High Court Karnataka High Court

Subhash B Basavareddy @ S B … vs K R Thimmappa on 1 March, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Subhash B Basavareddy @ S B … vs K R Thimmappa on 1 March, 2010
Author: K.Sreedhar Rao Gowda


IN “I”.i-iii 1-~-m1»1 (E()E§R”I’ 011′ §/{JXRNATAKA AT E’3AN(3ALORE%2

1)A’I’1’%:L)’1*1~11s’I’111; 1* rim’ or E\/IARCZH. 20:03
PRESENT ‘u

‘m1:: E1()N’I.3I.I:I MR. J i…fS’1’I(,’.Ii K.ESRICEEZIfii.-I_z§§E_§.:¥§£*§Q: % 3

AN 1)

‘r1»«;;’«: I~~1ON’BI.1′-£ MR. JUS”§”1C§}? AN.\f::N’uG01j>A1.;A:’G{j\2v:3A~A

M1SC.I£L1,J\.NEOUS mas’? :\1’351v’>11§A1, No.7:25’6,’.i:o(§%1 tfxm

[3fi’.I”V\7I13i{1IN:

‘ ‘V V’ _ (E33,/j ‘RA; 1’1a.1″‘1Hd i’é1’s5i”1§:k;:11′. Adv .}

I. Subhash B.B2’.1savareddy V
S.B.Basa_varedC1y.,”‘ .

S/<3. BElSE1p§i€–L;_ V_ 1.

Agpctl ;~:1b0’_1.:7:._ ‘~’LZ[ _”l-*c=c-117$.’ . ‘

2. E3111 1: .–LJ–ashj¢i /’bg. ’13. ,_ 1.’}E:l_S&,1V:’é’1’*I’f’?.d ciy.
A g(§ z1b(.)TiJ: {ff ‘ :36 y i::z:1 r . ‘ ~ –

§3()’Lf’1_ 211%? 1′<£sicfif1-g a1»
Behi mi G ()\-»'(;".'}'1V1I"}' 1.¢'1V1 E Vi*~I._Q{.sf';:)vIV":' a E.
Vidyz-1 1.'1},1ge1A1" 'I'1'V1)_E1 ir. 'E'<')'\i?_;L11.
TU.I']1kL1I' l')isi:'i£'t'1.: .

A ‘ ‘ .. .APPELLANTS

I; V R.T}1’i’1’1::1’}”Ei’al.}.)§.)E;1.

/ <3 C . 19421111513) pa.

E\/i;:2_jo1’j_i11 eijge.

.A I L R/0′.~Kn(.)1’1€I’12-xiii \’£1i;,1g€.

V Tipilw Taiuk.

“».’T..7i::::im:’ E”)Es:t.:’i(..’1.

p<)ter1t'i21} of c-,'.z.11'11.i1"1£;__;" aficl' S116' z11.1.z1i11s cr111§:)1()yabh? zzge. }'I<31'

1T1(}1'i0n.aE i1'1(.*0z'11c? is z==1:1s:esc–':5.=j;<.?d at R9;.3.O()O/– ;).V1;11[.~_ ?1'_V}1€

<..'0n'1pc*11sa.I1011 is a55sc=;'ssCd ;;11'1d pa1'<'I z.zb1.1I .*sc%\_._'{§’1″1″‘3,»’r:_’T

2:i(iv:111(“(= H’) 1’1c;’.t,1E.1′;;-111;/.0 1.E’1(‘.~ b(*11(=~fi1’ of ;1(;-(ft-‘E61’:-119d _ t;.:;j1i(:1’iL_ 1Lv\.{”

1n1.1iI’ig.)li<:r1' 10 be d£"(1L.1(',1.('('.1 a1'1('t 16, 1]]L.1h_.i]:?}.i L5,1" ""~.-.\{()'1–..1l'ciV.'e.1Lpp.!vT.

