Posted On by &filed under High Court, Karnataka High Court.


Karnataka High Court
Suresh S.L. vs Dr Gunashekar C And Ors on 12 February, 2009
Author: K.Sreedhar Rao S.N.Satyanarayana

1:4 ma men seam op KARNAT5}%§§’x AT BA;:€»!;é;j§1,G;t§§:._ ‘

DATED “nits THE Jam DAY” GF1:..:FE£aRfuAi%Y’:’;2{3{2§–

Paasmaj V
ma §§€}?~$’BLE1 MR.Jus§’r:c§é~§§.’:::I§E:E:V§;~%;§é;:~$.”RAé%:; H
,
ma HQ§’BL’;3_ M:2,..3;,§$;’f§*’:A§_EiT’_’s .§§_s;:f:*”§?§;§§é;RAYA:éa
R.F,A.Na.5§§§;;s§§8 g:9§g.’5y4:§,%’9:vs..__éaa.685; 1993
RFA 59<¥!:9t}*$ 4. 1' A
BE';""E""»%*'£:'_:§_',1"g ; – % ?' F' V
SR§.S.L.fS¥E%VE"€'£1SV%£; W£:;*§§§§i';)'§?–;;_:«V"':11' V
Sf{).LA'I'E :;:4:§"<:::::',G:}v;.mV'
R;ATNQ.1s?~1,1:im 2_Ps'§*=£1A:E*é,

_ 38'1'%i;,§1%<:-5;s_§ "{V"E'.._BLGC.i~i
JP;'f'§§.§*%:' A2§"'::.&R.; Asa»: G§a–L~-« E E4 15 … A§'PE;iLJ,AN'I'

{i'+:;§_ SEE '*%f;F:x::.~'R%;€3§§z:?AT}a'1, A§¥Q{i:P{¥'E g

§'3.§"§

' L §§2:.i:,at3%»1AsHE:»{fis§,
"»,S,!C),§,CHiE{i{A?~E?~EA,,
* agmmmgzm G?' m:a13w:R:<:S,
éZ}{}VERE"«%I%§EN"§' HQSPETAL}
MAN 53%, ms*rR3<::~'::

12 {Z ‘JE§3’E”?;S?§Ei§”<LAi'E5 §'=1ZAJ{}R,

Sj(}.fi.€i:H{KKANi'éA
ma'? 4?}; £22033

Q?

— – ” = V ;a'{:*j?:’3.Lv%.B’A.LAJ:,

:2;

V’ :.f_= :3;

VA

?sf£§§.E3iQ{}WB§’a EXTENSEGN,
M&§’V¥DYA i”;}1E§’E’Ri{IfT .

azwgzmms

Sf{}.L§NC§E{:$*Q§¥Dz5§.,§

$R2:E::-;’:vAs,a mRAHm;zA, ~
K.SE’1’T1HALLI HGBLI, 1
Si%iRA§\EGAPA”£’NA *1’AL’U K.

D.CHIKKANNA,
P9.[)VOCATE MAJCER,

JAYARAM, 5 ~ ..

S[€).CH!§~{E{A MU:3I”;gw”:);r;;–. j.
RAJA swag mamfi ‘- 5 :

:xéANJtm.»x’::¢§,%:.”’ _
SUDH_A–V€;’f§F;?E}I%3 EP§{IEE€:;%.;. ‘

s:VjQsz«:’E&:;éiAv’;4;é:14;é;:?;’:; _
K:%;L§iviA?viEss%’fEffI%jE’;”$§;£’1′-WQRKS,

vE§KA?ESH;*C,.~_
3; <1A"R.cHA;.,

EEQERA STQRES,

aéfiz. §”=r{A’E”?A, ”” H

“‘V”€*E;ig3i.?:}i.£§§£¥.i.E€K:»H,
PRE)i?R~iE’FQ¥2;

.RE;¥”‘AN.%§SiD§ES’Jv’z%R1§ HIE CAKQY §5iCT€}§€”{,

4..”S\駒AMY,
..=A.RR!:€E{ SE~EQP_§

msgassfia,
8fC}gRAMA§’~§N§%,
?§AGE1’%DR$ AUTG WGRKS,

4/

13.

E4,

332:.

1%’

TEEEBE TURE» §€E?’AE§§§R,

SEE BEAR ,
{DU RGA MEEJTARY H C’}’3″EL,

D.SHEVAP~§N;%;

s3;0.B0i3:3ARAN@AiAH,
$Ri§\EIVASi’s. GEKERAL s’£’L:2§eE:s,,-‘ .

LWGARAJU,
S;’C}_SIDDAP2§JE,
SEEDAPPAJE EEQGENERREEEGV}

WORKS Méfi ARCH: ‘JsfELDENi’Ss_ SE{{}P, ‘”

R5 Tc) :5 fi.RE ALL

sR:.€:;~£ArviU:x:DEsHv;e’AR A:é’:Q§”::’4:v»&r.:;:;’j%’ _
BUELBENGSE Mysmgg B.e§I\s’Q:%.’§,{}-R.Efi ._

ROAD, KIRAEGUR,

S,R.P&T?€A,~”f’R§.§}K.

3% <:;?e;_os:~:s, :1-_:TH~ §«.«:;a:';%~s_ '
4% B£.,G'£§§{'J:%'r'.%EiEAG~r%§€,

53:32:: Gfihf) 53.34 1' 1'.

._ “;~2.}:’.fii1§9;.%ymRA.§;5;?PA, 28?},
“’38?§_vCRQS’S_,_ .11??? Mam,
.’_J-41%’ EL-.G'{:K, V JAYANAGAR,

1” ~ i%APé{§£¥L§G}%’=E[ 1 1.

éa:m?.as:~%:’G{>A,

E§?'[‘f}._’§€, NXEGE-‘aRfiJ AF? E}

* : ;}/a;’L1:\:GEG0wm
?~Ei?).61, w1 @3939,

, fig.

. “£:’}M&£&I,i£1S’?A.GE,
% QQKULAM, Pv’E§’SQRE3.

