High Court Karnataka High Court

The Commissioner Bangalore … vs P Anuradha on 3 December, 2010

Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Bangalore … vs P Anuradha on 3 December, 2010
Author: Subhash B.Adi
$3 4'  

 

  fig'? €§g%.§%"§g%§.;{§§§;«
  Eiéfi     §§§.§
 %

 §§i§§€%;'E§- 

 

 

:

 

   §§§§ 23$?

 

§§§§;"§§'3{§:'i':§¥ _  -
"§;£*;%2:§%%s':§§§§;}:fg'§;}%{§é:%;E§"* " A
 §?:§:§%'§§%:=:::e_§§% " _V __ .
      

_   V V

  §:§';%; ?§§"§§f§ 'iéifi $3. 

 
  
    

     

V  fififizzfi 3% 

 
 
  

égfi 3% i?% 

3; 32:22.23 Efiiiéfigmzzgmgg.
Q Egfiifiizgraéifita _ _ 
,s%%'ifi§ §:§f§§E§°§. % jgfiffiffi

fifaigfiggg §:§%§+§g§;%~:_ T :7  _



& &   ..;$§§%;i§§?%§i fiégg égga 2%? §§,w:%3;§

¥'m¥

$2 §§:E§_%&?§ Egiifii  
$5? £3 E, %§;§°a:<;§:i€£%za§&§& 

 
  

    
  

gé  

 

  ; §E;:§%;:  ' "

 

35 $311"     H 
       '~ 

 

   
fizgggé gfgmuz ax;  *

    

  $3   
" §%g%:fi;:%";§§§, §% 

€33!

     

  

$8  $§':§§%§§§§§'°§'§

   

   Eéffiafififiégg  :% fiifi. 
 %% fig fiai  izzgfi; 323$ ézgégmmzi fifiéfié  
:§%,E§g%i%:§"§ §$,§§%§ ii: §Ez%§§§$;f$;%§f%i§§ fig} Eiém '§:2§§ $5

 sigiéii 51%??? fifmii % fiififgé £a§:§§%§ §;%.:°§g$%s:%§ §§§'i§

 3%;  'fig gag? £3" §.§@$?%g::=§f§ws§:a 5% ifiéééfiéfiiififgs

     
 
 

  
 

     
  

 W 5&3   2%   A '



 

 giifii   §§§%E.E§§'?§ Ea §;§§fii %,%?:§.§;%§'
 fifi fig   fig §:.;  mm}: §;%z;§1_ 
§Z§,g;§<;'§=%«§;E§ yagafié $2'; €}§§'§§,§§é%3g'§;Z§2 $3: *é}°;g 
X??? égégiie £5? iiivéi & 
§E:1.:2§ 33%  2:;  $2.33: €23' sifiéégrsaiiagz % " 
iigmzé éfifiwyfié ffi

 
 
 
  

§  f 

 §§a::é%;;%:§§i'§'éaé  %:a::£;§:

 

 Qsméfz

 

V  

sfigéfiééfigéiig §',.E':§:««T1§f§;§§&:f§$£ $:§«~$§%42§*s:.§.:'€;;'?'éz<3;..%,;%séé°z":§$ i:'§E%%?é%%§ $§"?3.§§i

 

a§§.sm;,,:";%"'~j§'2;:ii;E§ 52$; s::::s§§.§.,2.§§:fi ii

 

"  "  gifigfigméggi fifisfi

:23; fiévf fsfiézfi :E$s::§%:::.§ ~;:»;:g grggziiagg

'  Eééfi mgizg Eiwffi $3 ifigc gm

   

 

  ézém $2'Z%Ei'3'3§&§§§f;§E7§§%§ %i*"E§%?,§ §'§:2g;E:§.§ 'fig

 

   

 2:: fig my fig? 

