High Court Karnataka High Court

The Management Of North Western … vs Sayyad Mohammed S/O Syed … on 14 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
The Management Of North Western … vs Sayyad Mohammed S/O Syed … on 14 July, 2009
Author: Manjula Chellur B.V.Nagarathna


%’»J’;’1. §%§.e::’;s E i3:f:tf;:iT§«
: E 1
E5 ‘§’§E E333 CQEERT Q? K&§1P§1%.”§§fi%

amwiw BEECE A’? fiE&RWA§.

m’:’§::3 m:::$ ‘§’E~;%_}E2 zrfififi §.T};’-3″? <39' i::.€_:1?;<{"
W533?

i§’E~£E }ErifiE§”BLE ms,..§’£ar$’1′?:;: c§+;;% %i

$33 E-£m§*§§..g §;*s§.§§:AG:E§ATH§&
%5,:§’%;*§ A:>P$§gL :1;::30<; (L~»§{}

§3§3:§*%;i;§_–?;§::::a2;:;[

"§"§::<i f?x::§.z:"2;1é§g;,a;é?::j:€::T1'§,'£:€'§*s§:m:?Ei§: §§t'_"':S'E{3E'E"3
§{aiir,3;:E",ai{e::. §<a':m 'V'§..'::_fé2':;:,::<=;;u'§;:Q:"'E: {f@r§30rai:§<}1'1,
§3€f%i§§fi,'2«":3fs.3?i1EZ£'2i E}§:*§$§:3h§ E3;-f' E353

i§j;%i¥i$§:3':za§" {_'i<g:;i:;* §”§.NS. .§.§§é§~§ E*{{}?§ {}€E§i,

E52:-‘ég {§a§'”:{%%:§:1a.ga2’5 §f%::iga::_z?::, &¥ s§¥2;§f:$§3{} E33 E}E@Z’_s’€’,{‘

Thig 2%-“:=§€T a2:_’;’;§§:s:2.a§ 53 iiieai m”:::3;e::r §Z%é:€f:’.§4r::{:’:;–.A ‘that
i{.ar§T1:»;1i’a§€a}, §'{iV€”:1’$€: {he £§i’E§€Ei” iiaésai 3 T:E}?2f{}'{}8..paS£:3€i: EZij;=’

‘*:.§7_’;.<:% iaamizeii giggle: J1_.s"<:§g@ in 'i&f.E3'._?%s3–;j:2{3<}3"
aE};”r5: thifi .”§i1’1’E3it: €.f.<;:2;n'%:. A ,

'$35213 szwiii. agapsssi '«.g:0:?;1ii:g; " £31; :'f{;4:f .,4_E3:*s-:§';i11:i;"a:§:*§;*

H€a':"§1";.g {hm (flay; §AG=$§'{&THN.&; é:i<:;i1E'éfe::'r:r:{ {ha
feliaavingz — " «.

‘§*E1i$-“:;»:_;f,%:§é~§;;£. i4é’;{‘Ef§;E}éa:¥… £325 E’€’€s3’§~iE%3’?{“f %;:s§,-‘ si”:a3k2:1g§:1g
*{4§;€: {§:'{i€f;’_V {V J”%:3″‘;é»._:E€:a:<*:f'§%§{§ sfizglfi $"u<:ig{: gaassééfi in

imvx iféijzx ;§:_: ;;~yi%;:.s:;::;a 3 .227. 2{}€;’%8.

‘2. ‘”§§’:£§é ‘*-E€::v’§;::’¥{. f:9;c%és fééz’ {E13 {§.is:=;g’3a$:§i £2?’ ‘a;E;:;§;§s é;i’§j}§;}€?ié§§

:23-E:v«._:§;:i§E…T_éi:.§: §;”‘§iS{}{}E’§{§{“:Z}§§ a1:*§:”:{:= wag a¥o:§*E§§§1g as 3 {§:*§z:<:::*

VwiE§i.:.. 3.§'§§_3€i§§§3i},§",*»${3"i"§;}{}I'€fi.§{IE3}, §3§&S ;<:§-::*;'é::x;’~:

_A§;:ass;:e::g._>;::”s :3 *§.:*aa;*€3. “=§*z3’§?:§”‘§€}’§.§§, iéatézcig 3:”: :i§’:€: ‘§3f:2%.-:’; in

q:3:3$§:§{§z1 §:%:}m Sgagaggz’ $15: “¥’:ii;?iémiiigisaz’zzzgzlziiéas,

5-‘§<:<:::::"<§§:':g =33 i;'%':s: :a:;:§§:s§=:':Ea2':i_9 ins: {:E"1a.–3'*g;3; $32223, §%"1::::

GE?' 2&3'?

.”}=
(Rik

§*::::’1arE’1’2§<;i.&<'E 'i'§'"é€: §2:z'c::*': ;3a$&§<i.:;:§:,:3:'$ is §.§'z::*s;:”i$€2:§ifs; ‘§’¥€»3E§ g3:'<::v<?:{'§ £2: ma-2 <T'§{§§;1::€::<;':'.i%: éiiiii,
233 a ':'é:$a.3§%;, 3'-$333533 1<§€§'r£. 'iSi?E3;S {§i:3:.:;is$€{i fiféim –T'?J'i"}&

2"'

:~,§£3;E'§Zf;i ggavs zfifia '£13 an i1"1a%%3:%%;~$:.*§;;§E I 'i§$}j:5é;;*:I:*: éfga:

§5;.{§{§§;3§§€}i1&§L£~i§"}{§§Ei"' $s:";:1r%';, E§:.:'E:::.E§,7%飧{§§:::E'é;'–:§§':§::* ;:<3% f;".,,._.%:":i%:::f§::"1g " '
3'?" <=:vé<"§{:s:: {E125 “~;t}a:*{%€,%:§,__ §z;=¢;§:1§-.jr::’=””‘1:–i«;%;*;j”‘iélét c§:a:”g{:
agaégizsi, :’e:sp{2:”::;i:z”‘2::*§§;- ‘;_é’2i*:;}’a:é::<:?i ~{fa:':§::::gu<::":tEj,;~'

fi§.§"€{%:<~:<i 1'fi:i:}3t.3;i',é%:1:i§':'_:E (3%? §;§T:3?: _?;f1::%':~s§;:<}§';::f's§é.§'1{. ax-1'if§": fiélfi baak

aésage-2% 3.:";;<'%, "_zs:'§'{;Ei: a:<}fzS;gc:<;_:ia:%fi,i8.§ %:2é::'":5fi%.sk §%@§:'::g

22g§g;;"i<j:v::A{§v%'%:s~f~,;:V_ :.7:;::3v:esé..&§:j_i ;::§;*;:1*{i :3?' $325: L-z:2;{:»:.::' £'fi<}:..1::*E_., %;§.'}€

*6? fééizé

\sr

:5″§:s’:2″*a§.§€}s”; :x;§”iT;. §.}::-:’a:fi’i<:;::, 'Wis: §€;:21":"'12€:c;%

:K:=fz:"_:g'E«*:':L"e.ET"a.§:;'§g£: '::<}:~'–:§E:'.§::é<3§;1 iizii ::_3::;*<:§«;§::3:_*.§.§. {gig I:3{E% z”‘3§§i}! 31:}

3 7’::s<é_ A §'L?{:3§.{§'i§j' §§,1E'§ £?';% §,§:3'§.€z'<=:§":. §)€':§" 2:21:'m§2": ssmzé ii} E31133; €::x*§.é::':%,

£3;§¥éE£'{§ £3? E335 iabgzzi" €jf:::a§*§:, fig}: béigég;

:;3ai’;_§$::”‘*;*:=é-z:u”§ wiééia éizizé Eséiéii riiiiegi §’?:1:€:. q1″§§;2£::’a§éa12 Efgaér;

“g3i:*:::_§;::°s%.:«:_§ “dziés. afgxgszaig

= ,1′? ‘
‘T

3, ‘?§'”:::;:f:§%’; %’§”1:–:z*§:: £3 22 :?§5:Ez»::§=” 2:123″ ’28 ‘”§éIi%’8 in fil.;%:2;; am:
..:::jg>g:;£:g&, 135$: “£23. §I’i{?§§.§”‘€.i am E:’:z,::*:”:::£% e::{::’:a’:;’i:: 9:: gm-;=:’*%’::5~::& Eisé %::2::§ <:Q:':'§.<~:_:":%:E1<;z::s,* if–<}:,:':*§: iizaiksaé %';.e::; ;'s.g':=;;s:*<*:{:%.;–;*2:: %§;':e_-5:2; :;:§fe§:ii:a:é5:1%~..::;1'": Ifi?_C{"3F{} *

z;=;.:":§:”:é3?£: fiééf: fi”‘£;’:$§§f}{§Eifis’_;3€I}?,.'”

%§:%xaz”:<,§ £3: 33%': {§{)'i'i'}_'?.:i§*?Q€,§{3 €%§v2q2.;%;'fy°;»i: §.:Ei§{}i35§ 3;§'
*::€}il}"i', €i§"E'€i€§ 'ii: §3€'_a:£§:'1g 3:-§;_:Z_§£:_ %:i=1;<_~3 {)1T'€"','}.€::ETVvij'}f _{5?i§T$::":§$$z3§ 13:3:
:;:;rd:::§§::g :*e=:E:';$1:a'%.é:§::€:':"z?: '*é.¥i'£i;Ef::. f2:'}E[,"%E3f3;<:Ej<:wag@$, Ea fizzther

$%:a};.${;§ Ema: ii'.Ei2¢ §}:}e;§"'§;j:"3' :§'j:2aé;AE.§e;1 %3;E3:_;%}:¥§§; was {§:"'§¥€*'3: 'sgg {ha

:f€:%;§:z::3:':{E's::Tfi<%:. ffifizz} :'3;£g%;éega<3–:: '£9 'z"'<:E.i$:';;.:§2a::agué{i;;§; v=:a$ £5.

jaiazzi V' $;::a<:-:{;"iz§,VE ' if§':;_:s7' €;.;%:€ "€.§<:§;::"€$ §s:=:;1.:§«:{i% at

S"'–s;a;g2:{;?:':»., §;"f:':§éS':fi:"::<'§ 53%;. 321;? $3131'? <3?' mi-3 j;@':§:*::<i:f.; §';:f; Eizéi

_ H"'i*:’é;%3L’:,:ri£”€;::§:” ta: 33$ *£;§’}€3 §}&SS{i1″Egf3E’E~§ 23:’:<'§ Eihié Wag-?'~$§i;:: 1%,.-'gag

.VV{V:::€:E?;@ <ir§'%;<i';* §":.;€:1€%@:':é§;g 'zéjza '§:4::%%;z«:;E :"::;:2":%3<'»:::" <3?

"«;}:~3.$;_;:§:Eai%g€€:'$ ?;.:'3v:":§..§ing in EEK: E12215 wl?.1§:%1 12:33 $9 $333} :::::_?;§;,f

.' . , ':'t:§Ea::::§3a;':agu€i§ia, $321': at $16 $33239, §i'€§E€§§. §;h:~:< £3325 'sfi:'a$

;=:~;'i<§§3§s£§ $33' :"_:§':§:£§{§§'2g5. E? 1%-=35: §§1§TLEL§E{§ ifigaé. ihffifi

g::a3$<::":g<::'s; did get §3§$S{i§S é;§<:§<€%:3,, az':-::'§. i2'2$:'€:§':::z.:"E; iii E8 :3.

{':E§:::;:;' €L".«§§;S§f'. 3333?: éfzae <:§§'i¥<é:* had u:2;:"a':tI?:e:':1§;<i{'.§3}' :§iz:2§:ajg;:€{§

9

Eiffa .?€C:.€§ {T}?

%;E’:s:’: Zm§; :3′: ms: wag-‘ 1513:}: Savagaezz 31:} Y£§§§é”ri2’Ei”_ii1’iE§§7ié.g’%3{‘§§§£%

333:3 hag} ‘§.}€:E”:E1;%,’fi{‘:{“§ mg: ‘E}’i§”§:i3 ;}s§é:§€::1g::r_~:’-;..§.<3 gs:[,§j" -§:;':"'E,~::' i-Ifirsé

E3213 §*£i':E';:}1:':'. é:%€1<;§i€*:~i: '?%:z*' %aif%:i<:%'1 as': .. :':f;~.§,S{:si§=:':":gizigrgfi "E§f}:§"§:~-_A

{3£};€;:ra;'a%_'ie:};T3 was _§u$iif§€dj' §i'::"'::§§$::1i$$if§;g. .V%§:§'n:'V1%<1 '.f7}"{}fi;§.

§'§f.':}i'"'Ji{EEf. "ifs sézibnzééisigi t.%"3.a§: iléféz 1%:a;:€1&:i'8i}';s::l€:.E.}'s§%;E %£=a3${:§ 'A '
V ' C, . A V _

was amt: ré;g%:2f:'. in ms :*=i%:@;::*s;2z2s E-5.2a:'£. §"1€*}3§:;:j$'_3§:§'E.g3:1r::::i-.;¥'"i:s*
{3{};£}fi§'1§1%i"i§§ éhe wziez' <2fL""2?§é%:é $%;a'£.§::.::.f_:i:§ §§_§'=."1{i§ §.§"13i'. $13
§;'€z:i%_1c::f§{}}:'1 <:'{e:":i:. sf §CE%

i$ gziao :19? {:<::§:*r6€:€ f%;::i '%fié:v§' :3? fé::%; mat, tfzs :*{i€~:r sf

r:§§.g;”;’:i$_a§é:f§?’.;}’;;;;;:§:=: §;}f»; ‘?§’§’_3;{‘: _C_arpa:’a?:.§{32″: i’:a{§ ts”: fie ::<m§'i3"::1&<§,
in 'ii a;g}g§a:..<_3§} '- '- " —

éf §?;:<'2}; §*s3{:€;:’:;i, ii; E3 E”Z:{)’iL E2: §§i$}§;:z:’%:::

t,§’;6?}:§:% A§;§V:’i’H§;”é;2fié’§’§IV’::{};£’E ‘é5;g§.$ =:’.?§:€:’§.’}§€}fy'{“‘;{§ .€%:}§f ::;~;:s: }’::4;2:’§:s<';$€«?: 5}?

1:335 :*z::§:€ zasazs fizzm :%a:i’aga.<:s2: 1:23

A *~..:_;':'€}g'§2xii§.%:::§:ag::d{£a; E;ha%;: %:é':e §§<t§{'§€::§ %:'%5"§i§"if§ §$$%..3@:§. 21:;

A ; L' $é~§;ga<;:'3; zmai iiézai ?§}€§"'€ "§§?§.S gm <::;§?;<_%%_.:5;:i<§2* E1: %§°"';§: '§::s:,.:$§

V' v .:§;;':<§ §':::"'%E'::'~_:.:* i§':a:;”2 $:;:%;:5a.gza.:::§T_2 aztaé

‘€53%§a2′:;:fi’:éfiséigggiéaia a;§1{i :%1:%,%i ii is; iéée {“E’:3%”j;.’ {:25 Eiéléi

2/»

xi”)

115$; 3 3′ WE?’ ‘2i§f}§3

::<§:,:::§:s::§* %".€;';» is:§'m*%: E§<:'§<e';:$ 5:: 'E.§1::: vi!' :5;
53:2? film {%i1_:E;.3; if ¥%:,'ss.::: {L§§"§'¥:'3§' ti; sgszxiiv
magi. '§}n;:*<:f§'121%3£:<i §i§""ié? éiitkeiig
:':’:f.{~:’:={¥; E._’n_a%i. the atgggyaatéig-‘pT.{2§” §}*;.*.:1 :é;V

3..;a:=:~;s;€§’:g<:3;'"%3 E":éi{§ bifiafiififi §:;:_§_tf '$525:
Eiifiil'. §}{éL%§j§}:§I7i€3€fi K; ._'iiV,"§'.v3.i"::.'.:1212:§:Ef:'%::*AVV%3:i' %::i::::ke§:~; }:'}{E
haai :&&:$1T:e:{i ":<:: ;€:_:3'§-fig: a?:;<*s:,:Ji:. $15: %'é,?a§;;..

5:333 '::§m%g Ei;§1*;fi%.:é§~. @313:'3:<§"E};1§:'–%'E'1*§:z.ssé:*.

H ~ iséfiééiz _':"'::':'-..aj::%%:';:"<'"7é Ef';§i'é:%5, ém $25: §,';€:§:1s ifsféi-i’:’% §§€,<;:g:}g:%::i ilizéfi? ii}

:"::%%L::E_1é§;':§:":§a;§ §E~i%.§§§?;. szzrgfé %:§":€ Ezaus ii} iT§E_':€EE§"§,§{E§'E§ "axshécél 'e§»Z':§§

;i§;"é%2'::=:;:*: I-~%.%':5:. ;;*€::§'§:;::é:";<i&:1ig 3:3:-";x::: s§%,{}§}p5:{§ $1681' {$523

{}§}f§{5::TV £325; aaréaiaséa hast? S§'.G_'{}§}€{§ far' §'{':'§}E£§.E' "g3:_:§'p{:se, am':

2%="E£–:§::': S26 €:§i:fi{3§{§§};g gqzzad arr}£;'r:–:{§§ mg: bzzg £11 {§El€$§i€Ei"}

:’ 33 £35

‘m::~; afgzzfi 1.2%: ::i:%é:::%:’§:”:.g :;<.§§..:a{§ §.::;§;s<;:§;:*:<§ ;:ss::;i"28§'£i§; SEE !;;E':%3
%;?::'*€éé:: ';:':2«§.&;s,§*;z':§fi:f$ fa}? §.:»:'*:3._*s;§:i2%4:"':§ '£.§;_{:§<:§:%,§;<:$:s: 3325:? i::'iE.§a:'§§¥

fimi

§’};*{}::%:§:§§§1g;;s; 23.gs:»:§;”:&;?;’, am: §”€’:$§}i}2″i{:€?I?§”‘§{ :}:§’§:3~§}’:§§é§Ei.{:
<-'»::':.<;g:.si:*§a Ea': fz::.<:.E:, 3' 1.-';'~.§§i}{§i'1{.i€':§';}§ izszgi
h:?:s<:::s 2§;é':%;f<:: <3? 332$ Safilfi <:r;»3'§s:;?s;'f§:§;3
<2'i;.Ei;€r Ems :':2%§'§:§:. §':;33;5=; 'E}s1S i,';1f':

§::q.3Eg:;’:a§iz>§2 had :::§’. La;g:c:<:;V;§%i;%;c'§§"°-;;%;j;~* §§:p<:i§:mi:
:}T::3:,:g}':, a.{i§.Eu1}iEtf§':%"§:é:g;i§- E'€8¥},5'€f3§1;A:§:,1£}i1.§."§Lf§ cf {ha
<E:*i2?e1" ii": Vs::§€j; ifaé havizag 3Z§€3§{E{.S
2-3:15} '{1"1€~:_ féoiigi {hat in Saga $3515
§§;§§;1j"§é%$:;,.V £315: 1:1a}::ag€§;_},em:, hm': no
f!;1':<*:_' Séagspizzg {Ef ihfi 2221:: in :;z::€:~;%.§0:1

§3€i§QES'€ ~ r<§4ay::Ei;i1'ig éiiaxzsiizggiéagizziaig '§'?1s::'e§T{::'€; {E16

.._% .'§"§ni=:,.¥.i}1g 5:21? .,_f3{t"i'A §Ei€G§"€§€{3 §";}_'~£ 'she, E;ab@:.:::* C0'%_§2"£, 5:23': EEK:

A * .. _ §:::;1:~:.§:s.;§§..§:%':<: :";.':£:z:£~::§'%3E an §*i::€:<:§"'{§, $312318: E355 faizétfii §?'i5"§§§"L

Er: faciy {ha Efiarnfié fizzgle Judga ésshfiia

::<2:;f§:*;::i:":g $3.5: said fizzzéégxg bag 33% aaiai '{ha"€ ties

§vi{i€§a<':e af '£216 '€?°§ii1€§§S $Xaz::;;:.§:":e.{% {:32 323213}? {E5 zhei

zfia§§ag€::':fi::"2 iziaaréjg $§1€}w$e Eghsaéi ii. ":5; 332% a'iiué:§g; $'§ Eihfi
<:;}§":<;§:;m'§.@r ii; igsuist zigkata is $16 '}8;$§§€Ei'Egf':'f'S as: iihfi

'efif;-*2 ¥'<§::3f.:::2*%'? i,".'x§9' i2€3G€l*

{X3

:–t;f:.:«:1'*éé;'1g pisiné a:'1{'§ in 'i'3z"1»': ;;»:%;r:;€::_:<:<: £2?
9,? éthcé {3{32'1{§;'£"iC¥;{}I' wiizéz 2;'€:gar<i {ii} 'r.}":@ %
§;%'2:1':'.'s,x/'{:3'<": §.:*-;S:.1&::'i Er"; §"€S}_}ff{3'l{i r.:§':7VfM§;V.E"»1'.5:=i«'%i;V':*:'-«sf E312
S1:s::"i'3?:"2g }"}«t.'}§1?:'{, £33.55 €:£1§3;3.:::§.i'.§? ggf Qf
pa%_:§:e;{;*z':ge:*:: €5£§'1£} '%¢';é}a:.:*:i<~:::'i5V"L"?;:"é§;é*:: ;3<;::"§:§. £22:
0%' 21:: §'€§E€f"£a§'§{f€E.' :§§'a<3 Ef':%§'€:: 1 V§:Xa.1.3;3.%:t;€<7i Ea
$'i'.a%'.<: mt: :§u::2}:i:¢::j_ 1%?-*-5-::*€: igszzizé at {ha
f:§'%::2:'*%.%.;:":% §'3fi€}'} ;;:v§a£:<ét:{% wit}:

xarfia i»§=’f3i’f:f {“:Ef_:€::t}<:<':.a:i

§"z55.v%:.._ §:_::<f<~:e:1'=_ ::=;'E::;';::'jj:2Ig:g;s:*T:'i' " i§:_.:':,§ Z31 mgr: E5fi}$–£f'§"i.:'3€'f 9? 5:;z3{*:E':

4;:<:s*:,".E: §:§'::%: ;ez%}<;2.:2"

A 3 ' 55;?' ;:._$ *:Et:::'": i§:é:i:*:"§£:<'§ ::~;:',2":g:;§zA: ;._Ez.:{:E_g<:* :"§g§':i.%:-" ':"':§r:§::§ §§§§§.§;. %;'..'E;{-":

%;E:_t: :"€:$§:¥z”1i:A 25,-%::’§ 1?:_a:’s*z’. ;3m%;€:::’§ zfizii

%”:i.:X* Véészx, ins §::$i: :1; ad §’.§§”€}}T}{*;§”.,

”3 53%; §Z:z=:z* 922*; 3.3%: §}é§fg’§’*§TifE§’E?;’. GE’ %;:3.{:§<::w»?:;ga$ 32%

~?<t§::'1<::=::'i:":€{.% iii :43 $€Ei":I€': ?{7E':;5i'i' §;1?':z::é iizéziaééégiiéét $:{::'§'a;i§'}—' :::f}.<:§<::{% $3":

$:%';§=: {"§%§s:'::£:–:;%§&§ iiihét §"§fSr§§J}i}§'£{§;{'3§7§'{Z $2}; iéififfi' {'ia::€»:€§

./"'7

,.

§’*§:;7{‘> 1 4? ii}? ‘2{§{}’33

3 E. §.2,_2{‘}{}’2 221% i3:’13..i 53:2′ 3 E.€§$.’2%’}{I38 .i’%§%§%:§?3i.i§3€3″i§.
§’f§§§3″‘f”E€’.i f;:f€_>3::1 Sefisica, and. $223: ‘E3526
T’;€:Lz’:*t, {Eatfifi 3?, E€;%¢;Z8€i§’?;;

‘%;§~’E»§;’~;§ §'{‘:iE’}S§’£i?;f..{.§. ‘”:’*’%”:€:’§:. 38 :’1: ::o.’–.:E”1€
agépzefiaiiéi. to €:{}2′.:'{.a7;”:<% ':f%'1é'E: .:VV:f.":1"*e'::;':':.3. <§;3aV§;ViV§S1%'1%.$saiSEE
ms: aéass :3? ._:-;é;.:'§f;;;3;(;az:CE%:V§ 1At,Aafass ga;?_:}:f2:i':§;

€13.1§;2§s:;§e::.%. V }§{<::r1::s:=;;, ' §:Ef:«:-: E;aE::.:i:’~:’..’;VCm,::*i gI*:m’:’:£=:<} {L23}

ba£kwagf;§@s':;1i:2*s;VE":'15:}?;:ii§21$:2 -,}1;§s§§;§,€ 'p..}?é;a€i?:;2.§;':'*é§ié_3.:":::e: 2:311 E1351: <:i€:é::s:e 0?’ ‘she
§%.§}§i;’=s: -3:’: ; ££P.S’E’xé’E’..i?;* Emsswam

€933 gifiéé” :;§%§; “$3 ,,.§§§*2*§:%ER ysg mg:-*

,._;f«§§:§§§¥ ;:§:gs{:;%«:§3{%: an €2§fi§§ 2. sec 4% am} §:E’3,;%E§;§L

-“:§§%§4.é §§&§’§$,§’$ $39 §§§§§&3’§°

ii”: {Z § Sfig §§E,. ‘§.§::<::§3’°£a:_g:’::3.Eie::

%;§%::a1’€§ §Z’ 333$ :::’2§i§:%;.§::* fififi sii%:’::c%.a{% %:;%z;{: agjggefigsgzi is gay’ zzqslfg

AA ‘ 5{§€.i<£; ikafikwagag 155%": %:';§er€s%'i :3}; '$16 §'8.§".€ <3? %:3% E36?

§.i§§§"§'i§§:."£1 %:«:§§.§'z {f8i}§f.};E}'a§;§.§,}' <35 :§&::*¥§.<:& smii €§€}£"§§€{f§E,E€E;§';%'{§.E3§

'::2€::€;§'§"::$ éémzg fizz: {§€§.§.§i- 31%' §'3;§Et§ {fiS§Z13§§%$é3;§ 9;::<§ z»%?§:.,%: 22

'§:.1:'"§'.§"3;é5;" :"§%§'i:s::§,§_<§:'§ Egg: gfsfiéiz isis: {:?;'_.§'":€%:" %,E4.’? $<:1T2.{?:§:: <;:f 1:333:33 E'_2§:§;.:'1g 3113;' $€'f;é'§%;'}§_F:S 321:3:
§§_:__:22§:§:2,.2::'fs :1}? '£§:%{:é<:'i¥;:§g;§é3:~;, 11%: :10 E"Ezi}§ 'i;;'_.'l{_-4'::"§€»::._'f§:
*».%;é'§:7i'1 %:E':3§ §_3z:»§"E.§<;§: £32' '£26 §:1'é:*i:::;*« . srgii
1.2' uiigé 593%} £23 figs: sa§':z§ is }:.1;§;;:; I V ' —

Fag’ §;E”:& a§2}§*§::*~:a§:’:”-«; %:3asé”}’?@i}/2€.}{}?9 {ii} ;'”2€::::3 s;1:f%,’i?’ii:’é iéibr” ‘:f§tfi;j_3§%;§<¥;é::';=g:§§’§ and §§a»s:j;’

33:: <'iis§'p;;::$€5=T -Ax?' a%::z:a:4§*c1'§:':g§jg;' »

Sd/~
JUDGE

S&/~
JUDGE

A §«;:m§a* ' ' L. '1