The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs Sri M J Balachander on 25 November, 2009

,3′

:§ $3 333$ aama? ay K§E§§fi%E%%f_$$§§§L§§$
fififgfi ?§E§ TEE 2§” fi§§ G? mav§E§§§;j§§é§fu’_

§£E$$§?'”«
TEE gaafgag ER, :§$§§$§”§:L: §a§£§§§%§ ‘

*g§3

Egg §$§§E§§WfiRw&3$$f:fi§H§E&¥:§§”?fi§%R
Efififififi @7fi &§§§éL fie §3§f2§§?

§E§%EE§:

1% ?he $¢mgzgggg§§g,§§_::a¢mew%ax§
fi¢E;3Q:$fi§$dg §u&é§3″§Qa§,

E3n§aE§:g, g

2; Tfia Jm:mtV€§mmi§$:amar fig
Zagémgéfagg Czrciewgizég
Vfi§R.E§i:d:§g;k§fiegas Ragfig
.ggamga3a:a, V ,. &§§§ELA§?S

A”,: {fiy fifivmaatfi $xi.§a¥;$&$ha$&a1a§

§§§;«V

§;§;§;;gc§anégz§
§m;:s; aft gain Raga;

. *.?a$afitha fiagaxg
V_E§x§a19:%~§§w .. §E$§®§§$§?

(E? &fi§§aa%a $zip$.§a§§h&§a§ath:}

Thig Imcama Tax Agpe&i is fiieé u§§g: $@a¢2§§&
Qf E? fit ta a&i@w tha aypeai afié sat agia aha

$9″

2
If»?

erder §%$$@fi by ta Efifif, Ban§a;§:& R;n ET&
§m,3§§§f§angfZ§Q?§§at@a 23.11.2§$§f¢en§;rfi;ag the
srdgz mf aka: éggallafl $ammi$si@ger»_amé,_éaafizm
the atfiar gagged’ by tha $s5x;.,§¢mm§$5i§ua§B_$f
Encmmfi Tax, Cirgiemfiéiég-. E&fl§§§§§%§ } gm j tfia
iniexasfi af jfifitiflfi afifi:@§fiit§§’g’AV ‘V ~ *

?h1$ ¢§§péa:T is ‘a§m:§§g an §§:; §ifi§E “%éa$im§
thig dgy, ERJEEAEE 5, @g1ivred_§he;§§;1mwing:

€–§,_..,§’_i.,,.$ %

R$v§naa_na$”£iE%£W$h§$)g§§éa: ahaliefiging thé

:ega:::y3g§§;ce$:éa: sf i%é §§§%§ ef :%e txi§umgi
1:: : ,L?.% §«ss:%;.,3§%.§§§£§£%§,’g§C?§¢- fiateé 23.1: gasga

2* %§g 3a§$tafi§i&i gfiestigag af Ea? axiga ix ikis

a§§aE &§é=$:m;ia: $6 :3 safistafifiiaé qgestiagg af

‘;*lgm_K§fi§m&fi in Efk §$§!2§§é fiigpgaé $5 ax

u* §%;ii:2§§§§ fig égvg §3s§$$%fi sf Efg §§€i§§

§é$ég§z§g” t&e maitax fig the éggafigimg Qfiiaax

“*fi;ré$€in§ flaw aha &5$e$§m&nt has fig % gagfififi in

A fégeafi, af the aiifizng in gmafitififi. Ea thia

agaai aifia aha gabjagt mattar 9% the grégari :3

tfia saga §rmpeXt§ immivaé in Effi §§5f§%.

r”v

e
3»):

e

3¢ gaaazégngiyg fih:$ gygaaé i$ aiiewefi. wgtfiaai
afisweriag the gafigiafiiiai qg&$ti$n3 $5 law by
:am&g§in§ thfi attgr ta tfia Afigagaimg afficfir fax

fragh $$fiSi§fi§&fii$fi in the 3:4

the

abgervatiaas mafia by aa in Efé §s5g§é;.’C=”

Sd/..

JUDGE