High Court Karnataka High Court

The Managing Director Ksrtc vs Sri S B Poornesha S/O Bommaiah on 17 March, 2009

Karnataka High Court
The Managing Director Ksrtc vs Sri S B Poornesha S/O Bommaiah on 17 March, 2009
Author: V.Jagannathan
 '   ANmU1j'H--. _S/{} S B POORNESHA

 '.3.  SR1 ASHOK SHNAJI MANE Q3'); A s MANE

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALQR§j"--.  

Dated: This the 1'1"" day of March  '.  '  'A
BEFORE   'lj_  i _ L_
THE HON'BLE MRJUSTICE ?§z.JA§}A«;vNATHA:;q--   ' _ T f

M.F.A.NO. 735312003′ %:M;v) = A .

BETWEEN:

THE MANAG;NG I)iI2E<:.'rro:R }<s_RfI"<:,
K.H.ROAE), CENTRAL'OFFf3iE
. BANGALORE .,
THROUGH CHIEF' LAW ;12’E=1’«»:;;3*.I”e- «V
HLIBL; ” ‘
.. . * A’ ….APPELLAN’F
(By S17″. K NAG.AR,AJA—-, A45»; ) *

AND :

1 319:1 33 PO0RjN.EsH2:.s–/0 BQMMAIAH
AGED AB01IT”’27..Y’EARs
R/0 SABU. VILLAGE
‘Q BA;~IAKAL._Hc:>BL§ 55 POST
” MUD.{_GEF-2131″ ALUK, CPKCKMAGALUR QISTRICT

Ar3§E.:) A BOU’I’ 7 YEARS, MINOR REP. BY HIS
. ?ATI’§LjER?/ NATURAL GUARDIAN :?–1
._ R_,!’G .sABLI VILLAGE
BANAKAL HQBLI 8:. POST
MUBIGERE TALUK, QHICKMAGALUR D¥S?RiC§’i”

s/0 SHIVAJI
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
;{.s.m’.c: DRIVER
JAMAKHANDI 95130′?

BAGALKOT msraicz”

RESPQNDENTS

3

KSRTC has given a complaint against the jeep driver.

Therefere, based on the above material and evid.e13ee.V_

of the bus driver, the submission made _

finding of rzegligenee reeexde-gei j; T_

requires interference ‘the qtgméezjifi hf

eemmnsatien.

4. In the the V’-e§’r.:*-I.’.:t1i:’=;si1’1 put
ferwerd, I zeeord and
find that en: of the fact that a
case driver and it is
eiear sheet. In addition,

no eomplejht ‘age.insA:;t-,_»” jeep driver has been plaeeé

..,_Ao:1._’:}’j11:eee;11:;’s:i. “t.I*;i;–diy, the spot mahazar produced

jeep was extensively damaged and its

em: and moreover the hack wheeis of

‘*.,t:he jeepewere found just touching the main door from

Hi§h0tpa¥:h. In other Words, the wsition of the jeep

V. the damage eaueeci to it gives an indication that

the bus mus: lmve hit the jeep and ied to the jeep

heing eempleteiy eiamaged. Therefore, the everali
$52