High Court Karnataka High Court

The New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Smt Vijayalakshmi Sridharan on 12 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
The New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Smt Vijayalakshmi Sridharan on 12 November, 2010
Author: L.Narayana Swamy
2

E? fifi Efififi Cfimi' GP KfiR§%'&TfisE{fi; K3' B£:E%'Gfig§:G{E_§;

mmm mg TEE 12% my m' yggwmax L'

B§§'QRE

TEE Hf3R"BLE gm, wmcg :m:;m.%m:§3%:%$*§é.a§§?&;'«k  kk

ma E€e.6.S3=é--! ESQ?' (Egg; 
BE-TWE-EH: J ' L

fifi Raw amiss A$$:3Rgfi€Ef%%%%  

cawafiv L%"I"E»B§ V  "    , 
fiazmmzmg ~-- «$53   =      _
fimsufia yrs Esszmgza F __i1".?§§§    & 
zmmsaxzmmgg £:1*€§E;}®,"~ % %  %

magma awe}?  % {maxi  62$:

REP. E35'  a$3;I$.=:%:':§;§*'E. ~

SR1. i::.EL S§,i.B,R£a1%'*a§s%R1'z*';'§.; 4_ %    &P%LLAHT

£33' SE:  mag am»; }

 _

 

é  % fiefigéxggrag, Imam,
%  mag ';%E/$5? 54 yaaxa

2: l. §gg:.,:e*g_§%a%§@§?
fégiiz LME sasgm 

 

 X T afifiizfiaamwzsygaa

3 -   mg msmgm ass §a.3.:*:=*;:a
$1-::.I:2<::»: gmmrr, L$§fiR&.§£sR§E£§§

§fi;§%£§$§E «-e 5% 38%
 §E=;?§RE§§§E§%"'fi

2 " gay 33; R Q}-*Efi§3E§§.S1+§K.A.E§ gfim mg m 3% 3,3
3

5k

'x
K
'\



ms M.F.§.. ES Fmfifi 3:33 {1} Q? kw ACT'
éamms? '§'E$ Jfimervmrrr Arm £sVé'AEB Dh'Z'E§
zzwigfiar? ?A*&SE§ 33' mm Hs,4--41s;'2m§4 GK fim»
ma <3? gmmgfi mmgfi; B&E§'§A}£.GRE, $2339,
Awmfimfi a aslsmfisafiafi 0? Ra,3,4{},i8e'%[- Wm
mmggs? @§% 1%. max TEE; mag Q? Pmmay
ma SE-Pfifii'.   

ms §gE,F.A. cama GR ma  

DEE', '§"E$ QQQE BELPJEREE 11$;  

 

 apgi is fifi by 

chazzgngm the gfuamenz  V.fi£*.t§$§§.i2l§j{9 }'.2 {§{3?

gaaaafi in M95 §ia.@4~i*5f2€_§}5§  f"1l:<é"£zsf'V»vL.%'z.1dmge§

rsaémz   Qf lfiabélityfi

3? °E§_y"    333$ aw&'&; 216%

 

  Ems;  ef ¥ Efléfigififif =~ with

 

":__§,z;% §:  agmfim fram. iifza fiaia af paiitiatz iii}

diagwaigg

 A  iawmai mzmsa}. far fix appalmt.

x   gm: the mkygze m Id '£9 have men fa-mma in

 gmifimt :3 fa%&E§ imyfimiaég 'Fh& &%&&$& »= Sris

' ' '1  mi 'wmmm $1' film

 

amégimii amzseé Vnsy ma pffifiii. xsfifizzigg & f&}$%

'R



mmgainiz ma "mm mafia by fim ciawmarzi: mfg is have
i'akawmn§z1éga§z'z'Fk'w'§'m'huma1 has erraaigfizmt

ameptifig {Em fimraééga cf the Qhirfi £"@§$f3,d$fiZ£ ea'_::_;§1;t

flQfl~iE§fi n{ sf hm mhicle in the aflged 

mfi the méanm af 36:35: in 3.

