IN THE HIGH COURT OF XARKATAKA
CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD
m:r§;1:: THIS THE) 2ND BAY 0? gum', 2{"3:é.é%M 'T
PRESENT
THE; Hrjixrgm MR,J§JS'§'§C:§: 1:) V sie:YLE,tA1i\£..r:®€a.i;A:,;£rw;,§;E4
AND.'
'rag: H()N'BLE M'R..JUS'§'I€iE K 'gfi;s;§AvAN§§ _§)%;¥§:§A
WEI'? APPEAL N{§;§;1;§§2 j%L2:*§os'{L§.% RES}
BETWEEN':
THE
<:£;';R§*<3RA*;:'1~::'§'§w" _.254?, MAE~iAE\E'I'E?SE§' NAQEAR
BE:iiL{}§§Ej¥§%.r'§
.. . §%£§S}3{}NDE?€i?§~'§«4_4_ _
(E3? SRE K. 3 A}3HYAPA%{, AGA ma 1; M _ ~ _ 1
SR}. smzxzgwif; A PACIHCHAPURE, ;a,:>v._.,V§%<;;r£<3E ms: W.P.;~§{:)';~..:24:a'1_[2907~_D;é;I'}:':D'
I/4/2008.
TEES WRIT ::f:<§a:{»5? F'(}7R
ORDERS THIS may 1E3H','{}';E;N£)RA =:<::;:'MAR .3
DELIVEREE} THE F-:,L§Qw:NC;; 1*
' -V
_'§§;?;°it 'L€3i;;.i3:)e5a§l::"'i;Ir3cr:1§g3:;" had 1333:: Eisitztfii for
9:"<}r:::*S_ ;'4c:gaL:'<.ii1":eg"~.<:if::§¢cii§{a~: §::"€:s;§:r::aii£3n, {El} cur
;::€1'*1::it€i:':g -V ihai. _§i::ai';1:€:§" s::am";..s€§ far {her a.p}_:ac:1Ea:1?€.
«2i;;i%.:fi'* :}_;:$i$i:i:'1g "%;;%fs;a;:' dafscis s}i":s3:_:§{i he rézciifiegé
'{iz..:T;*'§§'ig«.§f:~:§"«;:{:'g;:'Sa of $218 day; iear:1€t.§(:mi£3I';i.:3 0.2}
i:§:"':e:=: appii:'1s anti. the: appaaig
A{i.c>ii€:.§0nai G()V€fI11"I}{':I'1.ii Ad1Ica'€;e 33 4'
mks: :'1<:t§,<:<3 far rr:sg3<;s1';cie.?:z'f.: .N(;_,:
KarI'1a_31aka, by" its E<§€{:1*<5;ia1"}; ": 'r:.o1 _' 7T
_£TT..3e;',;_:ss:'s«:*§;:m«:1'1§T cf' U1~'£)a:1 §£i§}(i'»v_§j€i:'i3f§}'1SE1é1.5gI" %
and Sr} E%ri1:z&n<i Pa;§'2<:F2a§g:a:fif%:v,.._ ;i:3§r1';.e§{i"'--§::;z_;;T;s;a§
w_%'; has fiizid §){>x&'€§f"' in 21
1"61s&t.6:{i C{)I'}i.$iE'}.}1'§: §)§§iLii§i§}§fi{._ " to §}:i§<I€
rliztéxze an
' .%§}§_é:%j; ,_ "§:Ei1é;:*.._ 'E,-:f:ajI;:$<i';s";t: {if the Eearrsftci
cgmgzsfiig a§$£<;.. Eazgfigcé'é駧§;E.imti:>:':s am},
{'.im 4g3.§'§g.:{_.i?:<?::' f::.%i' 1r':t:;§k§;*Ti1';g.
