High Court Karnataka High Court

The Managing Director vs Smt Rajbeebi W/O Mahaboobali … on 10 September, 2009

Karnataka High Court
The Managing Director vs Smt Rajbeebi W/O Mahaboobali … on 10 September, 2009
Author: N.Kumar &B.Sreenivase Gowda
:22? mm HIGH com? me' K&R!*IAT§.§m: Vf ' "j=. 

CIRSIIFF 331%}; AT xjzmfiwzm.  % 

mssmg @333 Tim 19%: may 0F:SEPTEi¥§3ER"§Q% ,: " ' x 

 

'§3'§£E HQEFBLE  .:.;'m$%rzé;a;;    

".§"HE I«zm~:*3g,g 2m.J§;:§£x4c;§:$, :3;;;§§§;§::w*IvAsE wma

.-zsxrg  :€¢.5v9V1z;'%2éw " "  
cxw ram. :§3€3«.;§§ 1é§_i2fi€}'?§"1u:¥*£;.Vr{_Qé. 1 we 11203?
2 fl    ~  

xzsz Mm i%¥Q§.7é§"i'i".;.{;2{§9§?  " t  
BE'*1'W2}';E__§§__I:'  t %  %

'm§:%":»§_;a:\€4¢:::2§N:} if:s:;§:~3E:{::T<}R
'aim; L{.:r{}V¥ST¥sf.fS"-L%_?i/MTPEIE
.. «.3«{F'{'_}E'<f§z?Er=fi"I}"%"J1f'-'s'. 1§s:N::3w:»: £3 °2;;'JAYANA_Nm
 - _Eé:i}s,i{§ igzmzs ;£;:*:;:é),
A j = .. _  v;?.§;fE*%7§<;«%Y <:<3zx;i;P:,1s:.:a.
"  §=;E:':§.§§%:.?:JR, Hzzgm
 "   ' H7;%PPE%ELE.g%.N'T

V L' {BY :§E?}.;§»§;%_NiEMA_N'?E£AR§3DD'f SAE--§E__,IZE{;'-':R§ mag.)

k V' "  :§§§*'§3i~..

A  SM'? RA3gE:E:B:

' W,' *5} f*v'fAE'".¥A§§€}{}IEZ%f§E,§ E¥'fz"~'a§'*£s%'§'
fiiirfi $2 YEEAPSS,
{}{.."§{.7i: §7{{}'{.}i;§"::?3* i.}E.,E'é '*3.?J{}E3€E{,



Rf if} §.%"§""§['Ti§. {'i§?3{}S'S,
E+§§§E"i'§gPU§<3,
§'3E~-§§£§§¥§A{}.

'F§»i§:§T}'EEi"£S§{}?iA§.,%'§;"'§F*§g%{§rE&E§=3   % _
"§"'}-EEE L§?fi"'i'§E£T': E'.§!.i?.E§§ £.?%'§§'§_,:'§€fa.?é'{ii--7§§'{L'i%:i}. E._.,'."£;'£i.';:~   '
L}"?:A <i:<};w?;,;%:}<:5      
?\I§§A§?€ MUE'§'.E{T§i.PAL €":<3§€Pi*§;a%§*§::.}':~%'
'Ef%§~?E;'aRWAE7}    '

EN}

gm" SR}.SE--¥§VA§2AJaP=?».!{L_II}E%§i3}1,;;%;§)\;f, .¥¥'{i>.§€ gm
akigmzz.vf§:N:«:m*;a:s:--:§ :g::3;:- E4'€'i'}'i?€ 

THIS MFA; gs 1s%&':.,1%:f§::: ; "i;§f'S37€§{T§. :*z:3:;:; {:39 M22 §%£f°.E'g
A€3~s§§?§S'I' *m_;'}a'; ;;;§:-.:*:3 E"}"1'::;2*f§ gm ;zs:::3::r*
passgg 3:4 Mm-::» .;%1§sC>,«::k:?%};::3a4 km' me: E4-'ELE 53;? THE: E
;»213;;>L. §:1x,«?;;,.%#;::j'$§:>(§%;a; ..{E§}i:..£T>"N*§ 5%; CHM $5 A3j3I.}L. MA(':'I',

DE~~I;4XEaf§¥A?§;" g;Léi:gaR§:3:.:~§:'c} ; C{3MPEf:NSz§'E'ION :35'
:%s'9,a4,4<;;0;~_ 2az:*:WN AS VIJA¥A?§§§I'*£'{);X
~~;5%(i?;AlI} m:£«:.s 'm*1:>}§

A.  Nam, ENKAY COMPLEX,
_  KE$HWAPi,?§%.A3

'  §~I"E.,';'BL£

, g ,§;PPEE,LAN'F

L

"  ' ; :;:§§:':fe§%':i>£?q 
S/Q §vEA%§.:';€f,--_ 
I}Hs%R.'Js:'A£) '  '-

2. 'THEI}IEflSI®NAE,;-MANAGEER.   
TPIEZ :,Ii:~m'EI) 1NI}4_f?=.; §1\;I'::";:_;rR',?s;N{*:E: *- <10, :35)
1.

35% COMPLE::x;, ‘A
NEAR Pe*IL§NIC:EPA.L-.. .€::Q;i§P<:xsx1'i'c3N"

‘ V

” 5 .RESP:~:I:w§«:N*1’$

gm’ s£3:%g%;*~;1~§§*g;%?%é;I:é}is;g:;:P§3:<if»t;::f;§%§€;;};,V~ zinxr. FOR R 1?
SEv§IY1,ETHS.-;A.,_M.fEi'3':€';1'~I'is:;*?:'I'E%§;":I~i &, \fl_-JAYA KLZ'MAZ'€
A.;+:§;1'*:};, % mzsig, }?'{}R.. R2}

3'§*£1é;"~%,m*;g ' _}F,'3 ~-._§?'i'£';;:EEIf} {US 2?3{:.) {ii}? MK? AC'?
acimg ""1'HE_ ;m:«m*§::>:

«._26{3i~2E)O'”;’PAS$E’;”‘ ~~~~ “£}>%I MVC NC}, I8/2004 ON *m;%: §*11:,E
,s:;>v.m’1;~1_§;…: .;§[E;?2.t)L., CIVIL .;t,r1><;E {SR.E)N) AND CJM AND
v}*;z::A<i::':'3 DHA_RV%"AIf), AWARDING A
€E::"::\}M}.:)E.§figV'gE;b'®r;:%X(.:}N- OF' RS. 90,272/~ 3'.R?I"i'§~'£ f£N'.{'§EH}-SST

5% Rlzx _".E-'IQIJEVE 'THE: DATE 0:3 :3§:';*m:x2 mi,
RE:2*\;E.,§SA’T’}’ON.