'E; 'Eheugh this 

wdum {ha magma 3%' am am 3% W  

5:15 daazmants as per Ex.R.i   <::ri1f':::4':itn};a$ mt
been cansfisrfi g'upsa2~}::y:-   has

humn    d,é_%@s§:i at EXRQ wimeizg
hm hag   gflkfi that an
E4,§3¢.§Q9f§~,   as asigzmé far his marmng'

é a 5&3 5:: 33% gag fium

 

 325$ father had mat with an amécéant

V   by  -
 ' "  .  1   and «g   

 
 

  aémftteé E3
kg was fihififi gs Igfiazziwl

  mfi tim imfinrad éied G33; },%,{%:E2fifi4, Tim

  éf aha gfifiimnfi 5&2 Ems 'iissm fgisiarefl is

 "' §§Q,é5g'§§€%4» far  

 

Swtisiz 275%; 33?? 33% :5; 231' EFC ma aim ilflfifii" 1&1'? fiat

'K



 

mama: far the appeljgmt

aazbmittafl fizat 9,5 per tfm camplairzi at EXFZE, A'

2%.? on mm ma gimme mil mi 643% aim?" 

fathar hm aamfma m mg, "

arm: to the zmpxzaz ané my §a¢:e;r=:é%1Ta§.x§T¢¢%V%%x§é 

was ahiffi ta Mafiyai   

has am: mfaryfi am whiela " i;».€¥uim: m  
in tlha az::c:1d' am! in  Sam was

rgsiatamd agam   It ia
cm fimm    did mi:
km?    acaidenf, 'mi: 3% charge

 

gm: at  tfm  

 h§V'£k,fl'fl§3;&£' 333% $3 £z:w§wed mxé; in thg

 *   3 :: 

 

1% $'§$:§£$ élzizai 33$ was me: riéirag
 :; z»za.§g-~a3~~m~22%a whizh; wag

    Qhagg  § He 'Q33 mi gkrmsnt at tiw

%    tim amsdm: mad at the aaifi date mg ma. «mg,

 



§

¥'ra%:* Tawfi. Feiiaa ta smflmi firm saw 

vézaifirzg Framr '§'fi*a:°fi whim sdkatimn fiw fir aka  

draw" '% licefirm wag flfii deéitaémé; ¢::§;§ 1&  figim " " 

mt fificafl' Es ans, Iwt mm tE3;¢?-._a~a§:rs3§* fi§i"._i:}:r§'

referred in the shagg  of 

K.Gma . Re 3.3 gm: &wg_3§iaféfA';$,'}sa;:!3,;at   sf the
vahzéig 311% he was    apwlknt
aka     .

 

 'figzef    he aha

deriimi  5ff:'3f'  --3fve§*~.gia§'».:;  aha abczsut rm

 

   335%? mafia}; w
:21:  = écsmgmai far rm appellant

 guidance 9% R'§§'s.l

 

aszifiméttaafi  in v%«  '_ 

'1";a§.._$£vt}m mhimée 31$ mtafly  «x 'E13

 

 

 ans Sr£.S:2%haraa mm hag

 

  Véfi  Er: his  

  :é,§.3,2m4 3;: ma am, Em wag

   

   mm  Elma: Pairs: Stfifik E-E::»u§e§ at

V V V '  . ,  ;'mn%m'::§:c}e

; §amK.§._w§3»E§w§§*$8 sigma hy its

 
   

='T  6%': Suraéfizzéag Etélaisz 233% ix: a ::

=(

\



a rash, and  ¢fi¢?. magma'; witimui ehaefm m%
m% 3.3%  fi5fi3 and wi?.mem: giv?@ any sigma}
dashai ts; rm gawfltrm ficm mm ?naa}wj_3:de:.a

 

 

 was shims: m Béimzépal 

am fzzrmr he fixfazmad the pclém abeui   

nwbwx His stafamwt Fa     V

a*?£atm}¢nt ymrégafi by tha 

thm 23 an inxmmsémmngéyv   
siatsamnt ef Esx.§,§.~SL1§barg:s=~~  é;3:a.rr1i*:§.sd as

P%i2 mm témi: an   with Izia

  wax gang 2% gig' gag": Q;

61¢ Zkiaéraé   3% amififint at ahmz:

  Whiéig. .f£*..,1r;::?: figmgaé asgmfimzzgfiai 22:3 

 "i:33.@  af :2» vairzigig as §{fis{%:;"§«E€'£~

 £2'. £3 $2 Eéw Eaat para af Erig ataizemerzt

  sté§:;a§'%.h$.§ flaw mafia aiafimgz ta aéatfia flag vaizifiia

'   ggfi away mm wiser: mg"  

 