_ . {};1 §'1€'§§3.,i""§§§g Sri Jaga.diSE": §3atiL Eésarzzfiii
'c{;%;::.1f::"sé':§ 'f%:3:i §:.?:§é: appfiiiaxzig 3?} As;§h}?a_;39&<, 3fia}'E'}€'§{§
§s;{?s3§ 121:3' "' "r<::::<,E:=:mi:1 .330. E anti 83% §§:'§.z1a;':<§
,§52§{E§§fiiT:§1é;§§i}?;.E§'§3§ ieaIm--':<i: a:{§a:::$€:%E f{}£' ré33p€::§{i€::§':f, E\§':"3 §::;r é:<mt:i{}::af§0s11 {'g:§;§_:'T:_zi_§;§£>::2: am $25: §'a{::<é vahgéi é;¥.E'1€.'§ czmsigsxié: :§':€:%
-4-
aieiay. Appiicatizm for {i:ispe1':sat.i0:3 is 3130
1'd.$I"€:ci.
5. We haw taker: up the appeal 'i't.§%;&if --
be €:X3_I"I"1if.l€€3 on merits.
6. End respondsnt. fa, _ 2 '$1-argi
par€::icipaied in thc; zg,;1ctiQ1;_..sg;2;i%:_ '(}i,'nE1..<i'3(')1'1:Tl..(?;I'VA.f;:§'I*t'{€,
Conductad buy the $1" '$136
City sf Belg.'g33_1j11.§' and had
Gffered 11": respeci
Gf a E51G't.~~vi*E£2.2655 measuring
40 'x6@ «if: Erxztensien
araa, Be1ga_=,L::::, '.!;'i"A1'c?m:.»"{::1i§'cle1" had e:i€:p{_)$ite«:i 1/4311 ("sf
?';i"3.,:'}f::' zzzlzciizfiig----E11' E{%i'11'1S of iiha r1{ii£i€)I1S GE'
I .m::::%:a;+;%;%'am~:~::%en: 'E1315: earlifir EMD Qf Rs. 1,938!-;
appaars, 'béfore the formal
agcsfitauice of the affer, the Ce:::*p<;m'£ie:1 had
' '~c§Eb"i:':iz:e{i I"i$3€SS&I"§:' apprevai ate, Thfi {',a?p0:'a:i@::
~~-rieaiizefi $313.: Sargfsa pari: af {ha site haé bear:
e:r:£::*(::ach§:i upm'; and wirlaé W33 3'€f8,i}.éib}€ £2)? baring
Ezaliétieéi every {'5} 'ifizi ai2C§.T.iG§1 §}3;E.;{'{3§1&S{"3i' wag 9:23}; an
@/
arcta :}'1s:::3sst_:1'*ir1g E5380 $q.fi.. as agaézzst. =24{}{} s<;,fE'
w'hiC:h was p:£'r::«p<)$e::i for a11ct§<3:1 $33.3. ..
8. In Ems V'_i(3W of the z11at.ii¢3?;_ '§?§§: : ;. '
{;Zo1"porati{3r: §:<:aled dozarxz tfiéi
gm;-*.«t«3131e by tht: azictien ;):H'c11a§:%1' in
the area wi';i<:}'1 {E15}? azv'e1'é§V__ §1*::r:§«:a§§=
2.3.1161 had <":aT§£@d t_1;;;01_1. the Vf1;:).!Y.§V9rV}A7<':L£f1;*'::"s§1' "£§f:;3Q$ii$. a
'tjaiarzce of was the
p'rop0I'ti<)':1ai;_6:4 .§;G5?. féfi L;$f' {S"8:£I5 sqft at
the rate as' 'f.};¥.€:;:",-?i1sAV3:{:'.{:fii'£:3:£rl gaigrchasar.
