Between
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 27"' DAY OF NOVEMBER 2009
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. 13.13. DINAKARAN, CHIEF
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE fiB--YR:AR:}A§;A§D_YAA«'
WRIT APPEAL.NO.32?'7 ofizdagé {EI)AN_3EX)'~ A A
1.
‘The Di1’e(?t01’.
P1″<-2-U1'1iversi1:y I£d2'.:.c;z1t'i<n1e.""' = "
Sarnpige Road. A A
I8"? C1'(,)-SS. __ .
§\/Iziiiezshx-\.-‘£:11jan’1. _ ‘
I 375 iiAg2::}{)§i?:: .
2. ‘1″: <3 1..)_€pi..11'.y '§..)A'i~mAt.?t.(:)ii» 3..
Of P.ubIiC. 11'1si.1'*':.:t';:,a'c)A'1'ags;
D. K. NE’:-11’1§__1§E1I()3T_&’. . A A
;’A1E3y_ii.ss Di’I'(:2C1bI’. A v..APP££I.,I.,AI\§’I’S
V”{E3y’A’;’5h19iAAE3 \?c:.e1’21p13a. Ad(§I’U(.)I’1&.] Cv()’\=’L”.1″1’11I1{‘;’.1’1f” I’1c*:z’:1.Cit;é1′}
A.T\AfAD:A
j I. A f5h.£1;11i1’1 M0I121m1’1’1;Oi_..c1.
Sr_)__1″1 of M()}1am111’1e?(.1 M. P.
AA Agged 18Yea1’s..
‘$131126 Chandm’
A Sim No.1 12.
Kulai,
M211’1g__§a1()1’c:–575 019.
$
2. Thcs I-‘1’i1’1(“i})al.
S1..Al03,«-‘sii.1s (3<)11eg(*.
i\/I2.-111g.___§z.1.1()1″c. . . .RESI”‘ON I) ENTS
‘I’1’1is.s Writ Ap]..)cz’:l filed 1.111dr3r Scvt.i0_1iW4= .V(‘)–£_:_1}:,g¢f’
K2-11*1’1a11’z1.1<d 1'-'iig1'1 Cm1rt' AC1. g')1'dyi11g to :.set. z-';V:~}§ CAiL{ C.)1'f1z(Ei'~ ' V
132'1r–3sc:cI in 1'.1'1(:* Wm }'vI1'ti0:': N<).V}'5A82–7« £1§41(i
d£'i1'(?('1Z 22.06.2009.
T}’.1iS Writ. Appeal com1’11g -;._:’1’isv..VI_’01’ I-‘.1*cE1f11’1i1’1é.1ry V’i:i(‘_’.”‘c’i.’1~’~i1i’;_§ on ”
1.hi:–3 cizw. ANANI) BYRAREDDY.—=3;.”-(iC1iyc1’c’d’ ‘i–h.;-j §Q,1§I<)wi1'1g:,:~
'}'?1'£{ i.".1;.)1.)€a":V1V 'e:m11Vi'1'1.g'.'"’i: I131’ 1T’1’e1i1’11i1’1.2:1’_v ET{ea.1’i1’1g__§ is
I16;-1:fir._i–. ..
_V 2. ‘«.Ti’}1é’~–.Efi1’s1 1’c:=.es}:)c)11(‘l(*I”1t is a 5aIL1cEc1’11’ of 1’css]’.m:1cie1″1E’
1″..0.”2,r A «(;v<.».11c~geé \.v§':<T) \.»\-"as; not 1)c1'1'm'.t.1c:d :10 t.z.1i§r;' 1.1'1(','
ex211:§1§1'12=yi,i0': 1" on a.('C<:n.111l' of sa1":o1"Iz-Lgic of E11'1'.(?I'1C.i&?11"}(.T(?. The
"1*(%:sp<')11ci'é?1'T11. 112=1ci 211't'.(?:'1da-1:': <:)§' 7()*–E/fa. Thc-:.* ::1i1'1imum 1'(?q1,1i:"c:?c.i
"we-is"75'%/E). The" 16?;-11'1'1(=*('i Si:1g"le <..I1:Cig<1 on 221 s. had 1:)e1″1:1’1i1.1Cc§ 1’E’1(‘* pcIiti(.m(:1’ to take 1.110
{S
‘H
e>e::I.11111’111a’.1t.i()1’1 and had ‘cu.'<'t'11*<'li11_L_;'}y <'1i1'<-é('1.e(:1 1111". app<;*1l2111i to
2;1cc011'1111(1d211.<? the 1'c'sp<:11'1(rl<*1111. 111 the c:x:_-1.1111ir1ali01'1 111 J1.11'1e
2009 2111111 the pc1i'11'011 w;1s's (ii&31}()r~s€r(1 of. '1'1'1e p1'(?5.-3(.'I']i'. a.1')pc2.11 is
filed 111<*1*c1y 011 1..h.o is-{1*01111d i1'1a;1t the R1110 1'Cg;:11'('1i1'1g 111111-i":1j111:1'1
days of E1'l.J['("',1'1d£'-lI'1(fi'.(? bei11g;{ :;s11'i('?t1y aci1'1c1"c-1d 1.0
LJ11i\-'91*s1's11'.y, the (1iS('i§)1i11t" <1i'1.}1c B0a1'd \:m1.11d 11¢"af§7e(f1V'c7dM
the i111;')L1g11e.C1 01'dc:'r would (.'.1'e2.1tc: V:-i p1'*c.1'1ec1o:31'11_,x\?1"1itr1'1VwG2_.11E§..
be ('.i{'€C1 by other .<'5i1'1'1ila1'1_V 1)I.z1('£1(i :1a1.1:'z«vc1e'1-'11..<.% I1'}Eé.I'€"_b)_;'. ,1'Q1'1('¥_t:3;
1.1i;:-:~ .
the R1116? 1’eq1,1i1’i11g 2’1 1’1’11’.11im11n1’pé1=i_0(i of Jtgte11ciz31’1Ei’tf”1’11:1gé11.c11′”y ”
and 01.1080. 11 is this 1.:i1j1’t’1’1:1’1’s’t’2111.x;e i151″1.riHm.y.’:¥.112.11 the
p1′(:s<:11.1 appe;-.1} is filed.
3;.’ “E1165 ;;1_;>1.3«e.§11:1.f1¥1_ “<j_:11'1ai111y _§11ss'1if1'c(,1 111 co1'11'.e1'1c1i_ng
that i'.1'1c i_111'41.)1.1g,§1.'1cc1__ 0'1jdc-"1'… n1..1g11i 1101. to be ('1"11'1:s1'c1(21*c(.i 1-15 11
})1'<.;§('Tf'L"?.C1€f._I'V11. whic1'1" 'vss.}.1_m,1I.(:§ be z1pp1i<:c.1 r11e(.*hz11'1iC21I.Iy to €v<=;'1'y
' c:aSe or 111 the fI'1,I1,§.ll'C \.vk1erc? a .~;st1,1c:§v;-111$; has 1101.
.s:*('.'u1'<-.*(i' –';'–1jj1-1;? 1"c(:;111sit1'-I pv:~1'<.',c~*1'11'.z;1.ge of 1-1';'1e1'1(ia.11(%cr. Fix-*t=11
()1.E1C1'}x'Vi's.=_Ve.V 11 c01.1l(:'1 1101 be <"i11:'.(1i as 21 1.}1'e(*<:(1C.1'11. I11 z.11'1y
}::\'%'e~1.1t. £116. 2'1p}:)eal sat21.1'1.Li§5i.a <:)s(*d 1,11" wit..Ii1 111:? (11):111 in
/5