 

 wag mi: ffiriiflé fig; tiw §§:-st, hargmg tiwg

  'iige pfiigim :3 miae gefimz ahmg: kgmfxg aha

afiifiéssgsia 32$ mid &3m§3a?mt ifififi madfi $2': §..§,{§3,2$3*§«§

"<

'a



'3'

ma gamaa was 

 

'iaréii  ma Circia Er1a§xa$¥',:.';:*.___c«§'

 

Fciiw} Enéranga? an flfififiéflfiéa Tim  :2

far fig appgiimzré: ftzrtm sizbzaaittéci $13:  H

in thfi  vi: fifidaenae and stafzfimifa.-:W§3.tA_ in E§§A: ;§3_,3;V  

 

gtzea quite ixszziraxy' mfifi ixmizfiisigagxézggé V'

evifimmag has says fiiat he    

Eséazfipai hfiapitai but  at E ::;:§;1 whm

 

L  bank  $pe.2.'§" was mt

prwcrzt anfi    kg was

 

   the am:Cd.&r2t,,

Eu: 3%: 3:%:€.E.i§  {hay wem gairg ta film

afawrg E}1:é§?_._V%§§§m%: é:§c:w§}$%:%;é5'§:§*$e aa$§§.$:fi§ 2:; am; fif gm

 fiififfifiififlig $13  § mmmei far fiw

 ghai ax aimmgt ig mafia is have 3

  "zgaéa {£2  :;.a:a:.gisr1fir szzf Fgiim esrhiefi 32$

 §aa'§l3* he   tkmi 32% aifitfimant

 

     y

 

    izmmatar srfiy afcfi ma mafia fiizm ifia

"  ..__' ';§§:§£d¢mt W§:*'2.i$E: £3 magi Etiiprafiiécafih

59 E2": thé aamyiafzzzt $3 $1" E:-::.§s§, fim wiiféfiiwr

Eafi gtgiaa am: Eifi mg fmiwfi magafiags fffim; Fifi

*6
'\



g g®gg§~

 ..§5;e:§§a§mfi Wham

§

iimsgzsfxiai abmzt his fat}-um Eu': ?W.§ Safifiwaa $.a3$ %:§:':a,t

 has admkttad the ifiiiilifififi is  

héfiyiéaii Sigma ?%3; 3 an gym veféiggzfig  ~ " " V

E931 Em the ma: 3? the éamaaag é§§m§£..%: --:'% z?*3;i§G1E:::."'i§".&VtfgkA:"cI1.T_:

far that purwae sf ¢«:rmper§ai.%:*:§_§t  -mézaii 

an fix mt': sf sfihmm  'aka  1%.?
1:233 mafia 3. ciafm as =§'%§;%z§tml?f__€*§§~i'¢1§'4,s;widaz1t. 1%
magma: midarm  £.;rj.    far fix

m___   said we quits

 

  ..  

‘E’. Emfifi’ mama} {fir Ek
ap@1§:g*;§:_ ” éguxmei far the msporzsiexzz ifi

‘ Wgzggzs mag by gig mg mg ma.

. * Egaw aigmfi aim flag

fif yafifiangr §a.1 ééwé wizgn E12 was an 3;

magi: 3:: §:’§h§3gQ§§.:3§x ‘fig vehiaifi

;’£¥g§§{ég–=$3»EG«2’i24~§ mm fins}. mgifi 12::-s mm ‘

§

maxim :a his §m2:, in ma aéaiamagit filaad as;

sf {ha izzsuxanw mmgaxy file ixzmzramm

mi-:51}, sgasiirig gcsanfi that 3.3 ‘ié 9:’ ” 2

the meter $E amd 3353 v’»;§ak;g§..:’

misregmamaufm made b_=,x=5:.«L::;f itma §.f=§§is:;%§

gafiémézzem ,

Q Tkm ggémgn for the
fifififi aftér two:

manfila ag fay fiw fiinrxie
whfirairz; he gave:

‘fha £3? mmgfiaézzt at Ea§.P,2 by
231:: aa§::»s;wf % Ems fifif. §i&&

‘£235 i2’§§’é.3.%£ gmézgzaxfi at EXEE

Z _tI?1.e$E1£:i£ Rfihtigr arm ifi fim §?§ £3 gar Exfiifi

‘ fwm rmktermd agaitzsé. mfemawn veaizisia.