L = :2; arm’ rm 1 103 1/2907

zzfirwngmg

:,}AY£’;Ri_} {BEEN
5:2! {E §.,,;%’§’§2 ?’e’IE)E-{:’*aE§{}{}§3g%iE.;E ?v€.r”:§E.;”:’T

{_Efi}§”:’ SE1.S}’§EV;%§€.g%;.}’,§5{E’JI{1§}§§(}’§J, ;’.i§i’§¥,5.’§«

;’%.<._'.%E3f} §'%.BéZ}i§'I{' 33 YRS

{ECG TYPES?' /' {,°I}{£*if-EEK"

Rffifi’ 8TH €T3R{}SS $z’§§~”‘I”APE§Ei9i
EJETEARWAFE

A33;

E’

*:#:»:§: zv:;2r~azz€m\:<3 £"}ER?%1<3T'€§¥E%
vzgaymasarexs §<1,:1x:1«:»$ LT?)
:~.:<1:3 EENKAY CG%%!;!?LE}'fi'"" —

E<1%::§§§wAPL:1*< ' ' " –

§:{L.:8L:

fiwa: Ef}.§”vff:i§§{i:=»T$JA1§gl’vfE.A1\§AG~E§R–.._ .

fm;;s mx::’1*:£:;j;r)< j§r§£:;%i.A.1::é4stTT;§zka;s::::_;?:'k<:@MPANY 131).,
LEA

NEAR M{\»3ib§'§VCI}"s1;.I:-,. {f':{};QP{)R£:TiiQN

I"ji1IrI1~'5&¥?sE'§»3¢'V'.)VAVVi'f}:':'»-_»i:"~ % %

– % ” ,..RE3?N::>§:N’?$

(EEY _SR};;:}%;r~mw;N*§m;.’:%EI>1>Y.$AHt:;;«:AR, Amxi FQR

_ R1:,«;:f§E2Lf§;;«”é..}fsavI.’\z*EL’;§*s-i.E§§$f13″?{%’L’S}T~4£§ AIDV. F’€)I’€ R2)

~T.§9;«:i%:$*i”‘%m1é; :$ E?’iLE*)I) 1:_,r,’3 173(1) {:19 mi AC’?
:a_c2j:;;:v:;rr’~ ~.,_”E§r1i:;’ JEIEECEMENT AME} AWARD }j}A’£”E£}:

2f:i:_3’52{>O??’Ef’sSSE2_E} EN mic: NO. 18f2GG4 QN THE E~’IL§:
L. €’;’E1?IiL JUDGE: (ssmpwg AND mm,

-..e_’*..,1f}f~1ATR’€&f2§D, ?AR’I’IJ{ ,:%.L_LQW.ING THE {ILAEM PE’}f’§TIGE\§
{3(‘)M’PENSATION” AND S¥;3E3I{_}j”NC§= ;+::NHANc:EME:N1*
T ‘– {_iC>§!§PENSA’1’E'{31\E.

_ .. .–. , ., ‘V K’

£33 §£F& Kfia }..394§/2%’?

3E’7§”WEE§I:

SM?’ R:%a.If¢§l§:}%3§-3! –

‘as/e:> m3f’§%: :~g:22:}~aag€a§%gag;Asia;–gt.
A{}§3[} AE-;é<}E,1'F "x"'i£€S " ' J
0:10 .E~{G£.fSE:¥¥H%'f:',:

R,iA’.§’ gm (j’i_E%I€3§§S,

$As*rm>:s’re,

:i3HA§22xIA:>
. . ,A§3i’~>I%3LLAf§’T

gm SEE. SHIVARALfwP.}§{£_§E:i}§f} é;§g,fVjxm~:§;

:1 THE §\'{fi§.i;.FAaL’&*1i:fé”:{3§;’§;”€:.:’ :§;:~%az%§§%<:z*1:%;
x{IJ2ma%r§iA:~s’:%§V R€j;g.:}% :T,1m:’S% %:_;’m
N{:n3: zé:?s:1»;;:;%g?%V%£:%sim:1,_Df:;-gf-?:;a’ %
E{fE3–S§~fWAP§§i??:_j~ A A
§~»:U§%>:g.%§ – V A W ‘

it»?

.. {mx?§:§v1:f3′:s:AL MANAGE}?

V. #3′;-25:9: :;;H5%FrE:1>’i’r§1>:Axrssmgzmcfrfi: :”:<;.1§*1:a,,

A A k V1J§.;;££§'.'£T:'}”<':i;$E€§.A.M*VE;NKATEZSi-E", Ami graze 1%-2;;

TEES MFA ZS} F’§E,,E?2Ef.} {§f;;’§ E.’?3{2) CEF’ ;?\»’i”xf

“‘;égGa£NS’F ‘m:«; JE;,iij3(°§M}}§N’E’ ANE) AWARE} :j:m*}3:r>
‘ gezgggffi? !f~*’A8§§£%3§T.’§ ifi M”=;'{“3 Ni’). :?;{_%4 ms ‘*:’%«§§«: ?+'”‘E_§’._.§€ ms’

‘§”H.i%’*L’ E A§'[.}.I§}E_n{.Z’;§’V{L J¥,_,§§.}C}Efi {Sf€.Ef}?’£}, {.13 M, Ai§f}IT}§,..E’zi§’:{4.Tf§’3

1/

::}i”£ARWz%:[D, ?Am’1;%§’ ;a.1_,L:f3w::x:::é Tm”: <::,.;ma4 <:.:z:*~;
§%EZCOM?Efi$Nfi0NgMfl)SEEKK}E§Hfi?§§fiE§?

{H?SQMPEN$$M$Ea P> .-$~Va°

Téfigéégst A}’~}PE€:!:;E,&§ <:<'::M1:~s:;%:r~:”% §2*;w, K%;3M!aE%i*,’.._f :3E:Lm«:R§%.:I> m;Ef: §§c:>f§,,.:,<:::}J
Jfifi§fiE§§_

MFA 69 E57?/Qfii}? anzi the tx2§€;s
a'§::p=s:aEs fiizi-id by the ::i§r%*;–%::' sf}? 'tz_§~:}f.{i':::{<j: 3_’.vi11¥§<*3:{;11}i4f§,»' iiriié {§wné:7 'i§_E_1$ driver of ms:

'€,E'1I(3§{: }'1&d "_:1<:.L'é§a}i&}_ciriéyifig _Ii£"fi':I1Sf:'§ gm on E326 dafri of the
a5§’.__ ‘t’i~;2::’;?;’> ziiaims a_:§3i:’2,g (31.1%: Gf Em:

;::<:«::id=.::é::':f{;.,

§:§«%,;:.d§*%::332g2007 and MFA 20940/200? the

'i:w?:;._: é:;;f3r3a£':s' filed by #320 5 ‘Elm cranxgaezzxsatiasx arisi1′::g 031?; 0? that

V’ *;*%:r§<_ $331116 az:<:3'.(£t2mi. i%;}"1i{:}2 is $11216 5;1:I*_;_'}'€e::r€'. :na'z.§€::" {Bf t",.1'::?é

' é2;jE'0r£:$;«,1.i{_i. 'EWEE é':1§i3p€tEflS, 'E,'§f;::::*<r:f{'%::;<'€, 3.3;} the, agypeaig aim

£/_

m:

§8}{§.’i.I1 32;’; mg<=:'§.E';:*:r' zmii <.i§$§3$:5{§ of §’:§; thig .«'{1%{::ii’:*:_§:é’s–s;:z:.

{..’%§’é’_§€’ffII

2% $15.31′ the p2.j:i’pf CQ§3V€fI§’1§€iEi{5€g .:?;h:锑;’3a;’E:§s3S” ”

aw: ,’:'<f:?fE-%§':'«:f:§i '$11) as %:l";£%§,: are £'E:.f:5::':E*€::e;%€,{§»._§£*: _é:?'1é%: '<?%.§z§'§}?;'§

§._;:n:,’:«;;

3. Tfizsz c:aj.:z;’§m_: {§.gj’::§é::é?§; ,\.;%I:;.&:«i’v<T:%"%%~::i:§. E'?/2{}{}4
is; £136: wi_c1{)w ijraf ?¢Ea11231r}-{§{}1§%}:i_.i; €iié:<'i E3"; the

mr vehisié”:j2;;fiti<i<%:_11:,a "Fhe é:":'£?"i:fr3.a:T1'£ Ja3ia:":1£§din £11

1'vE§f{3,?,E £§’f§§.0€3i§i:4§3.:§«;§~..§i}f:r5:_ }’-:si1§’i<:2:;1 ridsr Wmrx s:1st3i:"1e{i
§5§.EjE.TiI"i€:;§E='jy in fiizgf ;1%."f'a:2;f?é~:3;2:,i;;¥§;4";;?:{:C'i:i.€n§. (311 :T}6.€}9"2='f,'34i}3 at
a':3<':s:t iiéfiii §£.§i1,,'4f1"1{.§Viifliifiaffiiffl M3i1:a.bo{:ba§ Mahat. W35
:ri;.28/$4193 ‘f.€)’i%F231′{‘§S S{.a,i”,€

§3e’.3;;t_j:’f;3: gt}? Eizfzdia E§*<::n. rie:”I€r. A1: ::1i:a1_.