 

 

35 gfifigga fif fiw §.  ,§§ fifiig §fi;?§.§ 
§:.§x§%§§.,§§§ 3%.; {A iéfigf éfi azfig  5:2?' :"%:;:.2@:'fi figgafig

 § Egg? §*§§§3§:2§  3%  *"§"a2*§.:§§;'  i

     

  agéfiz fiéfizggiyézaé gézwfi §;§'i§'..ai'§ azéiiééég %%E§E§§§§}%%

%3:,Q§fE% tféggigag §&:::g;g§§§§:€é;2;' .

 fifimifig 3:: $3   éfigg ziig "

"    §§$§§;§* § £33.



 

Efifiéiig ::a:%m,§:§§::": 'é::;2:::::::§-' '§i='€1?'§ Efiigszégigzg  ifiiéfi

 

 fifilifi.

km gfififi  :3 

§;§3%§;E;;%f%;:§;ai%E§€;é;&§';§&§ §§;2%§:::::z:;g;§;;g5 agzfi Ak$g,%:%€2§€§§g$:§g:g4.;, 2 

    

gag:  gmw   

:3; fiififéwfi mi 3:::;§5   

  

 fig %£.%%§%£?'23%i~:   ' 

 

 'iifiiifi $3: agfimfié $2';

 

 

33%; Efiifiigi

 zzzzaifizs»  "

 

fiaifigé   izééfifi  3%? "%L§3:§ 32$:

   

fifiéfififiéfig   "%;?:§r..V%$;é% '  §::*m$§m%:§$fi§

 

$$§§"%,:*":,:%:%:£s:::§§ fif

 

     §"'%

 

meémwzgéaé '¥.;%T*"%.§§Q'£*§,.?:I'§£';§ .§,':',£"§:§  fig fi'§$E'ifi§fi§T§,?:.§ 

afiifi '  %'¥i.I§3:§.~ .__:§:;:§2§fi%':3§s§ §;%§m#*%%£§ §,§'"f.:§ fiffi ii: §;$'§§§fi§

 §§=&$%€'?§§:§§573§§§_ $§:::§$:§§§§::E £3? '§;E'§% gszgéi $§3§@§§éE:é$ §§§"€_§§Tfi;§'ij§"

 zwéfizz fmm fig égzg 3;? ggmkgag gzagé

§2:*€:*%é§;€}%:ég§;z'%;" ':}':a$§§ %§:z§.§z* gzrzé  %{'§§'§% Wfiffi ii: fiifiéiizfig

 

%.:3%-E: gézfi a%,i*;§§§*:m§:%i: §§ $23     § ¥

 

 %::%.:§%%§%§%';§g ::3:{;: Efigfiiéég §$§£3§{§§%_.,?§§ aw:i:?:2 :§::?§$ §§£:§:: ggéé

maigzwéfii

 %$'%é'%E" 332% @2231:   "T

   

E'
:§a::%m€§;%§;;f:*:%:§; ?.T%§€';? %§°2:§::$i%:t:§,"§ gézfia mi  zgaeéfé fig

%.:$%:2§§' m»%':§fi:33§§2§§  £3 §§%T"'$§:€§f;§§°'%':~,~ E:  if.;3}':E§}"' %§&2*

 



§§'$é;J?*%i$m $5  '

W412

333% %a:*:***:§:":§'2::a§, i§%;f§€§.§'§i§§§j§ 5%? $333 fiéfifiiffifiéfiééé g

fiafiwgar iéiéfig gaziéi §£:%:fi':..:9§§ §§"$§§8.§'"2Z}»-'§    

%'§§§%',.?3Z§?;= 232$ §zs:§;:zi$§;?:.é:s;%§%, :3-:::::?§Ea:*$§§s§23  

    .. 

