High Court Karnataka High Court

Sumakka vs Chidri Vishwanath on 30 July, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Sumakka vs Chidri Vishwanath on 30 July, 2008
Author: K.L.Manjunath & B.V.Nagarathna


3% ?EE EEQE Q§$R? §” Eéfifiéféfié Q? EE§§§§$r

SEEEE Tfiifi $33 Eé” 5&3 G? 333; 2§é$55} -‘

EEESEEE Mm

$33 §§E:ELE fig, Jagggaa
Ag .2 _ _ V

EEE fi§fi’E;£ fi§$;§@§:;§§ fi%¥,§£§&E$i%§$W_r

fi¢?%A.§§%:?§§1§?H§§§§

BETEEEE:

Z’.

$$fiéE§&. .. V»w».; — <_ 1a ;

W§§. E%?E_§%§E§§R§§?fi%m§%§§Eé5%
2%» arm Hm I ,1′ ‘ ” :_ x ‘

49 i&é&£;

R£%$ SE§KK§§§§§§§§§$$$ED?2§L&§E

$uEL%@§$.§§3a;”. V .

§§:§Rg§%§»E§%K’_T

?§¥E§§E§%%fi¥ Sig afimé §§fi%ER§
@ m§gH§£a9§g'” ‘

‘age; ¢fi:K3$§E$§£a

vEt?§ §§&§§EV§§EL§
‘$§§?§a$§&&}?éL§§

fiifififi Eggjag fia%a$§, §§fi$EA

_§A¥§E§&,£;G E%$Efi§§&§?A

“§V§a&§Raga

__ Z2″§E&§S§
,’gga;’cfi:gKgs§§§A§ggLL: vzmnga

?§R§?§§§% fififiki

“‘~GEETR$§QRfi& Efikfifi

EEKQE REF 3? fififfififig 8§E&££&

jfi§§;%&fi§§E&§§”f,”€”

é fifififififififfifi 35$ Léfifi §&§§fiE§A?R&
§ Eéflfiéé
13 EEARS, _M_
35%; $31K? fl fifiééfiéii ?:L;agg'”
§URQVA§§R fi§ELi V :”

$EiTE&§flR§ Tfikfifi _
MZEQR RE? gy mafififix, gaagxag . _ g~»,
“”‘6a §?Ea;$§§g

{By 33;: 2 a $:m§g§§Aig§vf ;*m

$333

1 cgxagz VZ$EW%§$f§ _ I
FR§§ a&§E§§_$:L{fi:;L$ =
CE? E&ZL%&§ $§gf:§§»”

Réfifi&§&R§ awgygfin 3 V
fififififl §?”§Aggg ;§fig£ ”

§G.KAw3§;§?$ WV 4a’

2 $33 §:?:$:®§aL’fia§§§£§,’
$33 @a:E§$§@ z§s§§&§§”$@ Lffi
EfiKa§;ccg§fiLx=_'” ‘
m”EESE$§%§§E, ‘”-.M« …..

.a§fiL:’ “‘ V
V ‘.’V. Efiflfififififififfi

§*g3g $r::”§ 2 Egg? FGR R2 :

_ ,:«:@A ?:?..a§2:: V:.;*%;$ §;?3s:”2.:» $9 %~§3 §.s:;*%¥§? ;;a:%;=§:%2§%
“gvflégfifi? $3-&§am ggggx: $_::,:§$3 §&3SE$ Efi gvc

uai gs; §E?§E§§2 aw §§E ?ELE Q? ?§E $E¥§L §§§@§
w_dbVgiSR{§§;}w_& éfifié, %@, ca:@§&§§§@& ?&?;§

W_vfiLLG§E§%§f§§ QL&fi§ ?ET§§2§fi Efifi £§%?§fi§&§£§E £33

‘a,”g$§§;§§Hg§§&§§gfi$§§ $3 §am§g§§$;@a,

“bébglf cf gfihe E§$§QR@fi§t”EfiS§£&fi$§ $$fi§&fl§ by
*,sa§p¢:t;ng? the &warfi Qf tha $333323: that gag
§?3n§ _ @f éampenfiatgam. wag fiugt anfiw §r§§flE

T’§éfi§ifi%:1ng tfia flag: that téa daceaged wag wgzfizag

Exam tfie fifififi $3 :i&;m gatatiaa fizii rfigiigfifigfifi;
Ea:n§T aggrieveai §3° tfie gazfi.-£ug§m§§fi, §%§ %%gr§;.
thfiz iegai §$§:a§§mt&$2vas E%§fi%mfi%i§£fl§fi§% »%%?é%A
S@fiEifi§ §n§aace&E:: 3% $mm§&$$a%;§§; A

a. we have heazé tma ié%§fiefi $Q$fi5§i fi@% the
aypeiiaatg and Ehevf£§a3fié§ §§&§sa; f%z the

ze$§@mfi&nt~ §fi3§€&fi§$ Q§m§an§Q:
?§ it 13 fiékmgfififié Qfi.$&h&£f’$§ aha &§§fiiiafi§$
aha: tag ?::§un&i””§a$”{§y:» ragga; :2 awaxfigng’ &

maagra sag af_§$:2,i$,$§§;”–éa t%e héaé mf futaza

195$ $3 fifigaaéafiag afi” §¥%£fi 3: £QE$€fi$&Z3Qfi

ifs;

x’;J:

$3

an the $afiv;fit;®fi€: fifiaaa &i$$ baimg ;§&m$§u&$$,
tk:$°’§§§:§7’§§g§: ta §fifi§fi§% the fiflfifififiafififlfi
gram§%§gb?V§h$n?il@um§im

$. *$n th§7 Qfihfif’ fiaafig it :5 fiubmattefia am

in am °:v§.:;3::2-2 arzzfi, flex”/:{:*;::+ it 2393?: aa3;.’;A .

intaxfaraanaa 3.1: ézéus aggaaim.
§. ifhe fiaiy @3223 %.’;§§.é’gS§Z .%éE”::.§é:§é’ V¢;§..:§a:’:

atzagsfiéraiiagz :3 wizatiraaer i:”E:§ :p§§g;ia~%:’:::«:%”

isfztitififif :3 §§’2§;”:?.éi:'”:rj¥£°fi§ ::z:x:”;:;gg§i:,%>3*:$;*;>:j$::;:§%*:’?..

13 . $1′: §82:”‘:,é$&l aha :é;%:”<.?*:,s::€e.%:2{::%;:'
an z:e<:§::::§;., we £:;:m. -:.":r:;…~:=2,::, –z~%;:§,:»=.«:»:.:é§.+:»-;:_–2,sa«:;::;

1:: a i~’§.i.§i’}fi anti :.;§’%;£é~_ ,i:::;:a”%;::a:”;z:.
fif; °%;.?2,§ aaagzifint aiias/;::.f’;’:.%.:é:_2;*£§::%;’.«=.,.i’:: f*Vigfgfi

mééi tlaa *g*<s,s*':<*?:«%;£eA:*"f;s;";*.§..VV_a:g".%;;«:s':. :';:;.:f:::,:f'; thy; 3. $2.33: £.:.~2*fi'
§S.§§f"* ,5'.:;§.:?%;@§:'}. ass aim $3313.? 2»:'ags:~:$

af ifzze a?ea§%«s..§5%=3s:%; *–:-s*'@21Lf:.fi ha §'::~:.2%€:s€3;"*- yer

msmizh x;2;€'%;ex""'e:%3¢:;;§:é:;:°;;ti:":<;j 253 $5 the same 3215*; by

:§§§3I.,§2"::§z§§' V' :::r:;a.§..%:3..§i:.$3:* by tezE%,§;§1§ ziztfi

¢<::*:$i'a.f§,§lzi. :§%:v:%i,_; <:."::5s:2* A.'%é_::§:f§,=': azgfi Qf fihe dfiaaafiafi, 2: 32:22: 3:?"

§s§§.%':;'%§=, §$§,§%*f—- zéiaauifi; fiavé 22¢ a%*.gax%.#3;v.§ 9:: time 'i%:ear:":

$3 ILS33 aéfi vé1."'i;;'§.?z§§'3$?;&§'§,i;";§?\ a.@:fi.::.:sa1:§; a. 52323 EIEE

'<2""»is7'.L;«éTs;§:,.T%':.'2i'_£:§',f"'%«a is awaraiari an c%:':*s;2~& étimzéai Egaafig,

%:;'hé;%sei§";::s_ .–' 221aZa:::.2::g 'i:%'Zf.&l scrigaasfigatgwzz . :?'*:;2$5§{'§£}?%;i%_z'«=~

&

'Q

insifiaé af ':'€;s~:'EE§§,{?:<é3$.:'~ as awagrafafi, by 'aha

Tribignalé 'SE23 enhamzzemé tiazzgzzgaizgéggm sézaii _:.r';s§,,::::'&i:;;,%;;£2m é:;i;,.Li $%.;’%;:§:~ ‘

fifihafifiéfl aaizwrzsatififi 2; 32:22; »Z?R:$,3;éé.1?»,i}’%:;sT£;*%IV:”=-=V”

§*X$;$§3: jg€é;§§~._3.:’: ;;§i:*;t%g» _1s:Eg,”:;;f:z;,<",V:£:1:"::'3,,;'i.Ej..$f;é:.3z?:a

%:;;a:*:::;s .5 ”

Sd/–_
Iudge

sd/-L
30119′ 9

%*