3. L. LEEL5-‘§Vfis.TE£E
W; 0.D§.’?.RAMA§{RISEiN;’%. AND
B; 0, :,::m§:<3(;vgm

CV

EV§E§_}¥{EAL« P'f€AC'"?fTE{}i'«¥ER,
MABEJU R TSWN _

gas. SEVAMMA SAKAMMA
if)]C}.%<ZALAE'v'IMA Arm
W[O.LEE'€{}fiiAH}
§{.SlE';'§TEHALLi§
S.R.PP(1'NA TALUBL
:21. §§RE,C.N.\fISHWAN.§%'§'%£
5:';/G.NAR:%.YA§\ifi. S%;'§g*i:fRY"_;" , V
45 YEARS, R/AT :¢r::;s~..1 1:33;.' ;
NEAR SL5) 902:2? EN'FREg?€'{3'E;;
GCESE Gifiwfiég S'*i"§~'-Z1E'2'E,"*'f'.__;" ' "
SRER%.£\§GA§¥§TN§;,=:_

.1 _ V , """,.;2§:s?a;%§3aNTs
gag; sm ; AS§%G§§"'B,?§xTE.L"EffG}?* .3: 3%,» 2-?

S€RAJU=.E'G!éi;_E4, "{GG;9;1€.%RAS§§MGH ma R23)

*:';:i.:s1§%3:?M,§..V_§8 PASSED 1:»? £”)’E§¢§*~E€},
£12,185 Evfiiiai Pm… f3§’a’i{;’*«;.;{,é”E§€Z}E, 8REE£§.Fé£%.z%Pz’»'{§’§%AE: ::::m:
:m:::-;v:1::~;s1;’«:c;—-.i:’:v;;E: $:::’:*._§x:’:a,r¢:’ SPF;Ci13″iC P*§,’;z%;2*§;m2:;a:e<:§a may
PER%v§ia?5ENT §£*%1§uU§€'C'§EGNy

sag: .

R?&sg;§;§§_:_998

“1.%3,L¢’*§;a~$}{:9Da_,
A{;.£::§”: ‘gzaam 42 ‘$223.?

‘2¥;Q,R.a§;a.fi~ARAa ANS
é;§1L1:aIc;E:GQw’m
‘ Nam, 43% 39933,
Iii: MAEN, E1: ST”A<f:;E,
" G("}E<:i3LAM, MYSQRE.

:~–««5¢3:

S. L. L§5EL;%’»’A’§’§§E

A1381} AEGLET 39 YRS,
W'{O,DR.’I’.R&MAKR1SHF§fi §i?€?;’§
E}/G{§;i§%Z§§E”.?C:{}Vs§{}A

CE/.

9% . ” ,

E*éiEQ1{Zs%L PR1′:C’§’E’E”i{‘_}?*€E3R,
E»iA§3’E}UR T’f}E¥N.

g FEE’ SE3E£%,\f.J;%Y§PRA§{1’iS§% A9vG€:;s:;f’f§;, ;
Afifiz V

Ti CkGUN&SHE-K3’iR, .

A{3«E;D ABGUT 4i} YREQ

SfO.S.C§iiK§{A1\EE€2:§,
ADVGGATE ‘ ._
MA:~é:::¥A nisfiaim.’ ‘

-‘2 Cv1mAsE%E:£AR,:MA;;Q;5:§_’-.j=.
s;0,D.C:!{:§{:;<:;a;NN;a %
R;'&'E"

NEAR£f}§f3\;%;_’£}A E:L’=i’.'{‘ ¢ “:~.2.;;<;:&’;a,_{3?:’E;7¥?.R_;£::*; ” ”

3 L’i?f~% GE§3Q’§*«’F§A _ _ –

E3E*”i”‘i’.?s{)A –L:’r<;rf;;r§,(;;<:gx:ue<.2:}g*a§
A:3:~3'+B4_A§3Q:;T 13:3 333.,

V Sg[{}.D{§i§i3§sF%–fNfis*._GG'€A5§}:%,
" SRi?:-E1?*$I's§z'aSfi AC+I%iAEz%E€A,
':~;~:;_§E:';3':HALL§–~–§~:~:;38L:,

– , SREE;’5.&3%'{}A?ATNA ‘mLuz<;

~ J S”‘§:§_<:§:'V§E:;m 5%' mg LES'
R54 .::s..:§ E 35'' mm AFPE:LLA§%"FS

4. s.,.:;.’Q:?;£;;%:<Am
53;; €§}.LE?€{}E€?:{)i5a'B?;§

mgsma A803? 43 YRS"

” SRE:’:£E’€I”§£§SA Aaméégm,
§»:.s§:.*:”*r:aaLL: iiifjfiiig

SR§RA%¥GAPATi’§:’§ *m1m<.«

gihgumisgga
Sm' i,iZ'%GEG@'%?€'BPs,

.a.A?PE;.:;I_§§s&s%':.f$.f: r.- '

19:

2 5;,

13,

EKEEEEE AEBQEEET 38 YRS,
S¥3EEN§’y’ASA AGRAHRRA,
K.SE}°T'”§’1H?sLE.-I HGBLE,
SRIP.£N{}e%¥*ATNfX T§\.i,iJ _

‘§.C}i§%§KA?’§Ng%,
AEDVOCYATE

AGREE ABGUT Y2 YRS,
MAR” DYE’;

..§A;’fARAM, –

S/C}.{°:HI¥{KA l%§{§D£”«-{}i)_Wi}A;V’_’. ”
AGES z§BGE}’F4i *~5R3.:,’ L * *
RAJA cycm MAR”lf’.,~– _ ‘

MA:€Ji,%?%§éT§%;%’
&G§:§3iAB{_§¥,§’§*’433 YR:”–L’é__.v, ‘ _
Si5E}i~{A–w..{3C.3§7?Ef’}3E§ i$i;IPi?_Li_i§EES,

P;{‘;%E§A.S}§.,* % ~
:’»4A}3{}lL3’.’i””¢}€}=YRS;;”
S; s.:3.,§;fi:.° W{‘}R§{S,

V5–.:%¢:;§’v%1.éj1g{3:;’:*”zia:s’may,

€},21£ R{§:HF&E<l SE-SBA IYENGAE,

" ' z%§;;:::_m' ;:_;_:;g:<::"rmC STQRES,

}§fi;_Rji E*;_}i1%TFA,
AGE}; "Assay 68 'ms,

R_CfT'EL BALAJ1,

" " CHRN mzau,
MED ABOUT 5:'; Y§?€S.5

'PRGPREETGR,
REVA?~E?:SESi§ESWAR.f§ ECE; Cflfifi? §'§X€Y§'§§€':',

SWAMY,
AGED §§.'B{3§fE' 45 '{RS,,

%/

156

3%,

1?.

