Loading...

The Asst Executive Engineer … vs Rajendragouda Shidagouda Patil on 29 May, 2008

Karnataka High Court
The Asst Executive Engineer … vs Rajendragouda Shidagouda Patil on 29 May, 2008
Author: Anand Byrareddy
.,..n....  ...,...g _.uV_'r mmmnm mun COURT or KARNATAKA men COURT or KARNATAKA HEGI-E comer or KARNATAKA HIGH coum

EN :35 31%;: mum' GE' mmamxa ATBA?§"~E§ALORE
mam $2113 'I'I-IE 29?" ms? 01? MA§'~'~'-- f" 

wag 1~m:~rBL2 MR. msnzéfiaflgzm 
z»gzs¢£;LLA.NEaUs m=k=;1:_g;%i9g

Bfigfifi;

Exmmém:   _ '  
Pukhe '*e¥'s:§rks«EJ'c';.*mb;m     
Hultkwti-»Ssw':fkzs£§i $v;§m*R€;~ac§.1V  1;
I-Izzlstkaeri-é.S£3I_',§4f.§VQ§'V       T  

2.E'fE£e§ii1e;*&?¢$:',  .4 
Healih     
'§3~'e%fm=,Ser*éi::3s,'  V'   "
Anmda%:$VCirc1e¢_  " 
Bgsagagxm-55$ 589. V'

     
" ._ '§¢iVaI-k§ma§Ei§.:;Extmu&n,
gesgassgng-gsreaa  APPELLANTS

 AA  Gmrmunem Advocate)

  zggmmaw

Shimmzxia Pm
Ag: 25 yams,
fitauwfin Buskzess,
Residenz af Emmi,



LUUK! Ur KAi{NAIAKA HIGH COURT-'OF KARNATAKA HSGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COUR1

ram E-Iukkaeri,
aims: Begm-599 on 3..

2*fih E§$? ,

agn  Gwfifivcr,

imp Ecs.,£3:'kG 2325,   

?ubI1's Warm E  

B§5'G5&€§3 .    V' 

{By   
Shri m.x,r~:am§, Ad*s?z~:1zma.fnz* *  O A 
Rc  1:31:11,  

fig ;§g!%§.s?g,x:flm5f2~we:2s is filed ands: Scriéon
1';*3:1} r;§§"§'§§__ imior .'.¥;Itic,1cs:' ;%gctV% aguhst am judganmt and
amd &§§d*i;"33t%_.Vl§;2i%€4';i_&éa§%"eé mms'c.Ne.15osi1992 on the m:
af t§1a%*=i7ii'§i§ Efiégfi (:3¢e1:i<:::'1";'5i*w:*i££139;1) BM» Mexnber Adfifiotnal
Maia: _ .&¢¢§:;éa3fi§  j Tribmial Hukkafi awfikng
cogzgsmésmfiafi. a2:é'«I£.,€,2,L§'i;--Q§§f~ mad ac.

 O  gsgéggaa  an far hming mg day, 1:11: cam

 A  fc3ait.*mg:-

JUDGMENT

Cmzztsel far the pmies.

.. 2: O. “V–‘$’§§efactsm:aerelemt fcextlzedismalefthe appealm:
O figflzwcandmztwwhitbyajeepbclengingmthsfirgmd
“jfifigspallmzsmzdirrmzredbythetiajxdwpeflmtandwarasult

affim %£, 11:: E133 suffmtd acvm injizriafi including 1133:! injnfiz.-s

m:énfi[email protected]flc£w}échmhfiwmh andtretted

%

mm 3 §:§m§§é cf’ fime. , £11: zespondemt hearing rfised a

cisim fzraempvznsafim fizz mam»: Axmdmnis

Rs.5fi,§£%f;’zf« tawawis pm Md ‘i5’2.s;:1.,3S;G*€3fi}v1€¥

3935 sf € cmity;’-,
R$g”?,§{%%E[a’« ircfwards Syeciai Bimd wandwrt
cizmw mad ?:?;ceacr.. It is this which is

3; ii $3 the year 1992 and
the ma the award of Rs.5£},000f-

maemés 91” even cvidcztwc tee
ample or gricvaus in name,
as fife: ‘En’hm1aI itself mum in an abmzy

%}m g.W;;wa 3$*v=§f&} “Fm finding arzfthe Téhmal am the ingam

‘ “4”_1;é9éfe.Vg:’ris2*;ra:;-;u:s.. md 12: had uxzdezgme fafiaw tq: maxim:

“ems is mt weé an my acseptabla ma!’

hm faflcd he axmmze the damn we had

trcatefi mu. am he had gamma tha acmdent” . Th:

……….. .,.- M..m…w. nlurl \…uuKf,.u_I- mmnmm Hum COURT or KARNATAKA E-HG!-I COURT os KARNATAKA Has:-I COURT 0:: KARNATAKA I-HG!-I coum

o§%zxé5m§§§12zm:?sh&bymed0c16I$w}w!mdexm1ined1&nua

Q

COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT-‘OZ? KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COUR1

later @335 aé’ fin: Wmalé 119% O 111: me he had

me pan mad s1zfi’eri% m 3 rain}: and

ziéwcfszsm ‘ch: man: is axe-rhifiatzt ad

dawn.

