High Court Karnataka High Court

The New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Smt Sujatha on 23 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
The New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Smt Sujatha on 23 November, 2010
Author: L.Narayana Swamy


% x 2, a§%*’»}f;§§?:’;3:}}i%$%;.’;*§::g%:%?§’%f Qamga 2?

but-sf

fig 2&6; 2:23: §§§éEig=?{3£’«§’}

3% fig: magi-i gm??? Q2′? §§;,g§§§g§a§«;ig $3 §.§sL2%:f:«;§sL:;s:;’;::?:a*>.¥:%MA%*%

garrgfi mg 32$ 2332 my Q? :§§2;§5a%§:§%L%j§<§;%é _ é %

EE§?{f}E3E':

22$ H:3E§’§£E Ju§§$§:Tk;L§§a&1§;¥§;:§g% J

‘ ‘ ” 5 “3 ._.ifIi=-ij5éi:’5*:-‘

fimfiew §E’1§ifi§z.$%?;.-“¥§«i%’$.;_’}§E® Q-i3§§.;?:§:i:.:
Kala; §§§§m§&:z€fi£€._f$y;f§3gi¢:3a§;_$f;E@ V ‘
‘ I %

1-‘a§71s$is;§z°,§ gfififig Bmagiagem 3E3?}3?A
By its mg? €1:3z§a:§a::::$&§”:s?s’$%;s§¥:*r:5&§* ”

 _     . ' m§?$§$¥1%

£335: 52%.; $3   V

A3:

 

    fi&'ifi Q1 

 

    &@§.3f£ 3% yggra

   

   

 " ' é '  as?

– ‘~ ‘gm §fl3<;§&a:1araa.n@1ssr*$;m*§

,2

N:

sggaa 2%. E§;23€§§?2§31?{T..,%§’$§

Eiaagba §%~§a§i2l§
Q}}:L’1

‘E”%;a r’a3§a:”:&e:”%.§5 Rm? ‘:8 ‘#1 am mlmrg’
Ee§3r=$&21’&a& ?§y mm: £33133;

§~ 5 2. $» $W&i§ 4% §%;”E’$
Rwifiirg at Ckifikkzsxefiéyixafii

Kasafia Eshsfig @3312: ;. Taiifiz

.3 $12. t Eaflmmzmmyazm
35% Sf: ffiazfizzfi
5:: Eéaia
$:*i13*&s&§32ra Tahfig
Eisiar §*Zéxfi*§fi$

gay: gm; 3% ;’§§;$E’2m1&§f;d%§%”,'”£;%§ R}:ié{ W

. , ; Eaawnéanm

‘?f”%1i$ Eéiégfieéiafisaiis figgeai £3 fiiefi Eifiéfif
$€.§E§.fi’%fi §’?;E§ };§’1@.:§’%E§§¥ g%.ci &;gz§;iz:g€ {Em §?1::é;,gm§z:§ afzfi axazaifi
éajted 2*?.j$*§;§§§;:§V-.§;’a;$§s$§; ii: §§§?€§ ?¥§§.2§§@i}1 an ihsfi fiig
Q? Sifiél Qzgriga {§E…__§1%:¥:,§ 3.33:? J7 331$ ééfii Ekifiiar
§%;£:{:i§§§§:%£ =i:§&§’§:¥3f§ ‘§ri’§3§.i:’§a1, Eiagi ‘E”:’§§%: 332.3%;
{:hi:::§.£.%fi§a::§§’§§§¥§.§:’;§im a. ézampazzsatéazz Q? §3§§;§’?5§G§j~
wiih “§.t:€;%3:_;m§=§ “‘;~’:: Rég fmm; {Egg fiiaizg gs? §:’:%§i§;?;§%:€; iii}

V:v.VL'””~~:-‘aa§5m§i§;z:E ‘~ ‘

ztigfiggifig $33 far

ihig $23.3, fihfi

2 ‘~$: Q¥T;§.§”§; fiéfififi-yfifi aha f$§§%s.23fng:- <

4§k ?:§'z:. §€';€';§E;'Eé§.@"?f.-%«:f'§':}

Jfififififiififi?

“§’I?:§s apgéai fig fig’ {ha §§i$”§Ef&E’E.§€ ::E3g.§§r3..§i:2;g§

§:,2qigm8::%; mid awaré gfifififififi by téafi fiéaims _

film gmuzaafi af Eiabiéity. ‘E”§:a ap§3§;Eaz’;§_ 2§%§;% ;:s’%§;::%% ” ‘V

‘zaafzsre éiw “”§r§m.:::a%, in ?ar& ?€$.,E§5’=.;Qf

$339523′: siaiafi tigat éfia z*%a$;$£::1:§$1*i’£. V§;:i*wg$L1rAa;i:V::§$’ f%3a.s ” V