ARRf*JZE<Z SEEKS},

NAGERfiRA§

$75/ifi),RA§vi£%NNA, _
mas z%B€}U"§' 42 '$3., "

yéasgmzruaa Azfm W{‘2RE{S,

TUBE: THREE REEPAEREERE

SE§E2%<.AR,
AGREE A.B<3U*:*-40 '$33.5 __
SURGA rv'ii§,:TaR*2" E::::.f_rEL,.=' " –

§.si~:ivAms:A, .»
S/Q.i3ODD&E_ANGM.ޣ~i,_ V
Afigm A3322?-‘;i 3-9 ‘$323., ”

SR§§$IVA_8,.§’-3 sz;s;>L:€§”;:-EVAEJ s:’§:f:*s:::R§:g_; ”

LiNGAR:%.J'{;§.. :j_ ._
A@.£;::’TA.g(§a:T”‘%,2.YI~?:§s;«,
S/1&3:Q;31;_A;&?Ag§«V,V _ –

3::3:}§;?:~>A.:I”;%::«»:..§1»:~;§:~:2:%:r~1€§
w0Hg3gw§fiR£fi@§m§nfi3sfisa

R22. :9 R15′? ;a§<E7R;{} "

{ZHAMU’?’3v§§jE3S¥3AR§ RICFE MILL
“”BU’i§;3″}E”:’%. ;G$, Eiigfiié GER,

‘ ” ~ _s,R,1:’~;~s::*;r§;£: ifmLU;<.

':3;

‘.’–.%:§.{§;§é’;ac::=;;R:’séJ,
.._g:;§::3 gggssur 40 *<m:s§.}
"2'9*;:, 3% crecssg, 21%: E-;EA§%%

$33 ELGQK &z'§YA§€;%GAR5

: 'gm GAmRE– 1 1.

” ;§.’m;;;M:mRmA§PA,

AGED ABGEET 78 ‘£33.,

:5’2*1§ 38% CRQSS, 1 21%: Mfiifi,
WI BLGQK, J&ws§~zAGAR,
BA,NGALQREZ[ 1 2..

<%/

2%' ;%:E?v'iPA?ss'EM§a,

gags ABCBU3' 59 "f'RSu
W,!O.i~{A§£-§SAYYAE'€A Bomiaeg,
2-<N.3g'r1"i HALLK,

:5. R.PATN'a TALU K.

2 3. SEVAMMA @ S.i%KAM?v’.{;’§

AGED ABOUT 6C} YRS,

f)fi1}.I{AL:XMMA Méi)
W/G,LINGAIAH,

£<LSET'TiE%ALLE,

$.RP§;§'r«:A TALUK.

…………é;%Es;9a:~é:3:€:*§-?§’–

EB?’ SRm$:~:{;I~: BPATEE; 4§«*-{5:fx{ 1′:-z:f>§2;_ §¢:;g,. *

‘»§”VE*£’§§V§’?§’f%:.:53a. :é°i»§”, ‘i;§z~:§*E*;Rv’v-;s7E:cT:N 9% CP{.”i,, Rgw.

fI}E{i}E¥%X, 4 1RL?LEZ§”.*§«.V_1″ .._;fj.’.?{3 AGMN8′ ” ‘§’§§E§ JE§Ex{}?viEif’~§’§’

Am 33Er::R*%:E:’E§’§’.~1″:2a?T;91$'[*—8%_.Q.s.r~:s:11:385 C:-E’-I ma FELE
or pRL.c:%;”:L%%J:;§;<;'*&:A;- $R«:_RA%mAPATN& E}E',CE€£EE§iZ'=2£T} -3'-235:.
SUE'? P&Z%'§'ig'3i»'.F€iR §?§,E{?_E'§'§'£UN §:'«:::.,

_ . . . . .. '

L1Bé:*§$§? E???-%.: " u

$.:,.».:}f::xm:z:1é;';§*;;%;V
2%t:§E§;2 339:3' «rm 'ERS,

– ~ . __ 29;; :3. Li:~§.§1:::<30w'§A,
.jS'§':Z–ENIV£§.SA AGRAE-EARA,
* §<;;;<;fE*§f:':HAL:,; HOBLI,

— 3§e:RA§azGApATNa TALUK. …,£sPPE;i,.£AE’*~¥’§’

“‘g137¥ SRI.A.E~iRiSHNA aazary, asvecmag

%/

. “€.z”i_ ‘ D

N ”

{X}

9’3

§3§€,C.C%&ENAS§~£EEE<ifis,R,
Sf£}.DxCH3KE{AF=EE\5A,
DEPAm':~¢1$N*;' <3? ?AE:{3§é'{§'RICS,
€§{}VEiF€?€§viE%~IT }iQS%3iTé:E,,:,
MANDYA Ijiif-_§"§'R£(3'f',

5: VIDYAS1~EE£i{AE%, M;;J<::R,
Sf €),E').CiHEI{}{A.NNA

Rffifi' 4"-"H mass
MAREGQWBA E'<3X'FI§?'i8EGE*~§,
zvlawmfsa DES'i'R§C'1'. ' ..

