High Court Karnataka High Court

Syed Md Hussaini @ Khursid … vs Md Rashid Ahmed on 5 November, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Syed Md Hussaini @ Khursid … vs Md Rashid Ahmed on 5 November, 2008
Author: Jawad Rahim


E55 ‘7-‘§E %’§ICvH CGL3 T Q? §(fxR;F~iA”{AK;’~’a_
CIRCUIT $ENCH AT GULBARGA

BATE!) THIS T¥-£E 5″” mm 0:: NQVEMBER 2::2_0_’ -sf

§E_FORE

“ma 5-:csss’a;ErvsR.§3L:s’:*:x:§’§é2:iim;2Aa%;éi_’%}% %

iv} F A, 4339 j;*;gQ5%m%:3%

EETv’ir’EEf’5:

31}

W}
s,.,,..a

saraa ?v?;’7}YHU$Sz?\I§%3.Z~~..’_ % ~
$”:’ED azséuasxcs E’-§ii$’§.-‘-‘ie.iE*é1I ;
Sffiififvémbiii HUSSAIEE
as aw.) C§~¥A.*~iBFfi.:%3§’+§”§–2L1’3SAI?«£I ; 2 *
Aaga 62

gaaw “53ALf§_Si- .::f¢:.:§-:emA§:
AEEL1’.-‘S,2 “:’EAE.$,. %
musk§a::»m:%

:§»ia’;E£>fi a:;;g:§g:¥asm as 3:25:

~ :~;;.:a;*s%_}.¢.:’s’E:_*: :a:ans;:-§%:.;$3:.,a..1.r~;z

._m-I

:=~..Gja§ zzygaas

k«%T%sAR?»;£aa; 1&5-i’§ii§¥?

1 ::>;:& s’a*’:~::_.r:s 5’£’~¥;E3.i-§i.f;’*1~’$fis.’iif*~§I

Am; 52> “z’EA&$

_ g§r:;:–{:3 335:-gm %r::;s3Azrx:1
‘Eff? EYEE ?*’§§}.HUS5FiI?\¥I,

‘ *»–,%GEs?2 2a ‘ffififis

(av ggvzmmafizvi mas:-s5*:*r*~.«; ma ;;

§i_’;L REG Affiffiififiifi VELLAQE
‘a’AE..§.5E-<1 & $131'. BIDAR
._ ޣ5"FELLA?iTS

E

ix.)

Aféfi:

1} fi»*’i§,R,i-‘s$¥~§I§ 13¢-if-“iE£.)
S/’Q S§–i.fi-Iii; MB.

MAJQR, §iiS1i’\§E§5
R.,fC?: H,3-3- 1?; fi_R_’r”.AN.3iGfi\R
Zfizifiéfiéfi (11,?)

2;» ‘ma a:xs:s:=a:~.:A; £v¥AfxiA§E§-ii
L:rmE£: :;-:t>z,:=.. msumxsce V
GUL,§AR(5?s.

– “‘3’3-4.§S?rt§Z>’5’§f§i&’f?w’:;§’S

§”3:F,f5t;, IS FELES 2:15 39(2):.e:=-V:;si;c:;x::frk,;a=:;A:ssssT mg
JLSBGMESHT mas AWARE3-ATE-353-.A2é.2′;2i3€”§§§$*«”?fi$SED Efxi
W{ZA,£R~3é;’2GQ3_..::’§g§ %”§-EE mtg €::;?~.’?§T;¥§§E *=::::;;v*zrv1:<s,s:o;*~:§a
FER *=.r'sf=f;'5¥~"?.§<:"~#'iE§*~§f_S:–.,Vi:i5;;f-?'fiE'E?~ii§fiC§Tm?~§, B§DAR';""ALLG*»A'ING 'me
CLAEM ?£'E'iTE'Qfé»."*–.Ff:éR;.__ 'i"g?v';'?*E.Eé'SfiTIQ?9' Aféi) s§E%r*i;?i’~:s;=;’i’:%=:%»:*+s.