Egzmfm as the ma of is the

T _ mnaunrs in
cczrgatéggg ihg :1}? The Tribunal hm
:R$.4S,9BOf- in wplyring the
Wfi wable sf earning
disabifity he was enlitled ts
R§.§g3S:i:h%E%35§_ em-1y mm: and there was an

V’ _ A gush mounts whm fix: elahzwtt 21% not in
such. 19% mé am being no evidence of
_ hamg able ta cmy can my avccaieai thm he; Wm

A’ agam in, 22:: Efihimal was mcjmfiw in dating 50, mam,
ammats mm. have bean wmfind we we 3 mlicwlmt.

In aha, 22:: Tsabumz having wwwéezi Rs.1,3S,0{tG!- tewmds mm

af cwaafiy’, has [email protected]ficat.nd {has 33:22.: by mdhg

5

Ra.4§,§§§€» mwmfis 19$ 03′ anaexfies and t31e.Ief<:re,.–the award

will h$2?e:£fi'w3c:§w5fie:<::thaamm:t,.

4, Fa':-it camm flue cmsel for

95 paéxzéw en: by the c£su:1se§;f;;c
the 3m gm mfl thcxgh which
mfiulimi in #094: as eaztifiad
by we ya :0 see the fruits
aim hem deprived of any
wntmtziern thfi the accidem
the claixnmt was 110$ miitled to 3

lug: afag.3aaeas;%mwaas pm and sum-mg mam ha

afk mu arm mum is mkcn ma bemg

rm mm sftims «ma still enable the

O %c2a3m,g::aC:2§sme:hesa&dmaamaasan am anammeiomam

C C' 'fE.§[email protected],Q&§!- tmsrwds pan mid sfifcxm can awoum. 0f the

hm sufrma is m axstbitmi err abihwy wad do-as

uuux: ur :\AxNA:A1\A I-nun Luna; 0,?' KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HEGI-I COURT OF KARNATAKA HEGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT

Ivmf%as§I2gf:.1£urc'ioie$af:w11jngi&' issancmzcd,
flaeiugwéiasmdthedisahifiiy mares}. The disadvfiethsthw

Z

hwfi fig: céfimm is hardly cagaabie sf M113 in

tm& afmimfiy hm his 3:: fa;-wax: zzrfarry 'I'M

pmmds tn uongrme the smnmmfi ._

scale by zeczzsmw its the

erg: 311$ gmumi aha the e1m'I:;+an$_.I1a$ 161%.

is may mm mé mgusz. mg R applyim the

gmzhatad $911110: be held to be

The does net wmant

COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COUR_T’O_;F KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HEGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT

Ingrtsfa EdS’.’ti’i:’_ laaRss7G”e£% being awed to be a
d®§-caisazegi Qf ilfilafi Gay is also met tcnzblc.
T;-£5 Q many which thn claimant has ta

flés is @331 harm the fame low of

Zifiiiisch is distinct firm the hm sf compettxsatism

R of €$. {.3131 the anther hand, the sum
1992 {sf xiiflm is 3 may: amcnmi and would

A % M amhmea though flm siaaxm hm rm filed 3. mm

an tfimig zngmfi mfi uamfm, vmuid submit flea the wpcal

does 3% wmma :e.

Q

St i:%:2 a ciese c:s:§.aidm’fii<3sn 9f the mania! available as

xgaaafzi, 32¢ name: be mi ihfi :1-1:: infmica

'W'fi'£ mg maéfiisimzi as 131$ they w-are net :31' 35'

Ema ms' 12.s,§i3,§G&!~ wads mzgégaagemg tOsOO O

be an :33: higher side md
fax the :e$p0n§e:1t,, when gs" £992 md me
mm $2 3% 42:3 se:eVt%.:§£'re;sLA:;_A1 t for in
view $2" an; Frwffi O

towwds 10% of

LUUKI Ur KAKNAIAKA HIGH CUURIACIE KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT

emw" gg v;:@a::§zi$§';- g§s§LI:;¥sé.&~':3!_a.:'§though mi mam of

— an is i;*’_;vi::1fmId unéus advantage cm the

:1§a:’mm§’ mm 1’11: 311% am at

Ra§’4§;3,f§f§E%~§§ is ‘inww aide fa»: than appallmt is an

is cmmly gwable af arming mach
$§*é:a—Ex levels ef inc-‘rams mid fuzthex, i: ammo’:
. Sgéé. thus is a d®fix:axi=en of the award. ef
mm the mm of 1933 er Time is an

‘&n®pcaistm.z:i3d327m1m’ ” ad.

@

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. More Information