High Court Karnataka High Court

T M Chacko S/O Late T C Markose vs The State Of Karnataka Rep By Its … on 18 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
T M Chacko S/O Late T C Markose vs The State Of Karnataka Rep By Its … on 18 June, 2009
Author: K.L.Manjunath And C.R.Kumaraswamy


am: *5;-$5 Hzaeé caasm GF K.&R?\iA.Tfi.§<§ M sm~:@§gL<;§L[§ %%%;;

§z3;"§'EQ ':':—€23 "'§:~»§§ :8?" Em Q? .E£3§"»éE If %

?RESEN'?'

"E"?-QE HS§s§'"B£..E EVER, .;msTz€§~.§<.L.'%«:§:::3:3:~.:;a$":%:§% _ %

Am
ms t-€Qi\%"Bé.E gag msnca €;¢%$<»..a:i;aéA9\g&$:2vA;»§?

war? pE?:"'m:a; ms::%k3:::2;:2§::é'%§L:§r%é;RE$~»§:a::

83ET'V%'EE§'é:

T.§”1§. C§”§,&C§<Q; _ _ » < V

figaéé 333:3: ,:3§§—E3i}§?&§'$i"1.;::;:A. ~ "

3&3 Late mg §*=2'?;ai:'%"<;l$,$a;t,;?w.V ¢ _ _ –

Eicraaka %~iaé,s~$a; mms;;%g%v;J::gg;g§ '

gfiuttzér '§'a%:..gi::[i> , ‘PET’.”£.”F1 0M E R

{fig Sr? E%§§;:$¥’ s<r§s:mkk;Bfia:%% Aém
~ …..

2. “§2:§:»eLgage%§:§§%<:~:%n§za:<a
Reg; by its ;$'a«'::%<*é:%ary§

?§%Ef&?§i:;%% ;i§ag;v3"r%méfit,

?\s*'E–:.é%2a;":a'§§:;;d§1;a§
. ' %§a;:%§a..§4_§2"e%2£

Cansewatar cf Farégis,

'j v:'%é'é_&ir:°:'ga%e:*a Ssvigémg
'*%;<.ama'z§§<§ Fares: fix?-;§3:§'m':e§':tF

VA '?*~*2§r§gg§§re§ $3;

3, ‘§”?2e Asgisézafit Cmgewatcr
9% $c’:rests;

Suéya “¥”a§L§k,
BK, §§st:r§ct*

6+; fie Range ?:$¥’&$t Qffécer,
Szmramanya Range;

§a,sEya Taiuki SK. §§3’E?’§£’?:.

5, Mr, Beizrzy Abraham

§;”& fisvéfaééa Abraham;

Karéyar Haugag $93132,

Nakkéiaéy véiiageg

Mgaréaéa past, u ” ”

Putité?’ Taiuk, SK. Sésts §’;–ff5′:.E;’:”;.”§-.??Q§’~«é§§§”€’7€’§

{By smz. ;%a~fV:§§*2$Véiis%%:asf§§;é4;*.é:gV’é%_’;£3?_–$5? R: Ea M;
5%’? §<,§'–'§V;'-._§'x3§a'§{§£"»3_;'§;' Vjf'£s§'__ 91$}

"?;"":§§ %'%3?§:i-Raéiiiéisfz :%sk%J:%§fe*a=%k%':g%::aar §z?§§€§§S 22% 3:25 22? Q?
ihé CQ§'§§?;";§ii£'{_§§F§u§fv§§":§.'§'a §-rafiéérzg Ea fires: ma resgaadefizs 2
££f%éfi'*v3:a:i é{';i:,.p:§Qa§§'; t%::e§l£:::*%§$§a%§:% 32.23523:-;:e§ $3; ma §§'€§%:§€En§€'
as »;§'&r j;3%;?':A§'§v$$':;;§'€é{'§5:—-. afié ::*e§t:*a%r: the rasgmaéent fmm

§%§"°s'§:§§"%'f?%§"–%i§;'}v§?§ .'§3.§ €;é§£§'§=:'§C§°"§ aggaié 3:23; §e:;%:%§{"2 :3?' $332 iarzé in

'v: §?g_; ?%§@§i'T?6§v–..':%{§§€1a§?§<a $§ §a§:?3§:3:" a.«*§§§a§a, $3223: {aim ma

"'§';='4:4§"";-:?§:";;f-=a§§§§ §%'23.:i '?@t%3er' éagfi atiém in that §%ga:é§

-_”‘-‘??’V§’:*§%”,.»::s”%;;s:”%: Qfiiiiififz agming fag fa: §%’€§§§’;”%§§§8:””‘g’ ?’:€§§”§§'””:§

%’§f;é$_§;§’y; ENE? §*é%?€3§§¥$:”§”%%; 3,; mggeé we f§§.%§wé?:§.

