High Court Karnataka High Court

The General Manager vs Smt Janabai W/O Fakkirappa … on 5 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
The General Manager vs Smt Janabai W/O Fakkirappa … on 5 January, 2009
Author: B.S.Patil


‘:”e.<-§§'A §'a¥;::'2€} $3852

IN TKE HIGK C6535!' $5' KA.R1\E.%.'£'&K$,

CIRQEHT BENCH AT BHARWAB

fiafrfifi TE-IE8 THE 5% may 9? émfiggv, 2243:} .. . jjy..

BEFSRE

TEE HfiN'BLI$~ mR.JUs1*IcE.§,s.9;§f£iL

mscgagmmesa gigs? APPEAL §é;'2s55saz27sz:$ irggvfig

Eetween:

2 ‘E’HE1 GE:NE1E¥j§L saamaag . ‘ _
R§:?§:§2:$§:’:NTE:> BY saargvxséaéréa:,..;ir<?;§éf§':3;t;:,L;%:§,"v
§:3':€';i.C§&L3M. . ' .» 'V

2 mg DE;PE§*"?'?'°:3'§.T§\§i;§:Ré%E;§-I}{%iAN:"fa{3ER,
§P€TE§Néi;E%£$¥kIRA§¥5'{f;§§ . *
'§«:sm*%€’E7E%GL§,%ZE% E’%%E{i§R’%”{iE
§E§§.,£§éE§’%A ” ‘ I AP?EL§..@sNT$

saysri»¥-€«P%tii:?$§v3 %%%%% -A .

An§i’:_V » «’

» .3 aw: l§.AVf;:éé’%sgé’§.~vv. . _ 7 ‘ V V

V . £53; £3’ §:%i¥ §«:a:{§{:g?§A :~§.m=»sN:z<§:§§
;a;<;;§::25 yams,

, _ "~::;c::: €3:©OLIE

' " Riff: :'»ANTHABE:,K:jN:"2§;

‘TQ Am §ES’§’:E§§:L.G;’%.UM

§v§FA Z’€e.’2Q58S§2G*3S

3 SM’? VANMNA
2%; ii} ‘§”ANA£i DQNGARE
Aeaazg VEARS,
<::<::USEHC>LD WGRK
RIC} SH§.S’£’RE NAGAR V-

SAGAR €201,953? KOTRUS PESNE
STATE MAHARASHTRA

4 gm’ LAXME MANGAL _
we SIEDARAI Govg:<:AR = ._ _
AGE27 YEARS, '
<:<:: HOUSEHQLD :i.=2{Q1*%;<:,;*<;' Cs<3:{-M R0£s§_}'~
KANABARAGI TQ AN_Dj;~@Is:f:*: :§3RLG§a:}:»:%

SEE GUSUSAB I'viA.MM_§}SAB Ts'-f'?K'i:1TI' .,
AGE MAJC}§"€"C§C{',i E3US'DEi§VE}R.._ '
ego %e:SR{"E'{;"?;?}3.;?O'}'._, B.%'%f}AM'Ew
BEST:$;gg2EPUl§Vf_'.V_ – .– V % RES?(}!§1')E~2§'TS

U5

This aiépgal is filed, under Sectisn 17273 {1} of ME? Act
ag3i.t1$f- 1:i.1i3: éawészfd dates} 20.11.2953'? gvaaesed in
MVC E\§=:3;30'4Q/2906:'V0::–~._the€113 of 'ma E Adfifi. <;iivi1_Ju&g€
{SRDHJ éi:c;:;1VM?\a1Ai'3fF.V,A.Bt:Ifg1:aNun3., awa1fii:r1g a cemperxsatima of
RS.4~,i1Z: 1,030"; – 3i;*:%t}:1.':Lnt::1*<3:§t at 69/0 ya. {mm the {Eats cf gfifiiitifili
{iii éepcasit. ''

éifspsal coming an fat' grams, this (133: ms Cfiufii

de:3;_s;¢:re"c: _:;he"fg1:.qw;ag:

JU§G!&!ENT

‘1’}r;§-ire is 3 dfiiajg 01′ 28′? dayfi in fifing this appaai. E315

is iisfied for Grders regarding conéanatisn sf cieiay,

Havmg regard; is the facts anti cémumsiances of the Gaga

pa1°t3Z<tulafiy keeping ifl miad the fact that ii is a case sf (math. :3?'

;'v§§A ':'~3's3.2€}58$:'2{§%S
3

a breadwiflner in the family”, the matter is heard an m€fi’§s’a;;1:3,

‘ aim on fllfi prayer for conéonafz-£011 sf dfiiay.

