High Court Karnataka High Court

The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd vs Rani W/O Late Muniyappa on 20 August, 2010

Karnataka High Court
The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd vs Rani W/O Late Muniyappa on 20 August, 2010
Author: D.V.Shylendra Kumar N.Ananda
R'? HE EHGH C01} RT 0? KARHATAKA AT BAH

mmm ms 11% 20% my as A.UG{JSI'__;§{'i1{'£~   %  %

mgssgr 

Tm H€}I§'ELE zam.aUs'ricE 7

 % % %
Tm HGEWBLE  
M.I«*,g.§ 3;   k
§g__'rv__:_§Eg_.: 4.  %  

'% Qrimm}  ;€i¢s;- Ltd,.«--, if; . '
No,éé3,IF£*mr._,;§V}4'iai:2.    
%1c$   ft,   

' a:1aw,IVP"§5:»a*a:as_¢"   
Bmalore-33  '
 {min-axmj'VQa';._, Li'd.,

  %  
  
 §Ia:..-$4;'4j=5:;,Rge¥si;iennyroad
035.  MFELMHT

may   adv.)

.' . is ~-
35" 1

FWI -:5: Jgate Iviuxziyaprga

 '  . _    " Agal abeut 39 ywrs.



2., Suguna
13/ ojate Muxfiyapm
Agfi ahcut 25 yam.

3. Vac1ive1@ Velu
S1o.la1:t: Mmziyapm
Agfi ahaut 18 years.
A11 are :1 at C{o.(Iiha&iah 
Ne.2*¥-1, $5 Cams

'-9

 

Baxgalcr&~3:3.    

{By Sri R.C1m13t3r' Shebmr': *, M. 
far R}.-3,, R-2 serveéi} '  *  v   % _

This Efi*'£g-"i3 "flied  173(1) of MV Act
ginaiz    _ ..!:_ ' am? «..g,wpri1'd. datad 2'.1}.'i'.2€}G4
  cii the file {if the B{ Addl.
Judge,   '(butt of Smafl Causw,
Bargaiore.-, ECCH' .fjVH.o';?',""«s1wa_ré;ir1g cempcnaatian of
R5.3,§'€3,.fl®.j-'  ilzitezféfit at 6% 13.3. fmm the date at?
 3&3}  dgepiasit.

   ' on fir  this day,
 2%.'  '&§gIi$tera$ tiw fO :

JUEGMENT

«§3¥1§ qumtien rafmed in this ail is whether

'    was justzifxsefi E1 awwdém zzscammmaticn to

 ciazfmnm when the ham? Campatly has

V ».  ' &tabIiah¢¢i that the firivw cf the imumd vehislc did mt

m,(£«~c«,wQ;\_ I



pwseas valfi and efi'e<:*£?'::va driving Iicanm, as am the

date sf awidant.

2. we have hwrd Sri 2sa.v.?nnmc1:;g_;  

Ceume} fer the Imumnm Cempsgifi?  
Shela:-g mm Gamma} for    
taken thmugh tbs moorda         k
3. The   I  an
12.5.2003

. adduced
any , the drivmr sf
tha ggsé-awn any valid 01: efiéctism

jthe» the Insuram Eampany has

Iiamee extract hald by tha driver cf

m’m,%ma’%%’ which was mm fiom 2-amggg in

éekflch has an baa”:-mg er refiwarma ts amept

4 txf the Insusraxm Company.

5,<3nyen.Lsa1afthea§davitfiiswbyRW~1,it'3

é that RW«l has mt ataw-.1 ma: imam: knowing