This agpeai iérziirzg ‘Ci*??’5;éf’«.}’.§V§ffiiSS§Q¥1 this éay, the Cami

:ie§§ve2*&e;i’ ‘:I§’S& f€:»i§cw§f2’g”

-il

“.fiE’a’§?’nva’r:%:5g;_ 1:-Lfé in agzpeai against the arder ::3a3$$§ by

“~..___t§ég mr%::’ni:”s;§§§ne:” far \f¥’D¥’§€Tr”I””!&L¥”I’$ C§¥'{‘f§&€’3$ati§fi, Eidar, an

‘* 4’__;:éé_:2A;V2G§A5 wgasaa-gézzaas, awaréirzg Cémfiefifiaiibfi {hf

:3;”-, diggatisfiéé with the award’

31/
e] A

\

W

2; Heard the iaameé cazzrssai fgr the api;:re%§a:rst arzé the
iaamefi cctmseé, 3:’? Naciagmsda win: hag Eifsiafaré

amearance fair féfifiéfifiéili E19,; iirggurar),

3, A pefusai cf the ireccrrég F&’xiE§?VS thafi’t’§*:§fa.g:§éiiaA::i;su

herein tiaimigryg is m Eggai hairs (:fV=»,Qne_-~;’?’~§ve§’=.4′-‘i»;$ii;a~::i”i’:§§.g&3z:?

Ciaim Liflééf ‘xi’s;’§ri<men's i:§r:_:§e:n?$;s:Eér; ;é;£:'s*:._jv…s_Vae§a:Er2a§

campefisaiien regarding death §'a§§';a:?d '%?: Fa !T!§t!3¥'

Wu

'x:efr"2i:§e agtciéiéerst an 2§,:;.?_:

€:uTg2 fat 1; They avérraé

he was emp§e§;a;i_ as ;aVw.r..i.;rV's%ze?r.Aa:§;""thé"'~ .'i" respendent»

:'vL§.,Ahn*':e::i__ta?'§:§;*§:i.§VSgt???"-igearifsfi MSEAP-19-33244? 91:'; 3

méfiifiiy 5'a§.;a: "y'. :12?' 'Vfr's';C$;«f§','=:';_a4:;ii;':.-$4' wéih :'«%.s,5£':;'- par' day 33

':=ata'4;§':":§_ha §¥g–';:_$ ':$f.i éfivfina Lméer the insirzgctiens cf the

ifggzxgréé' Sinca ha died éurirzg parfarrnaficé Qf big

§'r,.:¥{E§Ef§_, 'iz r:é3v*«._::_iai.§V:::-,%d :.;'§rn§er2$at.§<3rz assmfzssr the W',C, Act,

72;. 5fhJét_cia§m was resisted by the insurer, but the 1*

I »i=?}as §:L:rf::r§eni-ezyggzer-§ra§:.;:'ac5 did fiat éifipigie the iiaiffi 3? the

'~-_1__"7::§a'§-margts that Syeé Ashad wag émgiayefi ta érive the

""'Vx;$%*:ic%e in Questian and tha: he éieé in the acgiafarst an

2§gZ2Cs£}2, ma Cammisgicreer, weighérzg tha Céhiafiiiéflfi in

ii
§€§¥&$"7¥?f:'§&I¥'3§ in 5:3 rsaiifiaaiisn is the right cceigrse f::2r tie

CQTr'f1;?.I'§§S§§§;f§&f' {Q award ::r3rr:§e:"2,~:sa:§§s:':¢

3% ":'"?:e answer', afivigzssiy, $3 Sr: tha :r:eia§§:«'eff@.f"–«.%:§':$

fgiéawing ?E:&$i3T!}$§

e in case sf ftai a:+::§"ef:'1ts pa»rt§.tgia:%§y §; ff'§:1f2p'i'a:«.'g,§é}é_e;§s…

engaged :2': érivirzg 'v'eh§:¥e;=§, :§:&é'e a%s:a:%:§:¢:g%

€:§'\i'&L!'§§iI§' gimvviéeaf Vggrgfier ':3_Q€i'i§fi érf ftiéa

;'v'::sj',A::¢ 'five C§§§§??3!'?'if§ :§i;I§§,§ ham.:f;'aé:s:§iV§':?:"éVVéiti§er
:9 seek €;§'¥"f'!§EfI'§.S:§tié¥'§:.m'¥§éf 's'§§,C. FiC"tv..€3f.?34'§,\i,;9£Ci:
if it is mafia? SE£?§i'§_?§ '.1§§, than awaré raf