VT éim grzatigm éf tim gmifigfii afifi

izifat fiw fifiimxm $152 difi mt

aesuamz ?%:;§ séggafififii gf’ F%?§ 3% pg: 53.3,: dsmfi

‘<

Efi

§5.;%3;2i§$4s~, am aamg was rmizxé §; 2% mike an
%S§.2SQ~4~ that ia aftm iwa mnzztfifi, '?im irzfusrmr

svfzfiaé staigzfizant wag mmrciacl 'aa§'$r&. the wiim as per

E-x,R,}; 3 mt tmfigmhza gm sf gm

sfiatmgrrzz $1 tlag afidavét mréfiénam ané

§;sa!@$i£inFr2.§ it i& €2,111 fif ' V

m In hm afi&av§:£ e~a:a§ a;§§a Em §hfl¢
he wag Emma: :.§.=:§:€gaw écnaifient

but in ha 'wag gzaizg its me

afiwfi Ew swim 21%};

his mzmm. n % §aa’§.a?’v£ew*’ %;L§éa an 1§.§3§2m4» ‘bu: am am

3Z*afi§V’ “” the wfim er; 3$.%2%é§

ggggmas mag & a§m§t£;sé.§ sigma Sim

Z £23 Ezsspimi,

$25 fiitifimmr

at 33.92 mg ha rwsssm §hé::fi «sail fmm

Eécagiai a®:§J:

VT an afivfma of irks émisr 31¢

Emgieitai. fiw érmengifitfimy is w}3efir::ar frag

K

.~ ,a?33’@ *:”é’:. &t ;'”§ aigizrzg :1 -1.:

ii

injureé W33 1% {ha mnipai 6:37 am hQspfi£a _L:’f:

in aka izzmzzgiaimxzzgr faufl fimm fim .

11. 1% m’ $9 claaw shafig af,jE§§:.?’;3;_;,

Rum: tiw &mfi¢.fitt.’ié
I§s.E€A~%wE§~2*2-48? am: in [%§gm that
Im 53 :13: $3 owna sari’ tha ahagé

sheaf; mzfi ms: m cm

am
3&3 rzfi tfiam. E211: Quins
he thai he has
mmmizzeé ha was gfling m the

the aarty mam $36 am’. am has

§e3% am; in 21% firi

% ga tbs mm er 4:21′ am smhiek mhmm

aim: 333$ afifivit k

A’ tifmz has 11% mi seem: the awzmé at $223? gm: ef

23% gm: agfiaé $3!’ by tiw

peiim est tiirm imymtér :3? may waging; ‘E313

1

_Ea_?}&ji*wg&r

em mmm m it§ in him

I3

ghsws that 32%. 313351 Kama: Wm mi: fimim
ir3.§}1eag@§c§&:3t&$&?fi nfitgkgfiwmaffiwwhmhgfi

if it is $3 awiémt casmxzaeitmd fig

the wkémxe ha’: ha aiafias that he hm mt
as awzzsafi in ths awe’ E-Ea ‘
new $12312′ his mm’ 16 in

atatmtzt sf pafitienw H93 _g€a ;{3t3fxs.&fit.*’§¢f %

Sum} -: 331$ ;- -‘rTI:TI:.’

wigs}. ta haw bmn

fit Efisgja
Wham}; is mtmng* Fm: 533134;? A.j§gL;a1a§%1ma am an

= W znimmpmentizg
fihm 1&5 dam.

– v “”” Sgabhmafi is mi {km rmaiémft af

$3: ha is rwidmt azf

T 3%

3 %m 3% a hzmfimma mm mzé 23- -T

stahw

‘ H H ‘T 1% mfimt 31$ 13% gm: ‘£39 £333 33:’ $11»

13

mafia fiefam £213 ‘I’ribumE§ it :23 mi autamafigafly _§’:;§?-

‘£”m%u%3. is gram:

mfiy 9:: the

shim petitiézz $233. avfieram, Ska ‘§:ib:;m§_. ” ”

the matméai amflakie in the

fiauéuifizzt thing, Emg is

. .-*:,.;f

£3911:-‘E. mwrime is
Iapae an fix my: $16’

such Iawa 3221 tlagfiig.

” ‘E”h$ 5:11:

fim “E’ri’m;mi is amt

?;é%*§!Zi$;

égz éewsié is fig rafunfiaé is

” .

sdii
13,596