L’1z~$GE<;;vJm ‘
‘BE«::I’-Tma L11\zc;ze:<:;;'c;:a.z;:';p;;; ¢
3; C}.DGI3DAN§~§A Gaxwm, 1
SENSE Bags 8%' HIS

S.L.S{§E?[E'~$§vi;%§ . —

S; {)’§’L§AE§f;;E€C:C§-2%’3.};

im. 13%? 1;,’ vfé’_1.TfH”«’.e§fi *:x;:;%2;:,:s2§ _ ;

33.”-F5 i<:;%+:':3§;§*a,s' '£7? I§:;_,@:."::«:,

J&*€'3_N"A,{;;AR:, '£3AN:s’:;>a.:2:r~zA ::;w:;>AM

” Aizyzrga;-é.TB, %;§A*:%:D¥A.

._fSj€”§i*.’_(3.§§Ei:i’}ig% M53: {;i’r€I}W?;:’I*Pa

‘ Raga’ €__”:*”9CL£’; Mam:

§%’§:fi’s§’&§J{§ ?’*€A’E’H.«f’–“s

x SU%3é€A C.3{}¥’§3EE S’E3P§3L§ERS,

— PRAK;ASH,

$fG.KESH:%..VAf3¥iAE?1,
§{z%L§i{fiMBA TYRE C&RT WGRKS,

VEN §{fi’§’§:S%%,
Sfiltfififfiflfiié SEl$H:i IYEXEGAR,

ck

ii).

11.

13.

EA

. M.

6,:-2

M25.

ENETHRA EZLECi’T’E~3E€§1 STQRES,

HARE 8I4*§:%’T'”£’A,
HOTEL BALAJI,

Cfififi NMAH,
?R{}PR§E’F(‘)R, ”

REVANz’%.SiD§Ei:SWAR;%. :€s”‘:::§;:’~:{:'{ ?§x::9f{;s~f%§’,2I§

swam’,

ARRACK SHOP,

Nfi§ENDRAg_ “”

$fQ.RA!VI3%NF§E 9§, _ _. 4.

rgaaammzg 2’5:aVL_,§.!’§!C;” w:>i3:2<s.,_.– jj; .
TUBE TUB-;-E: »;R'E';"=:a.§§ie-35:.-RA,"* –

s§§§si§'é:;fl:§.,':ii. 4' _
f3't.jFRC§fi. m"§:':.s’Hv:W,N§;;.: V ” . –.

3; 9. D{E.DB_AR;§f%GAE;%;H,

4 ;3R:L:§:w.§:-.A.__ §3~E1E€E;R:%L S’I'{3RE§S,

« :,1:§{3A&~;xgU,

” –.s;«::;;:3:rmAPAJ§,

s1f:f:DA’P?m.: EE’~§GENERRENG
“=’sAfC}RE<i;';"é mm P;R€_":H wamwqg SE-§{}?,

';%5f"~'f:i§0" :5 A25 R/O

SEE CHAM§.§NB?:3-SHWARI REQIE'; ?\.r3;I.LL

AA ' u_BUILBiN{}S,, §&%'fS{}RE~EA§€{§-ALORE? RQAEE,
* ._ _ ';%Z}R§s,i'*§GUR,

Sfiifififi GAPA'£'N£'s 'I'PaLU ii

S.G.NAGARA&, 337:1,
38??-I CROSS, WE Mam
4% gaocx JAYANAGAR,
BAE'é'GAL{}R'B~ 1 1.

1?. 1%.’F.T%§§%sé?viAR2%dAPP;%, 1871,
3833 mass, 2 1??» MAIN,
4% BLC}{1§{, JA¥A:~IA:};xR,
R9LN{}§;Lf,}REZj 1:.

13. S,L.YA.SH{}I}A Wffi R.?~ZAGE§¥%A;§
3:, 3/0 LiNGEGG’i§?DA T V
MAJQR, $0.61, W1 €Zf%O’SS7″,–~,
HI MAIN RQAD,
:1′: gmaa, €j«0E<UL-AM,
M'{$GRE CITY'

1~:–;a S.L.LE2ELAVATHi _
W/G $r.*§'R2a:v:;x;R:,S.¥.i'm';é, .,
aw :.sN€_%«1s:=G@wm;;a " _ –

MEEDECAE} P§§1i%;:”3Ti’§’.EQ?§§;’E, =
?»»§;a.13fi;;:i’r:”T:0$gas.é’é; ” .j ”

xatgg G ,_ §’L1;_%B. “-._ ‘

29; §3§,%vé2x;:_re:;a .sg§_«:A.M i.:x«:A
, :2»; O.i{Ai.»5§vI5A}§ may
“”}”:W£\{}nL§§€G%:Rfi, ,
é ” ‘;a:.i.~s;%5~:*:”*:fi::~:AL;J’; “” ‘”
., ., , ‘ 534v ?f’iL{§K. RE_a’\gbEJ.\:, 1-.5»

{§3¥._;é%R:.;:£§§;§fé:;é1vAS;%.N 3:, Sfiéédifi FGR E4,
$§’s:’§’;2%4s,§z;x(;1~§:.%§>z%:’f:-21 mg R1-=2,

A 1_ ‘?§§’§S RE9″2%. :3 §’ELE:E) EENBER SE€T£{:s§’% 9:3 (3%), Rjfiiég
GRE}”§;?i§2 4: RULES 1 M13 2 CFC AG§s.iNS””i” THE J:.s§;’*’::}Es§\s%:E m”.13.-19$ IN s.$£:m.12;85 {EB ma FELE;

” 3%’ PRL.€:I\;’EL JEJBGE, SRiRzXi\EGfiPfiTNA§ :3E;:,{:R§;§::’;»:<:; -':*:»z2:«T:

-»-313:’? pgmz? msa ?§%RT”i’fE(3§§ E’E”C.,

TEEESE _I’§P?E?;§.;S {l§§s»’§i§’§{} 0%’ F”£§§ E”§E;%§?§§’§{§ TEEES
{E933} Sfifififlfifi Rfii} :.§.9 §BE,«E’§E§’§%Ei$ ‘?§%§Z ¥{}L£,{}§¥i?*§G:

&E}{){}§viEZ?~_é”f’

Thfi rsiqusgt frgtar §)1″O{§§.1<3E,iQi}. sf a£i:i逧’ ii§.{‘.;£i:’:€f’

£’€j~f:C’.€f;’,fi( ifixgfi smqi §Eif{}8 rgjectad)

{>116 §}€3<§€i3a;I1:1agaw{ia{p1ja::zjg:0si€u_s}"giissi 33,5:

2935, (Time <.:h:;;:ka2mga1ah;'A-VL.'L:'V:"' '–%"}.C}3:§}a};2fz3121}Le_i;_; '"'~= i{%§n7'ss=:'¢:§§%»;$
BL-igagcgvwfiia i:E:}€f§.§\§G.}; 311:3 sans
3:151 iiaugiaiser sf 'aha §)£'0§3:$S:if§f::SJ ciaikiirézi sf
Dszfs-.4. The {ie:j:.:~s;I§§,v:.*_2 aggéi gm. 1% 33%: '£318.

seas and sf Qjlhikkfiikigaizfii

and F’z.1:*za§ingamfi’:a.A ‘é;:3:fc:’>;}Lr::s~¥f._ ‘{‘f}E}.C€Z”§1if{i w§’i§:: the:-: gressné;

iifigationw “§’i’§;&1s:.:ii’. b:~’:t’=s:e£::1 €316: piafixfifias 5§€f€..<§

311:1 &::3.__§i:i¢ pészft anti <ief'{.?*€{).} ta 3 and £':€ft.Z*~%o. 18

,é;1'1r;£_. éixid E18513 on 316 Gfiifir pazfi.

facis iiisciefies €33? {ham was 2»:

§:;a:”£i’ti{>.n._ b3;-. §a§’a2~g:»aEt:§§m::mara:1ém:m ef gazfitissrx} at EXP. 3

: {§fI. ?a5.V§~’§§?’2 hsézwestn d::fi:,1 fat. 4′ “File suit ‘B? Schfififiifi

” , ‘ géfegeffiss ‘E3’ sgtileciizifi prrzxpertieg ami a Sims ifi ‘E3′ scheéuiié

M .,j?.Zi€)p€1″Y§~’ is aliattssti in favauz’ cf éieftfin The suit ‘C1’ Siéhecéuisa

pmpértias are ai}¢:}i’i[sd to égeft 1. ‘fixs piamsiifis ztantaxzd {hat

CV

M33-

1:335 sufi ‘E3′ ss:t§1€(£u1e grogefiifis aithgugh jam: fajgrgiéig

§33x};3r:1″ty, wera 2163?; sléiijeciaé ta pazfitimz 1}.IE(§.€I” :.’§?§f’:£;=:_

iaiifi Cfiififi E0 ha amendafi ‘£0 i32=::Eu.c”i€: ‘Cr’ gqthfiétxéé’ €::§”{>’i;T::”§?’i;is:s?1’v ‘ V-
k E: L. _ T

coz3.sis%i11g ef agxictfiturai laixds f02″__p3r:iti0rL.V’Tizéf g_=:;;§é:~%;”iE}1§}’./,V

geek 3 sfiiazeffi in 111$ prapemias $.E3;Gvsz1:’~.i§3. iézifik-»;5:{iii§§: ‘F?’f£§?;”.1E:f;”;*?1;_’

P’ am} ‘G’. $1} the j§0i11’t famiiy §:§§’o5j§§::”tie$’v§1i zha *§:fi;§$:%,£:$;§§Q§:§ :3?
‘£336 famiiy prim” to §ar’€_i%:i{>n a:f§:_-:;i:Gs.§’n if: ~ piaiiit ‘£33
schedrazie. 111 67535183.” W0réS~ .z;V’§1z°<)A13::'rti,$:; Siaiizxfiié in SCh€id"u}E 1,3 is

G szabjesteé. "£0 p.ariitie:}fl ~33:"t';" }?31':i ""-.§a":.::*<:s§. 23%" the 5%

3{3hf:{§1i§§?L "§3'ii*;§}£f:f'£;ie s:.:f:,: " '

3. i::i&fi:..}V {E131 ihairs was 0333? fiariiéal

pa3.”‘f;i'{‘f§<}i1 _:aife§:c§tc~:ri;A V'§'ai1¥§anhé2nse1f and :'}f§:.4 viés: E:x.P1 dt.

V?..$a ?L'?§'?i2 ' VV'"E7'_'§1@i*€ ware sfirious fiispuétzs :2i:i?i11 regarfi 3:0

t};i€:.j1ri;§s":;s€: proparties ai: fif§8;£1d§,-'3 311$ Bmagaiare.

T}1é:¢fer€~§E:{€j'..–said §2*o'perti€s wait not ziiviétzci because of the

:2 is mm that &ef'{.}'é':3.1 insistad that if

§::":f§= were ':9 Share the burdsn sf family §&bt in a sum sf

R2§.1f;29.:'S{}f3/~ eqtlafiy, the defanciant biog: wauid give up his

rights over the rrice miil am} 11:3: wmzld give the sams:

€}{€§11$iV(i}ja,f E9 deft.}*~§0.4. Tim Bfifl: dial Em? maiza €323

M514?

ggaymmrlr, therefore, ms saiiifismenii was 319?: EiE’3f’iV¥i’é at .-731:”:

aft} victie Eix.{}?9 dt. 1fi.9.}_§74 gifiaii gaaztéan sf éte:3i$~~

333:1 5% in 816 ‘P’ schtfiuie to his daugkters €01′ %2i;:{i3;§%;¥&§ ‘-T ‘

it is séubmittesl thaf ‘F’ scixaziifie ;;;:’::r3;3:%::jti:::§ -€:§j36 sicféfw

exiéiguiztxi prepfirfiss 0? tifii and 130?; a:%;*:3;L3?§:’£”3§é 7

3, The df<:f*£s.2 331$. 3 fiarfiagifis t§1§%~_fi€€ a
E:s«:.§'.}. is ufijusi and g2'<{s.7s.E3; ii_';é€L§3.§.:§é7§:§C.}§§{i':.§". §'§i31'iE3é;HSéfiik fmsia
gsariifiiéza.