Carnpafisaiien 1'13; irzz, '§;E..¥S–"'£7"~'-.Vé$:_'§:.§?V§S§fiE§ under

kv:fe':::m%§§i:% ':fhe '_"Vi:i'évim is asnfier i!'v;',€.Z,AC?:,
be wimz ting arnirii :23' the
';3%:3xé4§sié;"r§s=. 1&5 *«;'~;§";"{:". ;":£.:'i and jéi: that ::a$& wig

A _ .,R,s;4L§Q §i.»..§:a$ 'i:éEa taken ag minimum gaiary 322$
§3;. $';a,:s ':':§""T:sr:*——–é'ai&:rr:":§;1ezj as': the $3533 4:? wages

a{::::.;:a«.§:§3»r'. paifi is the emgiayaeg

<3, "'§€f.ee§%%§'§_t§:éase if': mifié, we have is rzéw sea the affact

_ ':3? the gmiéficaiién sgggifyifig 'mirsifrmsm zzssagegg' The very

: ' §§zai the Eayerrzment hag isgggsg' tits 32::-:§;f§::§t:§r2

____"%:§iV%f<yi::§ méfiimgm sagagefi gayafgie is fiifferent aaiéggrfias sf

V¥.é3Q§'§{mEfi, Sffiéw that it ig éeraa with iiza Efiififiiiéfi that m

fiyflw
if

.~f4:s.:<
.- MI:

4″

{I}

warkman giiaii be 9323? 5335 than the amaant méniiimeé 5?”;

the ngtéfiiaiiaa, §’*é§ where tie Féiiiifééaiififi §as::§ara~;”‘«–t;:3§:

‘szssageg s§§§%.2§3Ee§ i”‘.é*!’E§;f’% giaaié 53 ammani ta b;Va.._fi4g”:s.i§f:=*:%é”V;.a’sV.

6.1: ;-_

Eimiéiffza, gvhai ii

geiifiées :5 E31

iifie
fir

J

I

t it Sinai: be ti:-é; mV§T;2:mus..T V

wggé beg: Qfi gxirwf that ihé s;*i::arr:’J§%é}T:é:i’§?:€’s§::”r’;.(,a _i’f2:2!_M& i:§”i3Tf’1V”.

l<""§?"

1

.523.

11:33′

ifs, Er: the irsgiant case, iifig ma:-*i*s:«.§_§s:é’;-fife iha5i’:iz”2afa<::i§e::*:;:

5:135 I3t:Ci££fF&§ in ifié y'é2i1r'_ ' '

prsfessiémfaijv fi;.frf¥'2:e£°é::*s%§§'<;:ys<:§ §'§f"'i'§"§é §?3$TL§!'"&£1i in drive the

Qec:-23$ 's!é'§'_£§£f§!;§, ' §e§§%.si'V'é:?2,:§r":féis.s.."§:'s:;.::Eé 5:9: have been $233 that:

Q?)
M1
5723
. ‘E33

…,. ‘.

it: ,s’- -3′: %s::v;§’aa’:’i$v;:>~~’Ltr: be §<n:-2;: in mind ihat a$ eariy

ir:._':5§~?s§:?LA4€v$;, i?1é'&;'I3£§X«'C§?£.§fi whiie iayiag agisfeiirtes Sr; that

:'e'§a fé,._§§3$~a§*~a&§–._i?;ai mifiimflm wages fir?' igmsiééiieé fiafséigr

ccs_:'§d'bé takég 5;: R_S,:£}G;'- tfiséir" flay aim' far giééiieé Eabmjr it

_ gar: Elé ;%i:r{::<2rf_e; finécafateéiy ifié victim wiyzgié fast haxié hazi

29

I flé§’%*’.§!f3§i{‘¥§ cf Eégs ihaéfg Rs.,§,£}s§€fr;- gm, $3525; in zfsfiz,

V.___”‘*:”?:é§e%’§r&, the :§3§r;é; 3:?’ the giairnagtis that ha wag gaisf

‘”*&S=.3,§:3Q;’- §,f?’;L is Eeiievrabie arm? wigs: the £:<i*fii§"§§'§!' és

a

313/

i

hat, i"e;re Egg rm Dféfiibiiiéfi is iéiéc-2 ihat §:*:z::;:_;r;*1'o3 'aS'=,f§2.é"

8

|

§é,:2Q;’- with Ersieiregt at 12% gag ag awarééé ‘