” {i’§i1:.§;g 5:’ fi%f:;.:;:tk,”‘i’i%€a.{‘i_;t’:ag _I’~L'<}.€3'I*§¥ 5290 dI'ii'i:'€If} by its ('h"i'i%'€3I'

Er: :;':f1s§E';, 3iéam'i negligent r:t;az'3.r:@r* dashzad agairgfit 131$

$<::::;0ii{£';.3i;_ 3 On aL1m_. £3? accifianig t?1(~: d€{?f§38;$€€§ .f:3l§ denim

if :3I£é’:§:.g.g wit}: ‘$3.3 30:”: mild SE.’iS€”,a§}”zfi€} g,ri€v{:’:,:§~; _§_:1j:_:ris::?-;$

‘%?%T:i_ie: E._E’.E’i{§€?E’ {3.”€ii€–3i§:’}€:’:E”:f’,§ fixes {i€2{?’f’:e’:iS{‘2{i s;2.:{::%;§E”-15%.}, {fiiti

Ii.§1jE..i.1’ii€3$%. ‘;”§”E”.1%: piiiiim :*i§§eI* f:{3(::E{ §I'{‘:§fi.I’IK’:f3{ ?.}.r’;T.E§.§%Eé£*;’-2:5

§»;¥::}.:~;p.%.§;:z.’£, E%a.gaE}<{;%: :::z:::<§ its §'iV€f}§€§'fi§§?Zl£i'_E5§{}E§.}f3'E.1;.§§}.§2§VV§'§{_§%3V§.§

{mm i}€x{}<3,2€f}€E3 Ea 15*-"ég{}§}'i3f}ii}1i?§~_' '.*fE.'h:':: {fE§:a:fié:,

va;~*:;::’Z<:'%:':g 53,5; S(%:::ir Ma:V:ag é’:’:i; ” E21 SEi2:’:ir«:_ €E%m”:}%:’ 2:}? E::<"iia_

whersasm his; E':§€)Z"§ {fizz §3EE§§»::1';«":é_:’ki.tég”3S :2: c:.Eé:%:’*E<
in §§':z.=.. {.'ia:}:2(:rai:,i<m Ba:1i¥{._ '.'.E'.fl?f?.€f5,'bE'€3.i"L£}I:"£:":;;.:'V_'fhét Widms: {sf izhéi
<¥.e:*::3%ase<'i Eéaéé3;.jg§r§%féz*:*€:{i=:1§:: '::%Ea;?1:I1.: f}€':t,.i€§,{§E"1 §§€€Eki§{'ig

{t{.::1";p€?::1sz~irtV"%o3:'f;"'fm t}.t:3._"<_§éé::a§I:-':3? 2;v:£~Ifr .%m:9hand. Her 5-T§Gf3§

Ehffjf p:;§i_i0_}':. ré.{i:«:V:"…f;'as 'gsréfsi: I7'E3{,§ the <:.3ai_n::. p{?7£§'{i0I"1 §§€:'fEk§.I"Ig
z: far j§§@§i$!é>:T1a_E §I}jE_’i.”£’§€-S Sustairzezi.

‘ ‘{‘i;A.%;_?1f;’:%ii:–::’::ts appééaretii i_}1:”::1.zgh Ehiiii’ m.)fT}1:fiSfi§ ariii flied

Z <{}b_§${if1§{}§j1S {:{3§':?€<–Es«3'{'"i13g i.'r:€~': Efgiiiifiw Thfi a.<:<:i::i€~tf£2i. :¥3$ iiifrf.

s:_:E§s5j§.n…3E::%{_i 5:3 :51ia-;<:: i':§'.::s: %a"1:~";:1:'::aI':{t& :%<;s;z%:';;:.g::~3 is tbs: 'i:s"°2:si*.Eé 2:3':

':,;§§<:i*$%'.§{2?:":e %'~§':fs%3;é=é:2s"%=::g '%'.h§:;% §§":;'52Vz§'a;":<f{w: {:{}EB'."i §3£~13'1;¢' £::f;*;:'3.7{'u5%:=«%':<"%.§:{_§

§:E":.::§i:, 's;%':t:£% s.i:'*iv<5z* if €;%":,::: i"r:.::::§<: Eizé3z".§ :16; '*azaEiz"i <£;f?E"=sje-':i:':g' "Ei:¥;*:'@'r:é:–:=:*;' ~

3:. %.':;::~=: %:'::_:;_::~*: cf mg»: a£Tf€."f§€§f'3."!3§i., 'E'h.£3rsf:~§$._i:;%:"€:é:=f_'i}{ééffjéahéé' 's;§§%:§f'§:':$ 2

<33" 32$: E11:-;:'ar'§«m«::€: p€:1E{:}=' a:"::i" £f§'§fi:"%if{}f"af\ ,, 4,§'I'£$§1.i?}}?§£3T:;1A*i1;ff.

{§z’1f:;§a::}; is 110?’. Ei:~3E’;3E£ :10 i1′:a;§_§;§’§:r2g’:§TE:’y iE’r_e %i:’S:u_r%::§””é*i:*:::i’ ;3a§.,-”

3″:w

{En the aféiVii::$v;9;i~:?f* g;_2Es:;é::f§if;s1;g°:;, fine ?;:*32b1_:;11;2.E

f1*z21:a1{ad fi’i?t’: _.§:%$;::a$ {E39}: 35: V’ RE;-; .§.?/29983 anéci in

MVC r»:;y;vT;%8L+;%2é{§é;;j;;

gxsfiés ‘ 5:11;’
1, u “-.§§f’E?33§13ef’..V p.v§}’;i?V{“}V§}3 abotxt, E5515 3., :11. on 7£,3aga1kc>’t.~
A Efiayaiiaééax” $0351 Opp{}Si'{.ffi :0 New Medical
‘A ” 4Vé:§3:}§_<j~:ae:} Bagalkat, E1616: zieaeaseci ?=£§€h<:«:3E}a_i§
'j3:r:é:.s gaing akmg with his 3013 am 3 $<:<:20ter
é:3€a?i:1g ';\I.E{A~28/E~4IF%3, at mat. iime a
‘m.1<:i€::a3*°iz’;.g I’*£e.{?§7\V~f:298 $3315 frail:
Bagalkat: Sidi’ izzywarcis éfavajzagar, ziiivera by

its driwz” :’as%”zi§«* 3:153 :’1t3g1ig§:m’,iy and siiasbszd

I

W{..«

3*

L.

K

~’.§{}¢

ihff S{f’fi}i3?,f§E”, the a§:ci.ciss::3i wag :1ce cf the £:;r*11<:E< {i:'i§7:?:1-?