50% is to be (ie(.i2..1(t%;.c':l 10w2'11*(l:a_l1(r1' pE:1fs(mal <::;;i§e;-11VS(:s. "J";'h1'1s:.

£110 1012.11 l<)s3s of cf(?1.)e1'1(Ev1'1r..~y \.\?0.1i'IL*. be la;T5f)(){inc0n1e} x

12(1";101'1t:l1s] x E6(m11E.ii;;3i:ie:ai_} = ~. '1'11E fi§e1.it,i0nté;"s

are e1u.i1'i(2(i 1.0 Rs.25.000/–I. 't'”i)f”CXp€(Tt.E1I1(Ty and

Rs. .10.000/ ~ Ic_)..\\ma1_”(“i’s1s §’L.1§1’1.c*r:,'<-11_:£=x};)§f'i'1E§C5sV. .'I"h'c* p6*1.i[i01'1ers in all
e1'11.1'.£:lccl ['0 I_{:a.1.55.(}OO/– awa:1'c1c:d

by '2' h 0 17I'1'1'E;)1.11TA1"c-(TE

3. “I’Vl”:r.-“:§,’ V2?” 1″C?_..%]”A).’.)1’i(?’1’§’+–‘_T’:”1I–i1’1SL11″E£’ had acid1.1cccl cvide-ncte

beI’l.:11%j; I’}’i<: T1"i}3i1"1i..,'-1.1 1"i'1;;1t' the policy was iss1.1eci in 1"e€spc':(:t. of

.\.«'e'}«1.1',QIcu 112. ~qV1.'1"c:::=.I'i<;1'1 as age-1i11s1 p2;1y11'1c1'1I: of r)11E’.. the va11’1c’e.iEa1i():T1.

‘E’E”1¢;r.__pc’)sVf’é1E avl«;1″1(‘>wE_<:dg:"11cm z:md Ii'1c=. (".n;)_\-' 0I'1l'1(-' 0fl'i(:c Ee1'.I.e1*

é':_1'tit":'1i£:z1*kt*d 1'11 oz-*\.»'1'(ic11c'v 2-15; 1£xs';.I"'f:5 z'u'1rl R7 would Show £11131":

" ~~p<5Ei(r_v xvas (.tz11'1.<'c:ll(3(i !.i)eI"<)1*ct the dale of accident'. {me} the

<".2111n.'£'IIz1I'i i1’1..<sL1rc'ft’I1c SLlf.}]'(:’IH(” Cffmnrl. in the case of NEWV[INI?IA

INSURANCE COMPANY VS. RULA AND oTH§::Rs;{‘?AIR

SC 1082. 1&1:-2 i1’1su1’m’ wmxid I101 I.)-‘.->_.~vl–:’:«1TE_:)’:i”<'?V .;);;y'

(r.<)1'11pe1'1s£–z11'o1'1, SiI'1L'L" ihe 21<jt(:i('1é,1':L I17;-1sf+: '4,{,)(":C..l.'II"-]'f.?'L'¥r =.,_E1f{,r;?1'

('£"1I1('('11E1ii()I1 of i.1"1(.'. }:)r)licy '.-'v'i1I'] ~('_§l§.C' 1-1o—-:Am;: to E'hI§ .i!1.$Lli'CC13 ufrx

'E.I'1'c1'E. view. the 1"t-rje,-2(':1'.i11a}’5C’21’:1:sfé1!i(3’r1._sI’121ll bi? ;’)”£1yabI.€ by

Hie C)\7VI’1€-‘.1’m]’€’.’S])(}§.’1(‘1C’I1!”. No. ];_ ‘xix-?i!’ 1~1.VE”z”1′{L*:fgxs 2;;1″ (3% p.21. f,mr11 the

date? 0f1.}’1c? pc1.i11f:_) 1’1.1iI} (‘)_fAf:)§I1’yIT1<:'II'§Z\

'1'}1vc.

sd/-

JUDGE

A’ …..

3UDGE