ieAJiiARMA BALLAL
. " ji~{{JN'I'I§{ANA BEJAI M'ANGAL(Z}¥<:'E
use 'rag; HIGH <;0uR"1'uHKARNA'1'Ai<A Ali' t5A\N(;}A£§;;(;;%lf<%}3"
BATED THIS THE 17TH DAY ms FEBRU;*!+.;g;V;x; ;?;i§:*'.i'§4§)"V« ~
BEmR1_:,..,, H
"um: HONBLE MR8. aus1*1;.. " .
DIVISIQNAL OFFICE, BEAUTYVPLAZAVV " "
BALMATTA BA§zN::H, MAN(;:3L.c;RE--._aY '
REGIONAL o;~*1:b:;:E-'7'H:a: {3I€ENTAL"}N'S£§'RANCE
campzmv .1;r:f:-2. , 'sH.c3P:p1p:.Gvr;aVMPLEx
44;-45, 1e1::i~,;1;).:a:'::§s,.(:Y"i-e()¢;é;Lij;. A =
BANGA_LQEIa225;«:.;..,_ " ' '
REP 31? ITS T.;:;;;r:;3uT§3%' V
APPE3LL=AN'i"
(By M] 3. P 1;; RAJ(3"-flagf' :5: ;;»;m;;sH, ADVS.)
.....
1 ‘V§;§1}:3}s*§A’;¢:a;§%§”–« . –
W}d{}’A§§i)UL’j_R;5§Uk’
Raw ALIYOORU ROAD,
« VBELLIVAHE ‘VVILLAGE
” – v . __ Maiiaamzem TALU 1»;
gs; as K. PANDYAKAJ BALLA
~ SWAYARJEETH NIVAS
3 MRS M{fJH£§RUNN§SA
W] (J LA’I’iE:’3 ABDUL £..A’l’Hh$I::}£.cl\.i11 the accident, she fiied the ciajm
‘ 1:>e’iitj0r;’st:;t1i§i1}.g comwnsatien on various heads.
3. Service of notice from the ‘i’ribu;na1_. the
A ‘ f”:;;}§L;5t:1ia11t~iI1s11re1nc€ compafiy appeared and flied his
fifritten statement denying the aiiegations made ii} the
ciaim pefitie11 and sought fiismissai of the pefition.
4. (.111 the basis of the above pieadings, the ‘i’r1§:)u:r1a1
framed the feliowixig issues: £11»
recoré, the *l’ri§>unal awarded compezrsaiion of
Rs.7,£;}4,82’?’f~ ‘Wit.’£1 i:1t€r€st. at the rate cf (3% p.a;.~-._f1*0m
me date of the petition {iii realisation. Being
by the said award, the Insurance company i’–:. a;S ;3r¢i{éi*;~€ <f_i'
this appeai.
6. i have heard the ieaxzqed c<§L11i:3ai§i for
insmanca com'pany.
*7. 11: is submiflzed ..b«etia£f’V{§:’:.~-appefléixitv that the
‘i’r1bu11aJ has :«.tjWa:*ci<:<;§_ ffxcefiéitfe =<'::_m*r::1ie1i<;r.::Aas"'a1$«:} future medical expenses Wnicia
. rd be with by this court,
8.. . HVaév§;i;_g 1’i§;eard the seungei for the appeilant, me
only .pij;t1t that arises for my coflsideration is as to
A if figffiétner axe awaxfl made by the ‘1’I’imma;{ requires any
‘ ifitexfemnm in this 219963}.
9. From a perusal of the material on mcard, it is
noted that as par i::X.i~”-:5 ‘WO¥.1I}d certificate, tim first.
