Loading...

The Branch Manager vs Sri Saleem Hajilala Mulla on 2 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
The Branch Manager vs Sri Saleem Hajilala Mulla on 2 July, 2009
Author: B.S.Patil


1

§?’«% ‘THEE: EEEQH {KEG GP’ ¥{}’i§3N£’§T:’§K§’~;

{3ER€§§§,EE’T’ £§E;%’~§{3H’ AT’ {EULEARGA

E}A’E’£§;{} ‘F§~-HS Ti-{E3 2% my’ 09 JULY, 2109?’ F”

3313098

213%: §%«:2m3:,§: §x;iR,J{ISTi{1E3 E;?:..:?§;–?A’F1L f1; ‘ ” V

:v:§:;;{:;s;;,.§,,A_:€_2::_:3 E3’i3S”f’ APPEEEAL 142a7::e– .<_i§::*. i2§'@<§? {\':s%.,%';::)

E3 E?'I"JJ_E3E§§'E:

‘§’§Ei2 ¥{1§§*:=1:’z<~/h §\ria:1z£§g'éV'1',Vb_"'-. V
'E'.E1€: New India AssLz2éar.1<:{: C30. L-t.<i'.':,. .. &
aagapm-. %%%% ~ s %

:%::p$ isy me £)§;31:ty ?v€a:éa;;9;r::r,*» _ " _
T316 Nmv iiuiia 2–'<.;ss:1::"a391<%§:{T{é; Li.rij_.;" "
Regigrzai ifiéice, M . . S
NO. :3-=8, ?j:fz§'f:§; Bxiikiing 'fX:i11€:xr:5
§v§"§S§SiO§1 maigi, "

Béimg”2:E_3:’é=–55{l¥’~f3{};Z’t.

,.. Appaflmii

{By _a;r1d Sri. M. Naflgsanappa, flzivocates}
‘7 ;_%.?*éE:«;

_ 21523323 Muga,

‘–Aug-er; V19 yfsaats, OCC: Cieamer,
.g~,%::r13a’va1~g:,T{;; Jafia,

-fiffiisiz Sazlgaii

–. Apt ‘f”res€:n E: R; (:2 Ei£maVa{iz;..

V V ‘ Dist: Bijapur,

Pacinrua Vilasa Kadazna,
Agaz Majar, OCC: T1*a:1$y0:*i,
R f 0 K§*uS.E3i€i 3:21:13 CH S,
?E.(fl; £’*v§,

F4}

Sectionwfi, Kaiamboii,
Ifiiist: Rayagada.

.. . i§’::s,_2;$Ei1’*);<:i:;%':7:.f;£$§ .1; __

{By Sri. CL. Koujalagi, Advrxtate fer R4. anti '

Advocate for R-2)

This MT.§".A. is 536:1 undtér sectiofi-'3<;i_'_'T{~iV) 'gr '£315?'
against the j'uégmen.i': daied i26.{}§9._2O€)7'–ApaV$;sec1_§;i1,Wi3A,§SR–
1 1[2{)Q? on thc fig? of the Labraur' Oflficer and {1ommis,_s;ie:;Ver for *

Workme:1's {i§ompens'.atio11, S11b~Sivié:é:;=§i1»1, Bija;_pi1r,.V-I awaldizig a
compe:asa.tio:1 of Rs. 3,54,? :22 ,1 ~ with igtérsst 12%«p,3..

This M.E?.A. csming ézaflfgrl_0r2;i€jr$"=_'§,11§S~._e:iay, fhfi Court

deiivered the: fcfllowingz
%%%% ~ E 1*: 2':

in an ziccidéiit ifgiviié-.’46’€C iiifI_’é(§.0.I1 Z;’:r§.{}”?.2006 the claimazzb
rwpexadezzt izeréigau é;::i?t”:3’1’€{i’A.Cé:z:§é;i11 p&r3m1ai injurifis due 1:0 the
a{:€:;<;:151§:}a«}.;:f:g§ig<:17:cé'+522; $33.6 part <:::f Q16 driver of thc vehicie

.'m€é'Q§v%=:d« £13. 3;§}:.€;..'a1£i%ffi€}§3I1i, He :f'Li&d 3 ciaim peiiticn befifle tbs

{',g)1nni'i3S'i€2_I;r:r '~YWVrk::1en’s {‘£e:>mpe31$ati<)n, Sub~Division–§,

Bifizegmzx' <.:'lé§3'mi:;=_igf c.€5inp€:1$.:2:%.§ot1.

«.2; V"£'.}1s5: c§§ai::z12s.I1£: axaxninsd himsélf 31142} {i dactm" by mama

iiciposed stai:.i1:g that the .inj':1ri€s stzstamed by the

.T _ Z;;§r;mm1′?:. lcfl jififfilifiici p:érr:1a§;€:nt s:§.§.sabi1iiy to» an Extent of 60°/:3

e::53f1i;pa§*t%d {(3 ihfft Wh»:::k: bozfiy. Thfi ilsmmisfiioner fax” WG:*k}::::€:::1’s

Cm:sa%,i0:z:s. E2:-:3 ?if)Vs»-‘€’5.?€”€ takem {ha 103$ 01″ t33112’i:1g capaciij; at

?5% and bag 3.1%-‘aI’ti€& <::(::mp€'£3$a.ti21}-

%/

{Rt.2;:>t::<:s Tégzztci L;e:i<}':.:s; Fifty Fszzir '§"ho'13$ami SEVQEE ¥'§:::zdm:f(§".a11&

'§.'w{%ni§; "¥.'x=s;<; €)zt;..i3:}. Aggiievmi 'sf,-" ihrs: 1:.