§§!%’:§«::{‘%:€r pf-:t:iIf.i;<:»:'§:=:3€' §)I'{}V€S i}T123$"%.gi 'V

Saki :&§{tC§{'1€1"ii; {i€iCt':EZ:3E§fi€1v£'T'€f{?¢E?.iE§€E{1;fE§?§:i§. §I3j::;:*i€é_s 2

a::':<:E aiiszf (Em: in this ':;'1jt_?;z"-é5:%; é:'?a;;s§t;a,£:':"mé<iIV222%: '§.3f;_c

a_C§r:i{'§%::§1§.?

‘:3E2’§’:é”:ihe:r the §L’i€’iI}i3;\§€}E’§f3F ;:_?,$3″‘tJfE:-V3 °’ %}”fit the

;:»<[::Tii:i91"3s:}5.- er:'i;§t}ed 'fcfwthés <:tQ:1?.-psxisatiarz, if
$5; haw §1r1i:<*}3._a§.–3.;:1 i§':*;3;i1'–é}§;"Ej{;:n?
W%.'z:::_t1':ii:11:’i’£<é:"1*€$'i_~;;§::*0's2*€: that. the

§3,<::;i:fi§:';f: :=?wa;3–Vci:1e " iii» .r;aTS1"1 and m~:g1ig<':tnt.

:0'f,j–._Vt}:::_ _ 5'-*;t–Nava:1aga3″‘

‘«..%:4£;;;c1, Izaaa” New _?vk:di<:a.} cofiegfi, 3331313 he

afisi:-mg with his father as :2: piiiitm rider

' .?<3§1

smotsr bearing N0¢E{A«28/E4393, 3
i'.}:=1.;€:_k bearing N<1C'E'W~529{) came fmrrz
Bagaikerzi: Sitiffi t:0wards Nazzanagar and
zfashézai against {ha 5;<:s;3’r€:”, dzia is that

pé3t4f.%:i_<::'1§:.:" s1z:=;iainr:–::<i g1'i€:Vous i:";jzT1:'i€:s;?

~§T£.»»

2* '$JE";:=:*::.§a<~::' p:_:i'i'€,i<'m@:* §}!'€}§'€i$ '*{ha:IT '%%'§1€?.f}";f§:§'._fZ}'}€

a{:£:i{;i{é::;%, $<::§<":1§,-* (3¥.,}f.". fa ragiz ;;a.r;::%— %;j;e::g:j;'g;:::;:

{i1*iv"Eng {if €336 fm,2(:k {};"iV€Z" '{:$z,t:t§_211g'fN?:L V'

5293? .»w-

3. ‘§¥%:%:%.!1&:’ 1″)€f.§’Ei€};{;%{‘fL§” pfi”f§?é:§ :¥1a?’. fi;_h£’i-};;f:’€:ii§:};¥;1V€i’§’.u

has §=3us*£ai:§f:d 1g:%§€~:§f£_)1.i$ fi:e”:._§_:;.:’:’§¢$’?,”‘
=”-%. Whiéfhaz’ ;:)etit’:__:_:j:*’:.~E::’ is” _§3:”1′{i.t3€d fsr
{:{}I11I.’}€flS3{t§5GfI? If $v€”§;’E7iv§7.§’§c’;?’ mus}: and fmm

x%;’¥’:c>::1′?

U1

}?'{}:€ what ;_é;§:’€§é:: ::::;It4’£’m} ax}? A
” –TEi’i.%i:r: “7′}:[:*§E’;_: £;;rii:3:1 §§3i’:jh’b€d bath me £21313:
§}€'{.i’E1i.2’i3{§4 was exaznixaesi as PWMQ. 13

‘€iV:3s€%i.::’:vi’:;:+gA111::4§M’xfizégréz p’r’0::iz;.1{:ee;1, wiaich were markszd as §.:X.P1

§,{;…El7:>§.Ef1?§;_3}j*..- ‘G11 behalf sf {ha f’€’35§{3{}I3(“}.f§I’H,f3, no wide-*::1€:e

V was §ad_§h1:.:<–::(i,

" Z? , Tim €rib:,1r:_a_£ an €f{}I1Si;{i8}"d'Ei€}I'1 sf the

éiffirétfiaid 013} 3353:} :_i<:»£_:*z.u':::€;zf:'?{;21'}-=" 5-:*.22'31 frkififfkififfii”. sf :’a$§”1 and nsgii ‘saga?

«g2;_

sr’::’§.vE§’:§ E23? mar: :§.:”i%;s::.:* 0%.’ ‘aha? imzsrk :3’: <;'::s.%s;i:i€2§: fté-'w:::s»:}

am: ::i:.a§:":'_:§%:':§:$ 3'.}£»3'-,i€'3 <:3$§:a1}}:§.:;}*:::{i t.I:j£r:'

:':<%:gI§.g€::"1{::3 31".: U'Eii":i':':T§f.: <.:a$<::§, ._

8' T?i<i:ma§t§::*, in 5-29 far?"23$_§£E¥'C"NV{§.–.Eff[

€7{F£.'§4{,'f€i1"§"1{E(§, it 1:05)}: iwifi G'? :,§i::g%":£f3<:€: tlhggf. '?:§f:§~:".«;'E€§£:€Eéi:§e;4d waéé'

£§f()I'§.{i_iig a$ Sf."';§}.'i{}1' ?si§g3:r__:.:«3ug§V::'*"i;'*A54:fVL_:Siéziigfi 1't3'afi3f7:'}:;-'.53? '§f.m:iEa :3.:":e;f§
wag »:'iz'aw'i:":g :3 .'§8,1£'»'i1§"L";;" zgietimtied 1/3"
{'35 ms: 521%; fixpenses smszi
?;,1"1£e:'&?z91'§'1'.é?:§'tj. /' ~ §?€'.3I1i'§i(§I7£ pai.<.i§ is

am: {§iii<3*.:'s QI;i§,'€73?'fhéf-?{fé3i¥"§.£:i;§I§'£§.I1g RS3, }x'%,'?O{'}/'~. Ii ap_p1ia<i
ma' .r::u3_t:i_p§i_€i"-.3.V1i.'–«..a.:r1f_=;§."«..;:%;~;s;%%.§*€}$d 23 S»E.E£'£i <3?' R?s~:.8,8~4;-f¥-1?

;{)/~ ‘tav;;ara:}s

‘ mfiyri $a2§f%i£’§}’:}; –R3. i€,”},{“§{If(} ,1 «~ §€::*«.2V§2r{ii~: EH11′:sp{::2*f:a_€.§.0’z1 and

=f:.:;z1:=:1i%:i”€X1;ér;:.:EV::;%::-:5 ‘i’hz:S in all, theia ‘E:;*ii)i§:”:3§ 2s..war{_i€:d 2:

*f’m:§i {.iaf€: _g;:€:f,§i:ir; iii} fkae date 3?’ pagzgzzfirat.

saztmg r;_::’f’ ?%é:f3,{}4,{}€}€}; – wit}: §.n’r5:r{~és£: 59%; per 3;{1m,2m

~”§.Z§m

Q) E’: SC} £31′ as E315: s.::§aiI:::?mt
$330. $8; 2f)€}4 is; {?t{}I’i{2€’:§f}f3€f}, it %;.:><3%«:' '?':C:?€ 0f '
wag aésé} w9:*}{§:";g a5: 3; Clerk _i1":..VE,h4.€:

arid e’a;<':"s"'% Elfffiéf' 'chi: ae::€:id&nt§
i:}<:m'11€: ii; f_:eE{ 110:6: af t.i: 6;:v”f1};e€1i¥r:}€a} v:§~:\i;«*V’i{$V§’::VA’1!§’*A”f::.._:’Qt:f}~:{2:::e:)1″a’§;L’
whicrth :$;_h<::W3 that fie fgggd: ui§;';;_1_Sii.:r;1Li_r1éa.t"'i Q' '?;"i;.'§.§I33.E&§ i1'1jm":;,
difi."L1ss6:c1, tzmga. 31635;' two hos;p§ta_1sw
H5 was ;i,;';pa1f_i§'::3}t: fgfév' Takirzg mm