'f'1.E.\":':I'f.(';%~f"§l@'€V:ifA',A V3130 c§:::p9sit;€:§;§ {E16
:3Mz':1=:;11f1%:VV:<'3:""; »'%«1::.;;.'i'4 can 1'*€~:a1i;:i§'1g that, v;};a'ii
has-3 _ 'b§:e§T:"--«g§'g*#:;:§ ':E..r~i'=:ni~;'ss:31' in ama ?_.E'}£E3'} 4€)'X€:a{}'
$i€.e':t~i,. EE9:0' anti met: if 3 issgar area. it is
$31 t§':is%r;::':t€x€'., {:0:'1s%.é€:'ab§t3 {iOI'*£"€ZS§€}E"}.€i€:':1"i€€3§ anti
..s€:*s€:":&§ ' :§a<.:°€§:;p:':1e:':t$ hag: taken giiaaé am aiga:
1::2§;.§:.':~;€ "fern" E:Z{§ga2;§T<3;'1.
mg'
{Ex E53 il«;1E& to p:'<}vidz::j "a.,T
8:';1a}k3r Sim EC} {hit :3.u(:':i<:.m §3a_1rcha$e1' "
ihfj g,:«2'<:p<::s:;e<i Sifiifi 0f :31"; arfia cf 24€)0_ 1
Ilfiéiiiéi an aitxssmaiive 0f1"€~:r of _
N().;78 121% zrzeastnfimg 1f?'?f 5
vs:-orkeci out i.<:« an extra
was actzaafiy ;:3vai}a1'£;§:E_:E§':«in far
2%-*hi<:h an a:110t1:1i_..}:2V;§:_~7.V by 'iirze
€3:):'pa:r3.ii'§;if% j§§§%s"'g;cid.i:i3:1a1 arazi
0? 9:3 03%' a 313:} Q?
1333. §g}1E1'€3§1a;':§(i3.E' paid ihia
z"=3._r:1<'2zfa':é'§€--. ' :;2} :§;{§; §;.3..§.§§§s E3131". g-ffig
:;§;::§%.f£;§i.::;;3z;2'::é13:":.~ §§_i;<§. vzmi. fiiiéi fé"i'i?'{}{1§' $2;-'§'§37': Eiifi
.f${:~va:i:9:";:j7:.;'gtzgéisfg: x%,:E:<:: €§§Sé3;.§}f§_£_}}"{}'\?€{Ti Qiffi :~;a:':3§:w
'V E: "E€'Z%_::+': {§<}:'§}<::*aé:ia:1§, ii; ap=paaz:'$, 2*':a.:§ maiisé
azé .s"3'},Q%:é%i*i1:ai:i"%,I:$%.éri.z1g E8553 $<:;,§%.' :«::a;:h a€;§<§§;:}g 233;} 3,1': aéé R";
2?;i}€f} ${';.E'§,. é:1i"i{i Ezaaziy :32": ¥:.§"::%::§:2:§
:2?' 2523; :%3§s:.;,%'_'¥.T ai. €133:-1% {2Lii'§"§'"':3§;i' .§5.:a§.'}<::::%. §'}E"i{.T€f <3'?
33.,
?€:%.2'?{T::;5 pztx' S<;,.§":, ¥i'}':i{§§f§ v.;<::'*E<;e:<1 'ii: (3 §;:i2i":; <3'?
E€:T~:.8'?',?ii%iZ§/'-v, in $,£i1'§.;.3.:~; (Bf KS <::2i2:.ma::":i€a':§<;m ::iajE;<:<§_
2 i§.4;;Z{'}E/3?, i':{f)p:S;' §i}rc;<,iiai{:é:<1 223- é3";:":%:;<::..21:'c::--1i} _?:_i:;§"'é;§:fij; ;_.
ix-«?{*§'{. peE'i€i::}z'L Ei: i$ :TET:<»::'€af§r::*, fiiéi
;3:T:1*:::}"1a$e:'*, ?:)}j3€>-3Q:.ii§'*-.,__ AA
igad Céilififiii issufi {sf i:~:ga1r:<;«tice {i?31Zét;§L V14; ;v"?.A:;§§£)4{}V?