“j~:§1i:r§ESs;g- §%;;.–«:–; “j~}§_’;Z(‘3;{§?€i’}j};fL’j§£’: ef aggsai Said S.§.§,€ iii
S:’i§:~1ngajps3*é;;.a’ii;Vfaévsarvf:§fT._:4é:§=§;én£§€ni i’a§@.”.;31 was: was 319% 3

§>z1r’f.§.: is E55-;.._.S§uii. V’ Eiwis cm}.i:e:1%:i:; etxf Ffifigjrfliifiififli ?€0.:21

” V. «_ f{§13§:’ ‘$2: fiiié; avegii cf _f;__3::s;1_7:j’?’_*:’ais:>;a1 of pmperties ‘b€tweer§1 piaiiiiifis

*.:1:§[€3» .Vd3’€;.a§¥4«.’%*.§:*;€,fA’g::mper”E§; p11rrc.11ased by him may be afistteé.

e;;;,fiv::g1;;;;§ ta save mg purchase.

S. __’A’l,}’he trig} Court :31: the basis 6f the yrieadizags 3:16;

g:ve%ifié:}:ce found that fllfiifi was a vafici §}8_1’¥;iEiGfi betwaazz

€§§éft.4 anfi daft} vifie IEXP1, I1: rfispfizct 0%’ {ha ‘F’ schedule

pr:,P. 1. Eisrzce, i13;_;’*;:1;_’

fmzis ihat Cfiffaifi persmzs i:2:;i:e”–..f;ied’ AE4{?xf’fi1 E'<: {}3"§"i?'; vf;;ie§«:_?i::g

ifiiiléilfiiéfg rights against §efi'..?€o. E Efigféufiee of ihe
p<~::1de:1c:.2 (sf tenancy j.fi7§§:;§}.§'.'.'{3Q1Ii"§ §<:}A2ds; fazest
adfiudicatiaiz. is ksfii fix mafift of $16

Ewe s.€§a:{'a'{€ agkyaais
against §:é<::r*é:e: (sf {ha 13:13} €fi~<:surz¢ Eéaiis. 12%

afieri if} ..i<3gze't§i%:1f E1:i%}v:% fiiafi Té}I1fi agspééafi agaijmt E§1€ judgmézgé:

. "'z9a:1ti" €§.§;C§T€fi Sf Aihfi £:'*§§"£"'€;f§§:::"-'5.

.,_8. :'§f;(.'f§','!%§;'Eéaghupa:;§.1y aué S"r§.§{fiK:*§$Ema Bhai, €236

{§a%;:'£i§:eEv'.f%§§,:'&5éa1f§:1g far é;efi3.".?; axzfi 3 fizihmit {ha f0§i0w.i§1g

. . :$g1*.*fs;z:3é3 'E0.i assai} tim judgmeni 311$ &€:::re€: cf {ha iriaai Camfi:

9:} Tim pa1u~pa't'£"i aft §?:xs.E3'T§ is §11adn:aisSi'§1e¥ '?i15

Writfing in E;3s:.P.E is rapists with stri%:e~0ffs, QWQE'

aA§z;*31t3'.n.g amfi C0fI'€i{?fi§§1S. "§'hr:: §iaiu==pa'£.%§ ES 130%

I*egisi;a1°e(i. Hence thssrfi fig EEG vafid §artiti<:::3.,

Q}

U':

N-….w

.35″

Th6: aiimcmegsgi 9:” pr».:3;3€2*ti€s 1:1 partition is g’rs;$5<§jy
ézrzjfust anii inequifaifiie' "E"'he agzicugifmrai iazzds
havf: ham: iiairigz }3E1"EifiOI1fi':(i, but iimre £3 gm$s

inequity in aliiztxneni sf Shams $1: EEK: u;"i3;;-2:;

gampefiies. fififtsi hag beat: graxréazfi. §§13i'i'§j;4"

Sf firm {30IIS1iI"i3.€i€(i area in the rice

9£_}'*'3v'€:a eifaf T316 Vacant area is Bgfliiitfifii i;0.Vc__iéfE'ii.,=–'Ir; L.

'§'hc";t $132133 pmpazéy at Ja;§a:1agar,–'_' Bagzgaimfi £5_3{',a

mas? valuabia propsrtj; 15:; 'is"'gi€iéf:1-.__7E,:;:::VT_'

iiefi, 1 in the S816; p1'Q3_)g1"t}7, V V '
we isaems 3, 2 anti ;:;i~.§:31;VS1j§'”§:::ftE;s2z: from ;_:zarti’£i:;>n

:€:::<:.::i: pI"{3p€IfifiS are fie?

a3va3′}a’ nié:V:’f:§i* géitiiieii $.13; the suit

73:36. dtzié. :”v.’ka:i’:§;z;;%§.’s” that Exm rficcrrcis mags; 3

pa.2;”titi£>:1«.” Ths imuse property at Mandfga,

. £’2angaié§rev–..a11:i rice mii}. at Srkaxggagatna were 119:
V.$3:3.b.r}t:*ct:e(i toe yartitiou because {sf the £ii£¥m’€11cess

. f”§’;Eic-:?e:.fg%1*€, the 33116; propctrtiés wcra Rap: 011: f1’%3*’§}

_ ‘péijiigifirz imdfir EZXKP, L fiance, $26}: mopenézzg @327

‘” p:ai”i31fio:x, in tha altafizative, maid: partitigr; in {ha

Ewuse ymperties at iviansiya, Banaiore and rice

miil at firirmgapatna.

” ‘~ }’):”0;§’;é’s”ii;r:_fs’;.

.,§’?'”

