IN THE HEG'H COURT 01: KARNATAKA AT BAN'eg_;:x:§12
.DA'TE"ED Tms fmiig 31% DAY 0;: ]ANU.ARY_.A<"Zéf--0'7'; --
BEFORE
THE I-I.ON'BLE MR. I'tJsT1CErHj.N.NA:;;rxMQ1ȤA,i$: D.A'S "~ A
wgawo.28050/2o1 Q<L«;N"
DAVANAGERE; 1 ' " '
8 gr E312' §¢:?3:s;.f
. V,
(By ski 1v§.S.BH_}&'E;é{ffl §~.€UivL/§?{,v_'A.D\'.)
AND:
SR1 B..:DHANAPAj[A__:I{S'HA V"
" ASSIS'f'AE§$'I" STORE K.}ZEPE;R
._r<;.'s;R.'1'.C§, m.,V'AN_AG13:R':3 DIVISKDN
,.DA3,:A:x1A<;§4:;1::E:,..RE;3:zEsEN*r1s:D BY
B;D}1ANAP}§XI,A'.E§SHA, SECTRESFARY
Is:;sI<..1:fc: s';f_:w1? ;:-,NI:: "WORKERS UNEON,
; 13AvA3§;A;Q1:R:«: 'mv1s1 226 8: 227 OF
C:€;>'NS"1'1'rL,:"m>N OF INMA ?iR.AYIE'€'G
-~{:;R1:>I3:}%1
TO Q{,J';'\_.SH TH}?-L
IN 'I¢.I}l§.\J7C3.'}'8;'2{}G5
i)'I'.8.1;2.09 PASSEBD BY Ti"--I¥§,El PRES1T.3ING
}N"E)US'TI"RIA};g 'iE'RIBL§NAI_. AT 7f'i'I;3E3L§'.
This pse%;i€n;m. ceming am far pre1in1ina:'y"' hea_r»ii§g.z};é_TS'~
the com': mazie the 'f0110vv-"Eng;
OR D
II}. this writ petition {he ha; in
the nature of C€It§.G§8§"§. in
§.I).'§'€c>.78:'2005 passed by
2. Respvh3yee of the petitioner
C02'per3:i0n. 1C}:é1_..2Q.(3,2CO1'«erespendent was transferred aed on
the same he was"'vtelieV<efl' Linc} furiher he was directed to
.. V. 1"epo;"1:§.foVr 'duty' ai' transferred place %mrr1.ediate}.y, Accordingly, on
2E,.V6';?.OG-1_fespefiderzt reported for dllijr". Since no breathing time
\:v':1s»give:r1,"res;:$bI1dent ceuld 110%; hand over the charge and
V'-»(:0'nseqi1en£1yg he :e,porzed.t}1e same to {he cfpe.m31:y, tine respzmdent raised 3 (iiS}.31lf€3'"i'f)f&§1€iC}fi'iicyiiir,ii'
Court framed the foiiciwing issues adr tiie :.';:'ic?14';f'{1:ifci'fEii."' as defined.
}iL;t"i 947?
ii) Wiiicii the claimant is
K Board or Industriai
& under the Infiustriai
ii i
V¥7hei'EieriV§_ijg.:iain1ant is entitled to gez any relief
Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunai. Act
1 Articie 226 of Indian Constitution?
A =~i__v} '\i7\i'.iE.=:é§;i2er the r€$p<Jr1(§ent: FI1£1I}E}g€}"§18E1[ fig glzstified in
jiireducing the i}8SiC pay of {lie first pazty Ci.3im311E
irate two in i.r:cre1ne:1tai stages periiiaiientiy by its
{)1'(,i€;'I' ciazesd 303 .2{){}2?
'2?) Wijat créer?'
Additional Issue
1. X-'V"§1ether the en.q21iry held agaémt the i'i::;:..paft'§i'i:'$
fair and proper?
3. The Labour Court vi3§_e"a_rder c1'a1:é<;'.
preiirninary issue relating. to (iQ3a<:eA§tic"'-»enqL:iz:;,9am _:%.<«3gative.
Thereafter the respondent exa:r:i.f29q§' ;him'sTe1f 3S--W*\7v'.} and got
marked Ex.”-71 and ;§e:iiioi:efve:;an1i:ied one witness as
MW1 and ga:’:_m;::§1;;e§:
4. Tiie .I4E1¥1)x.(Vj’a11″>’C§J’;£;1~3TI’ CI} appreciation Of pieadings oral
afici {§.AGC1£§IiEE11ii’E%V_’g’ ev£de:i’::e p:assed the impugned award and set
Va3idé”tbé”51’riér.Qf penaify. Hence this writ pezitien.
V on recerd discioses £113: on 26.6.2001
resp’€;r1de.j11t wéis transferreci, on {be same: day he was refieved and
‘ x,f1§:rVLEn’_e: he was directed :0 report for d11§;y izmnediazely. In
0 Qedie:1cz3 if this COI”131″I18:1{§ the zesp0r:d.e;”1t regorted fa}: (§11E§:’ on
x *<»_…-
3»-‘””‘
r{f;?”
21.6.2061. Imn1e&éat;e13:, thereafter as per Ex.’W3, zespexfiergt
reperteé to $115 higher authorities stating that he c0u1§L…x§;;t,’:ha}.’;dVV
aver the charge since :10 breathing time was gi\;e11..tvf§_>”*V1?;§.:”:a.;:” Thié; ‘ ”
cannet be treated as misconduct on thé._§Jart- Qf’ ré’:~rpO:§.Cie1it’;Vi”-TheT A’
Tribunai on proper appreciation if {he eI1t’1’1=e evicIe’:}gcevv.:Qn_1jgrii:3rd
rightly cencluded that thgyresgoyzciezjtv-.h3sLA11:31: a;:’omn13′.t’§teé any
misconduct. This COflC1uSibf1.’_fj§ ;’Fré_};$i’1:1}:l in accordance
with iaw and thg.» is sfippgl/§.séd .011 record. I find
no }.1EStifi3;f)1€§”gI(§{j5;fl£1 itztérfere wriihthé sane. Accordingiy, the
wri: petititr: is. héreby’i§v;th0ut reference to respondent.
/W:
:z):I<i:;_ V