{<::e:::«pj; prQdL:€é:(i as
(;'i0r*p§_;fi:.'z,g t.E'1e:" area 9f
32% sqft, 13-'-5 her at the
tizzza Of'. .1.;§§13 %t anti igziiai {ha
'§{:§'p€;:*z;t€i:3:1 381$ sziazséigi :1: regpect.
sf 2 EEG s::<V*;V»:*V%.§;*c?:%V<~E,Vw".§ $aa§:'§ ivme piets.
1:. '.E'.Ei'1<a"%;i"3§:;§:'§:;<3;;*a¥:,§c::=z";., bafiag mat. :x.2ii}§z'1g, E:
I ;:3;§':a§:'{«32[3:5'"$,'*Eiéagi =€:ma3€:+.:i issue sf ax: ::§E;ima.'§u::: i.s:;~
::"§<:*é.':g'g'i:%é:}3:1<i_;e::i':{%'€'i__%f'.-é'éc:.i2 a}_::j;3Fé$i1{:g :'e$§}0:":c£€:I1t, 2%,? "E2133:
:1§ii€:s'3 {E13 anzmzm as §..i':€ii.€&'£€:€.i in ?C.:"}$ii" {i8;{'§§.f:E'
V"_033::§;:3.*:3.:':i<:a.*€§:<";:""a z.::':.i§a:*::' _z%:§z:1€:xu..r€--1} ES gaizi xss§;_'{.}":§;§;":
V. 3% §:_:r"::E':é-3? §:£".::*i<";{i': Qf E3 {E3553 ;?':'<';:11 2€§.'"?;2€'_'§£}"?} {ifitzéé
a§'i.e:'§"2z/3§%z«*<:: égiétz z2§§.<}%ii::$<E wiii be C8_ZE{'3{i§€"i§§ gala? fiifi
V
M3,.
az11:;n_mi. ;'°e:{:ie§v€<£ <'§u3"i1;1g au::i:_%.{;:12. Saki wiil ';;€%
1":2fm1(i§2z:i t
12; E: is Eh:;:re:af€,:,::*j€ "§.}:'g»'; ._fi:E:'_3':1g_ @§3';?.i_i A f
.§3€:'{iiti{){i. .'§\§Cs6 E2433 1/2E'}{]'".7E
E3, in {$16 wgij ;_}e§i%§:;§.€'f:*.i}i:a Eez%1§i€é Sfizigle
sfizdge, aftar .r:'1z:3't,i<:i:':1§'s:\'2::'<;.%;i directaci
ihe C@11:0:3:i§1;_ 2 siies fiach
'£i}.€*§3iS3.1Fi1";£g" i;}%§i,i:ir;1'1é:1' is canisnt
§;s;i1'"_}"}V W16 A it ;z11easLu*i11g 30 'x4€§ '
a1i;:e:i i':3fé.::§_:<'§ .aI110'2,:3:";:{1 witfiz. §IiiiZ€3I"ffiS§;
fiici, _v V % ' '
1EL,$ar:1es:;i Sixzagle aiiiéigii 313:} €;éiresE:€:ai {$33.1
3:1 23:63 22;; "E53 248$ sigft. can zmiy
beééézé; §:E§<3";§31'i{:{*: 222.3 haai been aéfsraé by the auatisn
H "gx,2;:f;iE:$;s€:" ggmi my: ever and a'Qve that anii {$11}? if
'A '$1115 a:2{:i.i:2 pur¢.§1a:~;:€r x-aramtsd a sité isiggfir §;:E":a.§';
V' 4€}'Xé3{E',,. far {E252 asiditrimaa} area, <iif.'%'m:*$I2f{§ai (tag: ag
is a§:;;§i<:aE}E:: at 32$ aims-3 sf sue}: 3;i'z<)im€::':§ ,z:::--3;§.,'* fie
' "3.s§siz5::;i.
#9..