Q’ ‘1’Eae ie2»2.’r:1<:»:i C{;au:1S<~:i Szwlfishek E§.¥3a3%;Vfi;A'

:f:%$p€3m:1t:11'£f p1a3'.::1"£ifi's su%n.1i?f£eé thai. the gfii ziaeii éé '

::§.%:.. 1{};9.19'}'4 I'E(Z'{}i'€iS an aiimisszégrsrsjf.§€;1:§'

Dft. E. 3313: item; N955' E, 12; :.:md 4 {if 'F' s£e;2;s3_§_51:1é

in his I1a111i: in the yeaaf 1%3¥§<3i;T._§E~Zé{;§2 t3£¥%§»8 :%%é$;;pr:~r."r3§r§ei}*
wkien thc: family was iivizgg jei.;1'§.V_.'T3:'fie:_::;i':':f_f:LA. 1 ;c.i i{i«
indefjsenzifini smzrca of viii::?i{;»:s::.:.é'§. L. fiéaalaging tim j0i%;1'§
fazxiigy. ?;E1?;_ in «%~§:::_Vj;e:e_a;” j3.€}}?’25m”%.zf?c*a1§:i assume the

C}1éi’§’E:1(3’E’§(‘i3,'””‘%;”V>’VIf”;’;,i3§:§iI. §éE}i3:§_1§””‘§f}§’§3§}€:E;§§V.””‘ti{§T1fi zéaid p1″og><:1°t§s::; §?i.}'€§?€3
3:01 31:E337é_ci.€§_i is _pa;éf$itic:1'; Vtszjxiiqr '§iX.P. 1. '"i'ht:r<*:f:;::'3:e$ ma} <:m::§i
has :<"ig}.1t1j;"–.g:*:=1r.1*;e€3£ "EC: {E15 pimfitfifg in E; 3 Saki
V' " E?(}v.V'7;'7'E'1;:v': «f«::::_::i"ta1ss of €3.13. 1 wauizi c1£«:a::3.}? séizaw $135.1. ii £3

a" ;1é'r2i§fz1m;'2;::'*ig"3.1§1:;:::? «sf raaard {sf pas: era} Exmisaaiiisza ef 3

'V p2;fl:"§:%:{§;§g3:"i". "Egg: EZXEPE 'gay' iiigfiii (£02133 3:}? €'.fi%C§ gjgéariitifiész. 'E'h€:

i$§€3}0S€S the Est af §"}'£'i}'§}€f§i€3S aiizatieci is me S;f§.3,i"%': 0%'

la?-ft'$$'A a:1{§ {iefi.F%0.}. the pazfiiix §1":r$3'L2a:;;;'£. is 3349.} have gei

u '"'i§'123 charzgs 0%" fliifiéififiil éffaitied ii: Ehs I"€¥€1}"E.1€ 1*€2c€e:'{'z$3., T116

{i<%ft.;"*~¥e._'; 311$? def%..§sEos'iI» have iittait i%?i§?,§1 ihfi'. pmpertés-:3

W13-

aiisfieé “£0 mam unfier Ei’-§<:.P'. 1, "i'he:'n.=:f0I'r::, ii is '::r:ie:1a.E3i§%é"'»€0

sgxntand thai EXSLP1 £3063 Constitum a vaiid pa:'ti€.i0:1~~:3:; ''

E 1. it is in evidence mat fa§ET1€§r=i:1_–'iaaa;i %fi:'f:" "{:7.i7'j'1r'_;:v-'% §.}*;':¢i3. 9;;

speaksr of 1116 fassembiy and 3180 a;":f*arii:§:i3ter. °S"h'e

?'iIé'%Efl$}'*8 is purchased in the 11$-igiaejef wifé of "?"h€:A

futrris ibr gurcizase is givgtn by c%:;§fifi,N£:,%.
Kaapéng ix}. vista: the pi" 'i.he £ath$r~é::~
iaw; it is prcsbabie fig pravideé 'i:=§;
'ihfif fa'{E1$r~i§1f1;3};§$:?4 of the §;e:n.§§€ at
§\£3;m"':ya 3;: 5% §'£co:1i{i be for the said

I'€t8_S€")§1 ._ h()i1E§¢;"~..§§;i'. §V1'E§.fif3;§fE~i was imp': out of pafiiiiezz

'£36–‘i. ‘*5.’«; §;2i:i*t Eémiiy px”0§t::°tjg. in ‘£115 C383 <::§:"

gmgscgtiy L.;3'£a11fi;§;::gV in $215 name 0%' 3. nzasia cowparcmiar,

§31*s?:&s{::"u§'i:£csfiu '§3'«?T_§}ifi{i arige ma: the: §_}rQ§3if'.f€'f,–' is fiafi jam? f'&?;fifi}*"

§:e}."r:;€,j§:'::f*:;y-, -siiowm £3131: {ha family haé sn§fiCi€11'i suzgtiaus

311$"-§:3.CQ:fi€_ff3:° iha yurchafie. Tixa zfizgusz. ":3 3:1 thc {fair-'§E£E"{'?fi1"£€:j{'

Er; :*eb11;tv..§':€ §§'€$E}I:E1§EE'iGIi that 313 §r0p€fi"j;: is §3':11fC}3.as€§. Egg

:*;i::Ta_ Egém his; persenai funés 311$ witheut 31¢ ait}. 9'? the }_'e3"i;:1*'£

M .V _.faiz1i§7{ fzmcis. 811%, in 37:31:: sass effemaie mfimbem, thaw is 11:}

VV prr:s11mp'z.':9n« The '§'::au:":i€:1 is absoiuic 3:": E3532 §}€I"§§O'i; aggmfizzg

m2§_

£31 '£16 wiiience he siatias that in ms yea}: E9?2 'z1€.V~za?;:§is».;a}gfi€i

abmrt TEG };'€é1I"S. 111 £336 fiepagitiozz Em givtés ':V1__if3"'!.3.;,<:;:.°':%:.A_Ta.:~; 333

jrtzars. if the daftf: mitzziziezitzzi in 1136: €Vifi€§f£{.'€I«_§f5C€::;;£Si3fi§:§5€«fL,

