The Branch Manager United India … vs Sri Mahesh on 23 August, 2010

.1.

R 13% fififi @953'? Q? K$%&'.£".£s.3A 4&1' 

nasrm rms 1% 33% 13.33: aw auaaaw 2§;_;;:e   ~

fifltfififi

rm Earn: xmmsflcm    

am. xa.  T
sfiwgmar V -   '

mgammca Rfifihfififi    2
33mm mam msmagxzsa 232$. gm"  ..
¢EI?&a.n"§mA$RE9. swig « ._ «  ;

mg nygmazezsaz wsgaagg  :  -
rmrran mam m'&*£3¥:a.HcEA.<.;*.--:%,_  
9IVE3§.I.'5§§;L mmcg   _,   
1=.B.§G§23?,34;:-_1  .   _  * 
   V ._     '
ma Q'-3#I$LE§';X, 3%?» mcnrag  '_  

          

1?.&.E:$ze'£2r3$:$§£..%_"'-«;;:._  ._ 
fi£aV.&§&:;"§ERE;~. _  _  _ '..fiP?ELI.&§T

  " _ $'*:f_i<.§3;"é;:'§z'1t;€._}1%:3:3?§s;c§.aa,,ma.r.;

  ..... 

=;>;s:s $§E.4§i3I1PsZ¥?£?Pé;

K “E G E.’3’€i’EERf?’@§i’

-._§gar;1:;a.K:£§i.a£m.*:R mw
Q§Q’I’§&§E§°R$A

ii

H ” AA : am§”é V 3gm..2″:3g&*ma

_ “$f$ S §VEER8§’I9fis
‘fiésaffifi RfA?$ 1§&
Efifiififi 3EK’%?1CE
flfi» 1% fifi
Qfiflfiiifififi R£$1’fl3.’3’3ER”‘I’S

$3’ $361 m ‘I’ Jfifififi Eéfifiafi, ABE?’ §’€¥R RI
£533}? 22 – KQQCE §fi?Efi3E;§} WETEE

iii-sir

.2.

THIS mm mm: UIUJER 3Ec’1’Io1I 30(1) or wc’T’..5c.r

maamsr 1:513 JUDGMENT AND ORDER DATED 2;3_1′;’~2’0Q6,
PASSED III we 110310102 02: THE FILE or ‘IflE’*’L!_£BQ’tIR_
omcnn Am) COMIHISSIOHER FOR
coupnusxnox, cnrrnnmmen, Awnnmzsm
CGIIPEHSATSOE 0? RS.1,62,655}- wr111″mmp3ST”@’_’v12% EA.

AHD

THIS APPEAL comma on FOR DAY,

COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWIEQ: ~ ”

This appeal
in WC.No.21§)if’:v2C§;1″;£’_’V …;s;i1mem1der claim
petition been allowed in
part :2 §kv1,52,655;- has been
awmiad.’ dated 15.03.2003 has

adxn;::ec1F%%nhe’k V Ii: View of the same, falbawirxg

; of law amuse’ for conmdera’ tion in

W1-1′ ether the Comma’ sinner has
_ overlooked tha material evidence on record

V’ awarding com;nensat’n3n amount of

Ra.1,62,655/- ‘2

2. Whether the Commissioner was right in
holding that tin has of earning; capacity at

-3.

in the awarias sf mi}? mafiieai rmmrcEs_7.._ *.__
35%? ‘ ” ”

exmpi thsa wcuné

2. Facts kaaégixg ‘£6 fifing

“Egg it A _ . _
Ciakm pefizfian wag 1% ‘
hcrmin kefarra Laban: = far
‘worhaasrfs C:3m@i:; a1fi§A’£’i;; ‘4 in
W.C.fi,§a.21G{.3§;.§Y%’ 1 empleyad
as a bus baarirzg
an 29.12.2001 at
absent wnrlcing an a

skamr $113. the fiua, azfi it was

‘Think far firm

ankfi ax ihat tima cit was

‘ Ffimm ‘mp af the baa afmr

‘ iuggfi passesgers am am awmmt efjaerk musesfi, N

% M awn frrcm bus and angered iz1}11r:ea’ ‘ on

% ggumnt sf wmh claim peactm wag ma.

3. Qt: $ aszf mama, rmpesrzdarrta apwefi amé
fled {Emir 3tatm@n% sf abjswtirzns, Emphyw am

mpkyae mkfiamfifig wag alas fieniwds, Remgandant

%

.4.

