High Court Karnataka High Court

The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs M/S Gemini Steel Tubes Ltd on 27 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs M/S Gemini Steel Tubes Ltd on 27 July, 2009
Author: D.V.Shylendra Kumar Kumar
 WKEWW mwmm UP' Klfiliiwfiififififlfla Wiisifl KUQK1 U!" KflE€Nfl'E'Wa%% Mifififi mmm W?' imsmmmm mam 5.;§§nI.5*%s§€'/-:1

en mwwmar mm" a'amMuwm.<s.MmW« WEWW MWWWQ. My  

.3.

 

E4 THE Efi CQIERT GF KAm¥i&'I'AKA. AT 

Dfifffl Hfi TI-E 2'?mBfi.Y $3' J¥.3LY fififi

PREaSfl'3T

Hm I-if.)N'BLE nmamnm mu   4%  3 '  = T 3

Ag . .
'I'I-m;HQN'ELE ammnw   1  
I'l1'.et!,E'-Et.av§.;é;_iV':?'._';;%"._2;)'*_Z¥*;_'4«;¥§   H N
BETWEEN:     X
1.

mg c:mmgen¢%a£[:;mm;m>
c.R..Bu:?1§:ng, * %

Quems Rifififif 7§
Bm1gs§¢::Ie7._ %

2. The Assi. Cz:::2$.:*§:i3sie§:.:;r”:§’f?f3ii2£§i§t1§c9»’§’a.~:$
Circ:§¢-42(1) X
_C.R.E;:§_;ifi£:;;;.; ”

A. …..

‘E§:gIe:lQ;’r;:,_ mé§§e£§$:£$.

L (By S§i;MT§T§?§A Siméirg fimzggsei fa: fiifi Revazue}
‘ ” Siefii Takes Liéfi
T ?1€}i m .9;x*e&

‘ 4. §v§€%§33gk.::r§ie;– ~ ‘
‘ agigalfirc Rumi Digmlfit.

_ _ _ Rggganémw

$3§#$1¥3!E¥0E

” ‘E71233 fzzcemg Tax égpgfieal £3 fiizé mm 25%. aif LT. égfi
£961 aism em asf {Em awdw éfieé §§–ii-»§§§? gzgseé £3;
IIf..A.?€ag934iBNGf2§§59 fog” the Asgeammé ‘fag 2§§3~$é

wnnwdriim VnuiV:nna9’VoaoMilVhM “°v\fl’%4 iTE\&¢'”W\$’Wai§’0kJ””I¢.@nW”‘WLI”$h£”‘[& Efififififlfi %g’§mfilmflfl’Q,_fi

-~:-aw

%w\mmVud”E-“VAL ‘4n4″$t flwr%I1’\sv”€=2;5J'”0.érJR””6m’~z.v#!”‘a axliifivacawma wtwwvwxmw fawn: mm:-wwa.u-was-mnw-mung:-as

.2-

praying ta (5.) fcrxmulme the szzbaiméiai qugsuimzs sf’.
therein (ii) alkrw {ha wpaai am sat aside aha mV§§;;t’z»;p*a$§;a<§. by
aha ETA'? Eangaiorc in I'1';%..E*$a3m§43fBE*§€7%;v'2¥Gi'?vaf§ji,*-.. égeg

§i.1i.2§£3'? mnfirm £11: arécm sf the A.§pi§Ilfl?;é;~._;i'»7£*3i$1,!ziiii§£i:*§i:§x"
aszé ecnfizm the erdar gassaé by .i,h;e_-_ Asst! "i_f::;:i%;.~::i;~":%f:§:«3;::a.#v_ 55%'? _

izmernc tax, Circic -~ }.1{2), Bm%a;iare,_ ' 3

This Irscnme Tax Aggggéaaé mfiééfifig 33:
day, SHYLENDRA K.UIviAR–,.,§';;,é£}i&*c:¢hé;i§1é',f€:=§§§?i%: – '

msughggm gaggggan af'
Ease? my Safiiéma 2531:; $2' $225

a, Aaiéaréfiss were mrrggi
"fie smpfiyeeg $&§:2';**§éz¢§§2§
%s;mra;gs1 W P}? is an aifimmék ggémzm

.i§z S颣2"$:: 53$ fif zfzé féfiff aafi 523;:
;a2§§i:2.;a:i canes}: be éfimiefi as" $2 ifimggg 9}" fie

M§,§3%e;éxee 23?: fiaeardarzse wizié Secfigpg @553 {mg

' Sécfiasg 2524} {ix} aj fig gm? £3: aséasg af ééé

1' jzadgmaizf {sf 2&9 52%;: iéfs .Ez"z?'g'& Sag': §f
Karmfifia in A55. Saéari §rz£§3*§s*:Z§§§ 52% I23?
14}; as fie ms? amawifi was §?§é'§§§ azfilar 3%?
spaagfigd "figs §a£g.s*"?

–am-«:wwrm.u 2…» gs:«v\icmmV£&'”‘:sm.w'”«n’amr'”m. nmrnuwvuyg; mmwwmm mfg a$&m%§m§%mlmmm I-Hg’?!-.3 “WWW?

wdkvnwwwvamm

‘mwnwmmw ‘Mimi .!a(“o#””ewMw.-‘eimr’mm#”*&uwa'”n auwwrflki “k:l|*w|’wzt|’§’9s|E warn 9<vwa'"mwAmIr\'un"naw'w.ii*e.aru

.3-

Sri: Seshachala, leaned Stmding Cami §pe%33;g f’§;:.__
E116 agapefiaxiéfi fmxiy szzbznifitsi rm giznifim’ qz1.$3§%é§%;§’§7.;’a;%5.¥§;V”. :
hm: mgwemd by this fisyzzré iizg §;Se’%%¥e~:*:*:i:§;v u 2

case sf mzmwssianim $3′? E”;£?’€;?fl::9i¥}9§§§;v 1*;;a;xsf’°:;%;g

szamm R3E$ é§§ic1ed ‘e;; V M3i;93.7@2:’;%:}*,%””
ITA.Z’~§as.iQ8′}’ mé 1$8;:S§’2.G{3锑é%_§»=:2i9§seé; is; t2?§§.,»§;’§% Eaéi
which cage has ‘Mm Erie ihig Cam:

mam g

~13. 9%” £3353.-3 €aur:, this
wpéai’ is the gmafian agfi ‘East fizz

% ‘4 %%%%% -4 .:

1′-Edge

S4/a’
Iudié