High Court Karnataka High Court

The Managing Director vs The Assistant Labour … on 31 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
The Managing Director vs The Assistant Labour … on 31 January, 2009
Author: Subhash B.Adi


7 f(By–$:%. $a;’;acge;e§9:’;a;éunda:g:. ea far 521:;

_??€:%s Writ Petition és fééed zméez .f§rt%c%es 22$ & 22? :2? £923»

*._’–.}..”}«:::_*s-.–.*~=2§4;’s.,:_:§a”e’:” ef indéa prayéns is quash the erder gassed in

-.f’*3Q..§iL$if3’€’5f5JC3?”3-?5f2C3G?–§3C?8 E’3i:.i3.’i€3.2€’:i”}3 vicfe finx-A passed by
V 15339 !’?;’~!,– -etc…

_ _ ” ” ” 3’%3%$ Peiétéen gaming an {as Preééménarg Hearing fhés day. ‘me fficuri
preacie ihe foiiowing; _

§§\£ TE—%& H§G%~% 623%? Q? K.!–%R§\£ATAKA AT B.A;£»3GALG;Q.’E
amaaa mes ‘FHE 31″ me: 3? Jfi\f*~éi.}§’sR’r’ 2999
BEFORE V N
THE HONBLE :«AR.J!Js?§cE SUBHA-SH BAQ: Q ‘ i
am: srgrsmse 540.252 : 993 LK

8ET§«”.!EEN: ‘

“me Masagzéna Qérestei.

Eangaiere Metropofitan Transgeri

Qaygaerazien Bivisien, _ _ _V

Canirai Ofiécé. K.5″‘i.R€*aG§, 3hani%;ér:égar,_ , ” ‘

Bangalare-569 82?. ” _ ” -.

{Represented by 91;’-%:§s?§._aw{}f§§se{},_,»’ ” “‘~V.}j,V-F”ET%T!G¥’~£ER

{By M53. s.5x.:§..:s*w:.:a4$;§:¢;;;’;awa§:a:,%;aa%l;s;§k 3 x

Am’ Senzraééing Au–E?:-3:321 ‘ –

3, The Ass§sié§::;;a£:.eur f;s7:=::re:::~gsA.ane:_ V

{Censtituteed Under the ‘F?aim::e*.e:’ pi érafuiiy i1’\ct,”‘s 9?2′;
£)§v:s!or2~4, Kiarrneeza Bf§’=_.?;x;a.n:,—-
Bannesgaéta Read’. Bg:v’._aaa~§._e:e«–%5$C! 929.

~ ~. A_ 43. £’:_%”%’§’*.!a:;§;:§3gsg>a, ….. <4 .
;*'-359, i;aia"~f§'uruai{:¥appa, _.

_s3:”.€2§3r_2vL;t’e38’§;e”ar.s;, am. #323, 8″‘ !\.%a§:1
3 i3;.r0s3..,.fiafiipfrwagar,
Vigaymaga?,TBar§ga!ore–589 G59. .3 RESPON$E?\§”§’8

AV= i ?3é:§o:a%éé:’%:.. “Q29 ¢§:?’ia§::z§%* ztemes as a seéace is the wezkman afier
“‘ %é:§r§§ae§at er.’2’&;§é§:zati::n. payment 9? grataéty és marzdaiezy fer ‘the
A{‘–‘¥émp§§:$}ie:._»!§§§¢~;e=:er. there is any difference, the weykman has get right
. fiiéfierense cf amsunt. if there is dispute. by fiiérgg an appiicatéen
the Contremg Authority and power is; aisa conferred on the

.?39n£ro%§ing Authwéty to adéudécate the same. No doubt if iheze is 3

LQW QFFJCER ~«e;:.-s– f?;.£<R!SHPéA F€'£}."3f}Y area the saéd gazdgmerzé is not

anzzlécabée is {he p§!§€écne:"'s~ ease.

6. Siidagadeesh Mundargi. !&a:’:=.e=:.4 $§ver:::’:j:en% 9«.d¥:a_;_ata
swearing écg the Centrcééina Aaéhayéty submétteé mat. the $o:z§:.§%§’§:§«r§s~V.VV
A:st%2s:§ty satisfied wfiés. the cazése sémwn by the c!a%maa§V.:’.ié§%§-‘ ~
€:G$”%§€.’;¥’3$£§ tha deiay. He aise subrs%?$ed that theme;de:’ éige ‘4

éeiay being a déscretianasy srder, iézés writ pe9£§;t%!.>a’3-A1;g}é§9s”=Aséétée …-.;’V.’1é*:iE.-‘,L,___r.:?;;VT AA

{he Csnetétutéen 9;? ma is net ma%niaE.rssb§e. §~%e,$a7§3o s:T;%:r;:«s,;2:e}e.s 2534.: ”

even aseazméng that €:?}e=;§§ és arfé 5::-ndaaafiiem <2?
deéay. ii $3 32%;! e;*:ef";-V 'is: 53:39 3%!
qaseatécm. if %:%:e_ awe: an megét £9; as':

apfieaé befare iége §z:e’€her aubmiitad thafi. t§’:e:’e is
m }z:s2§f%:at§s3s’: ta’ $s:i:e:ta§’r:”%§i rs.

2*’, §t,,i.s§:’:é’c%.i:a déséuéééiéativizhe zeaazsarsdent « *~.~%’0e’%§”é;aéé and them is sti%% an amsurzt due fwm the