The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs Shri M J Ramani on 25 November, 2009

@¥
:5 ?EE gzag cam? Q? KA§fia§gxATg§ a&§§g§$gE
$&§E§ TEES gag 2§% 3&3 SF fi$¥§$§éé; é駧f¥_
§EE$$§E__&   1'. u
$33 a$%§§LE fig? J§§?%¢gjKf;;-g$§§%§$$Vf 
 %§§ 2 ._ V_ . _ 2
$33 gsfifgagfxg, §fié§:cg2A§§§:$§_%§EAR
zficaxgv%%x-A§§§g§*§§;é5§!2§a?
§§§£EE¥: '"   2  .V"
:3 fhe ¢¢$gg$%;s§§§F$£ ;§§§§§;§aK§

fi 5 R  g   ggvéé F
£a§§aiaye*7  ';'

2; Tfia §mi2:'§§§;£$§:@fiar cf
:§c§§h?ax;"$;rél$w§{l}§
§»R*E%iidifiggg§fi§&n3 Eaaég
%g§gfigg;a:a, ,* &§?ELL§?S

"-_w fifiy fifigmaata $r§sfi5?$$§gh&mhaia§

  .

fi»§»§$fi§fii;

:=~:a.;:§«;.,, 1% Eviaslrz Raaé,

* x,?a$:§tha Eagarg
‘Vvfigfigalarawfifi. ,& §§§§%§§E§?

{E3 gfivaaata Sgig§$§ax§ha$axa%&i}

§hi$ Efigfimg ?aX ggaai 1% fiiiafi afifiax §&c.E§&
Gf 3:? £3: ta alias? the a§§&a1 and get asiéa tha

W

A
Ex}
0

axéez yasseé by tha E?é§, %an§ai@xg*.in Em&
Eiaxfi-§Z§_,fEa1*1g;”;L”2§§% dateég §¢.1′:52§§§ $oz’:f.:;:r:;’ai§3§’ tfzaa
azfiax §f the: gggallgtef fiammisgianer”aafijgaanfirm
iha Qzfiez §as$ad§’b§ tha ésgt, $@%§x$$i§a$r_ af
Eaaamfi fax; §i:ei@w§{:}; Baaga§§€a; ‘-in ‘ the
intexegt af jixgtice ané e@1i.ty¢ = ” ”

This &§§eal is aaming’ ma iifiz .£ina§, hfiarifig.

this flay, Mfifififififfi g. daiifiatad the £allé#:g§;u

Revenge &ag £:i&§ t§:$*a§ea; ahallanging tfie

Eegalitg amd,c¢zz§§§ $fL$fia&a: %:”af thfi tzifiunal

in :3; §§;3§:§}§;g§§ée$é¥*aateé §fi::w2sa§¢

2$ ?h&,sa%s§a§fi1aig§m§§t:mn$ Gf i§w axifia :3 this

a§§¢§;,ar§”$g§ii3$ ta 3&9 fiukstantiai §ua$fi:am3 sf

;a% ééafiéfi in ETA 5§§!2$§é digyafiefi af am

*g$;:::é$§§fy” fie havfi di$§$s&fi af :§g §§§§§§

§a§a§§£§§3 the matzax fig afia figgasaifig fiffiflfii

.°g é;$g§i:§g fiaw the afigessmfint has ta Ea §a$§&fi in

駧§$$t af the« bmilfiéag in qaagtian, Zn this

‘ ‘wa§§&aE alga tfia ggbjafifi matter ef tka psagfirig :3

the game grayrty ifivfiivefiia Efé fifiéffié,

3, acaarfiifigiyf ifiia pyaal i$T all®wé§ w::§aut

an$wer:§g’ the gmbgaantiai q§a$:i§n3 ‘§f z£awi%;g

rafianfiimg the mattar ta t&$”§$$$$$in§ $§f:§e$,§é£x

fzagh aamgifigratimm :3 ‘:§e ‘ i§g§t_. §§W V:§% A

afigarvatians afia fig &$Vi§>:€A.$$§f§§,RVW

$535123?