"tins 'gm piaiziijif mm be agea gméut

'§'heref0re, ii is axpiicit {mm téaflafiéifiziafi €313' {ha
suit is flied bayand t11t:.f3:::f§c::ci .6? '"§'}":é;'z."'a§ar'£, the
{rig} €031": has fztmnd frem the §3~;;=.,§;{%.s:V;:1<;'.t¢:é" $623 3 9f the E'

Scixeciuls I1€V€;1"'§3.S}"_t;311g::/if) $116 jo;i§':é_j§am:li:g' at any §;2iri.=:£: mi’

time. There:f$§é;~.3£1E1:é t:1§C”:’r:e:::§ filial Cicmrt iii favour {Ef ‘

p1aj11tiff§§’:1″‘€§.€S 8§}G3Z’§.€i:”§ as

{sf :%@f%,No.4 in the gariétiim are unjfisi 33:36: gr<:}3$§j«;

VV '"'i:iaq1:i:ai31ei ii: is argusd that {E6 mar?-:&t Valiifi Q? filfi §§{}3;_éS€i

at Jajgazlagar €31 Eazlgakre is much mare $33223 31% Ehe Sufi

CJ(%

-31″

p:°0ptf::”t:ii*s gut tfigathszz E1; may be £136.: iii} §’Ei’f;I¢’;’.””~;Tz’?;”i;”f$€i”.s.’?_A4

izzflafiaéxaiy Cafitfixtuai simaiiaan, bu? {ha _’:i.;:f’

;’m:>§t;<';;'%.*i5s ':0 §}§ij1}{1g€€§ wiii} I'€f€1'€11C§fi to _E;}i;<:*:_ s:i':;:Eé “i’;?§t”_.3″i”I}I;ii€3I’iL’%.:3″9′.’.v§’. §,’§:v:2£I::i€*§.ifs
in Szirangapama abutténg the E}i.:g;E:%x?a.y ifiégiiag
zmti a Wfirkialg Rice Q ififiéégflfis “i’§i:€
{§eft,.4 is givc-:11 a large ext€:1§i: §:>_f tile rises
mg} and 2:1 §*Gm the rice miéi
313% {ha :*:-‘:?f~A:>:”s;=,;:ia£i€mé, it Caflflfif 32:3
aaifl $133? ‘/:a’£éf”§:§é?iv§I1g?;i1{31″€:§ mad fizz”: i;a«::=a.:r2.t
maa aiéfifiéaxfir is gressijg §Z{}EE’3§l§

giisgazragiofiiggsgaia 9.116% i1;1§;c:’z§~~’%’higE1€r ii} vaizzé, The Vaczmi izarzii;

._wa§%_.’ ‘3;a::: __iATi;:::’:.V§}1»3z§9s3_:;;:ti:§.%_§¢;a$s€t’ at fhai amt: 01″ §E§x.P.i, “E316:

‘p:t}t£.13.€§:::?;v %:~:a;§’a:€%”vQf E316: rice mm émé “its iaigfame, ii}: px”3%:€::%iz–3£i.

véziubaf i”:i’£.V5&f,*.’g~.”£V§”‘.*:Zi-“;.zV€§11€IE'{S am} éis imtczms weuid fairéy glam}:

j i5é’§§f{i’ “:Z§j}”€5″ ?g’f3:£VE,fi: (sf $36 hmzse at Bangaiam 333:} 3 $33′; Ezwase in

.,:§?:£iL3;;ztii§1rE: éifiage in €216 jgsar §§’E’?;, ‘§’3::{=, daftsj aisfi 3E:$i)31S Sf

?*§0,}}W€%ra minars am {he ‘tima sf pafzitimiy it E3 319%

V’ ‘”léSt2:’:::ijS§.1&:”}; by de§’:$¥§’~E9.2 and 3 that the yafiiiicg; 9%’ ggrgyeafy

esgreséi is by timir fafiamr was unjust azzé gmsséfg i}’1€{;u.”:i’¥,8§fi}.€3

M33»

shegriaixag the (‘:€”)§’2SCi€}f3CfE <31' am}; réagonaiziiz E13831. §f£:::2*é:1js,~*'

httcatase in $116 p3'es::.:1t inflat;i»§:f:§

lizousa pre;}e3:”€.3r 21*’: Bangaifire hag i:1:::::€as6£§. E1″£11§iif€=x§{§”i$~~ E§.€}f 43:;

gffliiiiii itseif is g:{é:””m§’:: 1%-0p€::11?fig 0:” p;;;;’%a’ii{s::; ” » ._

F01′ ‘£336 1’e:as0;’1:=;; and; c%i$c:3$_si0:2AsT A E-kfiarié . ai.%*v:::%T .’

3{“t’§€C’€ tfsiét atazztazztiozx of {§€fi..?§a},_;2 aziiiv forT,ré:>u§ag€’:}§13g; {if
};}a!{«-fig-EEOIEG E-Eavezavar the QQCYQE gfafiieii by é§;3¢ Ti::§iaE ::<2u:*i in
faxmui' af ilzm plaintifl" in ifém 1.;, 2 a13€i–«§§V, }F.§§1e 'F' sc§'.1£::"E:,2E€ is

set. asifie. T213 B?€tS}3€Z.§'§v§.fi:%1.Vvfiiifiilfiéi' :?§{}'.V~"W0.f§{ mg: {ha

:*€:ned§§~61"'€c;%.é§;};%§13£%i§:,E2§§?:a'€;§::;;§=.%;tfi e§"1""'£§;é% §2r9p<%:"§§: §{§£"€L'§ifi§€€§ hf;
him £21 :5£:§','¥i'." The appeaifi art: _pa3"%3}=*
a}.E0w€:{i iizé 4V§AE:§i:ii1?%:1~)i'€5i a}3<;vé: a§::{"§ preiiinénazgy {§;::'c1':':{:

-‘ V. is }g:.§:’f¢af§f;?=;z ac;*s;V;.*’»:;>”35{‘1i,.¥}_,_;__}f%_{;*v.
Sdf–

Iudge

Sd/~
Iudge


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

103 queries in 0.210 seconds.