fiaiafi ::;:§3g%,.§$€r §£§%*§=z§%:*;, fig

?:;i’: Ex «%;§§%§§E{§€S:§ ‘%$?§’§.$§”%§§i aim §§g3:E”:§;§”2r:e esgazgfii

§§§>~?;§’§_%;a§ mg: §.§f’f;$§ gf

T” fififtiifiéfig £§%§%f§%.i§,§i£’;’§ %:;§.§:§ fiifi §§§.§§:§§§’%

‘A ‘ :33 233% Eiiififiifi :2? §§§$§%%%§

J

fiiififiififfi §;,z:s:§ i§’s3*€”;’=”%;§%;§£§1§;% %§:3§§”a2%§ E2? 332%
2?” T 7

ziéazizimgzm

§é§;%;;é:§§E§ §;:%f’%3 fi§§E;£;”«:§§$i%§§ fiiéé géiégfiéi iégfi géééfizjg ‘

iififgsfiéfgééfiifig

faaafi Emya §&§ §:e::Z@& gm mi

gzfgigiifiggi §$r %;,§:’:a: 3%; ” ._§.%%<:E§a§$;:;'§;é:_::,v§$:§::.%%?§§§ $3 §§:;§?:;§:£%:§§§§,

E 1; <§¥;%z§m§: %g Q,

:;§%,2§3§: Efifig T-

% ‘e;§~:§:a gazéi $$§:§§§;°:§E%

“gigs:

§z~§m§~g§g 1 ‘ é3aEiis§£§¥*~’:,”_’f%§:§&:%;é%§ V’ gag

_ :;s%*,:«$”§»’«v%::*:’:’f§::*:.§%T»if§?;rf:g$§é E3}? ;§;%E::**;%£§§g 33%

gfiéggézi §%;::*’§§:%m3?;?Z%g:V§§ mafia’

” :3 £3 flfi “mzaigy:

3-°§*£ gywgasig

$2

§”

§§§.::;§ §’i§’;é”§

Q9

Eféfig §;§§:E§,%§$§;*’§»;~:§.*A§.::3;;E§u:-i=’* “%;§*:§~ *’

” §§”3$§§§:$ §:§:a§f£; §§§

‘V £3; .. —

” .%a:::2§:§ iéfiifé 315$ a,;éf’;§’+” 3%:

” mam: fifiii z§§.:§rz;:§: mzéi aémtmié

§%€:}’§r&:**$ mgfizkgég E5: §’%.$a::%§a::u%;%m;~%s,’%§ Qfiiiég §§;$;%§’. is %§:’§

Q5:

5:?” ‘EEE §;§,fi§%’;§§§fi§°%’§? 3,33%? §§§’Q’I;§§;”3Z’§

3; $3? s afgfi $3′

éggégiazzég “fl

” Q? §$§fi;. wag

XE?” %$%§% fiazéagsfi; fig’: €:;9fi§;:f 1

fig §§%q$ Eyigé may? $3: Q? –

;_§3%*§%§:*:%:¥i 23:33? %:%<@%

fifigfifxfiéfli gag

'mg

aa.,:%i:, E: fig

§%§';'";§7:-%";*%:7§ §%; $§:iV *'"+:*&§§ iizé éssfsgmfiassfi

€32 Efizig §:;%%$:;%': figfifgifi

3% fa? fig: §%:*§§%fi§%§'ES'é: §?;§:i$fi§*§§i§«§'§§,

flag §§'§§2»««%,,.§*§$ §'%§3;§.3.iflE""§" &2.2§@?§§;§5§

°*{gfi§fi§§m%gg§§§:&§fi:§%g%§§gaaw§

% §§§1§'%'";.. § §Z%§2;a3 fif

: "§§§'§£$fi $3 ::@§2§§§?fi:§s§&%%§ aifigéfy Sléfiiééfi %% :3? "fix fig

wéiéfm %:fi mgzziéfi

wggfizfl ; ;:*':§ 3% ?;;%?§%

32% §"§§%§§g $2": %§';%£ §%§%:":"::a§§2'f% £3? 3 $243

"::§ § :fi:fg§§»§§§ =

__ 'gm u 2

E3

ggfi «:31:-7%: éfigér, §.i%f mg 2333 §:E§§i:*2%§§§§ égigga $3?