:»§l1egi.ng £1134: 1:316: samié £3 €’3XC€?SSiV€, me grassnt a§’;;}<:a§°'isL' i§1éd '

iiildfifi" Section. 38 (1) 0f the W0r?z:m€I1's C'3tZT'.1'VC£§£)I;1*eaz*i:;g:g.4f0:* ihr: ‘2;3p&}Ea12i~–i;13ur§331%:§i; _

c=:m3pa.ny {?O}It€f}’1€3.S that 21 sLi13stanti2ii=..qufistionfl’-z1. in this case ‘é.z§_ as ;E1]’ii1C1}VE:nS.’ :15n=:..{30m2nissi0n€r for

Wc:21″3{mc::1’s .§%13,;3;°1:d a%s€sSment made by
the {‘”:X:;’§f:1″i zmzi has proceeded is
amass the Eerii-z§i {ff ax: He draws fhsf: atiaxztimx
G? the cmrari t{; ‘igijgcf: sviriemxsz af the (§%3C’I”.{)I” axzd
<*,0.z:x'£6:':{§$ $.2€3.:*. u§<§;':.:~;_ {1 §'" t:%:1:€zsi:1g aagsacity' mxghi. to havfr bean
{Ezra of may ifyfhay ';}1:2{:<rr173§. Saunas}.

&:§3§3<té;é:2g-faé' v€.?1'::..:§ia§i:1:–3:1.'€' :<;1zpTpo.§*3;$ the fimfiizgs recgrciatrii.

— :3. ET§é?w?;§:Z’g& §i€%;ar(i {ha 1»5::a:’z1€:(i Cfifkiififiél far the pariiss am: an

_ §:§€r’g-a_é’.s:ai ” :35 .. €315: “:z:;12§t€:”ia1s 0:2; I”f5{,”{}§'{i, E fimi ‘$123? iim ciaimasiit 153.223

iii: Véxézjinéna the zicxctezr W319 {mated him. Tbs iriaimam; has

LT ” V _ 34121;? “.m’§’t p:’%>:§.’a3::z:{i ‘£3.16 ::1§:{i.f;c:,«zE zzizrgnis is Shaw 2315: natizm of

“€.§$é,im:e3r:'{ 152:: has; iiaktm. in fifiif E-‘:e:>$ga:£ta£ wlfmre he was zadméttmi at

Pmiiza {7}}: S;’~§,§i?€§_”§1 ex;.:::1:ii31::§’i by ‘the: e::lai111a:1t has orgy issued i:’:1{%:.

:%.§§21′::»i§§7z%; <.::::z'%,§fi{,*:;:1ii: 2&5} %,za;§; étxézmiizéii ihfz' CiEii1'I:£%3.}'E. Qrzifg for that

if

purpose. Ha hag also categorically statesi that thrit tifififil V'

suffered is abeut 60% compared to the who£e.body ; u

asserted in his afiifiavit f3V2id€1].C€ that there :,;s;-:35; a1T:'~.iiij:.,u';',-i

Iifiifk, wizicrh 3.1223 rézszziied. in gi(idii'1és;_S;—.gii€"fi{:i_':Ety in i13[Qv'€:i::1e:t1;£'an{i "

::iésE:u§'ba1::*.€ in spaech £:'i:b:;~ra::: ‘(his jI:’:«;_ gygrgmmsmnces even
a:~3s;:.i:};;i13g that ms peI’c§:én{ag¢ £>-f by the doctar
at 66°/5 reflszctss $1′.-1§j3’V.i.:L€’ there was no
jtasiiféeztzatimi ii}? tbs ioss of eamling
ca§a€:ity at §j¥z§:,\?é1;g tins natum of injziries emd {he
gzatzire Qf £313 wjg)i”3<;M was tzfiiacharging as 3
<:.Er:a11e1: '}'fs:aa x{'3€}fifi11}:i§$Si;{;;'I1f:¥' ifiéght to have: 'taken the 1035 sf

€::as%{*::%3;;g§= C£~fqc;£:§:s:?i51i?'§-'A at 639%) Ceifiistant wiih the medical avidence.

='$é.._§i':–.3;§e:ia%: .%_}1:*:; éfibiivfi, this appesai (1€3S€fI"'e'€'.$ :9 be aliewed fig:

;'a<:€§.€.;z1"vi.E;:::g:Z3}'v £3 ailawgxi in §az:'£.. If Ehe Lakhs Eighty Tiaras

Seven Eiuxzzired anti Scvsnty Seven. Oaks). In ail Gfllfir

L”27:€sé}.:»~.=’:e::i:;§, the awagfi pafised by the COfi1III1iSS.if)1’i€1” is Iieft

:é§%1<.ii:s£u:*3:2:é€}. Tht: ammmi df;p{}S§¥;€{3 before ihis {Burt shall stané

fran.§;f%:r:fz=,zi to '£315: C0l"£}I:1iSSi€3ZE€}{" 'REF Workm:::n's C0.173}peI:sa1:ion.y

-3

Tile: a;3p€11ani«»insziragxazttz Cozzapaxgr is at liberty to seek ;*ef1′:n;}Q-Q_fTf.I1e
E§(C€f$S azrmum”. dspcasitezi. Q

swk:

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. More Information