Suresh S/O Yerrappa Reddy vs Appareddy S/O Nanjappa … on 24 May, 2011

[\)

GUDIBANDE TALUK.

(BY SR1 B.A.RAMA KRISHNA, Am'. $0.22   ..  
R1 AND R3 SERVED) <    *

     V'

THIS MFA IS FILEDVSLJESEBSER .SEC'TIA:C)3$IVV"~-1 '?"S'(2} 011*"

MV ACT AGAINST THE JUDQ_ME:N'r ._AND jg AWARD
DATED 15.01.2005 PA.SSED"'H'~?_:E.!T¥'€: NO.9';'~i}8' GN THE
FILE OF THE cmx; _J'F_JI)iQ.E§'*--.._'{SRDB3.) & JMFC,
CHINTAMANL PARTLYQ A.LL'oW1N€g'" =__THE CLAIM
PETITION FOR 'fii1§enSati0n awarded by the

Tri.b§:§f;a£. The petition was lodged before thé

 CE:if1'Ei:'amani in MVC N03/1998 on account of

t3hé._inju:*i€.S Sfi::'Stained by him in 3. road traffic: accident

0c€i':;1.rr:+:é:§ Cf} 28.09.2992'. 'Shae Ciaimant was 3. Studsni,

  aged S'L--Sut 13 years on the dais of time accident. In the

" ~..aTa:s:%i_é£ent, he Suséainéé Sumrsd iacerated weuneti an the

  iéft Side 95 Shim CQEEEESTEQH Sf 'aha Esfi mzmillarjg regiem

fizzzééigéss gf:;braSiSnS Sf E:e:}:§3 K3333, E6 'W213 Er: {E39 fnesgiial
fa)? Eér'iz :::S:s:ii}%::%-3 §r:>::2 283* SSp%;S::*:%:>€:z; 399?. 319 has





taken treatment at Gavernmant Hospital,  V' 

Devaraj Urs Medica} College Hz).-s'§i:a}'.. "

Hospital? Bangalore and also   

Bangalare. He underwént :}.f_:f::_e mags: s1;rg;ei*i;e"s;~V~:»§hich"' V

resuited in shortening (sf  0f. his,_Aie£fE leg. On
account of the   he lost sense
of his left handmfxd   continuous
suffering     The Tribunal
has awarciegj    under the heaci loss
of   medical expenses,
Rs.64s,!.~" t.ox%xra£{;i;=§.':_:t;9a:§§11%:f1g expenses and Rs.63,000/-

toxazards fiiturew}¢e_sS~«,_ef~~--é§a.rning. Thus, in all a sum of

  ~ \$fi'th- .... érzterest was awarded Being not

 ' :§:iti~sfi§:.;:'x:;j:}§'the same, the present appeal is fiied.

  ' 2 Or: an €3.I'H€I' occasieng 3 Cowordinate Bench,

 €}ff,hizS'x.':EG1lI'fZ aftar hearing the parties, considering the

 --.3Z._f;§»L2.fies sustainad and disability suffersé by the

  ..._<:§a§ma:*:{ rsferrzsd 1:115 agpfiliantferriaémani is the

E~--§§Iv§H3%NS E--§z;:s;p31:aL Bangalere fgy meéiga} évaiugzieig af
fie disaéfiéfajgz. G133 §?13§1$.}T}§§T£j3}?'3 E, 31:35:, Aggaciais

§:*9fe$;s$r ef %f*Je:;::'<::$:::*ge:*y§ afisr éxamimiziig tins agpeiiani





has isssued a Certificate stating that he is ST.',l'ff€?f'}:::1"VV1"'g";_:"fi~"f3T.I"}.7,.'N'

100% cognitive deficit. Neizrologieaily,jihei" V

speech difficulty idysarthria} amide 

of the left upper and  ._\&'i'€'fViiV".C€ihffE(Cf:uf€S 'i

(Power Grade - G/5}. ,--i:}ue ieefl-'.e'--2iibi3_ve  he is of
the opinion that the Cii;<}Q_'L:)iii"1Z'i.,€3:*'3'::é31i'_€_¢}iit'3iTifi3,H€I1t in nature
and he has alsev-.sta'é;:ed:ii"i:at._3iieast 8'3}85% has to be

taken as; '*~.p_e%ifrfia11Ve'nt disability. This

certificzawe iSi'3jL1€d: 31:33,: iii'-1jn--.on '2'3';{}$i.201 1.

3."   ,.i:i'*i--i,§'Jfibackground, we have to

asce;1*t"a.i.n Whetiief the eompensatien awarded by the

 and proper and does it call for any

L" e::i1faunC'e%11,eIifi? 

 'Since the accident is not in dispute, the iiabiiiiiy

eiis :3;i's;e iiei in dispute, what has to be considered in this

 aijgxpeai ie 0:11}; with regard to the quantum cf

CO[§i§€I1SaiiGii awardeci by the ri'I"ibL§.I1§:'Li, fiidmitieciljyz the
eiaimani. wag aged abenui: i3 yeare arizé wag a eiuderii.
{Ea Bifféiiilifii, {ii the fiisaiiiiiiiiee {?é'iLEE§€'d ix) izimi iie ieeii hie

fi§§i,ii'£y 3.3 he haze: is éepeiifi er: eeri'«_tEe_2{teei  f:?E.:€:}?:

Government Heepita}. But w=efé:;e;1ne't :g:33re.;the e'f:ieunt V'

spent by his parents for   Be1?1'gva3;e1'§e, K0131",
Chinthamani and alse'  for their stay
in different pleeee fo:1_* 'e  eexeeordinglyg We
award a   head medical
expenseee   Vto award a sum of
 Hehigh bone and towards
3.ttende:1.§4'ehargeVe: ae_4"h.;.e"'£e depending upon others for

his :;iay;i;o--da3r'eetivifies. We are also inclined to award a

.  s1:L'rn{.0§"eR.s'Q':?.5,OO()}7'§"fowards future medical expenses as

    take constant medical treatment and

ia'3;ii1g V.  eeneideretion that even theugh the

 freatriieei: in the Government Hospital is free he Weuld

 spent serne amour}: teveareie travelling expenses.

Efhue £13 eii, the eieément fie entitled fee 2: sum ef

 ea meg» iéeeei  €ee%:% eééefee eee §3~»§~:%]

Reeéf' ffiéfil,/~ with ieiereei at 8% pa.
5:?"



5. in the result the appeal is 

The Compensation awarded by the.T '   V' 
5ee;V'§f%:%2:e*:es%£§£ '*'E*<%?
enhanced from Rs.80,200/~ Ste   '"xR;--ViE¥':A {§Q"?"'~

'~  1:; £1 5  5 'V: ' 
n "  Ci  if]

interest at 8% pas from I:he_dai:e  jl::ietiti0n»'Vt;i'£I: péiymemi.' 

Out of the e0m1gensat§Q¥iV;A' of. with
propertionate intereef' deposited in the
name of the appe11aI;t"*fer::;1  years initially
and   five years. He is

entitled fie {i1j3'Ca§«:}5_h€ in"*;efeSt.,_:::T rest of the amount be

releasecl te: ['f:'1*:t;. a'p;:1e£i-:/;i1$_'/ elai-rnani.

 .....  

Seifé
ELEGE

_ ‘ ea