$::§§::: aagrzzfi; $32. aka §a; %::f§:§$

' é§?;f:§ §§"%3%§' %% gzzii ggézfiaséss: "

éfiimfiééfiéigfi 232% tézfifwm

§§€3%%E'"fi%§"§ iééééa 333%: éfi?-$2-?'s Eéiafi gas

§,§%fi?;f EEK

3%;

$e%?,%s’:§§: a’Ew%~ £2?’ fix §;;§%:

;_ :;:*:~1′..’:f§é’;%:::;F%

33% Wféiififi ggggég

T 3 ;:@§:f£§_::*§;%*%,:§%:, :3 Egfié fig Eggs? fig: Efifig

mm§§§?§a;:”;5m.%,,%wv.;$§~;’:§.@’w.g§:%§§fi’L fig gsatégzg 33% §:.a°*§l

€322″? E; .:s..;%§§g ::’:§’*:a €23 émrgfiéygg !.:%£ gagxii fig igizaigiifigz

V.g:;a§”, “:.gL”§;:*§:%;*§,§§:;v}lz§:%; sf gfifiéfifiéfi %%%{§§ af ?:3§§ £23: 3%

33$? Eaztififr. éiméf £3

“aim £62-%& 22% *:,”,??;E§.,§§$ «:2? afizgiz wéfifiéa §§§<%%: fig

-. V’

E3 Ea aka g-méggfiéiififii fig? 3%

fifiififéfisfiiééfi zaizéfig $€=;$§§zé::%3, 2:? if fig %¥:%§i£§;”‘§ wag

§%:§§,§&§f;%§ $2: Efieifiyii 3&5 fimi gag

V fig $35’

$3

‘fig %§;%:§ afiéw éf Ezézg fiéfifiifififiifizfi; iii’: fafiéfi §

gégéiififiuaa 3&5′: fig §:§.,%§%% ha gamfimi a g

:§§%§§§§;%;;§r:§§§ Efiiifih Ema E23; §£§’§%§f$§’; §m§%%;é;§§i§:§.;-, ‘ M

§m%m,:%i

%%.z:g§:2:§:*: £3 mafia

mmgégifiéé haw §i§5’é.% fifiiifi fig

§§§§§$?§f Q?

;?s;:.$ 5:; . ‘::i;L’»§??§i’§§;i:§§’::;”§

a gag: faziéé. Ezazé Efiaézii 23%;; fig

$3: aaggazza fig ‘ijézfi égg

2§;§;'”:§§g%§:”‘ fiwiéégs %{;§§ gzgséz 3 §%:2§$?:§g§-sf ggiéfié

gifzd? mz1§@:.m:’:”§§§ Eggg 33$ fig

9;~*’;g§’~é:§”§$ ‘ggfsmziéggfiz

‘ .. ,§%n’§i% 33%;: gégéfiziiifié, é:§’§§:£:

Wafi gm gwéggggmg. fig aggzgg gig gzgmfi

~, éwafi; $3; Egg faaasazzz E+§§§%>§?:§: $3″: &§”;§fi§1 §§E 2%

‘4 «Ema gggzgzgffiii $3: fi”m%.4afi*§%:’: $§ %%§ :£§’§;f:§’?$§” Zéfiig 53;’

it fig §j”;%Eé;£%3.;i;%;:a3:§; .:§_§:gz:§; _

iigfi ‘%,E;§%§’Z?if_:,€;§::”i%._ n %V ”

%§? géfiag aim: Egg; éfi §:§§§ $2333; $2″:

«i§;; §,%§ié§;.; .

gm -‘

” ”

E?

§;§:%§%§%%: §:§§§;g@&::§=$:ig Eésgwgwg Efsifififi gag; §§&,.§”%:>=*=§ $35″ “éfirgfi

E§§%¢ Z2? 3 % $3 Efié

$3′: “§$%§%§::a:r: %::§§2;a§2$& :2? iéaliégfi 3; §§i?2%4′?;;;§3::’*–.é§V~

gam :%:.§:x%g;? E? ~:?e:$é:,as%%i§:m:gv:§;;§%”

a§* V G . fig: %:§f 352$

gf

iéfifi E?” fiigfififfifi .;;€:$&%%£.i::%:*’}g~ v_

figw

§’§,;3;$§3 3 §;%§m_ fig §%:**:§:i:§% §% :% fifi 52%

fig gag ‘Em: fif 22% ggg as zgg gm

fié Sim gséaéfzéézg §iE@ f§ fig

fig” §j§§%3:5’§E%§’§$

a §§i’@’%% Eglfii

fiffig; __ 3 E? ”:%m g

gfi

égééiaééfiééafi Eiéfia mg mg %%%%E;§$%§&§ éjiéaf; $5; &.§%§£%

gégfi-ggsgégzzg

gséfiiafi $353’ Eiéé? ‘ ”