C:0:T1si.da1*a€;i.:§:'; f3?;1€';'.afa§::::3Ta§d '§ar:§:'$.V_3'»t. has axxsardeci :3. 2313111

sf R:§,9€},;Z'?i?V_,f~_a £4:iH(Ef'tf'~«§faFi(}T,}S hsads as aoxzxpezzsafiaza
fer the E11}:1;'i€§.._s:.:.S'£.§§i25:55;

._}£§. ‘§1;f_1 :30′ far gig the liability of tha I::;$urar3_<:€:

. {)€;néV1}3:3*_;n..y"%'f._G pay' {lie C(}II1p€I1S.':1I.i()I'1 is concertritzci, it wok

::?:_<_2té*~£;ht:V§E:::gé~::n1entary tzvicierzce pmduced at EEXRE {G

£4§X.V.._R3,-w*_}}'jit:h ssfiows that the d1"i¥€I" of the truck was not

§123.v§_1'ig._.Ta vafisi €21*§€s:i.:1g Eimrzszs as; (3.2: 8'36: data sf '£h{t':

A' –..;i:'c:r':%.<:£€m:. £33: £316: :::am:rar3i, RC6, parficrtiiarg isszméi by

4' ,,_£i:E'_1:é R"i'€:)$ €,':a«::i.22g sfaaxxsg ?}"2a_'{. as {H1 332:: :3:-ms: if EEK:

_g_A

€i{2€'é€.i€"3§'E;§'l, fliiéi <1¥r'i¥€:'° W215 z3fl1..3.f,h{::1"*i3:::'§ ti} =:}1"§V€: §i§,";£r:.44'%'1€:a*¢f§=='

t1':a_.n$;3<;:*f, '%z'€:}"1§::§€: with :2ffi:~z<:ii. fmm 83?. §';39'2T–

$12} £:§":<':2 §3;{§{if§{§€§"E.'£'. has; takagt ;:}ia<:g';: :31": €36)";2–{§i?E3 ":2.:1:1 ihézfl

Eiitiirisitt Waa::: E'{'ff§"§€3*z-§9"fi{§ 12;} ii": "?.'Z,12{7§€};Z%' afggié "¥:}fi'::3:':i1;;it

fiéséasa :’:<.":=£: §"m"1::'§&?''§".?é3?"–'€}§ 'T£.§"'1{::*. L'

T,Fi,}€7:§{, ¥%-'?"3i€T2}§ ifié §&:'z;;f~_;.:.u*<%€%,x__§i§,2 _ izgfsfc, §Q$$§~%_$sAV,Vf§the Vaiiii
zéwvixag Ei<:€:n$$ a3 svzfi' .i:i'»"'.1V::{",'.:1:é"iLifI{:it'C§€33'1"{., 'E}1"§€:}"€:"? is 22
bIE'C§1{';h of élgtz "£.@3'*ff1?i$f" peiicy 3:151
§..i"i€3I'€i§'{:3I'€%,"' is not ii:-zblé: ti}
gay (3(}II1p€?3I}f§.:':'17{f£T%I"L
T§7i€EI'é§1?§t¥'fi*, Vi?' 3;ia'0i§§'f::§,.-g" is pay f{:3:1:: erztire

<_:::nsai.£Qf:’ -<31': 21:9 (}VJI1{ff' 3f !:.}7:6.: :,r:.:<:t}<; —«~ ESE

– ‘:’*&%%:e:_§f)£::i§’§'<%,:1,

jg/,

32.. 35:”: zlfzfzs 2§g;:§<3a.L an a;::§:§i=::2{f%1..§

€:,gLV§&€’:i.’.E€.”:{:/AER §°5fi{“§§}g zgsifiz %..Ef’:é: 9;.§};_§£.§{:2:i§é>’:”:;»’.f:ii’i%é}%’ A.'”i’:2§f:'{2<_%z1<is_:{%_ an €'i§'E€§.{}§."'$f3§1"§€":.E"1'{L 1.i.>-‘5-.é €.§”:.::at. O’f1*{‘E ?s.$§’1€}kéi}y:<%§~'.,nf§g§§E'E§§€'§§§§:§_ %%;::,2:":w:ij§_*g;:E… zgiziig}

f",.§"2;€: §3<'%}:::_£€:z'* {if driis.i.":":g §§.::£:z';s;e?-.2. 2§:év.,a:':-zt.LIfT:§’isa’%€;:€i._f{.{>_e:§;*§v&: §,.;’_s;'{‘x/’;,
E–{GE 22213:? E–%§§~””a§ wi%.§’1 £*;ET<?:e:r%;i* §l§i%3t7;§2{'}{}1. E"fi.S 3'.i{L'f%3§1£-T«€
'wags 22*:-:E§<'% E1533' Eififii?' V" §":?{§::1 E', }2£.2€,3€3} '£0

& :T2(<2<3:3~i%-% "*: .;_;_2f';:2i}{;¥_4:1'; :3,» 5. 22.1209?' '§_'ma

:§:z:::i<}§_'s¢::::i§%_;é';¢.. _§£:.<;w$~"«; _- €r:z':<i91"'$e:'né:}:";'i. :3 %$$1.1¢::§; '£0
;'J:§.*a.3<§*:;:;a::s% 4_E:a<iri'é:_3:*:2.f:;:Et'::-6- .¥:1?:*t;’:$;ai.€:§”4§Ea:§<7::1:1':8r:ai'., '£2-E"i:*3 £€aI*n<%d {2~:m:*:s:«:'»:E fcrz" éhs': mwxex'
s;::gf;z':j:i.:.éI;s'i:%{.§ .i'.§':-at tbs: f::1di3;1g :;f {}}.{'f §;:*.i.'m2:1a} that Ehrsz

V' ,{%§"Ev%:§l"Kai¥%Ei§:~,__§":<:2i". §}if.}§t'~}S{"?SS ¥.%}§.<.'3 <:k'.£zfi.1'1g §§:<:ii:'3$<~f: 3% £22": ifhsi

;:i.:?:'{:?é, é1:a3§ €:'2:x.§:-._zi§_.:::§«:ie:':i is i.:'1z’;*£<:t.. TEE? said fi:"i{i.§'{3£g '£933

" 3'+:–*:'s:f:§r:}:z"::i§<::<:.*g ij_ '::§€:%a:ta:1:«;»:~: ihig d<;<::,1::1s::::1?. 2553.5 §1<'}"§_. {}i'€}{i?;i€f€{3

3f§€§'§'='}Z'%}E. Q?{1'§.§i%3. "Er: $16: §:a:::E'.$ :3»? ii.E::i=; €3.36; wh_<:3'2 ii, <':S'i£i§}i."§$.§1{?€i

AA 3.’iz§.:}g :>”:»:.iid }§{‘.€3′:’1s€, the iiaijiiigz 33 {(3 ha

x§’;::§é§’.£23 §’.§’i€fE E1′:$z,_::’a.:’;_a::}=*.

