High Court Karnataka High Court

The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd vs Ningamma on 7 November, 2008

Karnataka High Court
The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd vs Ningamma on 7 November, 2008
Author: V.Gopalagowda & Swamy
1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF mnnarmm AT 

DATED THIS mm 7m DAY or NOVEMBER    

  

THE HOBPBLE MR.JUs'rIca%v%.I?AmAGnwz§A L'*ViA'1 

mm I-ION'BLE nm,J§8TiGE--iig;m3AYANA am"
mscymsr A1éI5n:_g_;:;%'1~ie:.a2?r3;k2cre5tnav1

BETWEEN:   
The Oriental i'.'{1Sii1';'%J__lCé'-(30;I.3Z(i,<,   '
Banglaore~4,   3  *  
'I'11r012g'1i%'itsT.R:3gi0f:a31 Gffice _

Leo Shappmg '€Zic.~m"p1ex-._ " '  ._ '

No.44/ 45, Residency :f~1'(;_°¥'é-.-c¥.' 

Bangaiorca St-30 O25}  .--  ...Appe}1ant

3 ._§ '(By  S.K0mar, Adv. for

 "  _ - ':'S;fi.AB;vVC.Scetfi31*am Rae, Adv.)

1. ' Smt.Nin1ggs~..mma
W' / 0;"lat§€; 'venkategowda
. R / d..Qm1a1u Village,
., A' ix'-asaba Hobii
 = Kanakapura Taluk
 Bangaiere Dist.

" "2; smwuttamma

W/ajvialigegowda
142/ a_A11ama;1'1aha1Ii Viliage
Kasaba Habfi, Kanakapura Taluk

\/



disputed by respondents 1 is 3, it W{)I_llCl be just and

proper for us to Set aside impugned }udgnent»””‘ax}d

award and call upon the SCCH~ 15, Smafl

Bangalore to record a finding lii”

be just: and proper for ‘tor .5tlr1s

impugned Judment§__ as ll ‘ :,._’iIr;Vf31eadi11g
applicant in IA 3/QTV which is set
aside at the insrarrce Therefore,
it would grist’ ta exercise its
remand the case
to SC€liH- 3&3, Csurt, Bangalore as both the

claims ulbe tsgetlxer afizer recording the

V. finvfii-lag: sxz rlxslquestisrz of their right, of legal heirship to

j1is”ijfy ~ 16:1;-311113 01′ compsnsatisn. Otherwise, there

ébzrlflisritvlaf decisions that may further compiicate

the filfesseflmgs. Therefore, it wsuid be just: and proper

A ..f_’ (301111; to exercise 1:8 appellate guxisciictisn and

V’ pswer and set aside the impugned judgmezlt and award

u and rsmarad the Claim petitizm along with applications

2/07 arid 3/0′? to the MACT, Court sf Small Causes,

SCCH«– I3, Bangalore by gvmg anoth I’ (:1 ‘ petitisn