$.33}. E? if-E} agg§'%¢:*»;::?::;§ §'}f§£ fizia §:'€,i€:1" aiaimi
}..¢'§.';;Z{'}{}8 passeaii by fiat: Eizamaééi Singiéi Jtizigfi
ifiguing 323:1': <1ire{:ti:'at.i£:£:. T
£63, we §"':21'e2'<5: haara Sri. J'aga_E'£iSh.._:fE?fi'éiE,--A
1<:€;z:"§1ei*1aii{;$f;%.._ {M
ami Szé Sxiinaxxéi PaC}1C}iR§Ii1i7§§j, 1eé.:m é<1Vc0€;::é§::£.._§;;:'_.3
I"€Sp(}1"i{i€I1i7 Nmnz, an the 1"i1f3_1f§;_'€S:».{;}f'7i;§_"3fi3' :'i2:«:11:':::_:x _3
1?, S1Eb11'E§SSiQ:"} :32?S'i:€fi';§:;zg;-agiisfg.fiézttié is that
'{l3s:3::~:._ iii -2173:} '7'.€€{}5%;fi{§?. &§{ai§§b1€ at 313 aviti": the
C€}I."§}(}i'E§;E%fZ)§j'§ a::é"c':f§'.::7;;s:f321$} ii. is 3.13:) dfi.'§'§.:::%;:i{, is fi_:';<'§
%:é§':T:s: §§:s:a2.s::§'i;':g 3{}'§<:4i7}' 2:d_'§a;c{i;':%: to 0:16
. 'a;§::;:':;§:é:%. .gé':<.,i in thifi viéézv {:5 iiiééi 1:1a%:.%E.::=:~:1.. {$16
~{i€;--:i?p§i*a2;§%ii£%:1'T;; i.§; :,,2§1a,§':~§e £0 =:::mg3i_},: with the
:i.iz5{«;::%%i':§;'2L34'0f 322$ itzarfieéi Sifigk: Judge, 62%;": if it
2 .. wag éiiééizzazi 1:} Cfa;iiz2;',::§ §}f»f E223 §'2;:§§35 am'?
§"{?:§3;E§?'&§:§§}§"}§ azizii 'i'§"ii3fa'€':E§:{'§i'§Ti, if im: 2;:3Ez}*£§::€.§'fi'. i§" an
w}_{}..
g;2.<;§€iiti{::I:a§ aysa IE3 0133;; as 9:' 1202-365, then, it
§Z'i€'V§?f3;bi{i ti}.-23.: the {3@r_p0:"at'ic3I1 has to re:<:0¥<-:1f
pfiifé for the aciditiona} areza at the ""
and 113:: at thtf: Mia as ff€~:re(i ms. 2;f_r:*; s;>«:::f:.*1§:}§'1r.':VxVéj;»
in the year E985,
1.
9. E’: is pairzted
w%’ziWI3 :0 the auctimz
;3s;;'<:§'1a§Sai:% agjtfi §;1EH'CE3€iS€:E" E"2;.3Ta3r 3.3%: gsrica prep<:=;*iiz:é.1'":a§{~': ii} i'E':x:
,' '§"'€.{i'§,:{T飧.. g-22:49:33 :12? @589 ft. £31433: anzfi zazzi, for 2<i%~{;3i3
~Se{;'§.fi:: é3;2;»::'%I"_~2':,§"1?:=:;.§é:arr:t%<i Sirzgia Jzxige fzaci pmcesaééci
9:": a;T:"_&?f<;:':ea1:$ assmzigxtimz 'that aha auctiezi
" , §;§;§E'§:§"i3QS€EI' hat? a};*&a«:E;§; paid the price far an area
if '2?Ai+f}€} gq. ft
2%}. S2fi}:2':is$§{_}:'} E3 :52» b:fi,E'i:'*t:$$ {$25
az"gi3:';::€::'1fi. 'i§';.3;i' ::{}:vp<}z'*a;€i0§: <::a:: e:§&f'111§i,eé}; zctzezsvar
wgg-
{E8 gf§)§'”i{§€T f<)§" "E31:-i z:;.{%<§ii.§.{'2§"1ai area {}"Jiff£" zmzii é1E?(}'i?€3
Eéfifé r:~:€;,fi& vg%':é3iE:a.{e'::2" at '*{i'}€3 {E;:<:.:1 i'£-';'i"i'.%? <3? at
f31'Et:§f3I'3i. raté.
