1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD
DATED mas THE 15TH DAY OF SEPFEMBER,__2fiG$.'_"ff: r. u
BEFORE
THE: HOINPBLE MR.JUs'm;El;<.RA§4;m1jA...' 4' X
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST A§'PE2AL NO .E}468 "
BETWEEN:
mg NEW INDIA ASsr;';RAz~:NA1%, '
RKALENGA HAO RGA3),
BAN(}ALORE+_- 560 " _ " -
REPBY DULY rcor-zs'1*1TU*i*Ea
ATTORNEY. » _ ' APPELLANT
(BY sRi.v IjAfi1'AR,x A-nV;';"'
1.KAvER1§t
AGE.3O YRS. " «
é.MARU'1*m ARJUWNAIK,
_4_;~-«.g>.4.1c+E;'3 32 ms.
'ARE, R/HQBEHINE
-. _ POTLYTECHNIC COLLEGE,
'- mnwgw.
V ._ 3..M()H:T MEHATA,
4_ ..,ty5AJOR IN AGE.
R'/o.sAINA'1*HA CHAMBERS,
\' CO'I'I'0N MARKE'I'--i~{UBLI. RESPONEDENTS
(BY SR1. T.M.NADAF' AND SR1 R.M.NADAF', ADV. FOR R--__1:'AND:.A2}}
iiiiiiii
THIS MFA ES FILED U/S.173(1) <:$;t+'__
JUDGMENT AND AWARD DT.5/1/2DDs~~..?Ass§:-D' IN 1Mi;CAvV.i;s;e..53.j2o05.Q
024 THE FILE OF THE MEMBER II ADDDMACT, KARWAR, AWARDING
COMPENSATION 09 Rs.2,i25,000f?"' vi.rTré""A.eos*TS"*-AND SEMPLE
INTEREST AT 7% RA. FROM DA.TE,'c3F"?};Tfr:QN TILL THE DATE
01:? REALISATION. '- A
THIS A}°PE£;1§--..:VC(1D9i¥_tiL'3v:£')N€ ,1éDR_ :AfL5MfSS{ON THIS DAY, COURT
DELIVERED THEEODLQWIAIG:"=li';;_ id "
AAAA
This challenging the legality
and conectne§3_4.dof ffiejA;dé:D::eDt and award passed by the II
_.A:1g11.MA«:5:T, %%%%% MVC. 53 /2005 whereby awarding
"R$.2.25,0GO/~ with interest at 79/6 33.21. to the
3 from the date of petition til the date of
d K " 4_Ti:ié.on1y short point involved in this appeal is whether
The MAUI' is justified in. awarding compensation under the
T : "los of dependency at Rs.2,25,00{)[- even though the
deceased was aged about 9 yeam who had no canning capacity and
whether the awarding of interest at the rate of 7% pa'
accordance with law?
3. Heard the arguments of the learned K x
both skies and perused the documents.
4. Respondents 1 and 2 benigiihe parents. * L'
Ajay aged about 9 years. On the day i.e.,”onA 2471/2005
the deceased Ajay was _ N.H.17 from
Karwar side towa1*ds’_Ai{odibag”‘ When the
deceased boy Kaxwar, at about
10.15 a.m. Regn.No.KA-25/ ME-0234
being driven speed and in a rash and
n:eg]igent,, xfinanner his behind to go towards Goa and
dashed ‘tide boy consequently, he sutained fatal injuries
and the accident he was shifted to the Dist.
KVIdospitald'”¥€an~:7ar;v svhere, first aid was provided and thereafter he
ddsizifted Goa Medical College Hospital, Bambolizn, Goa and
30/1/2005 while undergoing treament. Therefore,
Iespondents 1 and 2 filed a claim petifion seeking compensation.
elfiidtnittedly, there is no dispute with regard to the Ielationshiga of
at 6% 13.21. deposited by the appellant if any, 3133!} he’ «V
the appellant] Insurer.
“MUS