35;: mar: Sfiffiifié witéz a Vf§fia§i.£:£’-R-V-‘H. «..;?§;:~:%é;;’;*:;5§%§§.§i§§z*–..aggpaliané

rsmaizm &§a§.¢::*:t ‘Elm sahmiasiasé hag
‘team’; axamséfifzgfi :s}.;:3;’§ ffifiéififi $23: zgaéiat: was:
igazzad %§§j _¥:.v§*1saVVV’¥e11§»:;§1:§%;.V:§§*zVAE:§¥i.7;’§ “iaifag fig’ 2&3: gnfi iéia fiama
Eifiiéififi ‘flag gmagzad étakezz aé

Faré a,§§;vaE§a§i is 33%’: fifififififii ia L’

TV ‘Vv::’é§a§:§§%i€:$2$T§ g:%33’:;3f§:;§}T 33$ igayfigé sfimsgrifiai $r2;E3m§E$ $13.? fizg

‘ “_£§aév%;é;*£§’:¢§é;:’;: in §’a:& Efiégéfi wéié mw ta ha fififidfifififi

aggéai has ‘ig fig Cfififiifififfié fit: mgrzita, £3 £3

V éfigéégéafi ‘$33: 31% Qwgmr $17 Z1323 igaiéééiag Wfifi gm? £2’:

Zésilgfié. ‘E $3 3 §f§’§L”§.3T5§:;’ie§i’é’;§

psgaaggisn $3′ fiza izafiéé ygiéaga £¢:;;%m*é§:;gE§; Ehé _§.§§Cs;.€:a.§:%§é§_ %

23$ 22$? Eiabig is pay éiha mm§e:*z3ai%:3::V.WV >

2. E haw: Ewaré. E:m’%,h ‘:iEt;2;{a’.~V.__sifi$3 A”5a;;i:s3i*:.”§én%;

gagmyaé $2? §;%§E&2%’i}§E , %;:L£?:€§E&a.§.€§.’4%Saé.i”:%% .;:s:§;.é {.215
“§’z*ibm:a2 has gggge-(.5: iig grgég fisprfig §i3{§§
zhai :15 mars ‘iiraafz &”i§.?’$f:’§i=E€§ E3?
gm ‘§’§*§b°§.:z1a§ gfiéiiiéarzafg 351$ flag:

sigéajg ix’; raafihéfig’ “:;Eim?33fi_’VV{v;:2:;j§’§z§€&=%;:;1g3;.’s’.5i§:§. iii fig mfg}? %:;=ma.z,;.$§ 43:’
%h@ $§E’£§.§.§§’i~§.V = 9%” _ *i}z’;&$3: iimgez

<:ir¢:z§:$§«a,1:{2$$;"~« §:z4g:.§;;?a}:*7 madfi by tha appgfiaméw

iz§'3 :;;~:%;&:1a;é:;E:9°' %l?.§§1S§§§:¥;'§;'ii§§Z Q? aagpfiai an maiéifi £3 Eifii

§rég}§:7z*: §$;:*:d§ " apprggfiata Er; €315: fififlifi fig gzzstiagg

:7V'a_;%pgg:§r$Li§f2g;E§¥ gggfiaé Ea fisigmiéggaszi, fiizma ihara £3 :9,

< §&;2s3§r eé%.':$§é'§ ééia ta gmgiigsizzfig af iiérgfi

'5; iglfi

' grzizazzzzfié fyafifi 5% ms 3%;

Wfl

E%?2%, E35. 3 $33 i$.f?;.i’fi;’%?{§é’i§”§

3, ‘?%:§: ap§sa3§:a.z”:.”% Sfifiiifi §§§’§”;I:§§.§$?;i’;%3’E éfl V.

§§’§€£§§ifig$ agaémaé fzéze: awe? GEE $15 ‘

xygs mi. in §fl:$$§3$i$3’§ fif $213 valié };i:j:.:£::5:aa§; 3 :T’:r:j:

321:3 Sfihfiififiififi anfi aim f3;§%3:.*§.;:fi $3L?g%:mz£s%a’§:§%§’_§f

rzaaaf, fix: sspyaiiaxxi hag a. right §a°{‘r2v>.;asasv$;:%.éi.%i§ amaunt
fmzfsz 322$ stzwaaag afiar p§:*a::sééf’i::,g._ £2153 §=:.,¥if1’5§;E’:Té§§§«S§’:. Thfi

%§§&§§an§. is fiiffifiififi Ea afiirééigf “§§}é;£E?%’ ififiihifi ma

wgaies

fit; “._§ ‘*§’§3;€ §i§§§$i$ 33$ éramamétigé :& fize

%£§§_:§ar f*g§:§:§{§.s$;E’:?::5?*;.4V £i~§a§”%m$ Tiifiuaai eanéamaé.

Qfizfi i2§§fi§*fiS’E fffim §% 2% 3% aérgfi ‘éha

‘ ‘ .=

%§i?s::; Em mgémaéatgfi 33$ aha ramaigfifig %ffi§§;E,§§§ Ems

ma 2 :23: §i%*’j’;?€;f’,’:2a§'<«§'}

ii: 'rm pgéfi Ea $31: ciaimazzifig %s;i:§":i:1 zazm zzzsaafiigg: .

fiafga £7 m§§i§: gf E23: sap}? aé' figis Gr§s:i__

'sw