31. Sri Aiiiiyapali, V–i%’:ia.’:rm:d”.’ g5′?1€jiA{3;vi’*L_§-:3V’:’_;.3;i~
“§2>v€~:1’z:11}.€’::1iT Aciv<3;z'<i:%:;S *$.%:m"1;E_?ii'-.V V'
':36; }'}aE:§Sf§d an €}'}£': ::1eri'£':s ;3§:a}§
Sfi §73a<:§':¢E:a;§;§if::, ..V_§:;§:13'1S€§ §fi);;:§:€:z«3»:'i1T;g
f.A2.. gzliaiiiits
i:%’za.t wiifiiifi ‘ V’ “§};{*{;§pa1’€d :0
rsicézzsii:c..V.g§.?’§.£%::A:_:%;}%§ 4 ‘bf the COI”§3(3I’£fili€3}1
s:§r,_’ 133;” sits E’:’2é3as:.31.’i1′;g 2 EGG
$e;,.fi…;« i§§*z4_ g2″evVi§’ as w’§u::;t.i§E€a”£;io§1 ii”: caiiizzg
1.:«§i§<};'1L'~:"eSpa;é§:::;§::;f;_E[ E'€&2 {.0 pa}? far E115 a<i:§1i$:2 $9 $316
$?:§E:2§3′;:is;$:E{§1′::; af i;%”::i ‘i>a:* ami p€r:,i$é?d fiifi ;3ap€:rs.
&/
-13″
£3. Vviaikz it r:’;.aj_; be :3 fa<:€: {i'1a!; EEK:
:€§E°}}€}1§'éfiE.§;0I§ £3 f0t.::1'1<ii ii': 111%: imeriviable po$iti<_§"£'1V
flzéég 3._<:2Eua1£y E"';axzi1':g 3. 4{)'x6£)' Site x§*hi.ch"_\éf:}i:"3; -I~ V
a3.£ott.€:«f;f.i<):';'
Etc; abfiie the di,:*&€:¥"is.:m.s isszzrsfi by %}9ii$ :~
find 'i::ha*i:, with r<::3;30:acia2::f '?'§g} .2 VT%;1a%§%i:'1g
aCc:<:1;ri; §v'::';'i'} 3 Sift': ;;1eas11f§;£fg». :3,;1.._»§:xi.é:':E:.:s;:}f
Sq.i'£,. and :0 a::<:€:fi}f:-gize u $.ii:€$; put
t{)g€i'{;}'1€}:' EI1€$3.§3:£iTT§f1g <g§;i;1%0rati0I1 is
I'E:1i€V€d pf 331:3: a site
111easmii’i;{}1
2&3 ” _ §”§<;sire:%;s=:%:'; 'Ea [EbII1i.SSiOI1 {Bf Sri
'Pa{§E}f3§'}€ij;)E3;1'fi;,A i€ai:*:':€:'r:i <:<3u:1se}_ £232" ragpamiezii N92
.ii.h%§f égifié: €'§_}rp<22"a:i<J:: <::a3"11':o'£: <ie1I1a:r1é 02" slfisigt.