~.§€:~

Am; ..:a

E3 “3 ‘”§’h<~=: £€;3_:'§:§:~{T§ {3<}:,.:::s;%:E fig};

{B:”:::2;::2§__§_§§.>’ §”}§}§}{}§§€3{§ iiizéi Eszziaié EQWE: T
%.§’:§:_i_: Ehé’: 33538? §:*Ji:i«::E:1c<3 yhai: A§;'§§:f_;f%r::1′”2..:<';*%e*<3:i§
:;:'§.gi§'1aE {§_:*_i%s_i:z{1g I§<:€%:::_$€

"E'§1f,$; {§<3{::::'§:€1T:t <.f:mf:::::f,s_2_. %:3€:'V2*5r:'?%Li:&':':{§ 2:'§I.:~:";_:'*:V

E3. '§'1'2é:i £€,2§;1"I:::=sé~<:¥V_ {"ii§1i11";&–sé:v}.' '-£;<.:'37{f;z:%:g:*ir1g fez' '£"}";_:::

{*:§:«1E:':::a2':1{::~; §:€%{3:'};'§j§:g 3°51":2IiT%ia.z'1'{:;f3:}i~x'€':'2E:.5? t%:<t: §'?{3ILE1f}€EI1S{§§é{§§}

<:-‘:–_:.::.i:;E7 was met: j:._2s5E:Efi<éd in

<,E5:<"§:.i£:%.iiz2g f§i.ia%3§€i sag §'z;1:::zz§..Ej;=' §§€::1$§1″§5i?i”2fe*:§’»E¥’§.’;*_§.§.%f:’_:§3«S£%€3’$E~f§§i”Eg {ha €.f{3I£1p{*§Z’1$§;iTi€}IE :»31″:<§

§_E'_:i;%:*§§'{fé_é;a"f:;, ?ié%% « ….._s2.;m,§g?:t ft;-r €:':1han<:€m_€ni: ("If Lbs:

' £:i':':.;<';1;':~:a§_:§.:§,é:z1?§%§§:' Eff alsz} :§0:,1g}:§ fax' <::1%33r1a§'1c&:I:'::3:1£f. of

.'r%<i%;,':'1p<::1':§:3;§:i€f3:'1 53:": %}c:}*:a§f has

:§Ij_::;%i.ai.1′:<:c:i izgjzzmzs.

.2 34?, $5: %’.%”:€: i’§.g.§§”:t. of §,§?:€: z-:§’:”s::sa’§.d Sr?-‘ifi”}i’,fi§$S§{}§”E;-Eifé anzi.

?§E:1;3 E315: g:_:s§_>im$ fizafz §3ZE’§§:§f:E far <':r:S§_::’§€::’a$%::}:’: am $23

L/.%

:;:::»:i:-‘:%:’:

1. E£:’}’}.5:’£’.E:sz§'” €E”‘:é=: %E:”‘§?}1.::’:§2E; ‘%%.»’é§.:~§ j{..Z:%_§;f§§’§.{.§{I§:7._i§’i

§::x0I:<:'.~mi'i:'1g ?.E":€ E:1:~;12f§'z7§1'::tz~é €_"f{_;:3f:;g3z9:,':':j§;L_'– :'E;»:*7;7i

§j,.§'I{"3 }_ia§":_i§_E_£:y :15; <:=:}:}1;3-ayisatiétéii. gzfiti ..
§::$€.Efi€2{§ ii': f{}ii:§fiI"1g ?=f}";.é;é 2%§5;§i;.iI1§§},:? '1 {E}?{I§*}§?'.__§§'§ifE;é'!"

Qf §':%1€:* %2'€:?3;;%{:}€: in Q1 1:3:%r§._0:§i*1?.

2; W%’2~3:;%1e::'” {ha ~:::~;:$€:..__f{}:° :::1¥i:;2;::z5:Le:zf1mf:E1 £13K:’_§}e€if£i:§:1:§? ‘ —

25%, Paint E%’a.3′.:’ “£3515: , m:a.€.:::*’i_a_1_ an

:’z:%<tr;r€%, it is .€iE¢::a:', in xglbiigér ¥€éZ§':E¥f:k»_=. $,{ICi{§€}'lL $163

<:§€3c::2s;£[_Vééé'[E "Ea?!}fi§:E:a§if;é::E';é;§3:'%»%f::1i'1'éT%f"'s£?as ageéi ai_){:1.1: E36 3×2.-earsg
ciiefii _§fl§1e_, 'E;:f%1é:T:r1zai that the: aieam was an
:;s~1__1;’1éz.”». {ff -:*:–1s§–“: éafitif. E:-:%:§§3VT§ge’«::1!:. ::iré<;i:':g E3}? 111%: driver <31'
tfzfi, — ?£fm.§:1«.:E !;i,:i<=;':':::::.*';gié":g '£733 {he W1 .r€:spo11(i€:m is :10':

'E'§'2§2;9€:%i'€;–r~:3; 3:316: s:1ai}:n:–mf.s have estabiished aha

» ;z:–::iz:;:3;:*¢':31s§4V::–:%gJf.gem:€ and art: €3§}7f.ifl€(i E0 <:QH1p@::$-eaiiian.

.'¥'§?:<*: :;*:3é%£%:§iei;3;v.:§':% whrg hag ta pay the C€)§1':§f)€f1SEif,iOI3. Thfifi

2???? §'€$;)0_i:je:ién'{ — ¥:":s1,1ran::} ms: "§::::::4.:2"a:?;<::<: {E::~::1:pa:':"€_: is

+

{'§:"é2z5:§* iéiai §}<;:~;§:;@s;s 5: zizraiizi {E::'%V"§i:':g Eizztzzzéaia '§".i*:§-: Extiai
€:%1:*'§<'%e'%§'T:{t:=: i§::5sM%' <:r:3i:E_€i§ E136 }"}§°€§<'§i.1£f.'€'Tf€'§ is p:;'2;<2 ihzi-: czxiés-§:::§T3:'1<:e
«:3? :2 vs-~2%§{.§ <'%:'*§¥§::g Ei<:2:i:%:"2$:;: €336? §E:'§v§.§'1g
$5} 33::-2 §'€.ZE§.1f?fE3."£§?}€§I"€E§ E'.hz~:?. {@0132 {mi
%.}€§fm.,€ £2/,6": *i';s§v§'::;:.z.::":;2E §"i»g/giii ms":
éhtz £;'::'3::{.:’: E5; €..b:»1′;'”. ‘z.3″‘2<:*;. §%.T."rL'3'_'*a:€'£" ‘iTT2is 31%: :’i’tT3?!:’::”§l§%:f<:§:*:: V ';<.§":-s*.£Z{}':;,:i"{, if m1,1$'i: be <:v§4<:i$r:{:b€ai:aé:d by we

” v §f’3T§i§’¢.{}}ffi.{3§f§fIS fziéf €;%’:<'r?+..;;:md142£:'{:ir1 0f the Same in 1316 8021:”:

‘ wi;:;g;. g’::::.;’::’:%;i=E; Exi. (:{)§’:%;:i_<*1::%z*z::£§ as a proaf :33" {E162 eérsiisgttirzzre <3!'

?§"fi«;:§"fIf§E"5§:fi.£'i§.{A;— §§:::Vci*:1'1$«:~é 0.?' the fiIE'i¥€3' as!' the truck 23$ 0:1 the

iiatazfi sf' '1:§:e§:" ;3c::{:i<f{~:3":t, We 3.115: 11:}: sgatigfievzi that iihes

cI{%1.::i_:.{;é_f;t: :x:7§’:i_{:E1 .€4;1,: gm H; be §;>:°<:sdu:::<::{§ in ifiiss; §i§)}_f3€féi.§

":z,;'1<_§"~;z;€: §'1E1'é?€'3 2: fééi-ziizag Eézsgif: af3€:_:_::1€:”‘:’£:. is <:i {_3*}?."fi}'

'§€:}z' Efiéiif _§§'::2"p§::% 5;?’ *€,%2_§$ iféifiii ‘$20 ‘i?£”::»§.3’ ti}? Eigzbiiiiy E3

ia,/

–2{3—-

_§_’i§;§:::::pa§13s’, E%::{:I:’7 3; – j’i_1.'{2 ‘1’;:.i:g

5:5,-::’::’3<::§fi: §;:€~: §_:s~:i§"'::1i'E:i:s:é<:i. '.?}'1€?: zE:*i;2sc:;' :33" igmé: i:?'_2§.':<:E§g:_iV':i'£f¥;'% :'*:.£_j§E:

;3{.}SS%i'?:,':§S éihez <.2*23.§_iz:§ d_;*ti_s;E.:'1g
r€::t:”<i:?£'% E3}: E;§'7;:"%: t;E'iE'21,::"fz_a}; e:.1{§<::-S r1< 'é'*€..__C:§%:,'iT}A f"<}:'
it Eisazéfid an Esiégai .:?:%;i<fi:::r:<;6-é"z:%:T:"1'::*§ in V3m:,
‘E’}:€%1’€?f«:>:”&; We (Ea: z”;«:’:i’: ‘§%§i:.% t.I*:§’ié§”;:1’§ ;3:::§21 filéégi
%:§-T’ “EEK: am-*:T::%:’ <3?' {he I ' '

E62' ?é..§"'2;~1§: ijhié
{§E"iV%fiE' 5:1!' Q; i?3.§§{§ c_§;riv§:2g §i€3€'3I}.S€?,'
the a<:<:i<i{=:I;t; if réaaiiy,
'aha: aii:*Ai€g::;4' 53$' id pasgezazss t;h<=: valid zirivérzg

Ei<x:3_;':ss;»::%L_e::s1': utfig»-%=:V_V:;§9: £16: bf flag": a.£'Cidf§I1'§i, Q16: };ia'E"_2§3§%:y (:5 the

E;';f%;':_3"r"é';'i€:€m:' '={}<:_mpan§? Kr: i§}d€:n1:'1§.f::' EH6: §i'ESiEE"{?E{L '{L§.'}€Z

£}?{*_§"}<'fE""f§?.,§§'§%'"'§§5i§'E§Ci{i €"':X.§$'{§3 E1: E3215. E'v§€:"€3i§:* Eaecasflzgsz :3':

%.?i%:~1: §j1*:§<%<::5'i1ii:':gf, it heid Ehfii". ?Z}T§€?I'€ £3 ":10 gizéviflrzg fi{7{?i"ES€"E

g:~:r:<_'E 3'4}/ :'€:§'€: 1'10 éiafiiiiigs £32: tfze §3a..r:: <3? ihe .§:"::;§:.1z'::?z,:';.<:<:

f?éi:'fi;3a:":§2* :5; §§3<:}::zr1:'"a%ff¢ '£:%';e,=: €'§§'J2"i€§E; i;1§'1§s f"§:':r:£§:r:g w<::.:3{5E 39%.

2 62533325: in Em: W€i}' <2? 3:335: €}WEi£{fI' clainiing gm:

'é .

€”5{}§Z.§. g::ré:::”:$a1″%z}1′: §’;ra_i.{.§ ii: Eiisésté ;’}2″€:<?:€:€i§.§':gS '£'?:'{:r'§: 531%?

E§":&;~:z.2:*:2.:::f:{i=: {7§:1}.§;§a:”:§? e:”;§’2 ;3.:*{:<'§:,.:a.<*€;"§:”: <}§ £53
§i{".".$§""iS€":, ékfi ii§"f €.§2?i'i.E'§ 0%' %.%§:':E §§<:'{:§{'§i:fr§1E., ' H
3?. E31 3:} E232' E313; {}E.1é'.i3'i?;§v?!.ii§'Vf§ {?§E 5.-:<:':;T:i;«g_ $1:
;}a;''{,' '.z:i::§:'§fe;' $4: %f'%";<?é 1§5'§{§{,§'%–¥'" <;%'"_
€21": £3725: *§'23.::';<%% €35' ifs, féZm*::*s=: {,_E'1$
t:*.§.§::1.:':1a_§. E1; is §3<i:2:.. ;.__ éifééstzzi E§?é?if~3
§:am:'1i;":g{ a §§1i1";{'E Vs')? :fi'j_:a'§;'b:__'%":§<::'w;§«r:."é?«"' %e'§::2_:1a;g€}¢

in Statzi 'E%;;:;g*2§<:"':;§i2'*§7' igiifiag '"'§§<f:"*§.,:'A '§':"' iaaéwali 2::€:t%.%s:;¢”§-2:=;i<:é3L§"v {:3 E1116 *«;$§{1€;zv i".i'1:i§'
<::3._:'21:é'§¥_ 112$ 1,:9aV_1e{'<:':i3:~A%. é1"1€;:'_:!*r:f§€i:f:$ié:3:'23ti£:::M1 {Gr :¢:f:'::s<2Ss§:'}g %".?:€.-E

{,'f{}:'.'i'§§Z§€E?iE.$é§'E'§{3:*§ V ;;:_a:,a_}é;ta%.:?;ai.-3-;L' "'E'}i:::: am<:»z§::.%2" ::ar;::::.:?_i §§iT’E:§-22%; ‘§E’}{‘iéi}§.”i’}€3 <3? fhéi <Eé:;é%§T’:::§’§;% ,,§%£%i’j_:i£:§f:_ sfigxss {3.i{:ii.:}i”i 2′:::–2V@ gei: a~:v<»:°:':§. ®'{}'1€E'W13.53»Eiz

"'§%'§1_;:%f%2*£:£'<,f:':f§é,L~"I.§.:E 3':..:{::}f:1 {;'iI"(1"§,§§iZ1f:§f.§»3§"£C€i$, ilrze: iffiiflffififfifiaiiflfi $5

ti} 1%: ;3.é§.:5:2$$e::% 9:x<.:h._1(iir:g t;}":£-": said. ;::é:::.*:::ai€:r: e3;§::<}:mt.. B13:

;tz._E f,§;1§: §;%§i:'.2£:, that z:m::i:::f:i': i*£§'i§{3§: {§:iérn5: fa}: saw} {3″§'{>§’%:$s;i_<:;'1:«1} Lax, w.hi£:E":

§~2:"3':<ié:2:":%" £3 :":z::»i' {£é:§'§1,:::§i..s–:{£ §"£if§{ E:E§.<:3 Ei:"§}31__:_i'3;:i, Rfsg §,Z"3{}{}f -=- i3

':2:

vo Q3 ,
1.13:3: é:’:<:{;s§':1:? €15-2:2; {i€':'.'€"§.E1{",*1".§'1€'I fmm; {his S;i«1£a:'}; €3V€}'":§'" §T}'}:€}§"1"{.§"E.

E3.s;a2{}i}g' » f_;.E";i: §;m'f€$:i~;§<::r:eJ Lax. A SEEK} £35 F9'S.4§..g}'-{}{;£~[m £3

tag) E12:-: <_§<:{iu<:{:€-téui am: 05' R:~;,22£}f3€}/ m

wizzzici '€36 the ix-5521:: §:§a}.aI*j5..=". {:3i_1i §}f :ai=*hi;f_IF.':' "£ ,}§"_iTfii"w.§3" .Fg..f{}é:.”.

€ie:{h1w3r2;:§3?:?=:_{£.