50.2 — Ezwiirsi’ aiw dénicd the avarmnm

?fl:*’£5;’fi.:$2’1. Rmyonfimt Em}; in B°§.’i§§fiZ’i of

mm’ aif fix’ amifiga as; W1 and gat

$13 anfi aim d the

9%’? Wm has: iasufi .’£’%2:?;_ fiérgfifliigy .

Rmpxainéent csxw the

wlicry ifiguefi in mapc¢§; §iéf theA amidcnt.
G22 thfi fiasia af an rfird.
anfi hefl
that
and a§a;§a§ er Rs.1,6Q,fi55:’~. It is
this ‘ éwhiciz is qussfimzed. in £17.23

…..

in ma apwi mmfirranfium by the

4 af mdiua ‘hang abm was gnavu’ us

ethccr am simk in zmtzurc arfi

V’ ‘£1 éisahfiity’ at 50% as assmaaé by Baum: ?m

it is tmg¢d that an bmia cf said

V ” E923 ease, Cammm’ ai§r3m* errfi in afzammg’ m Gfiflfilflfiiflfl

tlzmt diwafiiity is at ԤG% mxfi ta am 352$ mtent ear7nn1g
gmpazzéty af the ¢ t ig rafiumdg

.5,

5. There is rm refientafisn on

rmpenéarzfi 3.133% Eiavfig Iauazmzsaai @*mun§s_

agwai and aim % ficamzzxi’ xg the 5vi&j«;e:f:e §~» >

by fiw mféea, s»1;%ta:zfia1

hash: abmre am bdm aI’i$Wfi”‘$_i’3. as/fr§§fa~W$ . 3

5s 6 5*”

fiffiiflfififiififi _Wi§:;v Court 53
cf mmiéfiad am wauid
ovaez’ Lap ‘£:agetI1er for
oormia:$e§’§fi,§ :3;: Emrein who was
my warzmnk

Cfimgmtégiiaéfi V-3? ;a;%fi”‘:;s3£*:t;&:5née;:1 that he was wctrlmg as a

behrzfi ffl Impanéem N92.

cf empiaym anti ampkayae has Ewan

_ .355-#5pAfiI}.::i% ;’¥::n.Q – ixmmar by statement

éfibjacfiérm, it is awn tbs; rmpondefi: Em} has mt

T a’ wimew ‘sax and has met tanéwfi any

T 1:295 a::’m:az.§¥,ig:£a its claim mafia 52:: time staizemmat of

V U abjaecfisrm. fin the mtkmr imfi gmpicyfixm 3;” rmpaxaxiant

— T=::[- timt await {#5 raxpenfimt hamitx} was

fix

..§..

the inarrxfizzcmr esf {ha bus iiimixm :73′; aaeidezm. A
caf rewrds ‘s&., EX.?1 EXP?

refiwt that awfient in cgumtfmm had fic;<j"_;e;u

$122381 at a&z-it $.15 pm, '

hwy: éerxiafi by rwpxmdmzt

atatint sf cbjaamsns viefispsf af "

wrsiéczfis cf gxmi azga the
mmgéamd vim f_»«.:1f7?e;3»;at:ia:::15I'1ip {sf
nemphsyer ma: H03 and
" "

“‘3’. “‘::m.:a:zsei far appafiarzt that

azaaggazgg a:é’4″2.§Vs¢ss:éefi’*.b§”..ttze swag: at 59% cannst be

V. ha’ mt; the émter whn had treated.

‘V x

§% yméuceé tim SP1?) slip

% mum ‘E:-3:’ assaermams Grarzera}; agagatax, Hm.’ ‘rut,

man mm as mm and aim amhaiw

pxodueezi 33$ mmk& as Ex.A8, anti tha

” W§ZLflI1d amerfifmahe at EXAB. fim cmurzfi carti.fia::a’:2e éated

% ‘ 29.a:2’.2@<::r2 g mm by gm Effitrici i*Ir;:spimL

Ekfiuafiurgaé it Era ssmfifi t1'mr%un that amp: injury 'Nn.1

@/

.7-

namasly ths ficastzzm fif radius berm ali Gihfi” mama are

sémpk in namre. The srighmi G? EXP? has

p’£’&(§¥,.1%§; fififaffi 12¢. an-:…?é

mar. ‘I’h¢ 093 szii1z;%’_:'”9′?ifi_t”;g1?§__j’.i$

markaé 33 E391} saxmt & .4 ‘*

tha raasmn iimt Basia: win 2135

e
3′ 35’ ‘I

in hia zzzzgmw

thfi has ‘max:

8. Hszaswasmr, an my the
wamzd mug reflect

that t%z_.é1″‘é is radius. in atrium’ to
subatafiéggie fir’ fi’az:t:.§ra 7% mt united first

r*$§fi?’§Eh.: 3}1:a£ .».-.-%. tim mcmr who

fisspitai, chirxaduzm, but

namiy Qrgfiffivafl Raddy whs

A méégamé f:1e;g¢z:;m’ni1e;2,g,« mar” mm ta mrzteml and czlaim

éiaa.hih’.t§ tn the first

x Q12 amtxsicieratian am pmsal of me

sf §rs Raédg it is seen that said

é flacwr Em aamzm gm: mm: and P?’ as: rammed.

H3 aka aémim timi: he has met ‘«-.=a:– the X-ra}=s

faint: afifi “pig ai;&tzé: –. V L’

W,

.3.

takm an {ha 6.332% Qf amfient in 3% at a

as m wizat wag the namw cf irsjuxy

exam: mi am am $3′ awifimt mg: what péewam: * x

atams gm” msaiy 43.2.: $3 wlrwzhser fine ‘fiagfgfie

umted’ $1′ mt. Thcugh

gm arée:-ad m be as ax.x?:::%gc§m gig’), tfm
ma X-my hm mt gay mm the:

Cammtiaaisnerv TIE:

Dwtor aim.    is a simple
 it wmzfi get

mm £vw}w. It is $1339 adzmzittcscl

by the %c:%a$* th§.£__§i$§§§§ty that Ema fizz. asamsafi by

– tn limb mg 2192: fir: am Wiwia hafiy.

eszidasam &*9a§£a}<31$ on ram-rd, this

:3: gave may in

$:) %3J';§i 12$ i¢;if__*;5%m mmidefi 121% that Camissinoxxer

; at the dfmabfiitg; waif

A rmpmfiexzt by 353-wsfixg it at 4391?; Exam:

V' £1513 efidefiw at' Easter 'Chg whaia body

» dimahiiity cmmt smwazd 3.5%; in zeéw affim same ané

aka fafing irate mmésfiarafinn firm dizsabfiitg wréiifiseata
imauad by Reéfiy which is 3.1: Ex.?3 this

$2

.9.

Cam is at” am cmmifierafi vim that aaammgzgt-gs’

dkabfiity” by rim finmmkaismaar is an tzhe %

ragukw ta ha msdifififi.

§§ ‘fizezzgh fimter has

a@ gamma’ sfimm ham”ng %3g5::g£§%efii at ‘V V

4% ma raaaazfis am té an
whimh éimbiiitjg ?m as pm’ flue
Amrxac bady wctxld
be 113m mag am and
mm be amaasaci in
rag: 19335 fimxz austairxed by t…&
c2aim:za;w§iacz arm 15%. amrdsngly the.

aawaréw by the iliammss’ ianer 1&3!”

rmguirfi :9 ha res-corwuiawk

‘ _ as§é11a=w%s7§

3;§2€3iX2L;£?§.’é{ 15 ‘- 6§,§*95[–
lfifi

3%. A$%f’ , 1%: wmpazmtien as awaréeci by

fag

V A. the Sammimianeri at R§$.§62,655f– is rfitmed tr:

Rsm,9§§;-t

.1g,
E1. Ensafar as the award sf Miami in zzaruaaesrrzad it

is wet: ihaiz Go -sigsrmr has awarded EV

— –= ‘– awarfi cf irzmrmi
the E-iaxafbk Supzrme Emir: in
Lat. :33. § Rad:

ems Am saw .s*z’.z*.r %V V
izztamt Em awardfi.

:2. in mew (sf above,

Qffifif –. ..

‘IEEJR

»…..¢.-….,.

(53 fipfiiux > Suktantial gumflcans sf

fasamzr vi’ aygfiant’

k awaffi dam 32.: 3.29% passed by

‘A Wlgtriezmnfs at£am Cammlsimnar in

zwmaw is maism by realmring ma

” , m Raéfl-§%5f -.

V. It is QI”€1&”‘@£1 that fiat rmpoxzdarit Wmzld be

mmfieé tn izztmmt at ‘aim rate af ‘?,S% pa. fmm
thfi fiaiza of eiaim ggtiticen :53: $8.13 :32’ aavaxfi am! at
ticze ram af 12% pan frsm {Em date af award. till

W.

.11..

éatsz $5 éamsiizg gaymmizi Whzéékmm is: earfia.

aréer as ‘$26 mam,

gal;

X§*!fi§