.§mi';"§;3£;:"t$~s'{3»c3f;<ié11'€. E€<;,2 its pay E321' me a{icii'§.i<::mai
azfia aif :f:f:::-5' ::m*m.z1t marks: price is égéiiifi jzzstifieii.
n'¥?:–'§ 83:37 39 far {E23 magen 2323?; it wag $16 mistaééa sf
'"V.§§::é a':0rps:;:'ai§{};:1 £2': i:'2<fie:a'£:E:'::g {hat 2:: :~;i:':22E}t:i' exteizrai
" 'is; é"55'sJ"£1§i8?I}i{f w§r.1ez'sas, WEME, 213:': bees": zzizfifiaci aria:
:4:2.:€_:E.iem:{§§ zmfi biéig were :"§:a':ei:.rt:<;i was in r”32
§}EiE””{3§fiaS€3E’ as$1m’1;iI1g ifzad a{:::s&2;3E:.€t§ {Ms <3§;E"§;;5-'=4-V ~
0111}? {4{3':r;6{"}'} :anea.$':,1:":1':g 2211": arrea <3?' .1:<:'1;'fj:i1;;*':4~;:
of the (3€}f§1II1i1Ii§{3éit§'.i0:'}, £:0z";fE:*I:1:§5.i'i§ :5:
aC{:s:p§.i1'1g {E16 hid far 3. arcga {pf :&I%f.§k, fg):§:*; .
2-'%1mexu;7e-A ami Ehai. bi:3.»:iS""L'$.i:E:Vf:.::é a;uc:i'<';f1
fin' accefstifig tfiiaé €X§?'§:}T1i r:ifv}é::1f1aI'1:"5éiVV:;A3{gVAf'0:' a
biggar Sim as the au§;;t§{3§.1A".:_ paid this
2111191121: 9.5; find 110
jiiSZi§§C&1ii:'}_§1 f;heT tg,i1ctio:1 puzrrhasex'
ti) ggag-I 1 -aieiat fhrfi present rate
£231' E11716: a1iC?i0§T£ pz_:r<:has€'r
paigé 'fahti §'u}i"';3:fi{$~:2 fig?!' 3 Siilfi 9? tin: mtzasurtzxiiemfi,
i:§%fi:j: Sqfé. anti had aim paid {he Cost fag'
~*%3i: ..:e1££§:};:%§:i'aif121;t;§iérea cf {-35 sqgfi: in the yam' }9§9, SQ
§i1'1 €:'v8Q¥§E{3{iGfi §}'L1I"Ci"i&S€I' has 113%" basil handfiii
" magi' pésgessiam iaf arxjsr site anci wkziie £323 31125311:
Aiigggqiéi by {ha 3:::€:§;i@z"1 pm":::ha$€:" is Eggixsg with {£33
'{:01°§:G:'a?z.i0:':, 21:} §[}€"3f3;€I§.$, has azzcruegi :9 {E16 a{:c'i':.;'§.Q:1
;;3:;.:°sE':a3€::
$14′
26. in the {I”i3′(I1.{i1″1Si”.€:i1’i{:ffS, we <%<:€::':'1 ii:
§;:»1"{};:s<:1* to aikaw Ehiae app€:a.i €:1':£3r ta} {I36 é«';;5;Lr.V§_::'2t_. T~.._
§:1:}dify"ii':g {Em czrfiez' jpasisfsd 1'2}: E}';<~: ic:a1'r1r:{1'§V._Si:;:§:.i,'<j: ' ' V
Jzzdge 311:3 {'i§§"'€C7EiE"1g éihe £3org:;f ig’.Zii11:}1f§Sf_E(i in
:3s54g;?gnui10§6&fg$(a§h¢g$§§§ybu:hy(guy
eiramng 113;*:{:>::_ a§;1é%i0§§ pay me
i§§f§€I’€I1C§:-3 “i::: -.;fgé7¢ 29 par Sqft
fin? “jv$<:;,f'é. whi<:.h £>ss:~:ssi.r;>11 Qf Ehis
€<}r;i:,€::"':%: a?'~_§.a:3.:}, a.:'1a:~<3{::u%.:+3eal {iiSp§S€€3 {if a<:c@:"<ii;";giy_
Sd/~
JUDGE
Sd/~
JUDGE
§Z%.§{'2?