/54.
respondent had fiustairled as many as 1 1 firacturcs
among other mjuries and the same is extracted below:
is
ii}
Right sided biack; eye
Cetrltusion 5 cm x 5 cm ever right si%:it~’:« 7:}? é
back; ef the head
Fracture of the shafi: A ; A’
J.~’racm1’e of the s’b3ff.._{>f Raft’
Fracture of the _th.:<_: lttft izédius §
Fracture of Shé;1"t.j_(:-§; ulna
1; ‘sJs:it§f1iiaemothorax
§<}i*a.cture of tI'8.1'1SV€I'S€i pmcess 9:' £5'? 85 T1
«'V"_'v&r¢1'§e':b1'a on iefi; side
. temposcai
Ubxjtusion 01' the right parietai 3:. left
iobe with $11 b-araclmaifi
ventricular
/5<
Haamorrfsage 83 intra
Haemarrhage.
r
i} Péiill as Sufléfings : KS. fi,£}£},{)£f>L}V§1ji;¥§§?._V_
ii) Medical expenses 5
(126 mejdical bill:-3} : Rs.3,C}8_,82f?.,(30 – ‘
iii) inpatiant 31):’ 40 days v «_ .g _ :
(Rs. 3.50 2; 40 days) 6~,C?O(3.{3QQ
iv) Cmnveyance chazfies-. ” Rs.
V} Attendant’5′,43ha1*g¢s,__ ‘ ~ V __ 2 __ : i< s;. ~ 5Q ,Qg_3U.0U
vii) t4’r1:stratit$11;’ _
Disappointme;1t,,”fL:..I;Iia;3pig_~. G
12¢-._3S,__8a i3T1{§f)i1V§iI1_iCIi{)§? I 1,2Ev,()UU.(.}0
vii} , e;xp£::1se§§Rs. 1,oo,ou0.t.3v:)
…. i<Is.7,U4,827.U{}
11; tiilat there were more than
eight» L1}*a<:'-{u:fa:s- "to ifié. riglzt humerus, left ulna, ierft.
,, ti¥;1ifi',W§é<:2i'1; radius and fracture of vertebra as
I 'Va-§x:r§§1ituSio11 of the right side af the parietai and left
..th_e n3;11i1%:ser of smrgeries that she had undfirgonfi, i am
me view that the Compensation of 1<s.1,uu,uuu/-
under the head pain and suffering is
h;'aemQi&'h£éige and intra vemtxictliar haenlorrhage and
reasenabia. Simiiarly on the basis of 1:36 medical bilis a
Sm}: of l’,’i§£_}£J:/’IL-:..i_s« _
awarded on the head of attexfglant -«..
tI’..v_V1;m1_:3 v
for iI}.t€:I”ff:I’€:I1C€ in this
1;-3. ‘i’a.k1’I1g mate 0:’ that the
first that she was a
lzeuse 3*?» has been awarded
the first respondent.
1101: only for her Pfirsofiai
routing: bzjft’ @150. .vi?c>r”V-tiiié. purposa of running the house
.’ V. <f<)2*=£1"ia.: 21 1<'.s.50,U0i)/« has been awarded.
age of the first respondent to be 44
yée:s;_;_~s, _*i of the considered View that the
comgaéevgfigafion under this head is just and pmper
–.Acr3n_s§ude1’iI}g the fact that interest an the said amount is
izreing paid by the IEISLHEHCE <.Tompa11y. k'urf.£1er a
sum £}f};'€S.1,i~Zi'},(){)U/- has been awarded under the head
0:' discomfoxt anti éacenvenience 311:1 keeping 111 mind
the multir,-lfi: izfimfias 3:16 the am of the fimt resmxidenti
'fiyy.
-18-
ma said %1iI1G1}2″1{ also does not «sail for any intetference
in this appeei.
1.3. As per PW5 Dr.St.:d,t1aKar Shetty
implaztgts iixeszi in the first respor1c£ent’s. é:11d
samé cammt be rexnaved hr}? fia sfizigjieé’-TTE:
means that the first respoxiaigant ha_s”t0 u;1t is:r.§;Q s<§ve1*;=_j° L.
surgeries for removal of fr” ~tx?i1i{:I1 Va sum of
i<$.1_.{J(},()UU/– has tjegégs; the head fu¥:ur{:
medical expenses Whiz:-'!1:*~in' -,;/11:5; {ides 13:): can far
inteI':E%':1*é1;c¢"j?;;1 tiiis appéeai.
14. 1+”é31r* €1*:e §o*3’é’g§§i;1g”ré£i;So113, the appwzai its rejectfid.
Sd/-»
Iudge