:2. Appefiants am the Gcneral :?v*’£é11ager 4 V’

Gfirrzemi Manager of the State R:::.t:.$;i:1V

They are cha11e:11ging the judgVm§i;.f:_ a,fg3s2;3;;;£;b..}%:§.é1§3_:3′::si.1’§3′ thé:-

Meter Acciciexzts Claignés T:fi%:fi 1j11al’,” Bgigaum, in mfg:
N{).g3{}4Gj 2606. Thfi :31 Sum cf

Rs.4,21,QGQf – aiszuig Wit1;:”‘it1tF§i’f&St $0 the c1ajma1:t.$-

re3§011dv2:T131;%;s..3:: §*;aa?1’e”3;1§;L’:>s§}1=’:3′ éhfi Witiaw and rchildssexa of
decaaseefi Fakiiapya fiamiikeri vézas.

}<:1€;<:3.<:££1 dbiszn ,a1::.tE. ax: accidant that (}CC'EJi}fI'€3é an

23.G9ifZ:GG*w§ an v.:Bffi§g3:.?.§.’$-‘B.*N€S3I”gi Rcsad 0:3; aecoxméq Sf this rash

£~¢I§€}..:;egf1bv:§,gA€;:s¥;vA é~fi§?iI;g by $316 driver 0f 3 KSRTC bus,

“*§’E1€.’;i)§;::§}:§£:den{3 {sf the éaceased fiftsé céaim gctiiian, ‘§’3:;r:~:

,$c:r: G1”. fig; fiéceassd examinsd Eaimself as E3’%V»1, Azmiizer

A » v?§5t:tT:€:<3s mm Arum Chanshavaie; Sirzavale was axamified as P'¥£«~'2.

' fiigcufinents Exs.P.i{ £0 Eixsj-".4 havs been marigsé in 61-?i{i€§.iC€,

" ap§€I1a.11t.–Cm*p0:*atio:'1 an its gfzart axaminaii 91:6 witxxms,

Tbs ciaimant in tha evigérznce adducséf. has siaisd that the

:'%'§FA, ?f€(%\;T3{3S8852€}§§§
.3

dsétsasfid was eaxflizzg Rs.1§G/~ per day" hy ca;'r}?i11g.j"C:§; fflf

izusizzessg of seifing Cigalfffilfifix and ckzocalates em, :f53V:1'£;*iV$

hicyclc Vis§t_i11g different vifiagesg Aithough = {fig

daczzmfintaiy eviéence £0 $u'§Sta1§'1€i.éf€<.ih'is .:as;Ts3'€:'z_ :i;::a,,T: the

Tztibunai }1:;1$ acceptaad the V€iI'Si0E1 czf CG2'm§;.§i*3{&ti

by the fivi-fiance of an §11d€§}€Il*£flf:If%f",?%'itI}3f3.f.§x$~ £356'

fads and c2'rc1z.m.sta;1<:es,.– of the ca5;¥:';. 'Tha 'E'ri?b'u:;a§.v»'§};as fsuzid
that the iixccsme of tha {ie§:t;?a$C§£' Ré'. ~ pm' mezzm.

4" Tbs accigiedt "12f§.09.2§{§€3 and the

c:16<:€3s€:r_:¥ Was" fig: _aE§.§e person aged aheut :35 §,»'€3I'!':§.
A£th<)ugEi–1s:ar§:€{% Vc?{;ig;;1_;s75«§. iha appcéiamts 3'ubmi'i:$ ihai thsls

fmfiizxg rsga£'2"§i:2,g;V t;jE1é3_ fimfiyma earned £3; the dazreased £3

.. _ basaiéjgs T2:.:31{i is' 'e.xQe$s§fé§:, E {E0 119%. {um any éflsgaiitg' in 'aha

2{;3}pr;ac.§{§ by the Tri?:}u:1:ai ifl mcerslifig suck; a fmaiing

3:_f;éf’__27″:: Rs.4,;’§GQ;’~ as monthly imtome of ms

s1<:c:€'a.seé,__;" '.f'E1e €Vi{3.€1}Cfi an recazd fismfis suppczrt ts such a

-‘«.__V'<ton¢111§;,<:f"i~ arrived at %;y the '§'rib:;ma}. At any rate, aha fimiizzg

"–$ £.3v.a::°i:*§ved 3:'; cannot be characterised as basekss, gmwarse mt

C8i{i}I'§€'i{fiEiS.