3 T.a:%:?:A

ifirfi, gaéégg 323:: _

§fi§fi E3: §;§f §%i’}€;%§

E

ffia $’%:E:%3f § fifiiéfifiefii __ .

E géfiaamgzififiz :§§ 332% gig:

fig Eiéé mi €:%5§L3′?i§g

fi$:’:§:’3’§§;’if €23 fifif’ a-:f§a:$%$%ia?::;%::%§’E{§:%§%§&:§< 'é;§f2sé'.=§'::Z:f§Q ifié

' — f&&::*" m*" .§.;§'%5§§*§& é§§é§%§%§§§§:§

gs; {.35 gg 33% g§g;:§§;g Tg;;;g:s:::§&g::::§§ as Eég

§?&% 23% fifizég' %§;§;2:§ gm

$33 § é%:§i.§;§'i:?;:§.%§% 'irfitzfi aiiggaé

afié fifi aazaéitgg Esézg

zm§2Z:%:_:§$§§::%%§3m2 fifi $3: fig §§'§:,% {sf 5% gsgifz

::?§«–§,;"§%:% §:a%&,§§,:"% 3%" %:.E%:2% 32% 32% mi

ééfig fig &£§%%§?§fi ;§m§%$§§%z: méméz

Ema %:::§:32aé%;§¢e2*;

3% %§_i2§3$:::*’%: 32% {xzrazzigsfizgiifgégzg §,:§$.§*§:”:%€§ éffgzfizgézi

* am %:§’:a§ s%mé%§:%§: gf 33% §€§%§§:?$fi fiagxiifi gf fiéia fifififi

§§*?;”}%$< E2": §a::,§$:'3%i§§:;%§

%§. '§:?E:E Qzfiawé: %$% Egg izigai & wmaiz £2:

233:3 3€%i's*$f;%'§; ,

$3': %%?.%§ia:.§': £3-3;

$3? fiéggwaémzzg “‘§”%3.$7.§§§_::é fig ”

azzé Emigimfiéézé V-gégfiéééfi; H

‘E

4,»;

i

<5

"x

V . ggéagé $.a§:;;.E:§'$é: ii <§:$% 2322: gfifigi ém

" ;§%§:;:+2 3 ga

32

%Zf;:::;%& fig fifiéwfié ?§$z:§¥%§Ji2§’% ?g::2§%$§$:£<:*:<: :§:§:a::?f?}; :33:

gfigmz 31% mi fiifiagéég Egg aka gm %;:§:'3%

zzzzméi ii': Eéfi Eiéififi Eiazmz

gfiayg. ,i?§§;§;£*%5 gzgéfmii

é"{aé

3%:

%”é§§?§§:%3:’f”§;’§:

§’§@fi$§ ::%§ 3% iéfizé, kg
§. §%’:Ei§. $2: §§%:::€::5;§:§ gfiéjg” §:*%§§§§:”§ iii:

§i%:§2%§§§§§%§§, 33% §§:’;§”i§3§§E:iZ:£’:i2″i

ggga 1 E2?’ :i%;:T.;j§%§*: s::5;:*:;%:§¢%*:T:§:%;$…§§,:*;’§ gzéjééfifiéiiéfiififé 5%?

Egflg – £2 a§r§,§_’§, §£%?;:§zé*§;§..§;*g:a§§*;*é;€’;%%§§é@:1 5,23% amfizéaé $2?

Eééfi ..