3i.}§G§V§EF\§”§’

The grievance :3? {ha Qetitianer fiefasre ifzia c§;g:*%i:’§’3§’ %;.§f§1a.f:

ag gar fi%§”:§’°i$§=:i§é””£-E éazaé 1§;§3»2.,2@’a.§8§ he ?’:af’%.:a_1:’§:::sjg’;:¥i§:§eé%i ”

fifiififiiaéfif fiefare $39 afiwuéy Ca:géé§é’?’vs:<;ar -;é§ "'4V%*"f'é:f°.:%§*'*§§%:§€,',".

?\'§3f'3§a§fl§'"E Sévégisrz gtaiifig tiéat we B¥&':f'§%é§€ ,&§r§§{%:'%_a§*":*: ;é%:::§%;:%$"–..L

bE'Q€§":§z" Ease e'2.§ra%°:am am ;"?:a§;§:éV§.._.a:: ;§:%;¥cE§°:f2;$"2:–V%:§ 'e;*::§aa£%'2

ifze §§§"&S'a: éafié ta an ex:é§'t.. %§.'_x1§ §;iT.{'%§'=§E'? S35 ?§3§fi:§,";?§ sf

Kasaaaa sf fiéifissr fg;%§%ag§_…a:§:SV a%sgg%i%k;gea tfi feéé me

trees $523 éfgaé:4'e3:?%:§%~..L§§»séa.$§r%*§:§ar attamgi: was; mafia by

zfiam :32 €§E£¥$é{?§§ =:?:Vé-fé:?;g§;.'~~'éa:':§ Eitiézfiiéfi in 3?. §%§@,:§2 3?

?s§&::%<s§&:jL§'3%j§i§.§A§g§ $5 %;aE:.,z»%<L:?§~E flag :33: Saar:

":::;::s;:§_€2§as*e& by me Saaagiag fimsgrvaisr Q? §~'a:"@3:s,.

'–«. €'?"§'€§?'§§3§§?*'%§ Em preséééi wféi ifiéiiiififé £3 féééfi,

{M

{2} The §$§§"f'§é§ fimzermment fiéxzacaza

gurguamt E23 finnexuremi, zine ?ar§$i §$§&§"{CE'"§"'¥€f?Z'%.§Ei.: "<§f§–;:'¥;';'f ig}{§;*:%e;a¥§3; '

ififiiééé zmtécg :9 {ha §€'{%E%Q:"38%" 3,5 :.'*3'€i$fiE§ ~, §.:$

§'é§§§€%§E§":'? ta gméagaa {fig reiévagfét résaféfig. "%*1T§*:"?r..%;'s':**<ég'$§:"é:';§i%.:¥%:.:'%s

€Gf'§§§?3éS tfiai the wrific fiétiiififi %'%§'s_§&c§§*":f:§"érzf§:u§tu§u$
sirzte aatéan is aireafiig V§'§'}éi§§'E%§fi{_'§'$.'g*'*-if:$_§§;;.""}§%""§§'%'"i%f3i in

a:§§:éa§::e._és¥é:?§ 3:."%%*se %':::;if%;%:e:* Swméts §é""'%§*; ;§;=z;s°"$%..§a:°:t is
the raiaépi §%.::§'%e r;:,:%:%§'éf§§§uéz;3"'§§:r $29 Q§§i§E'y' C§§"2$§€'%£§§£§§"

Q'? %re§;t§§§" §¥%a§2§a"§€.:_§%é§,' ':?ée §&?.§§§§§'§€f' as a-253:? as ifié féffié

§"§§§<'§§%::';§.€

:2:_é3§::.%?s;"gartéaéggzgg 3:2 {gag §:%'§"§§%$§§:"'§§§,
':EA::j:"¥g'é§~;aé:AVJ._;;::;j:' tfié §i.,§§§'%"§é§§§Q§'2§ Q?' iiéé $é'*2ié?'§"§?'?"§é§'£i

T'v.:AA"",5é;;:i:;;2::§:~e3; a%;%~§:f:;% 3;F {S33 agénéasz that ifiaaa £5 52:': :":@£a§$§§:3;

a;:%%;:. %%§§&f m iéée §Z}?%§§§§i3'_§'E§'§" £33 233% raéiesg gaémghi E32;

"«_V"':"?é§._'§:§':§:§s;§::§:* §":§§ §e£§:":*:e éféfmfiiazasgg éaga ia sa§$Q§:::§:"s'%:

Triégkavéajggmgréia Eéraaiifigi %:?§& fiégfiiéty i:§f§$%£""=.:'Ei:t3§" if

W.

?g.:”es:$; Evéamgaéara is axgefiéta the anggérg sggéé

aiézém $2′: §:m§=§a:’:£e zggiifz éaw, 23:3′

§§S;€3§§$§ 5%. -. 1
Tucige

” ‘ ‘– » H

$33-