‘i’h6:r: the? z.»1mm,:1′:t wmzlzi1.3;5€5T?/~T’».:*{>:;:fs;::Ti€:dV1cf $.54

13,580/-. Thff {i$a:sta$egi_ ?a~;asw.Vgfigfsii’ ‘9;.I?’;{::t:”*{._75€’: years.
Tia :”1m2ti;3ii<ir* app1'iCia?:§ie j.1'~Eé–§%;-"{3i.11::£ }E§3i'?{'3 c_:<::~I1tir;ue<i

in :'~;€~:r*s;i’£he«::1*”‘1f’%:):::é? yé:a,:”s~:;_’ ‘!.’%”:.§§§;*:éf’0:'<;:, far anf,her

_f:>1,:1″:}%:=:a:*;§;” :i!__ii_:€_2¢:%i:1.§:ati(}:’: is is bf? {:aEc:,11at€d on fhfi
%”)z:;:~:iS :?a:;’f’ ‘i;;3i:é.i 51:)i::i§’:_L’é_§:j:t£:;é’;.:t’ a-:fi:é:I* the af<;r€:sa§r:i d&2c}a;,1:”1s;.
Z§:”§<::r I%:3€[§:.?;e:1:;{:2":f",, hé: ':z»i<j.f§;:1(i flaw: gm, rauglizijgx 50% of t,.1"::<:

2,.'

gafigifi V§:13.s::<}::1€é " V.::«;s psznsiara. Thfiffiffiffi, rezfiaizzing Ea;

A.

§<§p§.,i,e;: A';-5; {:3 be, {aka} i;:::ts} cz2:1si:1 for zhé:

yl-owl

“j:.2ég3.§*;;::fVSe:_’ Bf V ::s ;:~<3:1satir:. 3%.’) {:a}<::ulai:ed {he amexmt. sf

.é:,:qf:'}.;;{?::j3 Sz§11;§t3i'_z_ vmzmki bfi Rs. 1{},54,Q8()/a T2; that ave a.<:k'£

E€s:;"E{§;'Q{}{,'5?~ %'.<:war<i5s i035; {inf €,'f(3E'}S€.}I'€iE,}H1, R$. iO,C1{}G/»~

A.?a:s§:z3m:"¢fi's f?J£I"}§3§':'=3§ :1§..IT£€fl 0hsz::=:q1.1§.:5S Cfiffifiififiy, Q55; i{},{}<}{}/~«

' 'A Ef€;§'i?%3E;?§§'€§Ei§ };:s:§ cf :::~$’i:aE€:*.: amt} %.h.t;.:s :3′: $3} WE? awarezi 3. sun’; -:;~.}’_’

3/

E-€:’:~:5 _§ij§,§§=*%,§§8;iTI}/~» 52$ g_E?;2§§§ i.’.{‘}IEiE p€i’.§1E5éi§§é;}1f”§. “7§T’Z%”sé%j”.T.V:%;v:2;;é<:§

:::s::s'n§i;€:;:;:s;;1§"§<:e:"; 2::3'2:;v:__:2':f :~§§':;;-":32 {'?§§i£'.{'}? Ef:'%V.__§§":Ti'§:::*r:.%$:;i% T*;;:'2}i'::*V'«

é_:§:';§';:.z_m .§':'<:2':: %'.E";i:”i€:.i3;i’ ‘::%’1_»:3’-,{‘E.:2§.:f::~3. ;i§i7.p:;;j;31′:&:§’:?,:g

E2″; :33 §}’;f{f*9 €?§:3::§§3€i§’3.s;é:'{.i{}1*:1:z’£%::;e3*{i€:{% €153 €,E”1:5:” ,

i:3}§3:”::’:{i, E325: §:aiE%§s:3:”3 Fiéiéi’-I’ “i§_ ‘{%:}:’;<tz3:*;'2Ac:€i; " Eras: Egg E'1('.1t
§*:I§'£S'§E%§.'§"1f§{§ am}; p€'fI"I'§}.fi;fI»3'.}j'1'{–'_(ii$§3§§Li§.§'i1§f; "«.1{~~_E<: €3(}f}fiI'}E.i.f?:S ta £35:
in <;:1n§31<}j;z:;€z:t sarxd €i§f'fi'§"§'§I}§§.3J€_,iI'}E".§§8.1%§£$§_'~E3€Sf§8.E"}7 ax préaz' to
{.1332 ifiattit 05f '_v2:{:;§;:§a'i:§:_:fiiR E32" fiicii; {I16 %1*ib1_2:1a_1 has
my '§:¥.I';{"§{':('§v %[1iig27'}i1€:i':3iazz":af3-2.::'2'§.s§ :A::'::..i5::"':%:zrt:ai:} §":s:ads ant! 3m-33:21'
s2:1.1':0i;:_r;§§;– V:a1?i%.<E6:i*< _ {'.1':s*T?.f:f"§I';:v"i;£7.i'3' hfiazig, Taking into
<14)::$§{%é.;1fa1i:im%:;=.?:.}:;'s%' §z,f:"j'a–.t;§*if6§s; $:,1sia.i2'1e<i, 3'::,:3:.:';b:~::' ef @3335;
héi' ,':<3=:,:2}; 'z:"::aE=;2:z%::'2f, E31 the hwpitaifi, m€:{iica.§ €3Xp€§If"i$=i§E-'x

i:':;<:€_:1:f;"€:<£,. §:":4:<::'1ir'€:':3;i§;'a{:e ::7a:_;_secL we gm:-2 $a%:i.€sfi.s:<'1 itlzai,

' ,§}';::*:V gEs.§'%:=§}_"€_::::_:11;9i:z1$af£<)I: 9:" E£s.<§{},;E?i2[– is just, 312%

" ~:;'i%':_'«:;y7g:r<?§:'*; T_E.€1_"§*§}i:é:a.'{_. ¥§:€2"W of t.h§*: matt£:I', W61' <20 :10? 3&3 3115;'

V «:§.:%=;ie::":V

:;'§_%€:–7£'§E xii": ?:=*Z{F='g~§ _E{}¥33£%«£}/f2{}€}'?, hsznzte '£6? yaw {Em f{é2130Wi1T1g

i/

pg

":34"

MFA {T3917/0’7, MFA €:9}8;’f2€}G’?’M
E. 1.08 1/20$)? am e:ii.$1.ni$sc~:<i, " '

MFA }€)94Q['2€}Q7 i:~;V;;;t;gri:Iy

En a<idi{i_0I: 1:0 1s;_E1:3jiT -5 hair':-. éé2'W§1f§:i.%_:<?::;§*I1

3%¥Ci NaJ?]2007,:¥5 aWafii a*sunr 55
Rs. E 3!} $83 j ~ V Mali}. i3"1'€=6I'€Ss"£' (5; *£';%..i ;;~~sazj;5 211211133, '

froxu the date "{_:et,itic;::':_ 'Ei1},'.=ti";.g: (131116 of
;:;=ay'ment.' " — 5

Fafiies t.c3"'?~:%a.;*'*§lf1€;§i1f Giassig fig':-St..

‘”;”E1:;:-_– _3;i:1t23’1€.”;,: %$zE’;i§3?3 5:3 . T6;5é:’13c>sit.eaE by the
japgu>s:;f’ia11i:, ;:§?:<1f'a3E'<» b:§=.._tI'z§1T1s1I1itted to {£16

{3fib5€§l1€i}".f{§Ef_ hazing gzaici Ea; f.h:3~ ciaimaxzta

Si/W
REESE

if'? ?'

%x_,:§{i W
'E'""'%"f%
J ins xgégm