,;:§- §r’:*–.%;’Eéxr§ §”§”‘~3:~:~t:§:Eed préncépée sf iaw as
afisa @n ‘r’:_h5e4:baéjiéiéf:%;::»2f§4fi§.§:§f;é Eaid dawn by the fiupreme
fiazgrt. I 522%’-s§a1§ivsf§’@-sip;A’§;.?éé~..§mp:;gnefi gudgmént 3::ff§r$ frw”:
._¥”i® a:”;§ ‘Aé:a:mr:r€i;*;§Ey, E: E5 cmférmed, “”§”%:e acquittafi
Safléffge. _r&2.:$;1;:sQ::g»e:i]’e’r%;t$ fig fuiéy gustéféedy. Acagrfiingiy, Qetétéon ég
r€:3l%€ tééE A .
t'”$_.
T3.’