;ig:§~ 32% gag %”a.:%§§§:?;:§§ %.§§’:§fi mg

V” &@ zgéaéé §:3§f %;%:2.:*; %§$f§’§a§ £3? :z§%*m%1″:

§%i;.f*§%’%§§» Eff” E3: 3% Em: agiéafié iag iii-*:§: gzzffiaggié €52?

fig

gfizzifizéééfigz Em aka $222 azmfizfir

%s:%§f§?§r:*;§-E 2&3: {:23 2%.: :%%f«% ségg ifigé gig

-2 15% $323 $335 %afE§’§i.%£§* §3I’%’§

am: ‘s;§’§%;§ ma? §;::§’3§§%;%§.” 333$ %§.§”:§E§:*

Eiéag $’§$§?%3 figggég gagggzz % igfiagfifigéfiié

§§’E{%§€§ éégzé: §}§$i%§§;f§§%-3% §:$ fi§§§§¥:ETE.’

,3″

w

mm’

/w§
.- “‘”<wu~

$53

$3
&%§;%m§§%:.;'s;%::E:§§:* §.§§;'%§ $33.15 $33: gaézfififiéag: §";;e;%:':§§Ef§:"i§f azigé; ii ég

gémzfitsaifi '§:§°%'£ Eiffifi §§€fi"§§§§§.%§: an

E'? 3%.?" izém 32:33:". 32% fiéfig .a§%;%:.i" 323:3 §i:?:2§..:"2

£3 mg:§:ij'§r:§ 3&3: $339:-=6; i"§§.;€1';:m.£3§§§§Qf': :3? $53-izzaizgzwé 9;?-«

aim: fig $3": flag éfiiifi {ref 33:33:; §§§: §g3=:*;%; :;§z%;§1§,:3g§§z%§§%a%§?.

fig %§2;**:2::*§£:%,.2:*a gzzé wag

31,. E? 1% ' ijfififi £3 $323 §:'é§;a§§§&:2§m":§"%§:3£§i.:§§év;;§::§: fig

gig k'a;:£ zgvga

E::%::§ E22: izsziwmmg. –

magma 5% fig

53:.’ fifififi fig fig

am: gag: gag; 232% mg :25:

$§ isfgr “mafia gg Eiféfiflfi
§%§g:’;§@..$§v:::;”:;§%:__ 23% ;%::€§*$§§§:} *-

._f,,-:”€;%”§ £3? ggggfigfifigg §§§g§§ Ex §§§§§§ a§5

‘ * ..

§§§’§§?§

V_ 3% ::§;::§f§:gmi:’§ :3?’ €E§£’§5fi;’§*§
A 5;’ §f.é?f§§siE?€§§§ ii? §?%.é:”£?§
” T $3?” 3333 fig? Q? Q
V .. .. ??§ “gig? T£;€3§§:%’:.’§§£§
$23 $23 $g:§:§?;T§§ §;?é:§°:§§ §:%”$2:£§%:?’§§$ ?is}*§§%
3%: {:5 $3
fiéé €§f§§’§%*’ *§ §§%$L§:’ gxaszz? afigé? .%:s?§,:2z: ??§afiF§§§§é§’ f”‘%???£
3&5 5%?’ 35%? wflggfi gf gag: gizggié g? géésgy

. zgfgggfigémé

‘:. éifigfi fig:

n ‘T 2:? :.:=

T $233: $2? :::::§§:§:? §?§:@§§§:?””a§§§

my ‘

%Q& E: 5&2: Egg gaégsi

E Sm §§;§.§Z:’%;’?;§§;’§ sf ‘I{f:*:2%

@312″; 23% 333% sag §;§§:*:~ta;§,%§:§”§%€§.*§§%m $35 – H

%;%§@:_E:: §§€%% 2% 33%; ~

2%_§§;&i’»’§%§§ 523% ‘ 5:32: §7L3’§I£§T§ ‘§?s:.é<:§~*% fif %§3%

Eifi fifififé '%i;§}?;%=;:;§,§;wi'.§'i:& _ . _§é:;V::~r% £21 $35
$2; ggiéa

§%§%§¥%2;"* fgigi: érfigr fig ;%:$§§§§§?:§&

Séiiw: