IN "1"I~¥E HIGH COURT C3?' KARNA'F;f§3fz" 4
{>A'§E::i> wig 'mg 12TH nAi¥4Q<31?"1':«*§::B3%;;A;:a:i*
33$§:g2E'"~
THE;HxwBLEAm2J§SNQE_A§iB9?AgfiA
M.%';1é;:rg;6..b:
BEfiNEEN: .. ,w»f='
The Ma11agin;§:_};3§ire<j£<;:sr, '~."_' «_ 7
NWK_R'-I'-C,' C}€)k111'::§§aad,. '
'f"£11§."}1Vi, C€I1't1'{§}.., Ofiicfis aé';-.
Reprévsemzed by {"3hi'€:--f_ Lézw Qfiicer,
(OWIR:-.1« and I11s111f:::f*rJf' £116 ' KS RTC'.
Baciami Depovt has fiea;r.:ji_.1vg Raga.
Nogqyzgziasagy *. " "APPELLANT
" _ , Da1§aIi,""'}§dveCate)
1.Sh$.rafiaWa,-
_ W/:3 Fakkirappa Hatijan,
A V ‘figaz abet}: 34 y”€:ars,
‘ Kama: H€bb8R€¥3pa§
Sf :73 Fakkirappa Harljan,
Age: 11 years, Occ; Student,
3. Kumari Saraswati,
{I}/ca F”akkirappa Harijafl,
Age: 7′ years, Qcc: Student,
i
4. Kama: Chandrashekhar,
S/0 Fakkirappa Hazijaa,
Age: 4 years, 009: Nil. ..REl-‘S¥’OE\iBEN’I’S'”—-
This MFA i$ filed under Section ‘i.’?3{1}….%4:i’.’i§’£%3i’ Ac:
against the judgment and award dated 15.11.2–St{)’?’ §aé$’aé:€1
MVC.N(3.33[2()06 on the: file of the HI fi.€t££1.C’.’;3.,V(S:’:;T§n.} 3:351
CJM and Add1.l’v’IAC’F, D11an&?ad, axvaxfling abém§3eii3a”i;io3;:;. of” .
RS.5,74,825/~ W133i} i1:t€:rf:S£ 53:: {$026 p’.3,_ Ff1*Cs:11_fi.:.<; {Eats Ersf 7
petition 1:33} the dais of realisation.
This MP-‘A Coming on ibf{j C)I”(v1’.€Ef’S ?;”his2
made the following:
V …JUDr3§v:fi:_x:-‘1f”
‘Fh€:::igE:: :;}_;}’¢-» iisted in the hearing an LA.
Catggggg” mg? ffifid fer C€)I1d{}I18.’i1fE011 af deiay,
bgfégrc is.suiI1g ’11ot§§;_¢¢.on the mgpondtnts, E theught it fit “E0
» s3;1t«.wé1;}}~–.1i¢garci to mméits of the case in order to come ta
<§é:1i'_j_1§1si§3:i as ta Whether the appiicaiien dxsservea
:is3°u.an¥;e sf netice,
Heard Sri fiabaii, iearzifié 80111156} far thus: appeliam:
pfirused tha appeal papers'
:3, The wife ané Chiidffifk of mi: decézased E3'akk§.r3.ppa
Eiarijan izastituied Claim pefétian fioutending that {ha iieath
had eccurrrici in the accicient which Eiaci 'taken piaee 011
«E:
3
§§12.2(}C36: due 1:0 rash 2:115} negligent dxéviixg of {hi} zjfjixier sf
the bus belozzgfizg ‘E0 the r(:$pQ1’1de:3$E. ‘I’i1e res;.)cs;:s.r:i.€;11§é’ §Ei§*:”%i=in
who am }}€'{i’iZi0fi€f3.’S in the zztiaim petition. i’::%i’+.§§ vqfu€é1’joT1;€:Td
bath on zmgligszice as Wei} as the g’hiC*19i has
‘£36611 snugly: fa}; The tribunal aff€f,a}§p;;€<:iafi;;g 'thtfi
on resort} has consitiered fh;ff_i '§;S§S1}t3" 1:*:1afti:1g_; {é fiiéig3';igI.':11<:'zé'
whfia advertiztlg to issiafi. N0.I;"I'::;;A{}E:i$"1'fr::gard«the §;r fi3una1 has
Izoticeid the svidénce of _PtsV .'-1 '{'i'O£"§E.i1E1(33Z1'{S which were
m.a1"}§efi fa.t.?f_} ={;:3 '§?':&.VV__mSc;fa1' as thc magma" of accident
'£116 €Ii};:1;fiai Tiiaé the atzgszs rssiatixtag to '£313 Fifi
{:O1T%'_1:3L*3_I,3f.,i1'£"'V£;,:¥}L{'§' ~Sff)<3*{- péfichaxaama. Thvzfr <:i<::::'a.E.i3;3.x:t:a"£S $63166;
'gig;-on3–i':: '{_§;:-.13 :egaf~i§"'b}7 Ehe 3:€s§)0:1da1'3t 79.6., Eixfél, was alga
?::0:i:s§:;1'tn;f3e(§ VV after ngtiiting {ha said {§.oeume3;1i', means
pgfii<:%;.1afij;7 'ihfi spat gjanctixarxama, ma E:*iTm32;za} has Cami: {<3
{ha Ceficiusiofi 'shat the driver (2? the 13133 was n€g§ige'.r:fi.
,§j§:%:':;=c€; am {he fizzziiixg recoxfiad an ihig E1S§3f3C'{_, i £13 :10': see
§e';"i1'}.}7 €tIT€}I', –
4: Wiih rttgazfl ff} the aguarvzum of csmpenszf-xfiom, the
Eeamed {ii-crrmasei far the appeiiarat Wcsuizi {“70fl§.{‘3I}.{i £313: ‘mg
?;:°§;”E::uI12′:.E was 330$ j’€.1SE”,§f}’.€3 £3: :’e{:ke:m,i1}g 31$ imcreazzxct at
Rs.4,8€34/~ p.111. and as such in View
compensation awarcled under thig head ‘kiss hf ‘€iépm1€1€;(;1cj;’
is exorbiiant. in this xvegard, it is $5165.. t11atvé:fa:’se ‘Q.f” ‘:h£:’
claimants that the deceasefii”L’?».gn%as a5m ‘ K.E’..S,
Ccrfiege at Kormur 111 this
regard, the salary c:e;4r”i:;Vi:<'-I1'.§;§§1":'¢" Coilege was
marked as :I10'(iCfid the saici
d0cumc=,1t1t=:' 'CO}ZlC}3.1Sf-[(311 that after
dcd11§j 1:§6'fis;" 'hfiiévyvincoms which was "being
f;a}{e:1 xho"1ne was in a sum sf Rs.»<¥,864/–.
Th€I';€_fO§'6, 'éi_"7t§f£ the said income, €116 tribunal has
»Rs.1,V( 3O€}'j"v~ tewardts hi3 persona} axpenms and
V r::§TpI§i11g':3:§§p;4o'p;§atc xnuiiiplier, has come: is) the c:1c1u$io:1
.&’1é§.i thfé.’;é{:r§ipensati0n payable uncier the head ‘less 91″
dep’e13d:é{mv}r’ as Rs.5,44,824/–. I11 afiditioa ‘£0 the same,
fl” §:¢f:*;eniiona§ amcunt has hfifill awaréeé and; taiai
Qgazzfiperifiatilorz in 2-1 death af a 38 year ::::1& has been
M§{“3ifiI”H13’E”.}.€(i at Rs.5,’?4,828j». Since the tribune} has
C£)”flSid€:E£’€d 3:16: materiai and eV:idsn(:e avzailabéa on mcoré and
has applied £15 ccxrnésct prizlcipies fer «:i€€erm§:’2a*€i<1:1 of
4
azompensafiong E 3136 11:3 ermr in the jucigmefafé a:;§”;3air;:;:f?{i ‘
pzissed by the {rib 11:131.
33. ékrctordixxgiji, the ap§§€:a_1 be1?1igV_éfcveié.’c§’f’;33g;i: ;
ciispased sssf’ CoI1seque:nti}*, E.}1;«..§ and iE’~-:3? art: 3130
dispcased ofas £10 is$i1a__é§.*:isc:S fgj:rV?é0.u3ide1*ation.
The amgfiint ‘=’i§ef{:a1’£: ‘Viifiis Court $11311 be
tranamittéz; tx:fg fi1e ” V’
AAAA Sd/’V.
, Judge